5 ms·
This is what happens when calling bullshit is shushed as incivility. It's not a new problem by any means, but just as a diet of fast food is correlated with dia
by anigbrowl 4y ago
This is what happens when calling bullshit is shushed as incivility. It's not a new problem by any means, but just as a diet of fast food is correlated with diabetes and dementia, a culture of hype correlates with mediocrity and mendacity.
- debacle 4y ago
- bawolff 4y agoI don't think that's true. Just yelling "bullshit" certainly is, and hn has a bit of a positivity bias, nonetheless, comments that say something is BS and explain why are usually reasonably well recieved.
- mistermann 4y agoIn my experience "are usually reasonably well received" is heavily influenced by the topic of discussion.
- kergonath 4y ago> hn has a bit of a positivity bias Interestingly, it also has a bit of negativity bias. This means that any story, however anodine or ground-breaking, will have: - a group of people using some motivated reasoning to show how obviously terrible the thing is and how clever they are; - a group of people arguing that the thing is the best since warm water and is going to solve everything (if only reality would behave). This makes a lot of discussions simultaneously very interesting and utterly depressing.
- lamontcg 4y agoProblem is that due to the bullshit asymmetry principle, explaining why takes orders of magnitude more effort than producing the bullshit in the first place. If you unconditionally accept bullshit but require an explanation in order to reject it, then you're going to wind up believing a lot of bullshit.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis is worthy of expansion into a blog post or similar discussion piece. Public discourse has long been weaponized for economic or political profit, but otherwise well-intentioned people keep falling for the same tricks over and over.
- bawolff 4y agoThe same thing applies to people yelling bullshit. Its a lot easier to just falsely yell bullshit than it is to explain why something is not actually bullshit. Generally i go with the imputus is on the person making the claim. I want the original person to back up their claim before i will care, but i also want anyone counterclaiming BS to also back up their claim before i care.
- lamontcg 4y agoIn reality most people tend to back one side or the other based on their "gut" and if they've had a similar showerthought before and it backs up their own ego, while requiring extensive proof to change their mind. Also in an ideal world you shouldn't just passively consume arguments on the internet, but do actual reading on the subject. Neither side on an internet debates actually owes you anything.
- bawolff 4y ago> Neither side on an internet debates actually owes you anything. I disagree, the person trying to convince you of something always owes you an explanation. Actual reading on something, while a good thing, never resolves an argument because you can't replace the person you are arguing with's premises with a generic premise from somewhere else and come to a reasonable conclusion.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago> I disagree, the person trying to convince you of something always owes you an explanation. Oh definitely not. I’m happy to make one post explaining my position… then walk away. I discovered and internet superpower… it doesn’t bother me if you are wrong.
- ineedasername 4y agoI call bullshit on this comment. Lots of times when a study of some sort is posted the comments are filled with people calling bullshit on the study either due to sampling bias or too small of a sample or flawed experimental protocols.
- gus_massa 4y agoI'm usually that guy, or at least I try to be. Some recommendations: ** Try to avoid insults like fake quote> They are a bunch of liars _or_ morons in spite you think they are a bunch of liars _and_ morons ** Avoid oneliners Try to expand the explanation to 3 or 5 paragraph. Explain clearly what they did, what they claim and the difference. I try to use a ELI25 level (the reader has a technical degree, but not in the subject). ** Explain if it break some physics rule Some articles make claims that break a physic rule. Some even give a wrong explanation about how they are somehow not bounded by the rule. Explain what they are breaking it. Try to give a high level explanation (like it breaks the conservation of energy) and a low level explanation (exactly in which part they are miscounting the energy). ** Expect to make a few mistakes. I always make a mistake in a detail. Luckily most of the time someone will make make a comment fixing it. Acknowledge the error, thanks the comment, and remember it ** If it's bad enough it will be reposted :( The good part, is that you can reuse your comment, with all the fix contributed by other users, and perhaps improve it a little.
- dylan604 4y ago>Try to expand the explanation to 3 or 5 paragraph. In the age of twitter, you expect paragraphs? Your comment is longer than a lot of news coverage, or at least, what passes as news coverage these days. You can try to be the change you want to see in the world, but this is like arguing with a fence post. As the audience becomes predominately younger, the trends of the times will come with them. You can "educate" till you're blue in the face, but being the internet, it's not going to listen.
- Agentlien 4y agoThis started as a discussion about calling bullshit on research in general, then veered into doing so on HN. Are you still talking about HN specifically or do you mean arguing on the internet in general? Because in my experience a large portion of the HN crowd comes here for the civil and nuanced debate.
- gus_massa 4y agoFrom an old comment by dang: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27047098 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27047098 > To a first approximation, the internet is wrong about everything anyhow, so for sanity's sake we all need to learn how to let go. Believe me, I know that's not easy, but it's what we all have to do if we want a forum that doesn't suck. It's about a personal insult in that thread, but I think it can be extrapolated to comment length. I agree that many news coverage are bad, or just a copy&paste of the press release. It's difficult to change the world, but at least we can try to have a nice discussion here. And part of the trick to get a nice discussion is to encourage comments of the correct length, not too short, not too long.
- k2enemy 4y agoClearly you haven't seen HN's reaction to any article about economics or psychology.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoI think people may realize that a lot of health science is closer to economics than math
- Semiapies 4y agoOr physics or cosmology.
- astura 4y agoOr food/nutrition.
- plorkyeran 4y agoIf anything I think HN has the opposite problem. Authoritative-sounding rebuttals to the submission tend to collect more upvotes than the quality of the rebuttal deserves. The key is to maintain a disinterested tone and write enough words that people just assume you must know what you're talking about.
- dang 4y agoCalling bullshit and calling names are different things. If a comment explains why something is bullshit in a way that readers can learn from, and is reasonably free of extraneous noise such as personal attacks, fulmination, and so on, that's a positive contribution. The trick is to (1) add correct, relevant information, and (2) avoid poisoning the ecosystem—like a healthy immune system that can go after pathogens without destroying normal cells.
- AmericanChopper 4y ago> This is what happens when calling bullshit is shushed as incivility It’s worse than that imo. Calling bullshit on scientific findings is frequently treated as heresy.
- potsandpans 4y agoits what you get when you have a culture of "I belive in science"
- tom-thistime 4y agoSure, or even slightly worse, a culture of "I don't believe in science."
- Agentlien 4y agoI find that surprising. My wife used to work as a lab tech in microbiology research and from what I heard there they were very openly questioning a lot of published research and there seemed to be a culture of challenging claims in papers.
- YorkshireSeason 4y agoMicrobiology is a STEM subject, a 'hard' science, where you have fairly stringent criteria for evaluating the reproducability of truth claims. Fields that lack reproducability, replace this (i.e. truth) by community consensus which is enforced, in parts, by threats.
- nosianu 4y agoI think the general public is more impacted by the problem. Especially with the "heresy" part, especially in public forums with lots of mildly interested but not-too-deep-into-it laypeople, like reddit, for example, outside maybe of heavily moderated places like /r/science or /r/AskHistorians. There its more about reputation of a source than the actual facts, because few have the ability to evaluate the latter. Actually, if they spent even a little bit of time and thought they might actually be able to, it's just that almost nobody does. When the interest in "science" is to read publications for the general public, but never touch any of the by now quite numerous deeper equally easily available resources e.g. in the form of courses. For example, sooo many people interested in quantum physics articles - how many bother, even after years, to just go e.g. to edx (https://www.edx.org/learn/quantum-physics-mechanics https://www.edx.org/learn/quantum-physics-mechanics -- or, archived, https://www.edx.org/course/quantum-mechanics-for-everyone https://www.edx.org/course/quantum-mechanics-for-everyone specifically) and just take a course?
- scifibestfi 4y agoWe saw this a lot with Covid. I just hope we learned to be more open minded next time.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoMy man, if covid2 came out of the same… place tomorrow, we would do it all over again. Fear was made into a virtue, and every government body on earth discovered powers they didn’t know they had. It would play out same or worse, no one learned anything.
- poszlem 4y agoI find it baffling that this comment is downvoted so heavily. To me it seems quite spot on, and I wonder what is it that people downvoting it think is incorrect?
- sva_ 4y agoIt worked out well for governments once. I don't see any clear indication that it would again. I think people are tired of - in some cases - arbitrary measures and I wouldn't be so certain that they'd go along with it in the same way. The real bitch of it is, that if we would now be facing a much more dangerous virus, people might not take it seriously enough due to covid turning out to be not as dangerous as initially thought.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWhat kinds of abuse of power did you see lasting on any democratic country? Or even being useful for the powerful?
- scifibestfi 4y agoThe squelching of dissent/free speech and destroying small businesses in favor of large corporations.
- 4y ago