8 ms·
Iran set to freeze bank accounts of women who refuse to wear a hijab
- machina_ex_deus 4y ago
- nh23423fefe 4y agoun-illuminating snark seeking backpats isn't on topic
- more_corn 4y agoI’ve seen this show.
- groffee 4y agoIranians: What do you mean you've seen this? It's brand new!
- dqpb 4y agoBefore anyone starts a flame war, I want to remind you that HN guidelines require you to either respect other people's culture and religion or keep quiet.
- joxel 4y agoThis entire comment is made up, just like the shit they’re forcing on these women.
- dqpb 4y agoSays the person whose been on HN for less than two months. Welcome! If you don't believe me, go ahead and say something reasonable about religion and see where it gets you.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoI've said a bunch of reasonable things about religion, and it didn't get me banned. Occasionally downvoted, never flagged that I recall. I suspect that the issue may be with your definition of "reasonable".
- Gare 4y agoCan you point to where, because I don't see it in guidelines.
- dqpb 4y agoI have directly experienced censorship and harassment by @dang over excessively reasonable critiques of religion. I would link to it, but I've been warned that doing so can get me banned.
- dang 4y agoHere are the moderation replies to your account over the years: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323859 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323859 (Aug 2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323840 (Aug 2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32323721 (Aug 2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29774080 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29774080 (Jan 2022) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24403195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24403195 (Sept 2020) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20032506 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20032506 (May 2019) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19237561 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19237561 (Feb 2019) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19228116 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19228116 (Feb 2019) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17371586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17371586 (June 2018) If you're going to make claims about moderation, it's good to supply links to readers can make up their own minds.
- dqpb 4y agoThank you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Nicksil 4y ago>Before anyone starts a flame war, I want to remind you that HN guidelines require you to either respect other people's culture and religion or keep quiet. It does not.
- nurettin 4y agoNot really, but the HN moderator might find the comment "boring". Usually it is loosely based on the guidelines, but sometimes it is just subjective. Much like the headscarf issues in the middle east.
- rektide 4y agoWhat you propose- either accepting or being quiet- is the least hackerly perspective I have ever heard. This is the most contrary to open society & open debate bit I've heard on HN in a long while and it deserves no respect & deserves clamboring as a threat to civil society. Booo!! Hackers debate & discuss, have opinions. We can appreciate cultures & diversity without agreeing to authoritarian enforced mandates, and we dont have to be quiet when we find behaviors & authority to be disgraceful & out of line. Narrowing down to the topic level, from your gross discharacterization, he hijab specifically is controversial & I think many opinions are due. Even within Iran there is a huge & wide part of the society going on strike & which has been loudly protesting this & other legal impositions as gross & unbefitting. To say that this is the culture denies the population & oppressed any voice. That seems vulgar & inappropriate. The legal imposition of the hijab is not an old culture. It legally began in April 1983. But it was broadly unenforced for a while until the creation of the morality police, for which this was a primary enforcement concern. This was not a longstanding bit of culture, to force everyone to behave this way.
- dqpb 4y agoThank you for expressing exactly how I feel.
- infamouscow 4y agoThe elites want CBDCs to control the masses for reasons like this. It's trivial to crush the people when you control their money.
- 36amxn36 4y agoThis. It appears that only those of us who live in authoritarian countries have learnt this lesson.
- phendrenad2 4y agoPlease explain how CBDCs give governments power they don't currently have?
- infamouscow 4y agoPaper money doesn't magically stop working because some bureaucrat has an axe to grind, or is corrupt. The government not currently having that power is exactly why power-hungry maniacs want CBDCs. Let's say we had CBDCs and the party you don't like wins the 2024 elections. Instead of being able to go protest, now the POTUS declares an emergency and just turns off money for opposition groups, or at restaurants, hotels, and gas stations in an area. Seems like a great way to invite tyranny.
- phendrenad2 4y agoDo you get paid in paper money that your employer doesn't report to the government? Because firstly, that's a crime, and you're risking serious consequences just to meet your definition of freedom, and secondly, very few people can do that (not everyone on earth can be a janitor), and thirdly, if everyone did it the government would crack down on it even harder. So you need to establish that "paper money" is the alternative to CBDC and not, you know, what we have now, which is an almost fully-digital system which the government is free to interfere with in ANY way they see fit INCLUDING each and EVERY negative consequence of CBDC you envision.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maxrev17 4y ago
- notch656a 4y agoNot to blame the victim, but having all of your money in one jurisdiction is like putting all your eggs in one basket. This is why the federal government loves FATCA, as it makes the banking requirements so onerous for US citizens abroad that a foreign bank can only afford to bank a rich US citizen after compliance costs. This is not an accident, and the fact the compliance cost far outweigh any tax benefit yet the burden remains make this crystal clear. Edit: to all the people offended by this comment. Ponder why international banking is infeasible for the domestically banked and then question why that may be and whether the state of things may be for the benefit of governments to better control their populace. Thus you will understand this comment wasn't actually about impugning the common domestic bank account holder but to show some incentives that keep them locked in domestically. If you pointed out why international banking is infeasible then you finally got the point of my comment and perhaps some understanding of why some third world people may be desperate enough to use an evil pyramid scheme environmental wrecking shitcoins like bitcoin or ethereum etc.
- jakub_g 4y agoHaving the ability to keep money is multiple jurisdictions is something that an extremely small % of world's population could achieve. First of all, you almost surely need to go to a trip abroad in person to create a bank account. (So, you need a passport, and money/time). In many countries you can open a bank account only if you're a resident in the country (which creates a catch-22: can't open bank account without an address, can't rent without a bank account). Stuff might be easier if you have a right citizenship (rules are relaxed e.g. in EU and you can open an account in some online banks abroad via a smartphone app), otherwise, good luck. In any case, if you open an account in a bank, and you want to have any serious money there - more than $200 or so - you need to declare in which country you're a taxpayer, and your taxpayer number, and that country authorities get notified. Also when declaring taxes in the country you're a primary resident, there's often a rule that you need to declare all your abroad accounts, equities etc. and if you don't and they find out, you can be fined $$$$$.
- notch656a 4y agoMost already banked people could realistically achieve it if KYC/AML and FATCA-like reporting requirements were eliminated. It is not technically infeasible, but as we both pointed out infeasible due to government imposed limitations.
- 10g1k 4y agoReason #304968204352 why money and economies should not be controlled by central banks or governments.
- AndrewOMartin 4y agoIsn't this more likely to be Reason #1?
- 10g1k 4y agoProbably right.
- nashashmi 4y agoAfter the disbanding of the morality police, they are about to find out what real brutality at the hands of the full police looks like. The morality police was not some violent police force. They were a force who grab, detain, and deliver to another location. Actual punishment (even if rare) was never administered by them, but by a different unit. This is what happens during a color revolution based on falsehood. Things become much worse.
- selimthegrim 4y agoWhat exactly is the point you are trying to make here? Any government with “Islamic” in the name is ulu-ul-amr and gets to kill people for opposing it? When Shias in Zia’s time didn’t want Zakat deducted from their bank accounts and marched in Islamabad would it have been halal to kill them in your book?
- nashashmi 4y agoThat's not at all what I am getting at. I have learned to respect authority I dislike because the alternatives are far worse. And it seems this has proven true in case of Iraq with saddam, Egypt with mubarak, alqaeda vs isil, musharraf in Pakistan vs any other alternatives, Assad in Syria, etc. The alternatives are always worse. Edit: Whats ulu ul amr.
- selimthegrim 4y agohttps://en.wikishia.net/view/Ulu_l-Amr https://en.wikishia.net/view/Ulu_l-Amr
- nashashmi 4y agoIs this why the Iranians hate their religion along with the govt? Because they mix them up as one and the same?
- selimthegrim 4y ago
- eroded 4y ago
- echelon 4y ago> Bitcoin fixed this. No it didn't. Bitcoin lost you 75% YTD, potentially exposed you to FTX-style insolvencies or Binance-style jurisdictional blockages, made it possible to lose your wallet or have it hacked, etc. The only thing to blame here is the brutal regime. A regime which could easily take away all of your bitcoin, regardless of where it lives, with the mere application of a metal pipe to your limbs or forehead. Until crypto faces heavy regulation and gains better rails for the recovery of losses, it will remain a poor instrument for the average person.
- superkuh 4y agoYep. The failures of traditional markets when applied to non-cryptocurrency representations of cryptocurrency are legion. There have been so many classical finance scams hiding behind cryptocurrency buzzwords that most people mistake the market scams for Bitcoin itself.
- notpushkin 4y agoRegulation by whom? Obviously not Iran (and definitely not my home country's dictatorship), but why would I trust the US or any other government not to become bad in the coming years?
- echelon 4y ago> Regulation by whom? Every single government. If you have a business that interfaces with crypto and the citizens of any country, then you have obligations to comply with each jurisdiction's rules. Crypto has been shown time and time again to have rough edges. I would expect every government to eventually evolve protective legislation, mostly to safeguard the non-institutional class from being taken advantage of.
- notpushkin 4y ago
- bushbaba 4y agoHow many woman in Iran have bank accounts. It’s not like woman have full western working rights for woman. E.g: “Husbands have the right to prevent wives from working in particular occupations and some positions require the husband's written consent”
- rocketbop 4y agoI don't know numbers, but I would think many - for example my partner who is Iranian lived and worked in Iran before emigrating and she certainly had a bank account. How else would she be paid? Iran has many problems, and I would love nothing more than the fall of the regime, but it's not as restrictive as you're suggesting, despite the morality police.
- seunosewa 4y agoNot yet.
- jakub_g 4y agoI'd like to get reporting on that subject from a reliable source not linked to cr&pto. Otherwise it sounds like pro-cr&pto FUD.
- Maximus9000 4y agoBest I can find is this: https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-hijab-alternative-punishment-jalali-protests/32164681.html https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-hijab-alternative-punishment-ja...
- jakub_g 4y agoThank you.
- brink 4y agoLike how we freeze bank accounts of protesting truck drivers and "right wing extremists"? We should be blushing, as imitation is a form of flattery. Or are we going to pretend to be shocked and appalled here, because it's only okay when we do it?
- mywittyname 4y agoThe issue isn't the punishment, it's the crime. There are many crimes for which freezing ones bank account is a pretty good idea. On the list of crimes that this is an inappropriate punishment would be: refusing to wear a piece of fabric on your head for the arbitrary reason that some book says it should be so. I want the punishments to fit the crime. I'm okay with murders going to jail. I'm not okay with jay walkers going to jail.
- chrismcb 4y agoMost crimes are a crime "because some book says it should be" that book is typically a law book, but still.
- version_five 4y agoThen wait until you hear how Canada handled peaceful protestors
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- joifw 4y ago
- akiselev 4y agoSpotted the absolutist. That’s how you tell the difference between a philosopher and theologian.
- 4y ago
- MrPatan 4y agoBlame Canada
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoYep! Also, somehow, after two years of calling anyone protesting for basic rights (anti-lockdown protests) a covid denier, an idiot, grandma killer, etc. we've gone to "brave protesters" in china.
- mrguyorama 4y agoI'm sorry how is canada responsible for a despotic regime thinking a head scarf should be a legal requirement?
- ars 4y agoSee this reply: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33900732 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33900732
- gptadmirer 4y agoTime and time again it is proven that we need crypto, despite the various scandals that came out with it (and the scandals were mostly CEX). Not your keys, not your coins. Not your printers, not your money. Not your server, not your numbers.
- Maximus9000 4y agoMods, is this thread hijacked? the quality of comments in here is exceptionally poor for HN.
- fjweoijf 4y ago
- Maximus9000 4y agoYour account was created 5 minutes ago yet you talk like you know all about HN
- at_a_remove 4y agoI strike the buzzer and murmur "What is a sockpuppet, Alex?"
- InitialLastName 4y agoIf you have a main account on HN that isn't a brand new throwaway, you're literally not speaking for yourself by using an alt here.
- samcheng 4y agoAgreed - it seems like HN got brigaded here. I very much value a diverse discussion forum, and am happy to see “alt-right” viewpoints in this thread, but it’s very unusual to see those viewpoints expressed in a flood of low-effort posts. Something’s afoot.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoThere's not much effort needed. The comparison to Canada is obvious. This is completely new tactic for dictatorships. What else do you expect to be said? At this point you either contort in various ways to fit the narrative or you stand by a consistent set of values. To me personally, hypocrisy is the worst ideological crime. It's always possible to construct a narrative, the harder thing to do is realizing when your values collide with your 'interest' or political side and standing by your values instead of the easy choice of picking the narrative. If your moral values only ever happened to be on your side, you don't have values, you have excuses.
- warbler73 4y agoUS to follow in some way, not hijabs, but some other issue.
- phendrenad2 4y agoWell this is shitty, but it's a huge step forward from beating people in the streets, so you have to respect that at least.
- rektide 4y agoWe wont physically hurt you but we'll end your ability to participate in the economy in any way & steal all your money does not seem like the upgrade you seem to be saying it is. Wont these people all starve?
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoPeople in the streets can atleast fight back... or run away and hide... with this now, what can you even do?
- nashashmi 4y agoThe morality police was not some violent police force. They were a force who grab, detain, and deliver to another location. Actual punishment (even if rare) was never administered by them, but by a different unit.
- Hizonner 4y ago... which kinda shows why maybe governments worldwide shouldn't have normalized going after people's money as the first response to enforcing anything, and why building surveillance and control infrastructure for that isn't necessarily a hot idea.