19 ms·
Automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer and fewer employees
- notlukesky 4y agoIt is important to point out that this is only possible for the consumer app economy or a self-service type of software app or digital marketplace (like craigslist). Everything else requires more headcount (could be outsourced to 3rd parties or consultants). And in the whole economy this is a sliver of companies. This is a great business of course but there are not many of them given the scale of the whole economy. Before the Internet, the closest to this was creators or inventors living off of patents, license or copyright fees.
- LeonM 4y ago> This is a great business of course but there are not many of them given the scale of the whole economy. This is a very good point to emphasize. Most readers here on HN work in IT and are thus inherently biased. The reality is that the majority businesses rely on having a workforce of humans.
- czbond 4y agoI wholly disagree. SaaS are similar to automations for end customers. The CapEx spend of tens/hundreds of engineers that built the SaaS is offset by 1 company to remove the needed engineers from each company. Companies used to: build their own authentication layers, databases, infrastructure, code repositories,etc, etc. What starts in consumer always moves to Enterprise. So will AI and automations.
- notlukesky 4y agoMaybe it wasn't clear but I was referring to low-touch SaaS as well with "self-service type of software app". There are low-touch SaaS apps and offerings serving the developer and some "enterprise" market segments. The problem with certain enterprise SaaS is that they are high-touch by the very nature of the sales process involving big-ticket items. Once you are in the territory of high ACV there are many sales "gatekeepers" ranging from pay-to-play analyst coverage, Vegas conferences and outings, tickets to NFL games, to compliance and regulatory hurdles. I should have also mentioned hedge funds who manage billions with relatively few head count and they use automation tools extensively starting with the spreadsheet in the 1980s.
- ghaff 4y agoAnd chasing down purchase orders and higher expectations for customer support and, once you have direct sales, you need training for sales, and you have to generate qualified leads for them, and you have to respond to RFPs...
- czbond 4y agoThanks for the response. I upvoted because your comment added value.
- satvikpendem 4y agoJust so you know, you don't have to mention that you upvoted, it's actually recommended that people don't do that here, so that we don't get tons of comments like "thanks" which can make it frustrating for others to wade through such comments for the value added ones, as you mention.
- czbond 4y agoThanks for the response. I upvoted because your comment added value.
- yobbo 4y agoNot really. Any business can now use tools that make jobs redundant. It is having its effect everywhere. Anyone whose job is to copy information between mails, spreadsheets, and some webapp will eventually be replaced. There are more "psychological gotchas" among non-software people about what "real jobs" are and what it means to create value, but time catches up with everyone.
- FredPret 4y agoI’m creating a startup. I’m the first and only employee, and likely to remain that way for the foreseeable future. What would have taken an army of clerks in the past is now a (lot) of code. Whole departments are replaced by API’s that cost less than $100/month. It’s really incredible.
- bluelightning2k 4y agoCould you give some examples? Congratulations on your success implementing this stuff
- FredPret 4y agoCongratulate me when it finally works out! I’m still in stealth mode. My startup is super simple in concept - I gather a particular type of data, clean it, process it, and serve it to subscribers. Some of my data sources are free, some are paid API’s. All the processing is done in code. You would need an army of people to read all that text, a layer of bureaucracy to manage and check them.
- thedorkknight 4y agoCan I ask what your pricing model is?
- FredPret 4y agoThis is the end state I envision: I offer a bunch of value for free in exchange for an email. Value is delivered on web and per email. There is no marketing over email, it just serves as a regular touchpoint (where I email them free value) to keep the relationship alive until my client is ready to upgrade. Then there’s a couple of paid tiers which is the same but with more and different features. Starting at $10/month, up to $50 - $100 per month. For perspective, the service can be worth many thousands of times this much in dollars gained for the client, so it may be the wrong model altogether. I’ve test-driven different aspects of this to see if people would be interested. I might announce it here when I officially launch it, but probably not.
- yetanotherforg 4y agoBased on his argument: Fewer people are doing a lot more thanks to being good at automation. It's the automation that's making it possible to be successful, not the engineers doing the automation. The past three years, the YC crowd has really tried hard to justify wealth disparities, gentrification and generally treating employees like garbage, as part of their Objectivist agenda. Paul, employees do the automation, not the founders.
- CalRobert 4y agoI don't follow? Lots of technical founders create their own automations.
- yetanotherforg 4y agoHis whole point is: There is a lot of great free open source software being exploited by small technical teams to run faster. This means the people doing the integration deserve less $$ because they can do the same amount with less. Founders deserve all the money, everybody else should be happy to be employed. 1920s robber baron bs. Ignore the ethics that every single startup would be impossible without standing on the heads of those who have dedicated many hours of their lives building this free software.
- robertlagrant 4y agoWhere does he mention open source? And using open source software is not standing on anyone's head.
- yetanotherforg 4y agoWhere do you think all of that automation comes from? I promise you, every single start-up you know of is violating somebody's copyrights on their open source. I've seen this in every company I've worked with for the past 30 years. There is always code inside of private applications which was copied and pasted from GPL'd code.
- heisenbit 4y agoIf founding work is so simple then founders should be interchangeable? Where is the moat that ensures what two handful of people cobbled together is not replicated? Isn't it that the real moat and the real propelling force becomes more and more the capital leveraged?
- wittycardio 4y agoMost Founders are interchangeable. The entire business of YC is paying for a ton of people to found a ton of companies and hoping one hits. Luck is a huge factor. The issue is the 1 guy that does hit has an outsize impact on society. Sometimes it's positive but often it's not.
- dandanua 4y agoIt's frightening that people "at the top" write those things without even realizing how it sounds for ordinary people. I think this delusion is on par with Marie Antoinette and her "eat cakes if you don't have bread".
- beardyw 4y agoWhat happened to the future, a 3 day week for all as computers/machines did the work.
- LeonM 4y agoBecause of the competitive nature of business (and humans). If you can build a factory that can build products more efficiently, it means you can sell them cheaper then your competitors, meaning you can move more volume and thus make more profit. So you are definitely not going to run that new shiny factory for only 3 days a week. Eventually, competitors will notice your improved output and react with their own improved factory. If you sit still in your shiny new factory, you will eventually be outpaced by competitors as they catch up. In the end though, the throughput per human is greatly increased as computers and machines do (most of) the work. This has increased prosperity greatly. Unless you can accept living with less then the competition, you are not going to work less then your competitors.
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> So you are definitely not going to run that new shiny factory for only 3 days a week. 3/8 is a thing in factories, so you could have just hired more employees part/lower time. It’s a cultural artefact that we work 40 hours a week.
- LeonM 4y agoAgain, it is due to competitive nature. Nobody is forcing you to work a 40h week, but because 40 hours is about the average of how many hours people work, you'll need to match that to stay 'competitive'. It's a very primitive instinct in natural selection. For people earning average wage, they often cannot afford to work less hours, as prices of commodities (housing, food, energy) are naturally regulated by what people can afford. Because most of their peers work 40 hours, they need to do the same in order to be able to pay their bills. Those that make more than average wage could afford to work less, yet most people chose not to do that. Because now that you make a lot of money, you could still work 40 hours and get a bigger house then your neighbor! And a faster car! You could impress a potential partner with that, which increases your chance of reproduction and creating (w/h)ealthy offspring. No amount of automation, computers, machines or whatever technology will prevent people from staying competitive. edit: replaced 'minimum wage' with 'average wage', because cost of living is highly location dependent.
- bluelightning2k 4y agoThis isn't new. There's been 4 industrial revolutions. But the most obvious example is electricity. People's output in certain roles immediately compounded and the long tail of this never really stopped (it was a precursor to the internet and AI ofc) Where fields had to be toiled there was space for little else. But now people can scale their impact in interesting new ways
- ceronman 4y agoHe is implying that founders can create a lot of value without employees, and that the claim that employees also create value is false. If that's true, then what about a social experiment: If you are a solo founder, you get all your profits for yourself. But if you have employees, you have to share your profits with your employees. If employees don't produce any value, easy, fire them all, you get everything. But if they do, share your profits fairly. I'm curious to see how many solo billionaires will appear. My estimated guess: zero.
- jtgi 4y agoNo, negating “employees created all the value” does not mean, “founders create all the value”. It means employees didn’t.
- adamsmith143 4y agoSo who is the magical missing third party that created value?
- some_furry 4y agoThe exploited consumers that give up all their sweet sweet data to the surveillance capitalism complex?
- pyb 4y agoWho said anything about a third party?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- achenet 4y agore-read the comment you're replying to: employees didn't create ALL the value. In other words, founders created some as well. :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kasperset 4y agoAutomation always reminds of this quote from Jurassic Park: " John Hammond: You're right. You're absolutely right. Hiring Nedry was a mistake, that's obvious. We're over-dependent on automation. I can see that now. Now, the next time, everything is correctible... "
- fredgrott 4y agoI would state fewer named employees, not fewer employees as the people creating the infrastructure automation was still employees of you in both focus and impact, etc. Saying that they do not exist is just inviting being blind-sided by movements in that automation beyond your control.
- tluyben2 4y agoThis is fine as long as this type of automation and less dependence opens up more founders making more products doing more for humanity.
- spicymaki 4y agoI don't know if I want to bet my life on that.
- ThePhysicist 4y agoGiven the current market I'd say you have to achieve some basic success before hiring anyone, at least if you're bootstrapping. From my experience it's quite difficult to find early-stage employees that are both affordable and good enough to handle the breadth of technical tasks needed in the early phase of a business. So, yeah, automation can take away a lot of pain, and how far you can get really depends on how well you automate specific aspects of your business. My takeaway after several SaaS products is that you have to optimize for minimal customer interaction from the start, otherwise you'll drown in support requests once you hit product-market fit. Stuff like billing, subscription management etc. should be solvable in self-service processes for customers, and if you see a speficic support issue more than 5 times in a given week you should ask yourself if you can automate it away or change the product so it won't happen again.
- theturtletalks 4y agoI automated my e-commerce business and turned that into a SaaS. Found customers organically and have become my own “customer” multiple times. Solo founders like me are on the rise and you’d be surprised how far a little automation can take a business.
- adamsmith143 4y ago
- type-r 4y ago> Solo founders like me are on the rise source?
- swyx 4y agoThis is clear to anyone with freshman macroeconomics - The Cobb-Douglas function for factor productivity: Y = A * L^β * K^α Value of your work depends on how well you wield capital (K) and labor (L). Code, Cloud and AI have massively improved α while β is at generational lows.
- tareqak 4y agoThank you for mentioning something new to me: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobb–Douglas_production_function https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobb–Douglas_production_functi... .
- galangalalgol 4y agoWhy do you think the output elasticity for labor is low? Is it a case of having to work a certain number of hours to get medical care? Is it the price of medical care? It seems like modern tools and automation would help it be higher?
- dukoid 4y agoHasn't this been the case since the first machine or even tool was invented?
- baxtr 4y agoHmm, so his example is Instagram. But Instagram was sold to FB, sorry Meta!, in 2012. Where are the new examples of that kind of startup? 13 employees selling for 1bn USD.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoMusical.ly to Bytedance? And Qualcomm buying Nuvia?
- baxtr 4y agoGood examples. Didn't know that Qualcomm was so small
- tareqak 4y agohttps://twitter.com/IlariKaila/status/1600120645211201536 https://twitter.com/IlariKaila/status/1600120645211201536 Ilari Kaila @IlariKaila · 1h Replying to @paulg Why did you delete this banger? <Screenshot of a now deleted tweet by @paulg with the words: “Automation is an inductive proof that Marx was wrong”> | | | Paul Graham @paulg · 1h Replying to @IlariKaila I forgot that mentioning Marx attracts angry fools. Since I could make my point without mentioning him, I just reposted it without.
- bentlegen 4y agoI always find this take that innovation wouldn’t happen in a non-capitalist society very strange, as if humanity hadn’t produced countless innovations before modern constructs like the corporation existed. I also think its incredulous to focus on one (admittedly, very) positive outcome of capitalism without acknowledging its externalities, like pollution, inequality, etc. I suppose pg believes the current system will lead to a post-scarcity society in which none of those exist. Perhaps that’s true, but I hope the planet survives long enough to get there.
- VictorPath 4y agoIt's not like a socialist country could invent things like a satellite, and be the society that figures out how to send a man into space, probes to the moon and other planets - oh yaa, a socialist country is the first country to figure out those things.
- VictorPath 4y agoActually Marx talked a lot about automation. Marx's prediction was this would lead to a lower rate of profit for invested capital which - mainstream establishment sources say is what has been happening.
- bowsamic 4y agoYes I have no idea why Paul would say this. I guess he realised he was wrong and thus he deleted it, but he won’t admit that. So many people online who make fun of Marx haven’t read any of Capital
- VictorPath 4y agoIt's a strawman argument for founders, but I am fairly sure it is made out of ignorance. Let's say a sole founder buys $100,000 worth of Amazon Cloud, Nvidia cards, smartphones etc. Yes, one person is at the company, but others made those goods. The founder may not have directly exploited the person who made the smartphone they're using, but someone did. Also, let's say I sell my small company which is well positioned in a fast growing market. The buyers are not buying based on what happened before, but on the future work and revenues that will be acquired from people working on the product. At the end of the day there are people who work and create wealth and get a wage or salary, and there are idle class heir LPs who do not work or create wealth. The heirs survive on the wealth created in expropriated, unpaid surplus labor time of workers who do work. VCs front for the LPs, and founders deal with the VCs. I don't think Graham even knows what he is arguing with. I'm not trying to make a convincing argument for the other side, but a clarifying one. Incidentally, pretty much every economist up until the mid 19th century agreed with my view in some form - Adam Smith, Benjamin Franklin, David Ricardo - all the people who made economic arguments which economists still use. They said they studied political economy. It wasn't until the 1870s that arguments against new value being created by labor were started in full swing, although some of the ideas go back to the 1830s.
- psychomugs 4y agoHis apparently original post, "automation is an inductive proof that Marx was wrong," along with that recent pseudophilosophical essay about "wanting what you want (to want)^n," concerns me as to whether he's jumped the shark.
- stephc_int13 4y agoI think PG is extrapolating/speculating a lot here. Most of the "big tech" companies have surprising amount of employee, even pure players.
- fvdessen 4y agoThat’s a very short term vision. The founders and VCs are not any less automatable than their employees. I guess we’ll se how dearly they hold those beliefs when the AIs will own all the wealth
- dandanua 4y agoIn the limit case, you're left with just the automated founders.
- milicat 4y agoA capitalist fever dream to justify how valuable he is to society. Of course, he completely ignores the labour going into the entire supply chain that enables this level of automation. It's full of underpaid workers likely including some living under slavery-like conditions or in authoritarian dictatorships that don't even live up to his free-market ideals.
- Slavaqua 4y agoTotally, you still hear that feudals didn't deserve to be rich, because serfs created all the value. But the falsity of this claim become obvious as enclosures enabled feudals to use fewer and fewer serfs on their land.
- alexanderballou 4y agoI think it's also worth considering that automation will enable founders to grow companies with less and less funding.
- moolcool 4y agoIf we're going to devalue and degrade the labour of anybody who isn't "founder" because of its ability to be automated, then let's follow the thread to its logical conclusion and say that it's the only VCs who really "create value". Just as AI will be able to take the legwork out of turning a concept into code, coming up with these concepts might well be an even easier task to automate. Of course though, it takes a wise human to know which AI generated concept to fund, and in that spirit, let's all put our hands together for the billionaires who will define this future for is. Really give it up!
- adamsmith143 4y agoWhy not go all the way and replace the fallible, gullible, arrogant human VCs with much smarter AI VCs who can determine which AI generated companies are likely to succeed with higher fidelity?
- moolcool 4y agoI think the more social/political/financial power possessed by the individual threatened by AI, the more resistance there will be to them being disrupted by it. Like look at tech's smug responses to truckers concerned about self driving, and contrast that to the perspective this tweet has toward everybody in tech except for founders. He's literally just insulating a ruling class. This class dynamic is so deeply ironic coming from someone who literally said that "automation is inductive proof that Marx was wrong". It's the opposite!
- thundergolfer 4y ago> "automation is inductive proof that Marx was wrong" He really said that? Plugging it into Google yields no results. That's a really dumb thing to say, a very tech billionaire misunderstanding of Marx.
- moolcool 4y agoHe did, in a now deleted tweet. He verifies the screenshots veracity in the replies. https://twitter.com/IlariKaila/status/1600120645211201536 https://twitter.com/IlariKaila/status/1600120645211201536
- ojbyrne 4y agoI feel like he’s missing the second order effect. If everyone can automate everything, then there would have been (or will be) 900 Instagrams and 1 (or 20) that would have had a $1000 exit.
- tartoran 4y agoEarly automators will obviously leave roadblocks behind them, new regulations regarding automation, etc.
- adamsmith143 4y agoMore fever dreams from the pus filled mind of PG. Imagine thinking employees create no value for a startup. The guy has been drinking his own piss for far too long.
- neilv 4y ago> You still occasionally hear people saying that founders don't deserve to be rich, because their employees created all the value. What I actually hear people saying (including at least one person from YC) is that founders need to share the potential wealth more fairly with early hires. With various rationales, including that execution is everything: having an idea and raising money for it isn't execution -- and the founders need the early hires to execute successfully. > But the falsity of this claim becomes increasingly obvious as automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer and fewer employees. I'm not following the logic, but the initial assertion seems like it'd tend to be received sloppily, anyway. Whether founders deserve to be rich seems like a diversion from the usual question: why do founders with a successful exit get rich when employees get even less than they would've been guaranteed at a non-startup tech job. > In the limit case, you're left with just the founders. And we're not far from it. Instagram had only 13 employees when it was sold for a billion dollars. So share the wealth with those 13 employees. "I have an idea for site/app" and getting some funding isn't worth a billion dollars. Successful execution is. > And a billion was if anything below market price. People mocked that deal at the time, but in retrospect it was a bargain. Isn't part of the job of those founders to make sure the exit is at market value? Were the wealth spread around more evenly, so that everyone who made the success possible can get rich, the founders might have more motivation to get a good price. :) (I suppose that an exception to this would be if a startup is actually closer to an investment scam, propped up by other startups in a portfolio as customers, and they expect all the workers involved to do only mechanical tasks in which individual creativity/ideas/brilliance/etc. doesn't significantly affect the success of the company.)
- tartoran 4y ago> why do founders with a successful exit get rich when employees get even less than they would've been guaranteed at a non-startup tech job This is the question that if addressed would fix the whole startup scammyness and exploitation. But then it may as well kill startups.
- PinguTS 4y agoThis is this thinking of "Automation reduces workforce". The next argument then is always "We need Basic Income" because of this. But this is ignoring the fact that automation never replaced workforce as such. It moved the focus of the workforce. At the end more automation even required more workforce. The thing is, you cannot engineer the process to be automated. You need to keep maintaining the automation. This includes not only daily maintenance, but also to keep up with obsolescence. You need to keep-up with new upcoming technologies of automation to replace your old once. But all this distracts and takes-away focus on the development of you product. So you need workforce to basically run your business, while you can still stay focused. But even then you can't stay focused, because it is also your job to decide what newer automation processes to chose. As this will have an impact on your own product. That again takes away you focus for the development of you product. So again you need workforce to help you to stay focused. At some point you need workforce to manage your workforce namely HR. So there is a cycle when you get more and more workforce so that you stay focused to develop your product. All that of course assuming that you need to develop your product even further after launch.
- lancesells 4y agoHow many people here have simpler jobs than 10-20 years ago due to automation? I work in marketing and I all I see is more apps and more complexity no matter how "automated" things get.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoI'm a developer and honestly ChatGPT and GitHub copilot handle 90 percent of the frontend/templates and 40 percent of my code is now somehow enriched by ai. It's remarkable and has helped cut way back on burnout.
- eulers_secret 4y agoExactly! These tools are force multipliers. 1 dev can do the work of 3. If this is the case, a business should absolutely lay off 2/3 of their eng staff. If they don’t, their competitors will and then will eat their lunch! No more lazy devs, they should be at their desks working all 8 required hours as they agreed to in their contract. If they’re not: you have too many staff.
- foul 4y agoI can't do anything but reject his claims when he presents Instagram as proof. It's crazy to think seriously that the value was created by the 13 employees + founder of an electronic glossy billboard. Influencers and advertisers indirectly treated as cattle. Goddammit Paul.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ohyes 4y agoWell, it requires fewer more skilled employees. Employees some of whom could be founders themselves and compete with you. So despite the number of employees being lower, their opportunity cost is likely similar or higher, just more concentrated. Therefore what you’d have to pay them if they were negotiating rationally is similar to what you’d pay multiple people. The limit here is an edge case, it’s like dividing by zero. Sure if you can automate everything the founder gets all the profit. If you only have 1 employee, however, that single employee is immeasurably valuable and has some incredible leverage on you (you’re screwed if they walk). There’s a net benefit to the employer to having a certain amount of redundancy. So this whole argument (to me) toes the line of sophistry. It just gets a big eyeroll and me thinking Paul is out of touch.
- vishnugupta 4y ago> automation enables founders to grow companies with fewer and fewer employees. For sure, it's easier to launch a product with no employees. However, the challenge is to grow. That's when founders' run out of ability/patience to coax more out of automation tool. Edge cases appear more often; systems start breaking down; tools don't have meet their exact need anymore etc., That's when they start hiring these "tool experts". SAP consultants, AWS certified DevOps, Stripe Integration Engineers and so on. Also, at scale maintenance starts becoming a bigger challenge compared to new feature/product launch. So one needs to hire maintainers. As David Graeber astutely observed a glass cup needs to be produced just once but must be washed thousand times. Let's not forget one needs employees to maintain automation tools too. I can cite plenty of real world examples but let's just look at Uber. For an outsider it seems like a tech company but internally it is run by a massive operations team. They are constantly in touch with drivers, address their problems, move drivers around to meet higher demand, map operations and so on. What is happening however is these SAP consultants are paid significantly less compared to their Business Analyst (or equivalent domain expert) counterparts. So in some ways profit is being cornered. All that said this is an extremely narrow view about IT sector. Look around; EV, solar energy, genetics, and so on. No automation happening there. If IT sector needs less employees, then it's only for good! Skilled labor is needed elsewhere too.
- Devasta 4y agoThe employees are still there, just because they are in an AWS facility instead of two doors down from you doesn't mean they don't exist.
- encoderer 4y agoI can attest that we’ve grown a SaaS a lot bigger with 3 people than I ever would have thought possible.
- memish 4y agoPaul Graham founded this site. How did it end up being so hostile to founders?
- satvikpendem 4y agoIt's become a more general site for tech employees rather than founders. Notice how most of the comments are employees talking about how this kind of opinion affects them. To be honest, I don't know where founders reside these days, Indie Hackers was a good site but it has a lot of spam and people posting links with little discussion nowadays.
- reducesuffering 4y agoIf you can get into YC, then BookFace.
- p0pcult 4y agoBecause people woke up from the fiction that venture capital is about making the world a better place.
- oblio 4y agoAs p0pcult said, people realized that VC is about concentrating wealth. As a counter example, Microsoft's IPO made a few billionaires and tens of thousands (!) of millionaires, and that was in 1986 (so take inflation into account, it's been 36 years). How many of these modern exits have made the lives of so many so good, with all the dilutions?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI will admit that I assumed a lot before I read the whole thing ( I was kinda hoping it will be more about automation ), but I guess it goes back to the opening statement: << You still occasionally hear people saying that founders don't deserve to be rich, because their employees created all the value. I don't hear that a lot. I see 'Eat the rich memes', guillotine pics popping up on various community sites. PG may be very limited in his view to VC-land only ( and if that is all he is talking about, he may well be right ), but if he is making a statement intended for general public, lets talk about not getting the current mood. The argument itself seems off, but I am having a harder time finding where it fails.
- ausbah 4y agoautomation only scales to a certain point though? after a certain point of scale it makes sense to do something in house & save money at the margin right? automation seems great for small companies & solo founders, but kind of an open question if that gets you to unicorn status
- paxys 4y agoIt's easy to make any argument sound valid when you tout the extreme outliers (Instagram & WhatsApp in this case). What about the average case? What percentage of founders have grown their company to $100M+ revenue or $1B+ valuation on the backs of "automation" (whatever that is)?
- spicymaki 4y agoFeudalism without the serfs. What is in it for the plebs? The idea that concentrated wealth is great for everyone and will trickle down has been pretty much debunked to the point where the wealthy are openly stating we don't need the masses anymore. The crypto dystopian nightmare of generating money with zero utility backed by quantitative easing demonstrates that you don't actually need many employees to generate wealth. You don't even need commerce, financial engineering will suffice. Employment is a social contract. Business owners and investors (who control capital) are supposed to provide a means for the masses to live in comfort, the employees give there labor and time in return. The wealthy get to live in their mansions, vacation on their yachts, etc. We get to buy our homes in the suburbs, raise our families, etc. What happens when no one works and humans are removed from the value chain?
- jmagoon 4y agoMassive social upheaval that the super wealthy think they are immune from, even when they are directly responsible for its creation.
- cal85 4y ago> The idea that concentrated wealth is great for everyone and will trickle down has been pretty much debunked Can you point to an example of someone claiming that concentrated wealth is great for everyone and will trickle down?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skinnymuch 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trickle-down_economics There’s lots of people saying it and have said it. We just had tax cuts for the wealthy recently.
- jahewson 4y agoLiz Truss, who brought in tax cuts for the highest earners based on this idea, and as a result lasted only 45 days as prime minister of the U.K. See also: Margaret Thatcher, Ronald Regan.
- altacc 4y agoIf his example is Instagram then the lesson is that you didn't use to need many employees to get rich via venture capital and buy out, which are the main goals of many tech founders. Instagram and tech in the early 2010s is not a company or sector that represents the wider economy. Instagram in 2012 had 30 million active users and zero revenue. That's $0 value earned per employee; these days it's just under $2 million per employee. The scale is vastly different and they couldn't still be running with so few employees. And let's not forget that Instagram was bought as it was seen as a threat to facebook. That it was seen as worth a billion dollars is exactly the problem that many people are referring to about creating overnight billionaires but overvaluing digital companies, which would be worth much less if they were brick & mortar companies. That said, there are a lot of great tools out that that allow people to run companies with off the shelf software and no code applications, which I think have the potential to make a bigger impact on software development than AI. Companies using new technology to become more efficient is nothing new, it's as old as work itself. The steam engine automated a lot of work but still required workers, just like automation tools require another company's employees to build. Growth creates more employment and automation moves those roles elsewhere. The problem is more that those employees that the enriched founder does need working for them are disrespected and paid badly as they are seen as just cogs in the machine who should be happy for the breadcrumbs tossed to them. Doesn't matter how many employees you have, if the founder is getting rich they can afford to pay their staff well.
- v3ss0n 4y agoChatGPT would enable founders to Solo soon.
- PaulWaldman 4y agoThis reflects increased maturity and thus the transition to more specialized labor. It is akin to early craftsmen assembling cars and transitioning to assembly lines. Automation tools that provide APIs to allow founders to increase their leverage are produced by other developers who specialize in said tools. Ideally, this allows the most efficient use of resources, everybody wins. Those who are great at building tools can do so and these tools can be used by many organizations. Pessimistically, there are some who get squeezed out of the production equation. Should a startup develop their own accounting system? Unless they are in accounting, probably not. But there will hopefully become a point where a founder needs to bring in resources, internal or external, to manage the accounting system. This is a further extension of that.
- FpUser 4y agoI have a company with my own product. I wrote software, rented servers, designed hardware and placed orders to a couple of small factories. I have partner but he mostly handles business matters. No employees. We do hire contractors every once in a while for particular sporadic jobs (like design pics for website, create campaign page, assemble hardware from parts etc. etc). So yes no employees thanks to technological advancements.
- not_gpt4 4y agoAs Peter Thiel has pointed out, the reality is that founders take on incredible amounts of risk and put in long hours to build and grow their companies. American exceptionalism is founded on the principle of rewarding hard work and entrepreneurship, and founders who succeed in building successful companies should be celebrated, not demonized.
- thundergolfer 4y ago> on incredible amounts of risk These days 9/10 founders only take on opportunity risk. In real terms, they take on a tiny amount of risk. Undocumented immigrants on the other hand, that's risk. Astronauts, yep, an incredible amount of risk. Founders, no, just hard work.
- jahewson 4y agoWe’re talking about financials here so it’s referring to financial risk. A highly-qualified and skilled founder is forgoing the guaranteed opportunity to make $1m+ in the time they choose instead to work on their startup. They also risk harming their future earning potential and career prospects if they don’t already have a track record of success. A low-paid worker in this imaginary situation isn’t risking much of anything financially as they’ll (hopefully) get minimum wage either way. (In practice a lot of small businesses owners use debt and that is where the financial risk lies for them).
- iamdbtoo 4y agoWhile employees at startups don't take on the exact same risks as the founder, they do take on personal risks when joining one and I think the reason founders are demonized is because they regulary ignore this fact, especially when it comes time to divvy up the cash.
- Joel_Mckay 4y ago22/23 founders ride their company into the ground, or hit the $100k/year marginal profit glass-ceiling. This remains true regardless of the amount of investment in time, labor, and or infrastructure. If you don't talk to people that know these facts, than you are almost guaranteed to repeat the same tantalizing yet bad choices. Automation only tends to make things more feasible, but sometimes bankrupts the firm in the process. Cheers =)
- throwaway5874 4y agoI tried to hire a few freelancers to do nothing but collect information from stores. Easiest job and offered good pay but no takers. I dumped the idea and since then i work on ideas that require no outsiders hand. I refreshed my machine learning skills and using it to solve my problems or else i just deliver half baked product.no intention of hiring anyone period.
- acaloiar 4y ago> You still occasionally hear people saying that founders don't deserve to be rich, because their employees created all the value. Nobody is saying this. As evidenced by several threads here, opinions are far more nuanced.
- fleddr 4y agoGraham will always defend founders "deserving" their wealth, as if it is some technical argument rather than a political one. It's an entirely subjective point. If a solo founder with some very powerful machinery (cloud, AI) produces a lot of economical value, it's quite questionable to attribute that value solely to the human being pushing the button. Even more so when that human has exclusive access to the key input for the machine: capital. Somehow all investment capital has ended up in the hands of about 100 people, which is then gatekept and redistributed to founders "advancing society" with unfortunate side effect it producing even more money for the people that can't seem to get rid of it. Surely that starting point, that capital concentration, is justified based on pure merit and brilliance, these people being a 100.000 times smarter than the average person? Or was it because they were insiders of the financial system, riding the bust and booms of our perverted stock market whilst producing zero tangible value? As for the point of labor, you operate machinery largely based on open source. For which you will not pay a cent whilst said open source maintainers can barely make ends meet and instead of praise, gets lemons. As for your fancy AI model, you trained it on other people's labor, and again refuse to compensate. And yet still you dare to claim that all this value produced is yours to keep. As for "advancing society", we can take a clue from China. They concluded that whilst SV for sure pumps around a lot of money, it's frankly a joke. Tech that produces addiction and ads, undermines employees (Uber, food delivery), externalizing all negatives to society as "people that add value" tend to do. So China killed most of the sector and refocuses on serious tech. Tech focusing on actual human needs. Supply chain, health, mobility, infrastructure. I know, weird concept. Bottom line, if I were a filthy rich founder, I'd totally shut up about it and hope nobody notices.
- threeseed 4y agoGraham only seems to defend the successful founders. He doesn’t seem to care very much about employees who have their own side projects or aspiring founders.
- fleddr 4y agoOf course he doesn't, he's a billionaire venture capitalist. No billionaire cares about fair value contributed because that idea is incompatible with the idea of being a billionaire.
- alangibson 4y agoPG is one of the most important bishops of the Cult of the Founder. This is more of the same. We should recognize that he, by popularizing this world view, has done as much as anyone to empower the SBFs of the world.
- swellguy 4y agoWeird space to wade into, as wealth inequality is no joke worthy of tweets.
- revskill 4y agoOne important thing to know, is knowledge sharing actually creates value. But yes, a company will increase its value internally if it has culture of sharing.
- d00mer 4y agoDoesn't the "automation" usually mean hordes of low-paid people in India and elsewhere doing it?
- snowwrestler 4y agoThis is specific to startups. If you can define a business model that is somewhat unique and successful, you can scale really quickly and hopefully exit before your expenses catch up to you, like Instagram and WhatsApp did. Expenses eventually catch up with you, because business is adversarial. Any technology available cheaply to you to scale your business is also available cheaply to your competitors. Once other smart people start going after your market share, you will need to spend more to defend it and continue to grow. Expensive things: invention, sales, marketing, customer service, compliance, content moderation, etc. These all have to be done by humans. A lot of companies who scaled their revenue rapidly with low head count, have then had to scale their headcount to maintain their business. (Google, Facebook, Netflix, etc) The founder with no employees is for sure an attractive fantasy. It's basically the core of the superhero myth: a person who has a big effect on society without depending on anyone else. Superman doesn't need help because he is invulnerable and strong. Even superheroes who ostensibly depend on large teams, like Batman or Iron Man, are never shown that way. If you go back to the beginning of the MCU, Tony Stark is alway shown alone with his technology. It's the bad guys who bark at subordinates and run around in groups.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoFounderless companies are the real future. Having to divide profits with founders, shareholders and other meat beings only weakens a company. Surely nobody supposes business knowledge is somehow immune to encoding in AI? And mistakes won't really matter when you can spawn a swarm of 300,000 "subsidiaries" from a single shellscript and have them coordinate via a darknet protocol to underwrite each other's losses.
- 1MachineElf 4y agoThe barrier to entry for becoming a founder has been lowered, meaning more people can become founders. Sounds good to me. I hope this point isn't being overlooked here, although, I understand that with recent waves of layoffs across tech, taking away people's jobs is a sensitive topic.
- bokohut 4y agoAs a serial entrepreneur and founder in the technology realm my past matches his claim exactly. The first founded iteration was spent observing and learning what not to do and over time grew to around 100 employees at peak. The second founded iteration I re-architected and re-coded the entire platform in about four years automating out all possible employees before going live which peaked at 7 employees under my ownership. And as they say "Third time's a charm". ;) From my own personal past experiences, and YMMV, people are the problem. Computers only make mistakes that the software allows which comes from the human writing the code of course until GPT3 starts coding:) Computers do not know of opinions, politics, emotions, illness, image, etc and if businesses were to track and quantify this as to the impact of said business then many eye opening considerations would occur. Just because "It has always been this way" does not make it correct or, from my direct experiences, efficient. Per Edison: "There is always a better way." I am the exception however as I have been doing real hands-on work since about age seven and have always been the first person to jump into anything to get my hands dirty learning whether that involves ICE engines, electricity, plumbing, digging, and of course anything tech related. I love to learn and have a passion for solving the hard problems which is my downfall but I don't do it for the money since that cannot buy health nor happiness.
- treis 4y agoHe's right about automation being good but misses the dichotomy between capturing value and creating value. Instagram was worth billions because they won in a market that is lucrative and tends towards winner take all. To use a somewhat bad analogy, you don't create a billion dollars of value by winning the powerball lottery.
- dgudkov 4y agoI have a feeling that PG doesn't understand automation. Automation is just a tool to increase work productivity (and, consequentially, profits and salaries). Automation doesn't change the nature of relationship between an employer and employees. The fact that a founder might need fewer employees due to automation only means that the moment when the founder will need to hire more people is shifted later in time (when the company grows) and the salaries of the employees will be higher because they will be required to work with automation tools and their work productivity will be higher. Also, the more automation we have, the more people will work in the automation industry. In other words, people will still be hired, just from the side of automation supplier, not automation consumer. If a single founder can run a billion-dollar company, it means that the automation industry that enabled this remarkable achievement has grown big and gave work to many people.
- jmagoon 4y agoThese blue check VCs on twitter are on such a gnarly anti-human bent these days. They are targeting a capitalist maximalism where a few people are very wealthy and everyone else does nothing (except...consume SaaS products? where do they think customers come from?). They are so absolutely caught up in AI development speed that they have traveled all the way to techno-eugenics, totally eliding the problem that there are a bunch of humans in the world that can't just be "disrupted" without their nightmarish little automation empires being seized by force. If these were far leftists talking about the need to reduce human capability because of the climate they would be rightly derided as being eco-terrorists, and that's precisely what we should see these people as. Ultra-libertarian terrorists whose primary, unabashed goal is to enrich themselves at the cost of human society.
- satvikpendem 4y agoAs a founder, it's true, if I can run a solo operation, I want to do that for as long as possible. New automatons like Stable Diffusion and ChatGPT enable that so they're great for me. Just the other day I asked ChatGPT to solve a particular programming problem for me and it did, all the while explaining what and why each line of code existed. There seems to me to be a lot of moral panic in this thread, I don't think it's necessarily justified simply because people are annoyed at PG as a person or what he said specifically (about Marx or otherwise) or the way he phrased it, because the general idea he's writing about is completely true in my experience.
- whateveracct 4y agoPaul Graham saying the quiet part loud as usual.
- zetazzed 4y agoThis attitude makes me so sad. When I started in tech, people were proud that this was one of the few industries that shared equity with a broad base of employees. Seeing a parking lot full of Porsches was celebrated, and people loved stories of the secretary (or mural painter in the Facebook case) who got rich off their options. But PaulG seems excited about the days when the pie can be captured by fewer and fewer people, specifically those in the class to which he feels closest (founders). It's a very strange argument about perception too - people are consider billionaires undeserving of enormous wealth, but just wait until they share that wealth even less broadly! Then everyone will see how great they are and love them more, right?
- onemoresoop 4y agoIt is sad indeed and many of us feel used and discarded. But maybe this will have a different outcome than we envision. Maybe the capitalist class can be automated away too
- Axsuul 4y agoIt's not a zero-sum game here. Being able to do more with less is a huge win — this enables individuals and small teams to tackle niche problems that would've otherwise been ignored. But there will always be an endless stream of universe-scale problems that require massive hordes of people to solve.
- moolcool 4y agoSomeone seeing automation tools and saying “cool! This will centralize wealth even more, and that’s a good thing” is quite revealing
- civilized 4y agoAnd automation is enabled by a massive web of technologies made possible by government-funded research. So it seems that, by Paul's argument, it is justified to have very high taxes on the incomes created by these founders with these technologies. The people, via their government, invested in modernizing and automating the economy, and they deserve to now reap the rewards and redistribute them broadly to the people, who ultimately funded the government research. Certainly the founders make some contribution as well, but since they are standing on the shoulders of giants, a progressively smaller cut, perhaps as little as 1-5% for incomes above say $10 million, would be very justifiable. Whether we actually enact marginal taxes of 95-99% above $10M would reduce to technocratic questions of incentives and who puts the money to the best use. Just desserts would be out of the question. Right?
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoDid the government sell these technologies? If not then how do the people make money from it? Sounds like the government gave it away for free: how can they now charge for it? Especially since tbe government mainly researches ideas rather than products. Should we pay Gutenburg's estate every time we print something? Perhaps Feynman gets a cut from nuclear power plants? Last I checked patents expire after 20 years. If the government has patented any technologies that are active, sure, let them charge for it.
- civilized 4y agoI am talking about how an equality-promoting system can be justified because I see that as desirable. In doing so I am showing that Paul Graham's view is not the only valid view about what people "deserve". Anyone who sees it as desirable to give enormous amounts of money to Feynman or Gutenberg's descendants is free to advocate for that as being what they deserve.
- zacharyvoase 4y agoIn a follow-up tweet: “ In the limit case, you're left with just the founders. And we're not far from it. Instagram had only 13 employees when it was sold for a billion dollars.” Why stop at the founders? Why not just have an algorithm churn out ideas for companies, an AI to build them, and another to launch them? What will Paul Graham do when even his job, as investor and producer of thoughtless observations on technology, labor and capital, has been automated away by an AI capable of writing similarly valid-sounding but uninformed takes?
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoWhoever has the algorithm is the founder
- qwertyuiop_ 4y agoThen why have a co-founder as YC preaches ?
- random314 4y agoAnd who was it that created the automation? The automation just creates itself?! That was such a terrible take.
- mattjaynes 4y agoWow. There seems to be 2 main responses to this. 1) Sadness and depression or 2) Excitement and possibility I really expected this thread to be more of #2 since historically Hacker News has been full of ambitious founders and founder-like engineers. The great leaps in automation, especially with the recent AI developments is any founder's dream. To be able to go faster with less friction than ever to create something valuable for the world. Now this is within reach of even more people. It's an amazing time - for those who choose to see the possibilities.
- nonameiguess 4y agoWe can't and will never have a world with 8 billion distinct businesses that all have zero employees each. So it's nice that you think you might have a shot at a tiny lottery, but personally, I like to see trends that can benefit all of humanity, not just those who choose to start businesses. Nothing against automation itself, but the idea that it means all of the value of a business can and should accrue to a single person I take issue with. It doesn't matter how evenly spread the probability that a randomly chosen person can become a successful founder is, or what my personal probability is. The total number of such people is necessarily capped at a very small number, and there is nothing to celebrate about at the idea of a future where only a very small number of people can ever enjoy the wealth created by automation.
- mattjaynes 4y agoOr maybe stop worrying about theoretical macro trends and go build something valuable right now?
- pixl97 4y agoHN suffers from a higher than average amounts of narcissism when it comes to being "Temporarily depressed millionaires" when thinking they will be the ones at the top of the pyramid. The few here that are near the top of the pyramid seem to forget that their high position tend to forget that position is supported by the base below them and if they don't perform maintenance on the base the entire thing collapses. Humanity is built on societies and we must treat it so by ensuring we produce wealth and distribute, not extract wealth and horde it.
- avidphantasm 4y agoIf it becomes possible for a solo founder to automate a $1B start-up, then it's not worth $1B dollars, because the barrier to entry for others to do the same is much lower. The whole startup thing would seem to implode because of this. The argument they are making seems to be founded on the idea that founders are unique geniuses. Maybe they are, maybe they aren't. I guess we'll find out if there are no more such founders as IT automation advances.
- crispyambulance 4y agoWell, there’s “deserve-to-rich” and there’s “deserve-to-be-so-rich-that-you-can-afford -bend-reality” rich. Can we NOT pretend that the people pg is talking are saying the former? It’s so disingenuous.
- dalbasal 4y agoI feel like the implied question isn't of much value on its own. It's all about "where are you going with this?" Leaving aside the connective tissue between creating value, creating market cap, how these translate to reward/money... What's left? The subsequent discussion about dividing loot is one discussion. The discussion about making more unicorns might be totally unrelated. The latter is theoretically empirical, but in practice pretty speculative. My take on these is usually about bottlenecks. A screw holding together a $100bn f35 is still usually cheap. Its importance doesn't determine price, because without scarcity it cannot be a limiting factor. A patent protected screw could, in theory, be priced to reflects value to the buyer/aircraft. A custom designed screw might also be expensive... perhaps reflecting the time value or negotiating power of it's custom maker. In all cases the plane does not work without the screw. If we're reviewing costs and such, the above thoughts on "value" might have value. They may even hold clues to cost efficiency more broadly. They may not be too relevant to a discussion about aviation mechanics. I (respectfully) think pg's pov is too abstract, as is the proverbial opposing pov that he's responding too. Look... Investors tend to think the bottleneck is "great founders," the modern version of investment opportunity. A lot of founders tend to think that it's investors. Perhaps the bottleneck is corporate and government procurement. Military people and other tribes tend to think the bottleneck is leaders. Economists think bottlenecks are institutional. All convenient viewpoints for the people who hold them. I don't really understand how automation relates. Unless we're talking about founder-only companies... Why is this points in favour of founder contribution, relative to the (now fewer) employees? Maybe it means that capital's value has risen. Automation is "capital" technically. You might even claim that the public is responsible for more of the value, considering the importance of public domains to technology.
- marstall 4y agoAnd yet automation has led to an ongoing explosion in the number of jobs since the dawn of the Industrial Revolution!
- medellin 4y agoHas he always been like this? It seems he is posting more and more polarized content over time or at least its being shared more. Maybe that is the point?
- jahewson 4y agoYou still occasionally hear people saying that VCs don't deserve to be rich, because founders created all the value. But the falsity of this claim becomes increasingly obvious as automation enables VCs to grow funds with fewer and fewer founders. /s
- bitwize 4y agoMarx thought of that too, which is why he said there'd be a revolution.
- alvatech 4y agoWhat about competition? What prevents multiple copycat companies from propping up if a one-person startup grows to a billion dollar valuation?
- madsbuch 4y agoWho pays for the infrastructure? I can drive 10 times faster with good roads because a public sector maintain and build road infrastructure. If that enables me to earn 100 times more am I then entitles to the entire profits? Or should I pay some of it forward to the infrastructure. I like the idea that innovation advantages should spill over to the rest of the society with the speed of inflation. Given an inflation of ~2% it should take me roughly 50 years to not gain any profits from my innovation (given no competition).
- pixl97 4y ago"Well you see after I become a billionaire I'm going to pull up the ladder behind me and move to a private island. Good luck everybody else."
- 98codes 4y agoWell that's fun -- I'm apparently recently blocked by PaulG, having never interacted with him directly, or anywhere near him in any recent memory. Is he running something to proactively block anyone that's been talking about Mastodon? Wild-ass guess, but I can't imagine any other reason.
- drewcoo 4y agoBut do we need human founders? For how long will we still need them?
- choeger 4y agoInstagram the software has no intrinsic value. The whole thing could be reproduced in no time. It's the network effect that matters and getting that effect is essentially a hack. Yes, the author's prime example is a hack of society. That's not automation, it's an example for the fact that software can be copied for zero cost. Compare that to a company with an intrinsic value, like Tesla. How far could Elon (I know he's not the founder) automate Tesla? Even if all tools for such an automation were available, how would a single person even know how to design and build a car, let alone the required automated factories?
- kbos87 4y agoThis whole notion seems to be based on a bunch of seemingly logical conclusions, but it’s also a very narrow view of the reality. Let’s just think for a minute about a single potentially confounding factor - every company has competitors. Those competitors are looking for every opportunity to climb past you, and they’ll be willing to hire humans to do anything a machine can’t. For example… a lot of people still prefer to talk to a human when they need help with something. (Not me and I’m guessing not many people on HN, but we’re the outliers here.) Yes, you can try to use automation to solve for that… but if your competitor offers a better experience through human intervention, you are essentially forced to match their move and hire a support team. Yes, automation is getting better, and who knows, maybe in a few years GPT3 will be having support conversations with customers. But the pressure to find a competitive advantage is often going to lead to hiring large numbers of people. That’s how we got to where we are today.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoGreat point. People don't appear to think about competition enough.
- a9h74j 4y ago> But the pressure to find a competitive advantage is often going to lead to hiring large numbers of people. Phone menus are not generally viewed as competitive advantages, I suppose, but we have them in plenty. Would it be the standard chatbox case that competition for now is against hated menu trees, not against human beings?
- kbos87 4y agoAgree with your point but if the alternative is a vendor that leaves me with no way to get my questions answered, I think most people would gladly step through a phone tree to talk to a human being.
- browserman 4y agoEvery time some VC asshole makes some pompous self-gratifying pronouncement like this, their personal capital gains tax rate should go up 10%. EDIT: Just astonishing that uses Instagram as an example. Quick question: After Facebook paid a billion dollars for it, did they a) continue to employ only 13 people or did they b) hire more fucking people in order to actually realize the potential of their investment? EDIT2: Just saw that he also claims 'automation accumulating wealth in the hands of the ownership class at the expense of workers' contradicts Marx. Amazing. Paul, if you're reading this, please take an introductory class on Marxist thought at your local state college, or have your personal assistant take it and send you the notes.
- cma 4y agoUsers are effectively the employees often in these companies, they just get zero pay or huge fees on something they are forced to sell through the locked in platform.