7 ms·
Supreme Court leans toward web designer with anti-gay marriage stance
- bediger4000 4y agoWill SCOTUS side with other Christian beliefs? I'm thinking specifically of the traditional "peace churches", Quakers, Mennonites, Amish, and their historical opposition to war and killing. What if a Quaker decides to not register for selective service because of strongly held religious beliefs? What if a devote Mennonite subtracts 28% (or whatever the DoD gets as a percentage of the yearly budget) from their income tax? The latter has happened in the past, btw. How far does religious belief and freedom of religion take us?
- hirundo 4y agoWe won't find out from this case, which was accepted for its freedom of speech rather than religion arguments.
- adamredwoods 4y ago>> Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett said Waggoner was on her "strongest ground when you're talking about her sitting down and designing and coming up with the graphics to customize them for the couple." Barrett questioned whether the First Amendment would still protect Smith if she wanted to decline to provide a "plug-and-play" website to a gay couple that an opposite-sex couple could buy.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> Barrett questioned whether the First Amendment would still protect Smith if she wanted to decline to provide a "plug-and-play" website to a gay couple that an opposite-sex couple could buy. This proves its about “speech” - plug-and-play is hardly the same level of speech as a unique design. More-specifically, there is a difference, legally, between “conduct” and “speech”. Eg. You can say discriminatory things, but you cannot do discriminatory things. So the question at hand.. what if you discriminate what you do, to avoid being compelled to say something you don’t want to. A Plug-and-play website might not pass the test when it comes to being “speech” the way unique artistic graphic might.
- crackercrews 4y agoYou don't have to avoid SSS registration. The govt already has an exception for "conscientious objectors" that requires appearing before a panel. [1] It sounds like any observant Quaker would pass with flying colors. Still a hassle of course. 1: https://www.sss.gov/conscientious-objectors/ https://www.sss.gov/conscientious-objectors/
- bediger4000 4y agoThanks, last time I looked, which was a few years ago this did not exist. Good to see this coming back in the system! But you still have to register, and I can imagine someone objecting even to that, someone Amish, say. They object to going to high school.
- gamblor956 4y agoConscientious objections have been permitted for over a century in the U.S., and the last major legal changes to the law were made in the 1980s...
- yieldcrv 4y agoBring the cases and find out This case is only going to modify the Colorado statute, and maybe others It likely won’t answer all your questions But in America if you have a little free time and money you can mold the country by bringing these cases, instead of just imagining them at your keyboard Dont let your dreams be dreams, or your slippery slopes hypothetical
- ss108 4y agoThere's already caselaw about a lot of that. Also, SCOTUS and other federal courts frequently do rule in favor of religious rights regardless of whether the person asserting them is Christian. Not always, but it's not like they conspicuously don't.
- adamredwoods 4y ago>> She preemptively sued Colorado's civil rights commission and other state officials in 2016 because she feared she would be punished for refusing to serve gay weddings. I know little of this case. She preemptively did this without a specific incident? How did this even make it to the SCOTUS? I feel anyone can refuse to work for someone else on any unsaid basis. It's when it is definable why they denied a customer, or work, then we can explore the implications. Preemptive fears are baseless in this circumstance, IMO.
- sieabah 4y agoThe bakery incident really made people wonder whether you can deny anyone and stay in business.
- adamredwoods 4y agoSuppose I was a freelance website developer and one day a Christian came to my work and asked me to write out Leviticus 18 with a big fat logo for their website, I'd say my hand hurt and ask they go somewhere else to do it. Even if it was later discovered that I am a card-carrying Atheist, will I be shut down? Could anyone prove my intentions? Doubtful.
- gsinclair 4y agoIn that situation I would take the job and do the best I could to satisfy the customer. But I would insist on my company name not being associated with it, or maybe one step further: a statement appearing on the website disclaiming my company’s endorsement of the content. They might not accept that condition, and I’d be happy not to take the job. This applies in many cases across many fields. Like in Australia we recently had a kerfuffle in which the National women’s netball team protested a particular sponsorship (on pretty stupid grounds, but anyway…). Why not accept the sponsorship but say your piece? Constructive debate is much better than virtue signalling.
- Natsu 4y agoIt's a bit more complicated than that, they're suing to test the constitutionality of the law because it barred them from doing something they would've otherwise done: === https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/303_Creative_LLC_v._Elenis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/303_Creative_LLC_v._Elenis === Before implementing the notice, Smith discovered that such a notice would violate the Colorado anti-discrimination state laws that were amended in 2008, which prevents public businesses from discriminating against gay people as well as making statements to that effect. Smith, represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom, sued Colorado in 2016 in the United States District Court for the District of Colorado, seeking to block enforcement of the anti-discrimination law. The district court waited for the result of the Supreme Court case Masterpiece Cakeshop v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission which dealt with the same anti-discrimination law. As Masterpiece was ruled in 2018 on more narrow procedural grounds, the district court ruled against Smith in 2019, as Colorado had yet to investigate Smith and thus there was no evidence that she had engaged in discrimination.[4][5] Smith appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, which upheld the district court decision in a 2–1 ruling. In the majority ruling, the Tenth Circuit held the anti-discrimination law satisfied strict scrutiny under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution, deepening a circuit split with decisions issued by the Arizona Supreme Court and the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit.[6] Chief Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented in the Tenth's decision, writing "the majority takes the remarkable — and novel — stance that the government may force Ms. Smith to produce messages that violate her conscience."[3]
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoCould a web designer refuse to create a site for an inter-racial marriage because they don’t believe in miscegenation? Is web design considered a public accommodation under the law?
- mensetmanusman 4y agoLegal experts note the risk of the governments argument: if you are an artist, you have a de-facto monopoly on your speech, ergo your speech is regulated and compelled. E.g. should a Jewish singer be forced to sing at a KKK event, etc.
- proactivesvcs 4y agoNot necessarily arguing with your point (it may be that of said legal experts) but a KKK event is not held, or run by people, because of any sort of protected status or attribute, as far as I understand it. Hence it's a fallacious comparison.
- joshuamorton 4y agoThis doesn't at all appear to be the governments argument though?
- roflyear 4y agoAbsolutely some things are not protected. Political speech is something you can discriminate against in the US. You can fire someone for being a Nazi. That's absolutely true.
- boeingUH60 4y agoI don’t know if this opinion is unpopular, but I personally think anyone should be allowed to refuse to render their services to anyone they want to…I mean, if I don’t want to offer my services, can’t I just make an excuse like I’m overbooked or something? Obviously, it gets murky when it comes to innate characteristics like race…but I don’t think religious views fall under that category because a considerable number of people change their religions or go from religious to atheist or vice versa.
- vineyardmike 4y agoI don’t think its an unpopular opinion, but I think the issue here is that there is a lot of nuance. Should someone be forced to officiate a same-sex wedding or build a website is different from should that person be forced to rent an apartment to a same sex couple which is different from should a cashier be forced to provide service at the register to a same-sex couple. The law provides distinction between speech and conduct, and that’s the main topic in this court case. Conduct can’t discriminate, but speech can. Eg. You can say mean things about a certain race, but you can’t refuse them service because if it. So professional services… is that conduct or speech? The Colorado law in question said that business is conduct not speech, and thats really what is at the root of this case. What is the line? Is baking a cake speech? Is building a website? What about being a grocery store cashier? > Obviously, it gets murky when it comes to innate characteristics like race What about innate characteristics like sexuality?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThis is a good explanation of the subtleties involved in this. - Alice wants to publish a website about how the moon is made out of cheese but Alice is bad at web design. - Bob is good at web design and wants to sell his design services. - Bob is discriminatory in how clients are accepted: he doesn't want people to make claims that the moon is made out of cheese. - Alice is rejected. I don't think Bob is really wrong in this hypothetical specifically because people who believe certain things about the moon aren't a class protected by law from discrimination. However, when Alice is trying to make a website about her marriage to her future wife: - Bob is discriminatory in how clients are accepted: he doesn't want people to announce or advertise their same-sex marriages. Seems like this is discrimination against a protected class. Personally, I don't buy the argument that Bob's speech is compelled because it's not his speech (not his website). (Not that the above comment makes this argument, just that it appears to be the prevailing argument in favor of this person's decision.)
- Nevermark 4y ago(If anyone wants to critique my solution attempt, I would be interested in any perceived problems with it. I have a practical interest in finding solutions to difficult moral problems.) -- Clearly people shouldn't be discriminated against for the protected class they are in. And yet people shouldn't be required to harness their own free speech for views that they find morally objectionable. I don't see how any workable solution can dispense with either of those principles. But I don't see any contradiction either. No discrimination based on customer class. But allowable service limits, on providing unique creative contributions to promoting ideas the supplier finds morally objectionable. -- The distinction is between mechanical services, creative non-speech related services (always must be provided equally) vs. creative service directly involved in speech choices. -- A cake maker should provide cakes to anyone. Put any combination of figures for sale on a cake, as a customer requests. Put any writing a customer wants on a cake. And even produce cakes in designs inherently celebrating any ideas, supporting the free speech of the customer. None of those tasks involve the cake supplier making creative choices about any ideas. The customer made those choices. But a cake maker can decline to come up with their own wording for phrases supporting ideas they don't agree with. And decline to make choices regarding unique visual designs, specifically promoting an idea they find morally objectionable. So a gay couple should be able to get a unique cake made (from a maker of custom cakes), with rainbow colors (they chose), in a shape of a non-binary symbol (that they chose), with two male figures on top (at their direction). And the cake maker can be expected to apply their general creative calligraphy and cake shaping skills to make the cake presentable, without having to make any decisions about the ideas it represents that they may or may not have personal moral objections too. -- The only other aspect I can think of is, suppliers should generally be able to decline projects for moral reasons, as long as the moral objection isn't based on protected class of customer. For instance, a request for a cake in the shape of genetalia can be rejected for being too obscene, given they would decline such a cake for anyone of any class.
- Georgelemental 4y agoIf a customer walks in requesting a cake with a swatzika and other Nazi insignia, should the bakery be allowed to refuse?
- primeradical 4y agoI would be mortified walking into a karaoke bar with a group of friends and they ask me and my husband to leave but continue to serve our friends because they don't want LGTBQIA+ people to use their microphones. I shouldn't have to lookup which minorities/protected classes your public business refuses to serve. Easy to stand with her when you're not on the receiving end of that discrimination.
- Ferrotin 4y agoYou’d only get kicked out for your conduct, like stepping up to the mic and singing some lyrics about gay stuff that grosses everybody out. We have a long history of having gays not being a protected class, so you can see from ten years ago how realistic your concerns are.
- freejazz 4y agoAh, yes, history only goes in one direction... except for when it doesn't.
- primeradical 4y agoShe didn't get to the Supreme Court because she was forced to serve a client whose conduct she disapproved. In fact, this case doesn't involve a specific client at all. This case is about the would-be client that hasn't even walked in the door. And the court isn't considering whether LGBTQIA+ people fall into a protected class category, that's not this case. Metaphorically, this case is whether or not she can put up a sign on her business's front door that says "No ___ allowed." And according to the article, this conservative SCOTUS appears to be sympathetic to the "No ___ allowed" sign. It appears SCOTUS is trying to draw line between public accommodation businesses and businesses that create speech, a distinction I believe Justice Sotomayor and KBJ countered aptly. I could imagine an ISP denying the use of its networks to LGBTQIA+ people because they have sincerely held religious objections to transmit those customers' data across their network.
- Ferrotin 4y agoYou can imagine all sorts of things, but a bar having authority over what gets performed in its premises is the first problem you came up with.