11 ms·
Google has a company strategy, not a product strategy
- discordance 4y agoI worked with several Azure product groups in the past. Although we had a top down roadmap, we were also heavily influenced and guided by customer needs. A big component in our backlog prioritization was whether we had customers who would use, test and provide feedback on private previews released to their subscriptions. With review, SWEs and Product Owners also had enough agency to add functionality/features to the backlog. Perhaps the Office org is run differently to Azure.
- rrdharan 4y agoThe author of this blog has been the head of PM at Asana for nearly 9 years, during which they've completely failed to come up with a sustainable product strategy and have been bleeding money for years. "... the world would be a better place if people spend less time on failed projects and more time working on things that make a difference." Asana was founded in 2008. It seems destined to fail, and will have largely wasted a large number of people's time, and seems very unlikely to be a "thing that ma[de] a difference". https://world.hey.com/dhh/the-bubble-has-popped-for-unprofitable-software-companies-2a0a5f57 https://world.hey.com/dhh/the-bubble-has-popped-for-unprofit... "Asana lost an incredible $285m in 2021, $210m in 2020, and $118m in 2019. They're on track to losing even more with over $370m in losses booked for the trailing twelve months. That's closing in on a billion dollars in losses over the last four years. Madness."
- dchuk 4y agoNot to mention asana just isn’t amazing either. It’s such an elementary pm tool given how long it’s been around and how much money they’ve spent, it really makes you wonder where it’s all gone.
- white_dragon88 4y agoWhat would you’d hugest instead? My org likes the flexibility it provides.
- dchuk 4y agoHonestly if you get a very skilled atlassian operator you can do massive scale project management pretty easily. Everyone loves to hate on jira, but it’s crazy powerful. It’s just easy for it to go to shit unless you have someone who is both highly competent and highly opinionated running it all.
- flappyeagle 4y agoIf you’re a dev team try Linear or Height
- aikinai 4y agoAt my last startup we tested a number of options and decided to go with ClickUp. I personally preferred the philosophy of Linear, but ClickUp can do way more and it’s quite good. Their feature velocity is really impressive too. And we did run into bugs and performance issues, but support was responsive and helpful.
- dtjb 4y agoAsana needs document support. Nothing complicated, just a simple wiki or doc editor that lets us capture and link notes, findings, requirements, etc. We ended up moving to ClickUp over this.
- impulser_ 4y agoI wouldn't really bring up them losing money as a reason why they are going to fail. You can count on your two hands how many small to mid size SaaS/tech companies actually make money. Almost all of them are money burning machines.
- cj 4y ago> You can count on your two hands how many small to mid size SaaS/tech companies actually make money. I think you’ll see this change slowly in the next 2-3 years. I’ve been running a small/medium company for 7 years now, bootstrapped but with a small $1 million seed round in 2015. During the 2020/2021 bubble, our seed investors were very angry at us for being profitable. (Angry isn’t an exaggeration) After the bubble bursts, those same investors are now praising us for being so “cash efficient” and profitable. Founders are heavily influenced by the recommendations of advisors around them. Now that the entire VC community is condoning/punishing high cash burn companies, you’ll start to see more conservative ways of operating a business become more common, since that’s now what VC, PE, etc all want to see right now (and for the foreseeable future, at least until interest rates go way down)
- quickthrower2 4y agoHaving investors doesn't sound like fun!
- ShredKazoo 4y ago>During the 2020/2021 bubble, our seed investors were very angry at us for being profitable. (Angry isn’t an exaggeration) That's nuts. Interested to hear more.
- bushbaba 4y agoYou’re a profitable SaaS. Would you take out a loan for 100MM if you can use it to make n * 100MM? That’s what SaaS shops are doing. many (not all) could show profit. But instead they e reinvested all profits and then some to get accelerated growth.
- Terretta 4y ago
- joegahona 4y agoI believe she left Asana a few years ago.
- aikinai 4y agoThere’s a joke in the first episode of Silicon Valley where some mundane startup oversells their mission as something about enabling humanity to thrive. I saw an interview with Mike Judge where he said it was just a copy of an actual experience he had where a founder was telling him all these grand visions about how he was going to lift up humanity and Mike thought it was some sort of charity. But when he asked again what the company was, it was a todo app! Mike didn’t name the company, but I Googled the mission statement he mentioned and it was clearly Asana.
- gz5 4y agoReminds me of this terrific rant comparing Google and AWS: https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 The great HN discussion on that rant linked at the bottom of that post.
- qqtt 4y agoThe rant was interesting in it's time but I'm not sure how relevant it is in 2022. 11 years ago Google had a nascent cloud computing business and Amazon might have been at a bit of a peak in terms of executing on it's dual track cloud/retail businesses. In the time since, consumer trust in Amazon has eroded massively, as China-based sellers turned Amazon into a more expensive Ali Express. Amazon has had some very public missteps in investments such as losing 10 billion a year on Alexa. Amazon's market dominance of the cloud has been eroded by Microsoft & Google. And even now, 10 years later, Amazon still can't seem to figure out how to make its retail business profitable without resorting to littering their web site with ads. Amazon recently set a record for losing over one trillion dollars in share holder value, while it's competitors like Microsoft and Google have weathered the economic storm better. Microsoft and Google have very promising trajectories for their cloud businesses while at the same time having a solid profitable cash cow in their core businesses. Alternatively, one gets the sense that if Amazon didn't stumble upon AWS as a business all those years ago, they might legitimately be in trouble as a business.
- acdha 4y ago> Amazon's market dominance of the cloud has been eroded by Microsoft & Google By Microsoft. GCP appears to be under intense pressure to become profitable and they’re lagging on features. I hear about migrations from GCP to AWS or Azure more than the reverse, and that was before the price increases.
- qqtt 4y agoThere are rumors about what's going on internally regarding GCP, but by all accounts Google is still investing heavily in GCP and their current growth trajectory means profitability is almost inevitable. Azure & AWS have relatively stagnant growth and there are more and more signs that the growth of GCP is coming at potential market share from AWS/Azure. https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/analysis/google-grabs-growth-share-from-amazon-microsoft/2022/10/ https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/analysis/google-grabs-gr...
- SanjayMehta 4y agoIn a nutshell they have no strategy except "hire great engineers."
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoJust keep paying to roll the dice again and see if you land a business as profitable as search+ads. Again, and again.
- defrost 4y agoThere was an arguably "better" rationale given for paying out engineers to play hard on the chance they land a success . . . The denial of those engineering talents to competitors.
- danielscrubs 4y agoTried many different search engines and none was as good as Googles until I tried Brave search, something I really didn’t expect. We will see what happens with Googles search business in the coming decade.
- ShredKazoo 4y agoI suppose the benefit of being a niche player in search is you don't have to deal with targeted SEO.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoBrave search is quite good and the support for DDG's bangs is icing on the cake. Yandex also gives a different perspective on the same queries.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoinderd the entire post appears to be trying to rationalise and explain away objective failure of leadership
- blondin 4y agoguys we need to stop supporting these obvious bots. nothing they say matter. they won't even let people read this piece without some kind of subscription that goes towards their online social status. i am so, so, so tired.
- vs2 4y agoI wont click on any substack link!
- dchuk 4y agoThere’s a “let me read it first” on every sub stack modal pop up to subscribe, you don’t have to pay
- jbay808 4y agoFor what it's worth, it seems authors can disable that popup on their own substack. I did, and it doesn't seem to have reduced subscription sign-ups, but even if it does, not annoying people is always a good principle. It defaults to 'on' though, and maybe not everyone has explored their settings. It took a while for me to find it.
- keepquestioning 4y agoSomething.substack. yeah, not going to click.
- flappyeagle 4y agoThe example the author gave seems flawed. Why not geofence that optimization to Norway? Or to Norwegian google? It’s a micro optimization but the search engine is full of those and google has 100k employees
- musk_micropenis 4y ago
- daydream 4y agoBecause “Their change didn’t make the search results better, and it unfairly promoted some sites over others.“
- llampx 4y agoSo they stepped on the Google Ads team's toes.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoWith regard to Microsoft vs Google planning, I wonder if a lot of that difference comes down to their rolling release of the web vs the previous boxed version releases. I remember in the 1990’s a release of Windows or Office was a big deal. There would be a ton of press. The boxed version would be at all the computer stores (and even at stores like Walmart). There would be tons of reviews talking about if it was worth upgrading, etc. With all those things, you want your release to go off perfectly. You would like to avoid half-baked/buggy features, and also have enough features to wow the reviewers. A bad release would be a decent hit on revenue and market position. Now compare that with web releases. You can slowly roll out features when they are ready. You can fairly easily A/B test then with a small percentage of queries to make sure everything works ok. Most people likely don’t even think about versions of Google web apps. In those circumstance me, allowing more freedom for people to work on new ideas with a minimum of overhead is likely a win.
- fbdab103 4y agoIt is difficult for me to ascribe any strategy to Microsoft when I suffer through Teams on a daily basis.
- roncesvalles 4y agoI've come to realize that the damage due to Teams to the Microsoft brand name is enormous and in no way recompensed by the market share that it captured during COVID.
- bigger_cheese 4y agoCan you expand on that my org switched to Teams during the Pandemic and it has basically transformed my workflow. I work as an Engineer (The non software type) so maybe my workflow might be different form Software people but Teams has basically managed to almost completely displace email, phone calls, sharepoint and a lot of in person meetings. Things like sharing documents between people working on a project together. We used to use combination of email, one drive and sharepoint document libraries. Teams streamlined this immensely with it's built in groups it is really easy to create a new group for each project and it stores all the documents, chat messages, meetings etc all in one place and it's all archived and searchable. Even stuff like screen sharing and screen recording (so people can catch up on meetings they missed) work really well - we used to have to use Skype for bussiness to do this and it was not great at it. I'm not a Microsoft fan but they really nailed Teams in my opinion I'm surprised to hear people are negative about it.
- jasmer 4y agoAfter trying Android on Samsung for the first time in a few years ... I feel it's a bit of a disaster. I could almost not find the 'settings' with the help of 5 other people. I was at a loss to know what I could delete and not. After 20 minutes of trying to delete an 'Amazon' app I realize that Samsung probably forced it to be pre-installed and not removable. Along with 10 other garbage Samsung and carrier icons. Paradoxically most of that does not even benefit Samsung. This individual also had almost 10 terrible spyware apps installed without remembering that they had installed them. Such poor design. Like an ugly, dirty esplanade off the main strip in some gambling resort. I'm awaiting the gambling and girls preloads. I loathe so many of Apple's policies but I wonder if it's better to have a monopolistic overlord that is 'mostly benevolent' over the Android bad design and chaos. The sad thing is a Trillion dollar company should have a better product. I suggest Microsoft in many ways is not that that much better as can be seen with the abysmal degradation of Skype, and MS Teams which is a poor copy of Slack. This could be a function of the nature of those divisions, or of the company losing it's touch.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoThe best government is a benevolent tyranny tempered by an occasional assassination. - Voltaire
- beaned 4y agoJust get a Pixel instead, there's none of that. Android the OS is great.
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoYep, Pixel's the best game in town until a usable Linux phone comes along. (Pixels also get security updates the longest, last I checked.)
- JadeNB 4y ago> I loathe so many of Apple's policies but I wonder if it's better to have a monopolistic overlord that is 'mostly benevolent' over the Android bad design and chaos. The problem is benevolent dictators don't stay benevolent. Or, to put it differently, things are great while you're on the same side as the dictator, but, once you get on their wrong side, things get bad suddenly, and it's hard to find allies since your erstwhile community is probably still on the right side of the dictator. (I am not a software developer, much less an iOS developer, and have no experience with being on the wrong side of Apple—but I do have experience, as a long-time OS X user who now finds macOS becoming "iOS, but less important!", with what happens when the dictator controls your working environment but doesn't care about it any more.)
- blondin 4y agowe need to stop supporting these bots. i said it one more time. go ahead :)
- pradn 4y agoIt's hard to take this post seriously when basic facts are off. > To support this company strategy, Google makes it really, really easy for anyone to start up a new project. The culture of “20% time” gives people permission to work on ideas outside of their primary role. There’s only the lightest of reviews needed to launch a “1% experiment.” No, it is not super easy to start a new project. I'm in Google Cloud and we're pretty focused on executing team priorities. I can suggest new work-streams and write arguments in their favor, sure. But I can't just randomly add a feature or go away to work on a new product for a while. Every public thing in Cloud, at least, is carefully reviewed with a large checklist covering privacy, security, accessibility, API style, integration with existing systems like metrics, legal, etc. The simplest cloud service can take an extra six months or a year to get past these blocks. These requirements also apply to features. What we get for this is quality and consistency between products/features. And 20% time isn't really a thing any more. You can get permission from your manager to work on something else, perhaps. But more likely this sort of thing is more like 120%. It's not at all as lackadaisical as it's presented to be. The most I see around my team is people volunteering for large-scale clean-ups. But these are more slack-time projects like 5% projects. It's not totally gone however. I think the person who made Google Maps zoom out to a globe did it as 20% project, and I believe adding CitiBike support was similar as well. We are also super careful about experiments. Every Google Search experiment has to go through a senior management review. In my team, every flag rollout is discussed and approved before rollout. Insofar as these tidbits are presented as evidence for loose leadership, they don't make sense. The ship is fairly tight, at least in Cloud.
- kouohhashi 4y agoLet employees to start new projects and shut it down later if it does not seem to be profitable. This strategy just make sense. But I just want google to make the works open sourced when abandoned. I hope google opensource Duplex for web...
- romwell 4y ago>Let employees to start new projects and shut it down later if it does not seem to be profitable. That's not the strategy though. The strategy is "I'll get promotion for launching, not maintaining" for employees, and "we're still making a shit ton of money, so why bother" from the top brass.
- nowherebeen 4y agoNo one gets a promotion from fixing bugs mentality.
- bruce511 4y agoStrategy leads to winning the big picture. And Google is not doing that. They are the King's of advertising, but move outside that stream and it becomes "when" not "if" it'll get the chop. This leads to a lack of trust, so things like GCP suffer. Regardless of the technical merits, or price, I can never use GCP because I don't trust Google. This is largely due to their willingness to kill things, coupled with a lack of phone support. Incidentally lots of the things shut down were successful, and profitable, by most company standards. Just not by google-scale standards.
- rippercushions 4y agoBy and large Google can't open source anything internal even if they wanted to, because it's so closely tied into Google's own ecosystem (Borg etc) that it's useless outside it.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWhile I feel like this article is a good assessment of Google's culture, I think it's a bit weird that it ignores the prime reason Google shuts down so many products: if it ain't tied to search/ads, it's hard to argue it will make any significant difference in Google's revenue. That is, Ad Words and their other search/ad products are so phenomenally successful, basically any other product that is even slightly "niche" will be in the .00...001% impact on revenue. That's why if you look at Google's most successful products besides straight-up search (like GMail, Chrome, Android, YouTube, Maps, etc.) they are somehow tied to viewing more ads that Google serves up. So many of their other products, probably Stadia being the best most recent example, may have great technical execution, but they are just afterthoughts and would probably always be afterthoughts, revenue-wise, compared to Google's ad revenue. I think the one area that is interesting is Google's enterprise products, particularly GCP and Google Workspace. As others have commented, Google has great technology in these areas but they often just don't understand how to work with businesses in a way that businesses expect.
- soheil 4y agoGoogle has a company strategy, rather than a product strategy, because its business is focused on providing a wide range of products and services, rather than a single product or product line. As a technology company, Google offers a diverse range of products and services, including search, advertising, cloud computing, hardware, software, and many others. Because of this diversity, it is not feasible for Google to develop and implement a separate product strategy for each of its products and services. Instead, its company strategy is likely to focus on broader goals and objectives that apply across the entire business, such as growth, innovation, and customer satisfaction. This allows Google to manage its business in a more comprehensive and cohesive manner, and to ensure that its products and services are aligned with its overall goals and direction.
- Mikeb85 4y agoGoogle has cancelled a lot of things. And they do kind of suck at product strategy. The worst part is, they don't even realise when they have something great that's on the verge of gaining traction (Hangouts and Stadia IMO could have both become enormous with just a little more persistence and marketing). That being said, on the technology front, they're still better than anyone else. Chromecast just works in a way nothing else does to get media onto your TV. Google is better at syncing things in the cloud (Google Drive/Docs) than anyone else. Office365 always has weird issues with synchronising documents in the cloud and is a huge pain in the ass whereas Docs works perfectly in real time. Google search is obviously the best. Google Maps is the best. Gmail. YouTube. Android is an amazing OS even if some OEMs add crap to it that detracts. Chrome is by far the best browser. And so on. I put up with Google's subpar product 'strategy' because it still makes life easier than dealing with MS or Apple's nonsense.
- riwsky 4y agoIf by “technology”, you mean just “web services and browsers thereof”—then yes, sure.
- shepherdjerred 4y ago> Chrome is by far the best browser. The reason this is true is simply because it's dominant, so every site builds for compatibility for Chrome. This is similar to how Windows is the best OS for gaming. Not because Windows has any technical advantage, but it's simply what developers build for. Firefox would "be the best browser" if it were dominant.
- uejfiweun 4y agoEh, I think there are other benefits too: excellent extension ecosystem, simple and clean interface, default search engine is Google, generally fast and stable.
- Mariehane 4y agoChrome is the iPhone of the browser world - there are probably things in other browsers that work better, or that you could customize to fit your needs, but instead of spending the time to optimize those you can just choose chrome and you'd be pretty satisfied overall.
- osigurdson 4y ago>> I loved it as much as I love Microsoft Excel I've never hear of anyone who loves Microsoft Excel. It isn't that it is a bad product (it is of course very good at what it does). It's just that spreadsheets are no fun.
- stevage 4y agoI know lots of people who love spreadsheets. Generally they prefer Google Sheets though.
- osigurdson 4y agoIn what problem domains are they fun?
- giancarlostoro 4y agoThis headline made me think of Google as one of those money laundering apparatuses you watch mob / cartel movies about briefly, they overspend on “projects” and make it just functional enough to look legit. Course if I were a true evil money launderer I almost want to say Amazon as a “shipping company” of sorts fits the bill too.
- tzury 4y agoNot a single word about Google Cloud Platform?
- 752963e64 4y ago