20 ms·
France prepares for possibility of electricity blackouts during winter months
- Raed667 4y agoAnd yet we allow extravagant malls all over France to light and heat 24/7 with open doors and no accountability. All streets are filled with large high-definition ad screens & computers that cool and heat all day long. Restaurants and bars can just heat the outside terrace air, etc... And the liberal take has been: This is fine as long as they're paying their bills.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoI have no idea of what you are talking about. Blackouts are a solution to consumption surges. We are not seeing surges right now so there is no reason to restrict anyone. We can’t store electricity after all. In case of a surge, the commercial sector is the first being hit, long before houses. Plus the issue is mostly heating, lights consume next to nothing. France electricity is mostly clean by the way. > Restaurants and bars can just heat the outside terrace air. etc... That’s been illegal for more than a year.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoFrance's energy production is not as clean as one may think. There is considerable damage to the environment in countries in Africa, where Uranium is mined/extracted. Probably still better than lots of CO2 output, but not actually clean.
- pitaj 4y ago> There is considerable damage to the environment in countries in Africa, where Uranium is mined/extracted. That's equally of not more true of renewables like solar and batteries that require large amounts of rare metals.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoDoesn't change the fact, that it is not actually clean, does it?
- yodsanklai 4y agoNo energy production is clean. Actually, I'd be curious to compare the damage to the environment caused by uranium extraction vs producing batteries and solar panels.
- guggle 4y agoIndeed, there is no clean energy, it's all relative. I'd like more people to realize this.
- kergonath 4y agoNuclear and solar panels are about the same. Better than wind and hydro. But all of these are very similar, and are miles better than fossil fuels. It’s difficult to have accurate projections for batteries because the technology that can be used at these scales is not clear (though he vast majority of them need cobalt, which is a huge issue on several levels).
- loeg 4y agoMost uranium comes from Kazakhstan. Australia and Canada are also major producers. Namibia produces some, but far from the majority. This isn't exactly a "western countries dumping environmental problems in Africa" story.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoSo is the Uranium extraction story better in those countries? I think that would then be the next question.
- loeg 4y agoI don't think it's particularly bad per GWh of energy produced. You just don't need that much uranium. Compare coal (still being actively mined and burned for energy!), natural gas, exotics for batteries/solar.
- tomatotomato37 4y agoIn Australia at least most of it comes from a copper mine that happens to intersect a uranium vein, so as long as the demand for copper exists its extraction is essentially environmentally free
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoOlympic Dan is the fourth largest copper deposit and the largest known single deposit of uranium in the world.
- rockinghigh 4y agoThe uranium used in France comes in part from Niger. The mines in Niger are operated by Orano, a mining company whose main shareholder is also France. There have been controversies about France using foreign aid to pressure the Niger government for more favorable mining contracts.
- kergonath 4y agoAny source at all? (Good luck finding one that supports your position). FWIW: yes, mining is bad. But uranium is unbelievably energy-dense and the amounts are ridiculously small compared to any other source of energy. All things considered, nuclear causes fewer emissions per MWh than most solar panels (which are not radioactive but still need heaps of metals and semiconductors). Also, there is no contest with coal, oil, and gas, which is the thing that is actually used when you don’t have nuclear energy available.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoMining can be done poorly, it isn’t bad, everything rigid we have comes from mining of some form.
- zelphirkalt 4y agohttps://invidio.xamh.de/watch?v=ioRtzOWm07A https://invidio.xamh.de/watch?v=ioRtzOWm07A Here you go. But really, if you had done a simple search of something like "france uranium africa" you would likely have found this yourself. If you only ever search for things supporting your position, but not the opposite position, you are prone to being in a bubble, never seeing contradicting information.
- shashasha2 4y agoGreenpeace documentary
- Raed667 4y ago> the commercial sector is the first being it That's not what they announced, the day before an area code will be revealed, and all electricity will be cut (including schools, public utility and telephone towers) > That’s been illegal for more than a year There is an exception if terrace area is "covered". Guess what everyone installed in the past year?
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoWhat they announced is in addition to what’s always done. The commercial sector has always been the first to be cut. Some companies actually have special contracts which mean they can be cut with barely any notice. If they do large scale blackouts it’s that they can’t manage the load without cutting normal customers so obviously it’s going to hit everyone.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoSame stuff in Germany. We ask households to save energy, but at the same time store windows and malls and whatnot are lit up all night long. Maybe it needs a separate higher energy price for businesses to change that behavior.
- bushbaba 4y agoIn the US industrial & large electric consumers often pay a cheaper $/Kwh price. But they also have additional peak demand surcharges.
- oezi 4y agoI can talk only about Berlin but many furniture stores have started to switch all lights off at night. Even the Ikea sign isn't lit anymore.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoI guess the take on that is, that there is no good regulation for it. If it can be one way in one city, for some of the shops, and different for other cities or other shops, then the measures/policies are not really reaching the target. Apparently one cannot rely on people doing the right thing, especially not, when they are in some kind of loosely associated group like a business, where no one feels responsible at the end. It might be a topic which needs intervention by the state to get the desired effect.
- morelisp 4y agoWhile I'm sure there's a ton of possible places for commercial use to optimize that aren't being done yet, stores leaving signs on all night was banned by the EnSikuMaV back in August.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoThey should come to my city then and start fining businesses for violating that.
- 323 4y agoIf malls waste it like that it means that the electricity is too cheap and still plenty. I bet that a lot of it it's subsidized in good old French tradition.
- f6v 4y agoSame in Denmark. A shitload of storefronts lit up at night.
- sofixa 4y agoWhat are you talking about? Did you forget to update your talking points when everything you're complaining about changed? Stores, including malls, are mandated to shut down lights and screens after hours. Christmas lights and the Eiffel tower shut down at 22:00. Restaurants and bars have been forbidden from heating up terraces for more than a year.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoWhat’s the reason that nuclear is so unreliable recently in France?
- martin_a 4y agoIn the summer they had lots of cooling issues due to low water, if I remember the news correctly. The article speaks of "ongoing or delayed maintenance, or corrosion problems" as the next reason for the problems.
- meroje 4y agoThey had to limit the output of warmer water in the stream because it was so hot already there was no margin left.
- lm28469 4y agoA bit of everything, 5 have been stopped due to cracks: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stress_corrosion_cracking https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stress_corrosion_cracking A few are having their once in a decade maintenance check Some are waiting for maintenance which were delayed due to covid We didn't train enough maintenance workers because everyone was talking about shifting out of nuclear in favor of renewable (we're using American contractors now afaik) So mostly bad decisions and poor management, it's a political issue more than anything else, it worked fine since the 70s to more or less a decade ago
- martin_a 4y ago> At the moment, half of the country's reactors are offline because of ongoing or delayed maintenance, or corrosion problems. The new generation of power stations has yet to be built. Meanwhile, in Germany, pushing renewable energies is frowned upon and people are saying "look to France, they're doing nuclear, THAT would save us, too". (Even more) Strange times ahead.
- lm28469 4y agoFrom absolute gold standard electric production/infrastructure in the 70s to barely able to light school rooms in 2022 I miss politicians who had a vision that didn't stop at the end of their term. We even had to restart a coal power plant last week...
- kkfx 4y agoThe issue is simple: privatizations. The public in the past have invested for the public interests. After the private have do not profiting from old State made investments leaving anything else falling apart. When they reach a certain level of mess they going out, leaving the State arrange the mess and handle the rage, waiting to came back once a new wave of investments will repair the mess. Unfortunately people seems to ignore that, allowing such model to prosper.
- cm2187 4y agoNot sure what privatisations have to do with the problem. My understanding is that it is a combination of a technical problem (corrosion happening at an unexpected pace) and the impact of covid lockdowns which deferred critical maintenance.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoPrivatization has everything to do with the problem. Let's take EDF and our nuclear plants. Why is EDF struggling financially today ? Because, through the magic of _opening up to the market_, they have been forced to sell up to 100TWh are prices as low as €40/MWh. The new private operators that came in simply resold that. And right now ? They're even kicking out clients, just so they could sell on the market at €1000/MWh. What does EDF struggling financially mean ? Among others, fully depending on the state to give them the money they need to exist, not being able to keep training and maintain specialists to repair such corrosion (we needed to import people because there were simply not enough qualified engineers for that), not being able to build more plants and therefore losing our edge in nuclear power. Why are most of our public services struggling ? Because over time, they've been handed out to private companies. Unemployment office ? Partly privatized. Tax collection from employers ? Privatized. Healthcare ? Partly privatized, and the beast is being starved so they can privatize it more. There has not been a single, memorable outcome of a public service being privatized in France and it getting better.
- cdot2 4y agoSo the issue is that many of their nuclear plants require long maintenance downtime simultaneously? That seems like something that could have been foreseen.
- lm28469 4y agoCan't forsee covid though, nor the war in Ukraine Without these two things we most likely wouldn't have blackouts
- Normille 4y ago>What had not been foreseen was the Russian invasion of Ukraine and the associated general energy crisis in Europe... >Can't forsee covid though, nor the war in Ukraine... Yes. Who could possibly have foreseen that announcing you're stopping imports of gas from Europe's biggest supplier, in the run up to winter, might lead to... er... a shortage of gas supplies. No-one in the corridors of power in the EU or UK, apparently.
- lm28469 4y agoIf you plan for these events you'll quickly stop all imports and exports because you'd have to be self sufficient 24/7
- f6v 4y ago> No-one in the corridors of power in the EU or UK, apparently. The whole conflict is just the other party calling bluff. But both the West and Russia have invested so much neither is going to settle. So they up the stakes and get dragged downwards. The only thing left is to complain that “it’s unfair the the US is profiting”.
- cm2187 4y agoI don't understand the advice of switching off appliances and lights at night. Surely if France has an energy production shortfall, it must be at peak period which is during the day from 9am until about 7pm [1], not in the middle of the night. Particularly given the vast majority of its production costs the same whether you use it or not (nuclear, wind). And even for gas, the problem isn't the quantity of gas available, it is the output of the gas power plants available. So saving gas during the night doesn't help peak production. [1] https://www.rte-france.com/eco2mix/la-production-delectricite-par-filiere https://www.rte-france.com/eco2mix/la-production-delectricit...
- hinata08 4y agoOn top of the peak production issue, there is also a fuel reserve issue As half of the the nuclear power plants are down, they have to rely on gas. And gas has become difficult to import. France feels both the liberalisation of the electricity production : Private operators promised to produce cheaper and cleaner power back in the 2000s. But they didn't. Virtually all of them used a scheme (the Arenh system) to get public electricity in bulk, sold to them at a loss and at a fixed price, so that they could compete with the public company on retail prices. Then the government was still in their privatization bubble, lobbies told them everything was fine, and they began to stop to maintain and to phase out public nuclear power plants. And now we no longer have electricity. The backup would be electricity made with natural gas. But you need to save that natural gas now. Russia froze the export of natural gas. And other companies know that gas is in short supply, so prices skyrocket. So yeah, we have to turn everything off at night.
- cm2187 4y agoI am sure France isn't contemplating blackouts to save on the gas supply.
- hinata08 4y agoNo i'm just saying there are 2 issues nowadays : peak production issue and how to keep producing electricity in the next year, as gas is difficult to source, and the tank might eventually run out. The government is just making a single campaign to simplify the PR ! In the same ads, they ask citizens to both reduce energy consumption (eg lower heating to 18°C), and to delay intensive usage out of peak hours (eg use you washing machine or the space heater during the day and not in the evening)
- daVe23hu 4y ago
- oezi 4y ago
- lizardactivist 4y agoYou cannot be serious. Why would Russia blow up their own pipeline instead of just saying "no"? Did you even listen to the US in the weeks leading up to the invasion of Ukraine? They were agitating more about Nord Stream and their own Energy Dominance agenda than actually talking about Ukraine, and to top it off Biden literally said right in front of the cameras that we want to stop the EU from buying Russian gas, and in fact we have a way of doing that.
- kazen44 4y ago> You cannot be serious. Why would Russia blow up their own pipeline instead of just saying "no"? because it denies the non hardline faction inside the russian political sphere the option of negotiating with the west. This further solidifies putin's position. Blowing up the pipeline made sure the war in ukraine had to continue, because stoppping the war will not result in the resumption of gas trade with the west.
- nullifidian 4y ago>non hardline faction inside the russian political sphere Who are the supposed "non hardline faction inside the russian political sphere"? What's "russian political sphere"? This is pure fantasy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oezi 4y agoBecause it is part of Russia's strategy to drive European energy prices higher and by forcing a hard winter to bully their way to negotiations in Ukraine. Europe already made it clear it won't go back to Russian energy so the pipelines aren't needed anymore. This also explains why nobody started with any repairs. For your insinuation that the US did it, there doesn't seem to be any evidence or motive. And if anybody wanted to really disrupt any Gas flow they would have needed to blow up all 4 pipes. Yet only 3 were destroyed. Also it would have been much too dangerous for any NATO member to engage with a military action against Russian property. It is most likely that Russia had already installed bombs during construction and just had to pull a trigger.
- brainchild-adam 4y agoFrance is not alone in this. In a way it seems Europe in general is headed for a challenging winter when it comes to energy supply. I wonder where this will lead. I assume that once larger parts of the population start feeling the effects of these energy shortages, some dynamics might change. At the moment, most do not seem to take much notice or care, not that I blame them. Life can be stressful enough as it is.
- kazen44 4y agoat the same time, gas supplies are at an all time high. The main issue seems to be absolutely atrocious timing of nuclear reactor maintenance. (which is just bad luck). > I assume that once larger parts of the population start feeling the effects of these energy shortages, some dynamics might change. I sure as hell hope that the dynamic will increase in providing ukraine with the weapons required to end of the war far more quickly. From a geopolitical standpoint, making sure russia does not win this war or end it in a stalemate is absolutely vital for European stability. Also, it could lead to further defence integration in europe. (this has already been fast tracked once the war started).
- lzooz 4y agoIn what way will Ukraine winning (whatever that means) help us in terms of energy?
- iudqnolq 4y agoRussia is already going broke. They could be forced to resume gas sales by financial need.
- sofixa 4y agoBest case scenario is a revolution in Russia leading to a new democratic free country that immediately withdraws from Ukraine, starts selling gas and what not for needed cash and goodwill, sends war criminals to The Hague, etc. Of course that's highly unrealistic. There is very little chance of a peaceful settlement between today's Russia and today's Ukraine (what Ukraine wants - its territorial integrity and probably reparations and war crimes investigations, is simply incompatible with the very nature of Putin's regime and situation), thus there's very little chance for Russian gas to flow as it did before any time soon. Hopefully by the time it's again possible it would have been replaced by alternatives.
- septune 4y agoAfter Fukushima nuclear accident, France green party shot on French nuclear plants, it was the new cool thing to push for sustainable only energy and bring down our nuclear industry. Newly elected socialist president stared at the green party so he also pushed against. 10 years later we have no plumbers, no welders, old plans, no gas. And more to come : because of Ukraine war and increasing EV, electrical power consumption is anticipated to reach peaks and cause outages. Thats what you get when politicians only consider their popularity, ignoring what experts used to warn.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoNo one takes the Green Party seriously in France. They won a few cities because the socialists are a mess and people wanted to punish Macron but generally speaking they are only useful as the butt of jokes. It’s not a serious political party in any way.
- masklinn 4y agoFWIW https://energygraph.info/d/cM9gMNZ4k/availability-timeline?orgId=1 https://energygraph.info/d/cM9gMNZ4k/availability-timeline?o... has a timeline of the various french reactors, and shows that some (tricastin 3, 4, cruas 3, budget 4, belleville 2) were restarted during november. I assume the part of the bars which is after the green (“update”) dashed line is previsional. It shows that more reactors should be restarting in the next few days although several (most notably all 4 N4 still) will remain offline over winter. And Cattenom 1 and 3 are apparently not planned to restart before late feb / early march. There’s also an overview dashboard which is just… sad: https://energygraph.info/d/q7IpAJHVz/overview?orgId=1&refresh=30m https://energygraph.info/d/q7IpAJHVz/overview?orgId=1&refres...
- coulditbenow 4y agoI wonder how this will affect people's circadian rhythms and subsequent health benefits, prime time for a study.
- seaman1921 4y agoIts funny how this is just a usual night in Indian cities where electricity cut happens daily - people will adjust and will be fine there is no need to panic, just put on more blankets and dont sleep naked
- locallost 4y agoWhat's interesting is that they are now a net importer of electricity, but not much. But it's straining the European markets in an incredible way the whole year. My guess, and totally not backed by evidence, is that a lot of countries like Italy etc. were extremely reliant on French electricity, and that they were basically using France subsidizing their nuclear plants and enjoying the deal, not needing to actually take care of their needs themselves. And now it's not there anymore. What's bad for France here is that nuclear plants basically need to run all the time to be even remotely economical - I read recently the EdF is losing billions and billions this year. Personally I think the situation is a lot worse then what they're admitting. They keep saying all year everything is fine, but then miss deadlines. The futures market was already going really high earlier in the year, but it affected the surrounding countries as well. Recently though it exploded in France only after they again pushed some deadlines back. Even Macron came out recently and said they need to remove roadblocks for renewables and be faster to give permits, which was a pretty big change in rhetoric compared to the usual "we'll build new nuclear plants". I think the next years are going to be renewables heavy in all of Europe, and people will be surprised how quickly things will change.
- tatref 4y agoEDF is losing money because of stupid decision like ARHEN that forces EDF to sell electricity at a low price, and also forces them to buy at a high price... So called electricity "providers" can sell electricity to customers without generating electricity in the first place, and also without transporting it. And at the same time, they get money from EDF through ARHEN!
- stefan_ 4y agoWe have the same in Germany with hundreds of "electricity providers" that themselves own no infrastructure whatsoever, just resellers. As far as I can tell the scheme is to aggressively recruit customers with signup bonuses and more, profit from the wholesale market as long as the prices are in your favor, and should the market turn against you simply declare bankruptcy and start over with a new company.
- codealot 4y agoUSA, Europe, China, India, Australia, Brazil, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Japan, and South Korea should just raise $1 trillion towards the sharing of nuclear reactor tech & know-how and renewables tech. Each government should raise another $1 trillion in debt to fund labor that will R&D, build and install more nuclear and more renewables 24/7 so that within 10 years from now we're carbon neutral. We have the technology to deploy and the labor sources available worldwide to create new productive jobs doing this right now, so what exactly is in the way?
- llsf 4y agoTechnology (Generation III+) is already shared with France, India, Finland, UK, Japan, China. Generation III+ are likely the most efficient/safe nuclear reactors at the moment. Ideally we would start to build hundred of them, so we could electrify our societies (including heat, transport, industry), and so we could transition faster to low carbon emissions world. The main international cooperation seems to be for the nuclear fusion with ITER. "ITER has already been described as the most expensive science experiment of all time,[24] the most complicated engineering project in human history,[25] and one of the most ambitious human collaborations since the development of the International Space Station (€100 billion or $150 billion budget) and the Large Hadron Collider (€7.5 billion budget)".
- DoreenMichele 4y agoIt's a shame that so much of the developed world just defaults to designs that require heating/cooling. Historically, we did a lot more passive solar -- often for the cooling part prior to AC, and then defaulting to wood burning stoves or whatever was standard tech for providing heat in a given era -- and it's a shame we have decided to pursue electricity-eating options rather than upping our game on passive solar design as the world has grown wealthier and more populous. (Yes, I read the article. Yes, I realize this is temporary for France.)
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoDevelopers will build the cheapest thing they're allowed to by code. While old world low energy homes were fairly custom, we know how to build low energy buildings and homes. The passive house standard [1] discusses repeatable low energy usage homes. The problem is that these designs are expensive. Developers build cheap houses that are only comfortable for use with lots of HVAC usage at low prices. People buy these cheap homes and then use energy to heat and cool. This places pressure on governments to keep energy prices low, which spurs higher consumption, and the cycle continues. It doesn't help that most areas with jobs in the Anglo world are very expensive lots to build new housing. When the lot itself is so expensive, local governments will be loathe to mandate too much by code and make housing even less accessible. If France is better at reigning costs in, they should work on bringing their building codes up to lower energy standards. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_house https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_house
- charles_f 4y agoBeyond the political outrage, what's interesting is that France is one of the only countries that makes nuclear safety legislation retroactive. This means that when new measures are decided, all existing reactors need to be upgraded before they can operate. This is not the case in the US for example. A few years ago during maintenance ops they discovered stress beyond tolerance on heavy steel pieces in some reactors that led to a change in regulation requiring new ways to measure carbon content in those pieces. From what I gathered basically the rule mentioned where measurements would be made to determine carbon content, and of course manufacturers didn't measure anywhere else themselves. Now the problem is that some of these are >100 tons parts in irradiated zones, it's not as easy as just going in with a carbon meter and taking readings. These have been built decades ago, some in other countries, so the know-how is somewhat lost. Plus they're under heavy industrial secret protection. From what I gather, EDF is now coming up with simulations based on their understanding of the manufacturing process to prove they're up to code and restart the plants.
- bamboozled 4y agoThis is a pretty good sign they either the people we are electing aren’t doing their job , don’t actually care about their job or they’re just overwhelmed and or incompetent. There has to be better oversight into what our tax payer money is going towards and for me personally, this is a prime example of where it’s not going in the right place?
- Kuinox 4y agoA recent article, in french, explain a bit why our energy sector is in this sorry state: https://www-marianne-net.translate.goog/politique/gouvernement/ignorance-stupefiante-lex-haut-commissaire-a-lenergie-atomique-dezingue-linculture-des-politiques?_x_tr_sl=fr&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-marianne-net.translate.goog/politique/gouverneme... > High Commissioner for Atomic Energy from 2012 to 2018 pointed out, in front of the deputies, "the scientific and technical lack of culture of our political class", according to him "at the heart of the problem" in French energy policy. > The propensity to consider that the technologies under development – hydrogen as an energy vector, smart-grids – can be, in a climate emergency, technologies to be deployed massively, in the moment, testifies to a profound ignorance of development deadlines. > Conversely, the procrastination on all decisions concerning nuclear power and the policy of announcements while waiting for concrete decisions to start construction show a staggering ignorance of the intrinsic inertia of heavy industries and the need for a stable long-term vision to maintain the industrial tool at the right level
- sbaiddn 4y agoWow. What decay from the excellence of a country that once picked presidents from the Poincare family.
- ck2 4y agoMore suffering all because one man is being allowed to be a tyrant. I know little about France except I thought they were well regarded by pro-nuclear folks for building a standardized system of duplicate nuclear power plants around the country that all used the same model/parts/system. I guess that didn't work out. BTW it's only 18 months until the Olympics at Paris 2024 and unless someone is going to drop a bunker-buster on baby-hitler-wannabe, his war on Ukraine is still going to be happening
- genjii931 4y agoIs France now run by Texan Republicans?! Mon dieu!
- 11235813213455 4y agoMy monthly electric bill, alone here in France, is 10-12€ https://imgur.com/grQqOdm https://imgur.com/grQqOdm (no heating and a good sleeping bag, lycra, socks for keeping the heat, no fridge (even in summer, no need for me), just a fan in summer, there's no discomfort, this simplicity is enjoyable, just saying this in case it can inspire more people
- psychoslave 4y agoDo you work remotely?
- 11235813213455 4y agoyes, 100%
- psychoslave 4y agoAwesome then. How do you manage to keep the bill that low?
- 11235813213455 4y agoVery few dependencies: a rice cooker, my laptop + phone, hair cutter, lights, fan in summer, washer very occasionally. No fridge (currently outside is the fridge, but not even in summer, I don't need one), no hot water and no heating besides natural heating (sun and my body and good clothes like lycra, sleeping bags)