6 ms·
It's still kind of odd to think that you can be an in-favor executive at a company, then somebody else can buy your company, fire you, and go back and read all
by dekhn 4y ago
It's still kind of odd to think that you can be an in-favor executive at a company, then somebody else can buy your company, fire you, and go back and read all your work emails (many of which would be extremely sensitive) and share it with journalists who then screenshot it and share it with the world on the same platform that employed you!
This was always a possibility (and a probability- my friend was a lawyer who went through senior employee emails at whatever company to find incriminating evidence to fire them... 20 years ago). But it's just odd to see somebody do it in realtime, blatantly, while also claiming they are doing some incredible product work.
Maybe twitter's policies were bad, and applied inconsistently. But there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party, and to be honest- I don't really care if they do. If Elon thinks this is some sort of big shock that will cause people to get excited.... I can't really see why.
- ransom1538 4y agoUse privnote it takes 4 seconds.
- mikkergp 4y ago> . If Elon thinks this is some sort of big shock that will cause people to get excited.... I can't really see why. I don’t think he does, I think he can literally see engagement falling in the days after a stunt and he’s trying to keep it up. Matt seemed to imply there would be another thread following this one so buckle up
- nkozyra 4y agoThis does seem to be the play. There is a story here! Politicians having direct access to social networks to suppress narratives they don't like is interesting. But 1) I don't think it's surprising and 2) it appears it was not politically motivated at least in a bipartisan sense. A story but one delivered with the kind of panache to drive traffic.
- starkd 4y agoThat's flat out false. He clearly claimed in the thread there was clear evidenceof political motivation. For one, he cited the political donations are heavily slanted. Secondly, he mentioned the mass confusion that reigned as they tried to fit it into the hacked material case, even though it was clearly was not. It was a NY Post story about a lost/abandoned laptop. Read the thread. A lone company acting on its own to suppress a story may not be surprising to you, but collaboration between government and a corporation to suppress speech definitely should be. It's where fascism begins.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- freejazz 4y ago> There is a story here! Politicians having direct access to social networks to suppress narratives they don't like is interesting. That's not even remotely news. This came out years ago. Still, your characterization is a bit ridiculous.
- nkozyra 4y agoIn what sense is my "characterization" ridiculous? Should we not take Taiibis tweets at face value? That's exactly what he says.
- freejazz 4y agoYou can do whatever you want. However, Taibbi doesn't provide a single email where the Biden campaign asks to suppress a narrative. There is an email where the Biden campaign asks for twitter to take down a few posts that were naked pictures of Hunter. I'm not quite sure that's what I'd call suppressing a narrative. Frankly, given the email, I find it hard to believe that could have been even most of the Hunter nude posts on Twitter. My reasonable assumption is that they were particularly graphic. None of this news today except that Taibbi has now proven that Twitter actually did have an internal debate about whether to take down the laptop story, which runs contrary to his own narrative. That's why I think your characterization is ridiculous because there is: a) no suppressing of narratives; b) the "direct connection" is the same thing any other VIP would have. Further to this, the guy was running for President of the united states, I can think of dozens of reasonable reasons why the campaign would want to have quick access to someone at Twitter. Also, your characterization is ridiculous because on top of assuming all that (which are contrary to the facts you are pointing to), you also made all of these assumptions without even bother to inquire what it was that was taken actually taken down.
- stale2002 4y agoWell that's why these executives get paid millions of dollars. If you can't handle the scrutiny, then don't accept a high powered job, at a multi-billion dollar company.
- nells 4y agoThey are not your emails, and you shouldn’t discuss personally sensitive matters using email accounts that don’t belong to you.
- madeofpalk 4y agoYou seen to be responding to a different point than that which was made.
- raphlinus 4y ago> If Elon thinks this is some sort of big shock that will cause people to get excited.... I can't really see why. Of course people will get excited. If Elon were to flog a "Hunter Biden's laptop" story that turned out to be that its hard drive was 4500 RPM when the SKU was marketed as 5400, and that capacity was measured in gigabytes rather than gibibytes, people would still get excited. Facts have little to do with any of this, it's all a post-modern, post-truth exercise in perceptions.
- pessimizer 4y agoThis isn't about any story that Elon Musk was flogging. It's about a true story that was published in a major tabloid about one of two presidential candidates on the eve of an election that every major media outlet colluded to suppress. Minimizing it is condescending. Tainting it through associating it with Musk is as cynical as tainting it by associating it with mystery Russians.
- refurb 4y agoIt’s pretty clear that the policy was heavily driven by connections and with 97%+ employees donating to the Democrats (edit:of employees who donated), it’s obvious which party had the ear of executives. What’s even more damning is how their own internal folks are sounding the alarm “how can we possibly defend this decision” and yet the decision stood. It’s pretty clear that Twitter had a very strong alignment to one political party and that resulted in the deliberate suppression of an important news story right before an election. It’s pretty scandalous.
- madeofpalk 4y ago> 97%+ employees donating to the Democrats 97% of Twitter (US?) employees donated to the Democrats? Is it normal for approximately 100% of your staff to donate to a party? This seems quite odd to me.
- afavour 4y agoYou’re conflating a few things there. It surely isn’t 97% of Twitter employees donating to Democrats. It’s 97% of donations by Twitter employees going to Democrats. I’d imagine the actual percentage of Twitter employees who donate to anyone is pretty low. Plus you’re then drawing a direct line from that to access to execs. IMO that needs specific evidence. Plenty of tech execs are well connected to both parties, because they’re, you know, rich elites.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoIt is not even slightly odd. Everybody from the lowest pleb working at any company is made very aware that emails, messages, and any communication that goes through company systems or computers or phones are not private, and may be accessed by the company at any time for any reason, or be subject to subpoena by third parties. > Maybe twitter's policies were bad, and applied inconsistently. But there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party, and to be honest- I don't really care if they do. If Elon thinks this is some sort of big shock that will cause people to get excited.... I can't really see why. Authoritarians love the idea of corporations subservient to government being used as a tool of the state to crack down on human rights. Lots of people don't see a problem with it.
- scifibestfi 4y agoIt doesn't matter which side, because isn't the problem that the government is doing an end run around the 1st Amendment? If you don't think so now, you might in 2024. So it's time to care now.
- john-radio 4y ago> Isn't the problem that the government is doing an end run around the 1st Amendment? "The Biden team" was not the government in October 2020. (For that matter there is a "Biden team" right now that has no governmental capacity, that is, his re-election team, which is probably engaged in these same kind of activities with many platforms.) I have to wonder if these communications aren't just pretty normal? It might be easier to evaluate how alarmed we should be if any detail were provided by Taibbi at all.
- bilvar 4y agoSo was it ok for the Nazis to beat people up before they were elected into power?
- andrew_ 4y agoThe discussion could do without this tangent.
- freejazz 4y agoThe prohibition on beating people up isn't limited to state actors. In fact, some might point out it's the opposite!
- bilvar 4y agoPeople keep conflating the 1st Amendment with the ideal of free speech. It doesn’t make it moral to suppress people’s speech because you’re legally not on the hook for it.
- scifibestfi 4y ago
- imgabe 4y agoNothing you write in a work email is private. Everyone knows this. Never write anything in an email that you wouldn’t want read in court.
- dekhn 4y agoThat nothing in work email is private is well-known (not everyone knows this). That wasn't my point. I place "company looks at employee's email after a credible report of hacking/abuse/whatever" and "rich person purchases major tech platform and uses it to publicize ex-employees email to affect public opinions" in two different categories, especially given the ex-employee was a C-level officer handling some extremely complex and sensitive decisions.
- imgabe 4y agoThey’re telling people the truth about how the decisions were made. Complaining that this “affects public opinion” and that the emails were “sensitive“ is just a fancy way of saying that what the public was previously told were lies.
- freejazz 4y agoWhat in the emails indicates anything was a lie? You'd think Taibbi would bring that out if there was such a hot example. Besides, the poster's point was that many of these people are now going to receive death threats from whackjobs, not that their contents were too sensitive.
- jonas21 4y agoIt doesn't seem that different from the more typical "rich person (or company) sues major tech platform, employee emails become public record as part of the lawsuit and are publicized to affect public opinion". Though it is amusing that both sides are the same company in this case.
- partiallypro 4y ago> But there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party You don't even need this "Twitter Files" thread to know that there is plenty of evidence; I don't really see how you can say with any such confidence that Twitter's policies have been even handed.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoThis seems like a kind of question where people are going to come to different conclusions based on what echo chamber they are part of (because news of different instances of policy enforcement are going to be promoted by different groups). You could try to get a handle on the objective truth through a quantitative analysis. Otherwise, we’re all just claiming our priors are obviously the truth.
- chroma 4y agoBecause of laws passed after the Enron scandal, publicly traded companies are required to retain internal communications for long periods of time. So if you're going to blame anyone for this, blame the government. Also the owners of Twitter knew that Musk would have access to these messages. That was priced into the deal. Executives and managers at publicly traded companies are very aware of information retention policies and make sure to avoid putting certain things in writing. That's why so many of the emails are along the lines of, "Can you take a look at this?", or "More to review from the Biden team.", instead of being explicit commands. It's just a miraculous coincidence that every single one of those requests results in censorship or banning. > there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party, and to be honest- I don't really care if they do Ah yes the old, "It didn't happen. And if it did, it wasn't that bad. And if it was, they deserved it." If you truly believe that there's no clear evidence, then I don't know what to tell you. Taibbi shows emails where Twitter and the US government collude to censor true information that people wanted to read. That is a big deal.
- Bilal_io 4y ago> Twitter and the US government collude I see everyone saying this while ignoring the timeline. This happened before the 2020 elections. Biden was not president back then.
- guiambros 4y agoThe golden rule: before sending anything potentially sensitive, ask yourself: if this email/doc/note were to be published on the cover page of NYT, would you be embarrassed by it? If yes, don't send it, or rephrase it accordingly.
- dekhn 4y agoI don't know why people keep pointing this out- I already knew this when I made my comment. I knew it from the day I joined Google and it was just proved out when I read my own manager's email (from a previous role) on the front page of the NYT. This is very different from legal discovery and disclosure.
- bvhvhfcgxfdf 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>Maybe twitter's policies were bad, and applied inconsistently. Clearly they were. >But there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party The evidence is not only clear, but overwhelming. But more than favoring a party, they favored the DC blob narrative. See the treatment of Wikileaks vs the treatment of CIA propaganda accounts like PropOrNot or Bellingcat as crystal clear examples. >I don't really care if they do. If Elon thinks this is some sort of big shock that will cause people to get excited.... I can't really see why. This is really the problem and the issue at hand. Many whose perceived political opponents are being silenced and attacked by the unholy cabal of government and big tech don't care (or worse, are happy) because they have no principles. At the end of the day, those they look down upon, or that they think are bad for whatever reason, are getting the shaft, and that is just fine with them. Those of us with principles think that everyone deserves to be treated by the same set of rules, even those people we don't like or who we think are bad. Unfortunately, the schism between the principled and unprincipled is only growing wider as the former group shrinks and the latter group grows daily.
- dehrmann 4y ago> your work emails You mean emails the company paid you to write for its benefit? They were never yours. Also, there's the adage about never emailing any statement you wouldn't want on the front page of the NYT for this exact reason.
- bakugo 4y ago> But there is no clear evidence that they explicitly favored one party "There's no REAL proof that large corporations overwhelmingly favor the left" is the political version of "there's no REAL proof that the earth is round"