12 ms·
Starlink speeds in US dropped from 105Mbps to 53Mbps in the past year
- grecy 4y agoIn even slightly rural Australia and Canada Starlink has been life changing. It’s easily the fastest internet available once you are a tiny bit out of a town. In actually remote Australia it was crazy to see locals go to the pub to use it, having never had access to anything better than dial-up. In rural and remote places, it’s changing the world, exactly as it was designed to do. If you live in a dense urban environment, Starlink was never really designed for you.
- deevolution 4y agoI've been getting about 80 mb/s. Still outperforms the only available alternative in my area by 500x.
- diebeforei485 4y agoThis article relies on Ookla speedtest results. I don't think those are representative for satellite internet, when speeds vary throughout the day based on satellite positions relative to the user. People usually go to test their speed when they feel their connection is slow, so it's not a uniform random sample.
- yencabulator 4y ago> I don't think those are representative for satellite internet, when speeds vary throughout the day based on satellite positions relative to the user. Huh? It's not Hughes, Starlink is not geostationary. Starlink satellites are in low orbit, orbiting the whole globe in about two hours. The dish switches satellites every few minutes. https://satellitemap.space/?constellation=starlink https://satellitemap.space/?constellation=starlink
- diebeforei485 4y agoYes, the satellites are moving, so the quality of service at any time varies depending on where the satellites are at that time.
- yencabulator 4y agoThey move quickly enough that your variation would be on the time scale of minutes, not over a day. (Earlier in the beta, I had a 20 ms hiccup every few minutes, during the hand-off to next satellite. I'm guessing the IP routing wasn't in sync with the satellite switch.)
- diebeforei485 4y agoCorrect, and it's when users feel those hiccups that they're going to speedtest.net - so the results are not representative. Terrestrial broadband doesn't have hiccups as frequently, so the speedtest.net results would have a better signal to noise ratio for terrestrial ISP's vs for Starlink.
- hasmanean 4y agoWas that when they went from 1 user to 2?
- wdb 4y agoStill shocked that satellite Internet is faster than copper Internet in parts of Central London (U.K.). Definitely not able to get 105Mbps
- mickotron 4y agoI finally was able to get fibre in my area, so I dropped Starlink. Data caps are incoming, and the cells near me are over-subscribed. Speeds have been getting worse over time.
- belval 4y ago> Starlink's median US upload speed dropped from 12Mbps to 7.2Mbps from Q4 2021 to Q3 2022 I wasn't able to find an answer online. Is this the expected "ok" upload speed? 7-12Mbps seem low for typical WFH usage like video conferencing and sharing your screen.
- fetus8 4y agoWell, considering I've been using Starlink since Jan. 2021, the upload speeds have been more than adequate for typical WFH video/audio calls. The download speeds dramatically falling over the last year have been a major annoyance when it comes to updating games via Steam or stuff like Microsoft Flight Sim, but streaming video has been perfectly fine the whole time. Seeing the speeds drop is a bit of a disappointment, but given the reliability of the connection versus our previous ISP, it's 100% worth it for now.
- belval 4y agoThanks! I've been wondering if exiling myself deep in Canada and using Starlink to be fully remote was viable. Do you notice any impact from the increase latency (compared to coax cable or fiber) in meetings/voice chat/video games or would it pass the blind test? Additional question, do you get any connection degradation in bad weather events (if you have them)? Things like snow and storms.
- fetus8 4y agoI don't notice any increase in latency in meetings or voice chat. I don't play any real online multiplayer games, but I did do some summoning in Elden Ring the other night and I didn't notice any lag or weirdness with the other players. We've noticed some slower speeds and satellite obstruction during heavy snow and super heavy intense thunderstorms, but otherwise it's been fine in most of the weather events we experience out on the eastern plains of Colorado.
- extragood 4y agoGeneral rule of thumb for 1080p video streaming = 8 Mbps 720p is half the size, so it should be half that rate = 4 Mbps. I have no doubt that modern image compression algorithms can bring that down a bit further without too much impact on quality. So with a median of 7.2 Mbps, that's probably enough for 2 users to have an acceptable video conferencing experience. But if that's the median, then half of their customers have a lower upload speed than that and may only be able to get away with a single user streaming at a time.
- chrisco255 4y agoThis is the opposite of my personal experience. For me, the service has been more reliably performing at higher speeds and since launching more satellites there are fewer drops in connectivity.
- smt88 4y agoGood for you, but not relevant for the topic in the article. The FCC should make decisions based on data, like the data collected by Ookla (if the FCC can't collect its own), not based on anecdotes.
- hunterb123 4y agoGood for the FCC, but it's not very useful if the data is all from congested cities, I can't find where they list their sampling. Starlink shines when it comes to rural/remote environments, not cities where towers and fiber can reach. Side note, look at HughesNet and Viasat in their data, LOL! edit: instead of downvoting if someone could find the sampling method?
- mike_d 4y agoCities vs rural has no impact on Starlink speeds. You fall into a "cell" which is a hexagonal region roughly the width of California. Each cell is served by a satellite that has a 20 Gbps downlink to a ground station. Everyone within that cell shares that 20 Gbps, and everyone using the ground station (4-8 cells) shares the backhaul capacity of that site. (This is oversimplified but puts the capacity scoping in context)
- hunterb123 4y agoProviding broadband to rural america, what this whole FCC broadband push has been about, concerns those cells where there aren't many people over a large spread of land, where towers and laying down lines doesn't make sense. So if you take a cell that has LA in it, it will be much more congested than if you took a cell in Wyoming, or Nebraska.
- Netisneverfree 4y agoSince this is network and internet related, just want to chime in with some experience using non-standard internet connection methods. It may help in understanding what's happening here. Starlink as I understand it, while using 'satellites' is more like 'terrestrial tower' based internet, but with low-orbit stations in use instead of towers erected on a high hill. I make this distinction, because of other 'satellite' internet companies having been used to compare it in the past, in my opinion, erroneously. Satellite internet like Xplornet for example, do something else where you have just a few satellites only, providing line of sight connection for EVERYONE on the facing side of the planet for that satellite. Starlink is more like terrestrial tower because you have essentially a choice of which satellites you want to use to connect through, since there are many that could be connected to at any time. This is like terrestrial tower, because your home might be closest to a tower in a town near you, but the other tower just off the side a bit further away gets less usage and so you have less issues connection due to congestion or 'things' getting in the way. Things could be tree canopies, house roofs, etc. So what I figure is happening here after reading the article, is that their current configuration is reaching levels of congestion that can't keep up with the demand they expected, and so they are going to start launching more satellites to keep up with the demand. They are also looking to increase the broadcasting signals strength to help ensure a higher quality connection to those who do connect to their system. That's basically terrestrial tower internet itself in a nutshell from my experience using it in the past. Even their ping times are similar. Now for those who get their knickers in a knot because 'thing orbiting planet in space is always a satellite'. Yes, I know. It's technically satellite internet in that right. But my point is that this isn't how we should be thinking of it. We should instead be calling it Aerial internet, since it helps differentiate from the other satellite internet (which in my usage experience is crap and should only be used in the worst case scenarios) and terrestrial tower which is also not the greatest, but is better than stuff like Xplornet. I've never met anyone who likes using services from folk like Xplornet, except obviously ignorant people who never have had anything better. The moment I show them the difference between their connection and mine back at the farm, or here in urban life; they immediately try to make up excuses for it instead of accepting it isn't that good. But that's besides the point. My point is that Starlink is doing pretty good if they are only seeing that much of a drop in speeds and latency. It's still a usable connection by rural standards, which was its intent mostly to begin with. It wasn't meant to be used by urbanites who have access to much better; as I understand was what was intended by Elon in the first place. For comparisons sake: Most rural internet only ever gets UPTO 50mbps at best, in the best locations. You can expect to get much worse in rural areas with terrestrial tower based internet. And while many including Xplornet may falsely advertise they can achieve higher speeds; latency kills their performance. It doesn't matter if you can get 300mbps, if your latency is a full second or higher of ping time. not milliseconds. Seconds. Even minutes sometimes. Depends on how bad the situation is for you. So, with that all in mind, despite all the Elon hate going on right now; I think Starlink is doing pretty good still. I don't have it, yet; since I don't need it. But if they keep on this path they are on right now, when I move back to the rural areas I am probably going to get Starlink as a backhaul connection, and a terrestrial tower setup as my main connection. Or perhaps vice versa. Depends on which one has the better and more stable connection in that area. But I would never use traditional satellite internet like Xplornet. If I ever did, it would be because I have enough money that I can throw it away and not care; all just to make sure there is a redundant connection to ensure that I have a backup for my backup. Even then... I'd rather just get a second company on terrestrial to hook me up instead.
- seanherron 4y agoI've been using Starlink as my primary internet provider for the past year. I'm just outside of Eugene, OR and prior to Starlink my only internet options were Viasat or dial-up. I definitely notice the variability of Starlink. My download speed ranges from ~40mbps to ~200mbps, and my upload speed ranges from ~5mbps to ~50mbps. This doesn't really seem to be connected to time of day or what I would expect to be typical use patterns. My internet is never unusable for Zoom, streaming video, or other average use cases. A lot of people complain about decreased speeds, my personal experience hasn't really shown this to be true. What I have noticed: * Over the past year, I've seen a huge improvement in latency and packet loss. I used to have latency in excess of 130ms, and I would typically see a few dropouts lasting ~30 seconds per hour. My latency now is rarely more than 60ms, and I never have dropouts. * Being behind an IPv4 CGNAT is annoying. I get a lot more captchas and fraud prevention techniques being applied in my browsing. * Geolocation is way off. I wish SpaceX did a little bit more effort to dedicate IP geodata to specific cells in their network - everything defaults to their Seattle POP for me. * The adoption of Starlink out here is astonishing. Virtually every house near me has gotten it in the past 2-3 months. It's a huge game-changer for people. It's pretty amazing what the Starlink team has built out in a relatively short amount of time.
- nekoashide 4y agoPeople were tossing traditional internet satellites from roofs, chopping off the old dried up copper from the side of the house and pushing the wisp tower down. Starlink made remote living and work truly possible. No more turning off video, pixilating and worrying about data plans. And low enough latency to make up with skill in games. But just like everything it got too popular, cellular carriers are trying to service that market though and t-mobile might be a last mile internet provider with decent speeds and unlimited data. But, fiber is also getting buried all over rural areas to help with this as well. Between fiber/cellular and Starlink people are going to get interesting data plans for sure though. Wisp are regional and the market will shrink because the service is just inadequate and poorly maintained. The smart wisp that got federal high speed internet subsidies will survive building out fiber even in some pretty rural areas.
- Dig1t 4y agoAs someone desperately looking for connectivity options in a more rural area (though not that rural, I'm only like 20 minutes from one of the largest cities in the state) I won't hold my breath. My whole neighborhood is on the waitlist for Starlink still. I've called every provider that could possibly service our area and nobody has any interest. T-Mobile is supposedly offering 5G home internet for people in this kind of situation but they are not available in this neighborhood either. No idea what to do other than wait for Starlink availability. There is a WISP, but it is truly terrible and very expensive.
- mdasen 4y agoI'm always curious about details on situations like this. Really nerdy stuff like: what's the average housing lot size; what's the average driveway length; what kind of "largest city in the state" (since 20 minutes won't get you from LA to another part of LA and in most places I've seen 20 minutes won't get you far from a city at all which makes it sound like you're in a state where a top-5 city has 100,000 people and becomes rural fast). One of the problems a lot of the US faces is that the cost of infrastructure is shared by so few people: rural roads that have few homes on them, electric lines that have to travel farther to reach customers, sewer systems that require more feet per customer, etc. In a lot of rural places in Europe, people often live clustered in a town center, but rural America tends to spread out a lot more with a lot of distance to cover to connect people. It doesn't really matter how far you are from a city as much as how easy it is to connect lots of households in your area. As you note, one of the problems that Starlink is facing is that everyone who wants Starlink generally lives in the same areas. Are there a few hundred households that want Starlink within a 7 mile radius of you (150 square miles)? Then there's likely to be capacity constraints, at least until Starlink can launch a lot more satellites. All three wireless carriers are offering home internet in situations like yours, but with slightly varying offers. T-Mobile has an unlimited offering in areas where it has excess network capacity. T-Mobile also has a "Lite" offering that is available everywhere T-Mobile has coverage, but it has a data cap and costs $150 for the 300GB plan (https://www.t-mobile.com/support/home-internet/t-mobile-home-internet-lite.html https://www.t-mobile.com/support/home-internet/t-mobile-home...). AT&T has a home internet offering for $60 with a 350GB cap (https://www.att.com/internet/fixed-wireless/); https://www.att.com/internet/fixed-wireless/); overages are $10 per 50GB up to a maximum of $200/mo. I don't know if that's $200 total or $200 in overages + $60. At $200, it's certainly expensive, but Starlink isn't cheap. The average home internet user uses around 300GB of data (data from both T-Mobile and Comcast), but that's probably not people on Hacker News. Still, 1TB would be $170 which isn't that much more if you're desperate and doesn't have as high a startup cost (Starlink's being around $700 while AT&T's is up to $150). Verizon also offers home internet service at cheap costs (either LTE https://www.verizon.com/home/lte-home-internet/ https://www.verizon.com/home/lte-home-internet/ or 5G https://www.verizon.com/5g/home https://www.verizon.com/5g/home depending on where you are), but availability is limited like T-Mobile's unlimited service. Have you looked into Starlink's RV service? It's more expensive at $135/mo and you're deprioritized behind standard Starlink customers, but that might be a good option. I hate saying this, but once you're in for $110/mo, what's another $25? Well, $300 per year. But if you're desperate, it might be what you need. Things will likely get better over the coming years. T-Mobile will be covering half of rural households over the next few months with mid-band 5G and they're also embarking on a huge rural coverage expansion with 10,000 new towers coming to improve coverage. Verizon and AT&T are behind on mid-band coverage, but it's coming. Starlink will be launching more satellites which will give them more capacity. If you don't mind paying an extra $25/mo, Starlink RV might be the best solution. However, people have reported being annoyed that they haven't been able to switch to regular Starlink (and save $25/mo) when capacity becomes available. Definitely check Verizon and AT&T's offering and see if there's something right for you there (and available). It feels like a long-shot, but I'd rather mention them than not even if there's just a 1% chance it'll help. Over the next few years, we're likely to see AT&T, Verizon, and T-Mobile gain a lot of capacity in rural areas as they bring online a lot of spectrum and Starlink will launch more satellites. Right now, since you say you're "desperately looking", maybe grab Starlink RV or even AT&T's service.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoInteresting: “Starlink outperformed fixed broadband average in 16 European countries” https://www.ookla.com/articles/starlink-hughesnet-viasat-performance-q2-2022 https://www.ookla.com/articles/starlink-hughesnet-viasat-per... Here are their methods: https://www.ookla.com/articles/how-ookla-ensures-accurate-reliable-data-2021 https://www.ookla.com/articles/how-ookla-ensures-accurate-re... They do not separate between rural and city speeds.
- qayxc 4y agoWell, the methodology is flawed, or at least it doesn't actually reflect what it says on the tin. It's "consumer-initiated", i.e. what they are really measuring is which contracts people are using, not which speeds are available. Example: I could book a 500/100 line at my house (1000 symmetrical available if I switched providers), but I stick with the cheapest plan, which is 50/12 simply because it's good enough for my personal use. Same for most of my neighbours. Most don't have more than 100/20, though higher speeds are readily available. With StarLink there's only type of contract: you get what you get and that's that. In Europe for example, there's usually more than one option per ISP and you pay more for higher bandwidth. So if you're fine with the smallest plan (usually around 50mbps), why pay more? So in essence they actually answer a different question.
- rr888 4y agoThis is expected with a new network though right? My first 4G phone was a rocket then slowly slowed down over time as more people got 4G phones.
- kalleboo 4y agoI remember them claiming that performance would actually go UP as they launched more satellites to fill out the network
- yencabulator 4y agoIt did. It's a question of ratio of consumers & usage vs satellites & ground stations.
- Scoundreller 4y agoI could see there being an opportunity for 4G+Starlink setups. Run Starlink when you need the throughput and turn off that 100w heater when you don’t. I’m already looking into a timer to turnoff my modem, gaming console and router at night just to turn off that ~20w load doing nothing. http://www.tpcdb.com/list.php?page=2&type=12 http://www.tpcdb.com/list.php?page=2&type=12
- sneak 4y agoThere is an argument that if you have 4G/5G, you don't really need to go all the way to LEO.
- Scoundreller 4y agoTechnically true, iff you have functioning telecom competition. In Canada, 1G/2G/3G/4G/5G has captured the regulators for decades. Would be interesting to know where the starlink demand is in USA and how much it overlaps with areas that have 4G+ coverage.
- giobox 4y agoIn many-to-most cases 4G and especially 5G will simply outperform Starlink. If you have the 4G it may not even be necessary to bother with the Starlink. Unless you want redundancy of a 2nd connection or you can only get a really terrible data plan running both is not likely to make much sense. Starlink also has very onerous North-South field of view requirements that are actually often hard to meet even on completely remote sites (speaking as a Starlink customer with a handful of trees in the yard). Cellular is nowhere near as fussy about placement. Starlink makes most sense when you have no 4G or 5G reception at all, generally speaking.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoIs home internet pretty much "fast enough" for anyone else right now? I used satellite internet for almost a full year. I was about 20 minutes drive from 3G. Honestly, it was absolutely fine. Video conferences, online real time games, streaming videos... Right now I'm on a copper line. Granted, it's only us villagers and country folk using it since the local big town moved to fibre. But again, the speed is fine.
- ghaff 4y agoStarlink isn't for people who have decent copper broadband somewhere in the 10s of Mbps down that's reasonably reliable. It's for the people who can't get that and there are a lot of them.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoRight, did you miss the bit where I had satellite internet and had to drive some distance to access mobile internet?
- kiratp 4y agoNot even close. As an example, waiting for my consoles to update games and losing half my hour of free gaming time is terrible - and I have 10G wired around my house to a 1G Comcast connection.
- bobdvb 4y ago"Fast enough" is a contentious point for many tech people. There are very few consumer use cases that demand super fast broadband. I think basically you can say that you need about 15Mbps per person with 10Mbps overhead/margin. But 50Mbps is basically "fast enough" for the average household (browsing and streaming), it just means that game downloads or OS updates will be slower than you might like. My experience is that 200Mbps is "more than enough for most" and above 500Mbps will barely be used in most normal applications, it just makes the internet /snappier/. Most websites and downloads don't actually support download at 1Gbps, well there's always all those ISO downloads... If you have a house full of nerds then super speed broadband has value, but most people aren't as nerdy as that. That being said, Starlink is showing how over hyped it really was. Sure, they still need to launch more satellites, but it's a continuous obligation on SpaceX to keep replacing the infrastructure. I respect the need for those in rural areas, but suburban/urban folks (who will be affected by congestion the most) need good/affordable fibre. Even many of the rural folks (the less extremely isolated ones) could be supported by good mobile broadband infrastructure.
- neonsunset 4y agoStarlink is seeing heavy use in Ukraine with most stocks in the neighboring countries getting bought up. The reason for that is russian strikes on our infrastructure causing electricity blackouts to the extent of regular internet or 4G being down/highly degraded. As a result, many companies, individuals, offices, etc. are procuring their own sources of energy (diesel/gasoline generators, portable power stations, etc.) and reserve internet connections via Starlink or powerful 4g modems that can reach further cell towers with access to good connection. That with already prevalent use of Starlinks on frontlines (they are very hard to jam and far surpass other satellite offerings). We do not have access to data but it's not unreasonable to assume that such a spike in use must have eaten into overall network capacity.
- dotancohen 4y ago> prevalent use of Starlinks on frontlines Wouldn't anti-radiation missiles (usually used against SAM batteries) seek these Starlink terminals?
- yencabulator 4y agoOne would expect the missiles be a bit more picky about what they target, or setting up fake targets to defend against them would be way too easy.
- to11mtm 4y agoAdditionally Satellite and Microwave links aren't new technology and are likely used by both sides of military for communication, so there's probably some existing value in making sure you're hitting the right thing.
- neonsunset 4y agoIt's not powerful enough of a source, different frequency bands and, as with GPS too when it comes to jamming, the signal goes mostly upwards so the missile won't be irradiated by it to respond.
- 4y ago
- karaterobot 4y agoFor people who used to be on old satellite systems, Starlink is still the best value by far. The qualitative difference between 105Mbps and 53Mbps is much less than 2x: there's not much you can't do with one that you could with the other. Not being an apologist, just trying to keep perspective. People who really need Starlink are still getting a great value compared to how it was a couple years ago.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mdasen 4y agoIt's probably also more beneficial from a policy standpoint to get twice as many people signed up at 50Mbps. As you note, the jump from 50Mbps to 100Mbps isn't that big, but the jump from 3Mbps DSL to 50Mbps Starlink means that you can suddenly use a lot of the internet that never really worked well before. It could definitely be annoying to customers who had signed up and are now getting significantly less speed at the same price, but Starlink has a bit of a captive audience since they're mostly serving people without other options.
- kccqzy 4y agoI moved from one room in the house to another room when working remotely, and I experienced a similar drop in my speed due to being farther away from the Wi-Fi access point. And yes, there's not much you can't do with one that you could with the other. I made this choice voluntarily but tech geeks should visit the homes of non-tech people and see that (a) their speed is limited more by their connection to the Wi-Fi access point than by the ISP, and (b) they aren't bothered by it.
- test6554 4y agoI pay $110 per month for internet at my farm land that I visit two to three days every 60 days. If they can pretend I deserve to pay as much as people who use it as their primary internet service, I should be able to pay a lower amount if they halve the bandwidth on me.
- 4y ago