11 ms·
> The popular radio program “On the Media” feared Musk’s support for free speech would lead to a free-for-all environment rife with child pornography. But that’
by ceejayoz 4y ago
> The popular radio program “On the Media” feared Musk’s support for free speech would lead to a free-for-all environment rife with child pornography. But that’s a strawman: child pornography is illegal.
This is itself a strawman.
No one thinks Musk will permit it on Twitter. The gutting of the moderation teams who tackle it is the concern. An underenforced rule is often not a very effective one.
- throwawaydad12 4y ago
- ceejayoz 4y agoAgain, it’s not about whether or not he wants the stuff on Twitter. If you fire all the staff who find it, handle user reports of it, and remove it, the end result is the same.
- throwawaydad12 4y agoIt doesn't matter how many flunkies you have on staff. What matters is whether the stuff is effectively caught and removed (and probably reported to the authorities). Time will tell on this, but currently Musk looks a lot _more_ credible on this than Twitter 1.0. They seemed to have been a lot more focused on repressing wrong-think than dealing with actual criminal behavior. And this isn't just abstract--they helped ruin countless lives.
- seattle_spring 4y agoDo you have data that shows Musk is taking down more CP or similarly vile illegal content than "Twitter 1.0?" Or are you seeing the news that he took down a few noteworthy hashtags that had previously been ignored and using that as broader evidence?
- skorpeon87 4y ago> (or who's old enough to remember Polanski) That's not a resolved matter by the way. He's still alive, still a convicted rapist, still a fugitive, and still defended and respected by Hollywood-centric media. He continues to evidently be immune to 'cancellation' because... influential people in movie industry like his movies I guess.
- rayiner 4y agoThat was a product of a bubble of 1970s liberalism that was open minded towards sex between adults and young teenagers. It was an intersection of the 1960s sexual revolution, and the 1960s trend of treating kids more like adults (e.g. Tinker v. Des Moines)—but prior to the #MeToo era focus on affirmative consent and power dynamics. They simply couldn’t understand the backlash against Polanski.
- whateveracct 4y agoAre you implying Balenciaga is .. trafficking children or making child porn or something? Not sure what you mean by "the person we should be worried about." My understanding is they made an offensive photoshoot using children but I wasn't aware of any sexual abuse allegations. I'm aware of the court opinion on the blanket and the sexually suggestive stuffed animals. It's inflammatory, sure, but there's definitely a case that it's artistic as well.
- throwawaydad12 4y agoNo abuse that I've heard of. But very offensive. Look further (not at work). It's too gross to describe on HN. I'm pretty strong on free speech myself. But if you want to repress awful stuff, Musk is not the place to start. And the narrative that he's somehow lowering the level of discourse on Twitter is absurd.
- User23 4y agoFor added weirdness “ba len ci aga” is Latin for “do what you want.” See for yourself with Google translate. It could also be translated as the more familiar “do what thou wilt,” a rather infamous occult credo.
- whateveracct 4y agoThis is started to smell like Q-adjacent nonsense to me
- feet 4y agoThat's basically what it is
- axlee 4y agoThe company was founded more than a century ago by a spanish prodigy named Cristobal Balenciaga...stop with the conspirationist nonsense. Not here.
- andsoitis 4y ago> tolerate child pornography (unlike the prior owners of Twitter) Twitter previously tolerated this? That’s the first I hear of that. Do you have more info?
- Amezarak 4y agoAt least some activists are saying that since the takeover, the moderation of CSAM has been dramatically improved after complaints had been falling on deaf ears for years. There are complaints that the old moderation team was ignoring clear and well-documented reports. https://twitter.com/elizableu/status/1566255230374842369 https://twitter.com/elizableu/status/1566255230374842369 https://twitter.com/elizableu/status/1594137408186073089 https://twitter.com/elizableu/status/1594137408186073089 What's shocking is that apparently Twitter has had a massive CSAM problem for years and Twitter's crack moderation team apparently did very little about it, not even banning hashtags reported to them repeatedly. And none of this got attention until Musk bought Twitter. [removed section about addition of new reporting option] I say this as someone who is not in the slightest a Musk fan.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThat thread is debunked in the comments; the CSAM report option predates Musk. https://twitter.com/ChronicBabak/status/1594762640357982208 https://twitter.com/ChronicBabak/status/1594762640357982208
- Amezarak 4y agoThanks, I will remove that part of the comment. Assuming good faith from someone who appears to be extremely active in this area, perhaps this was an A/B tested feature and she didn't have it. What I find more concerning about this is the way media attention is used offensively. Clearly CSAM has been a problem on Twitter for some time. But only post-Musk is CSAM on Twitter becoming a focus of attention in the media. Is it increasing or decreasing? We're likely to get only fearmongering articles about the T&S team layoffs.
- someNameIG 4y agoI've been following her for a few weeks now. I think she is coming at it from a good position but she also seems to be a very big Musk fan, and takes what he says at face value. And many of the replies to her tweets come from very Qanon people.
- anigbrowl 4y ago[flagged]
- autoexec 4y agoAll online platforms need to have moderators to prevent things like spam and illegal content. That doesn't mean that they can't also uphold the idea of free speech principles though. Musk really went crazy with cutting staff, but I'm not sure if it was because he wrongly thought he needed to cut the moderation teams in order to support free speech or if he just did it because moderation is expensive.
- drewrv 4y agoWhy is spam always glossed over in these "principled defenses" of free speech? It's legal speech.
- abathur 4y agoA kind of motte-and-bailey, I guess.
- Extropy_ 4y agoWhat desire does a platform like Twitter have for spam? We have laws that prevent people from uttering threats. Twitter has rules against spam. It's their platform and they want their users to be free in their discourse, they just don't want spam.
- onetimeusename 4y agoit is or can be. It's a weird case though because you could theoretically drown out everyone else's speech with it. Like imagine if there were no spam inboxes or spam restrictions on SMTP or email inboxes and for every one good email you got, there were 10K spam emails about enlargement pills. It would make email much less useful and maybe unusable. I have thought about this before and I get kind of annoyed when people assume spam is a given exception to free speech. Free speech by itself doesn't imply a limit. So I think you have to carefully design around this issue or just let it happen and maybe it dies off on its own since too much spam chases everyone away and then what's the point of spamming? edit: drowning out other people's speech may be allowed by total free speech but it's also contrary to the intention I think. I think free speech means that any speech someone wishes to make, they may do so without restriction or censorship by the medium. This isn't a completely satisfying definition though.
- elpool2 4y agoThis is the quote they're referencing: NATALIE WYNN (the mind behind Control Points, a left wing YouTube channel) I do think that looking at 8Chan is a pretty good case study in what happens when you create a "okay, let's just let people say anything." People are posting child pornography to this website on a fairly frequent basis. I think you're right. "On the media" was just talking about how having an "anything goes" policy leads to a place where nobody wants to hang out, where people post illegal stuff even though its technically not allowed. Which I think is valid when Musk has previously said Twitter should allow anything legal.
- krapp 4y agoFor reference, it's ContraPoints.
- User23 4y agoTwitter recently shut down several child exploitation hash tags that had been ignored until Musk took over.
- andsoitis 4y agoSuch as?
- jessaustin 4y agoIs that really the sort of thing we need on HN?
- nonethewiser 4y agoYou can easily find them on google if you're actually interested.
- willsmith72 4y agoWhat a hero
- nonethewiser 4y ago> No one thinks Musk will permit it on Twitter. The gutting of the moderation teams who tackle it is the concern. An underenforced rule is often not a very effective one. This isnt cause for concern because they've already caught some longstanding CPU. They are doing a better job now.
- watwut 4y agoI mean, they are actually not doing better job. Nothing like that was demonstrated at all.
- pjc50 4y agoIt's been grimly entertaining to watch the Musk/Kanye cycle from inviting him back as a symbol of free speech to discovering that Kanye interpreted that as antisemitism was green lighted now, to banning him again. I guess that's the context for today's free speech discussion.