6 ms·
You know what baffles me? That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. When I see a independen
by crazygringo 4y ago
You know what baffles me? That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies.
When I see a independent developer complaining about Apple (or Google) being arbitrary in their app review process, I can at least understand how it's some low-paid employee trying to fulfill a daily quota. It still sucks, but I see the economic rationale of low-paid, low-skilled app reviewers there.
But it really surprises me that when it comes to apps from well-known tech companies like Coinbase, that Apple isn't doing a higher-quality review by people who actually know what they're doing and understand the industry. That there isn't a knowledgeable team inside of Apple making sure that corporate partners are treated like partners rather than niche indie developers.
I'm not saying a two-tier system would be more fair, because obviously it wouldn't be. I'm just saying it surprises me that a company like Apple shoots itself in the foot like this with bad decisions that then lead to bad press. It's such an own-goal. (Because in this case, the 30% cut doesn't even make sense conceptually, it's like trying to tax Amazon 30% on physical goods sold through its app.)
- naravara 4y agoThe problem is being an established, known company doesn't mean you can be trusted to not behave badly on the platform with regard to security vulnerabilities or user privacy. See Facebook as a prime example. The bad press doesn't really matter as long as they have such a dominant profit share on all mobile software sales.
- shagie 4y agoAn old example of well known companies behaving badly... https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/23/15399438/apple-uber-app-store-fingerprint-program-tim-cook-travis-kalanick https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/23/15399438/apple-uber-app-s... > The practice, called fingerprinting, is prohibited by Apple. To prevent the company from discovering the practice, Uber geofenced Apple headquarters in Cupertino, changing its code so that it would be hidden from Apple Employees. Despite their efforts, Apple discovered the activity, which led to the meeting between the two CEOs, in which Cook told Kalanick to end the practice. If Uber didn’t comply, Cook told him, Uber’s app would be removed from the App Store, a move that would be a huge blow to the ride-sharing company. According to the article, “Mr. Kalanick was shaken by Mr. Cook’s scolding, according to a person who saw him after the meeting,” and ended the practice.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoCook love money. Meanwhile he is cracking down on Chinese protestors and doesn’t bat an eye.
- rootusrootus 4y agoYou read that story and Cook is the villain? Uber deserved to get slapped down for that behavior. Should have knocked them off the store for a week just to punish them for the attempt.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoIt just shows he has principles when he gets paid more.
- shagie 4y agoUber doesn't pay any cut to apple. The money collected by Uber is for services and clearly falls under: > 3.1.3(e) Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase physical goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry.
- bilbo0s 4y agoWell, this is why we can't have nice things. I get so ticked off with these other tech companies that on the one hand want me to support them in their fight to get more laisez faire access to Apple devices, and on the other actively engage in what are undoubtedly some of the most consumer hostile privacy invading practices on the planet. They actively compromise security, and then lobby and payoff senators to get better access because they are unable to compromise consumer security enough to make the profits they need. The entire industry from Apple on down to startups needs to be nuked with a "no use of user information for any commercial purposes at all" law. Coupled with draconian fines that pierce the corporate veil and are assessed per user violation. We need something like GDPR in the US, but more strict. Apple isn't the problem. I'm starting to see that this entire industry is problematic. Apologies for the rant.
- shortcake27 4y ago> The bad press doesn't really matter as long as they have such a dominant profit share on all mobile software sales. It also doesn’t matter because there’s no alternative. “Side-loading” can’t come quick enough. I have no issue with the App Store vetting apps arbitrarily, but there needs to be an alternative where developers can provide their apps direct to consumers without this BS.
- naravara 4y ago> “Side-loading” can’t come quick enough. I have no issue with the App Store vetting apps arbitrarily, but there needs to be an alternative where developers can provide their apps direct to consumers without this BS. I'd have agreed with you up until I heard about that Facebook Onavo thing and now I don't trust even that. Turns out companies whose whole business is emotional manipulation are really good at dark patterning users into doing unwise and unsafe things with their machines.
- Marsymars 4y ago> You know what baffles me? That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. What makes you confident that they don't?
- selykg 4y agoMy experience working with a very large app is that, yea, they basically do. Or at the very least, you get yourself in a certain relationship with Apple that it sort of is like this. When we had a version we needed to get through quickly due to a bad bug, we'd shoot our contact an email, a few leadership members had this contact's phone number if needed. We'd make a call, and within an hour we usually had the version approved. Sometimes it did come with a caveat of "you're going to need to fix this issue before the next update" or whatever if we hadn't quite followed the rules, but they gave us a bit of leeway in emergency situations. This does not really mean all updates went through this super fast process. We had to wait weeks at times for app approvals. So it's not really VIP reviewing, it's more like VIP treatment if you're big enough and know the right people. Edit: and yes, we often ran into the situation of the previous version did something that we figured was fine, and approved by one reviewer but then the next update was flagged as no good by the next reviewer despite the last one approving it.
- Aulig 4y agoThis process seems to be available to regular apps too now. When Apple rejects an update, they ask whether it's a bug fix update you need approved quickly. If yes, you can resolve the identified issues with the next update. They started mentioning this in the past few weeks when I was updating clients' apps.
- selykg 4y agoit's a little different. In our case we were circumventing requests to make changes to the app to get approval. We were effectively getting a free pass to ship the version with a possible App Store rule breakage, this one time, and getting it approved super fast.
- musk_micropenis 4y agoWhat difference do you think a "higher quality review" would make? Apple is enforcing their strict policy that all purchases from within apps (with some documented exceptions) must use Apple's IAP and cough up the 30%. This has nothing to do with Apple's kafkaesque review process and everything to do with their policies, which have been increasingly strictly enforced for the last couple of years.
- bonestamp2 4y agoI think he means the "people who actually know what they're doing and understand the industry" part. Someone who understands how crypto works would understand that the user is not making a payment to the app developer and therefore Apple has no claim to a cut of the transaction. If this is the way that Apple wants to enforce their policy, they'll have to take a cut of the transaction when I open my banking app and use that app to pay a bill.
- unityByFreedom 4y agoIsn't it obvious that making crypto payments easier allows devs to circumvent Apple's cut? I don't think people would accept any percentage taken of crypto exchanges. Let's not beat around the bush. This is Apple protecting the way it earns money, not trying to levy fines on crypto to make more money. I'm pretty sure they understand that this decision makes them unpopular with some people. Their bet is that it preserves the model where there is still a functional review system for code that runs on your phone.
- simondotau 4y agoApple doesn’t ask for or take a mandatory cut of in-app money transfer services. They also don’t take a cut of any physical goods sales (e.g. grocery shopping) or physical services (e.g. Uber car rides). They take a 15% or 30% cut of all in-app experiences (e.g. entertainment, productivity software, content subscriptions). This is levied through the App Store and IAP. (They take 0.15% of card payments if they are routed through Apple Pay, levied from the regular merchant fee associated with all card payments. However this is not forced on anyone and bank pays anyway, willingly, as the lower rate of fraud means the fee represents good value.)
- freediver 4y agoCurious what would the criteria for VIP status be if there was such system?
- littlestymaar 4y agoThey could charge a few tens of thousands a year for the status, and most non-small companies would pay for it easily.
- Marsymars 4y agoMost non-small tech companies. I work for a medium-sized non-tech company where the total resource spend on the apps for our customers doesn’t amount to tens of thousands a year.
- littlestymaar 4y agoYou're right, obviously as a medium-size company can have a very little digital activity. Such companies probably don't fit in a “VIP category” for an app store though.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago> ... Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. Why do you say that they don't?
- matwood 4y ago> You know what baffles me? That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. I'm not sure this is true. I know years ago they had an expedited track you could get on. Once we got on it, we had very quick reviews, re-reviews, and releases. I would read about people waiting weeks while we almost always had 48h turn around. I don't think expedited exists anymore since turn around is always quick now, but I could easily see them routing big names towards a senior review team.
- maccard 4y agoEchoing the other comments here, why do you think they don't? I worked on <insert_very_large_game_here> and we had dedicated contacts at apple, special agreements for (some) rules and a different SLA to what I now know is standard.
- singularity2001 4y ago>> Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps they do. Some years ago my app was in the top 100 and I had nice telephone calls with real human people.
- smoldesu 4y agoIt's shocking that this isn't part of the $99/year developer program. 15-minute quarterly check-ins with an Apple developer seem fully within their means.
- richbell 4y agoBut then it wouldn't be free money.
- danpalmer 4y agoIt sort of is. You get 2 developer technical support tickets (DTS). These are essentially at the level of having an engineer look at your code and help you figure it out. With these they’ve done things like review my build settings when I was having difficulty with a complex build. I believe App Store consultation is one of the available topics, but if not it would be worth trying anyway. These tickets are clearly worth a lot more than $50 each if used well.
- smoldesu 4y agoInteresting, I didn't now that. Still though, my recommendation is mostly tongue-in-cheek because even spending 5 hours with an Apple engineer won't fix OP's problem. Nevertheless though, thanks for sharing!
- 1123581321 4y agoWhat's OP's problem? Everyone has told them that there are multiple tiers of attention in the review department. Plus you get the support credits for specific issues (i.e. ones that aren't a business problem like the 30% cut.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- busymom0 4y agoThey do. Small developers get apps rejected for now including detailed update notes whereas big companies like FB, Uber, Google routinely put out updated with generic update notes which is against Apple's developer guidelines. Uber geofenced Apple’s Cupertino headquarters to hide that it was tracking iPhones and yet they weren't banned entirely from the App Store. They got a mere threat from Tim Cook. https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/23/15399438/apple-uber-app-store-fingerprint-program-tim-cook-travis-kalanick https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/23/15399438/apple-uber-app-s...
- varispeed 4y ago> You know what baffles me? That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. That sounds elitists and what is wrong with capitalism. It gets distorted by big corporations having their way with their big elbows inhibiting growth and competition. Then you have people supporting the VIP lane are part of the problem. Corporations should get equal treatment regardless of their size or in fact small business should get _more_ help than big corporations.
- pixl97 4y agoWhy? If a company is giving me millions of dollars a year which is going to my employee salaries I am answering their call first. The guy paying me $10k a year will have to wait.
- hackernewds 4y agoThis is what doomed Twitter early on. Not respecting the devs, Apple has its day of reckoning approaching as well.
- lostgame 4y agoThey do. Source: I work for a major bank in Canada and I know people with direct lines to people at Apple who handle this kind of thing.
- trevor-e 4y agoAs others have said, they do. Apple also has dedicated representatives to handle communications with the top apps and partners in various App Store categories, like Games, Travel, etc.
- jfoster 4y agoI suspect they very much do have those two separate tracks, but make it look as though it's a single track. When Coinbase get their rejection, I very much doubt that it's due to lack of consideration within Apple.
- joenot443 4y ago> That Apple doesn't have a separate, "VIP" review process for apps that are from established, known companies. Something tells me you've never worked on a top 20 app before then. These VIP review processes absolutely do exist, and any company with an app consistently in the top rankings usually has a contact at Apple on the review team. Coinbase is a very, very small fry with an app which probably less than 0.1% of iPhone users have installed. I'm not at all surprised they wouldn't make the cutoff for special treatment from Apple. Why should they?