3 ms·
Missing: estimated Covid deaths without intervention (lockdowns, vaccination, etc.)
by amelius 4y ago
Missing: estimated Covid deaths without intervention (lockdowns, vaccination, etc.)
- jehb 4y agoMissing: estimated Covid deaths with adequate intervention (lockdowns were followed rigorously, everyone actually got vaccinated, etc.)
- seydor 4y agoMissing: Arguments that are deeper than tweets
- xeyownt 4y agoMissing: a reason why these fictive estimates would be of any interest.
- amelius 4y agoMissing: years of potential life lost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Years_of_potential_life_lost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Years_of_potential_life_lost Perhaps a more useful metric, since so many more older people died from Covid.
- smt88 4y agoThere are enormous numbers of papers trying to quantify this. If you haven't seen these estimates, you didn't read any Covid literature in 2020 or 2021.
- marcosdumay 4y agoOr, to be blunt, they tried to stick with non-fiction. People asking for estimates that fit their agenda is quite predictable, but those estimates aren't very useful. Anyway, your point stays, ignoring the huge amount of estimates produced, and asking for them later is quite a bad posture.
- ren_engineer 4y agoIsn't Sweden a decent comparison for not locking down? And the majority of less developed countries also did minimal lockdown. And Africa as a whole has a 6% vaccination rate, so we can make comparisons
- spurgu 4y agoYup. While they had a lot of elderly die early on that's mostly been it. They certainly haven't had the issues of people missing their cancer screenings, alcoholisms/suicide due to isolation in lockdowns etc. that many other countries have had. And Africa as a whole practically unaffected.
- triplesec 4y agoThese are countries with much higher mortality rates already because many of their health systems are not even close to as well-funded and available as a European one. So, many fewer cancer screenings to go to. And more deaths already from other ailmants. Also, largely these countries are much hotter and more aerated / outdoors places. So, comparisons are not particularly helpful.
- ghaff 4y agoAt the time, there were at least claims that, well, even absent government edicts, people did adjust behaviors to a certain degree. It's unfortunate but, at this point, it's starting to look like there are so many confounding variables--and so many people dug in on political positions--that it's going to be hard to say, even with the advantage of hindsight, what optimal courses of action should have looked like. Vaccinations were almost certainly helpful on net but not a silver bullet. Other mitigations were probably more or less helpful at various stages of the pandemic but likewise were probably not as helpful as proponents said they were and some were probably on net harmful.