11 ms·
Hungary used citizens’ Covid data to help the ruling party
- xiphias2 4y agoFor us Hungarians this isn’t really news, it wasn’t even secret how unfair and illegal the last election was. Viktor Orban is running a hybrid authorian country that’s going into the authorian direction, and right now I don’t see any way to stop him.
- kspacewalk2 4y agoTo me, Orban is the symptom of a larger problem. If the majority of Hungarians are against him and the ruling party, stopping him will be a matter of having massive protests and forcing him to resign. The hard part is breaking his spell over Hungarians.
- saiya-jin 4y agoThis... world has no shortage of hyper-inflated egomaniacs who would like to rule a galaxy or two if they could, regardless of their actual skills. If this is combined with smooth-talking, these people, albeit being horrible leaders and bad for future of nations, tend to get re-elected over and over by folks you don't see nor hear about in the news, aka silent majority. Same as ie Putin - for every protester/leaver this year there is literally 100 that are +-content enough to stay, maybe sometimes throw a complaint or two and continue business as usual. And vote for him. Even with some corruption and election rigging I'd say (and happy to be mistaken) they are properly majority-popular, just not 96%-popular. Then one realizes part of population is plain stupid in rather unfixable way, and the choices become being cynic for rest of life or simply leave.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> for every protester/leaver this year there is literally 100 that are +-content enough to stay I've never been to Russia. The impression I've formed is that there is a strong nationalist/imperialist camp among the Russian population. I'm inclined to trust the Levada polling organisation, and they say that Putin (and his invasion) have broad support among Russians. We tend to personalize these things; e.g. it's all Putin's fault. I think that's a mistake; if you don't acknowledge that the nationalist/imperialist sentiment is widespread in the population, then you'll attack the wrong target, e.g. by trying to assasinate Putin. But if the xenophobia and nationalism are just part of the national sentiment, that's not going to work. I have no idea how one might set about combatting nationalist/imperalist sentiment in a foreign country; traditionally we use spies and trouble-makers, but I don't think that works well.
- kspacewalk2 4y ago>I have no idea how one might set about combatting nationalist/imperalist sentiment in a foreign country When it goes beyond sentiment and into a genocidal war of aggression, like it did in Russia, there is one approach that no one in their right mind would advocate for, but it does work. It certainly worked in Germany and Japan.
- denton-scratch 4y agoSure; strategic bombing (I suppose that's what you mean). Actually, my understanding is that both countries were militarily defeated; I believe that strategic bombing was really just political theatre.
- saiya-jin 4y agoWell Japan gave up immediately when Soviets entered the war with them, fire bombing of cities wasn't doing much on decision making. And Germany was literally defeated to last soldier standing, so yes strategic bombing definitely didn't defeat neither of those, just helped starve army for resources
- xiphias2 4y agoA lot of us who have the means to protest left the country instead as a form of protesting, because it's so easy to move inside EU. A huge other part of Hungarians who Orban gave votes to were born and poor people living in Romania and getting just a little bit of money from the country to vote for Orban, but they are not paying taxes (representation without taxation is just as bad as taxation without representation, which was achieved in Magna Carta). Hungarians living in Hungary had 1 day to vote, while Hungarians living in Romania had weeks and could vote in letter.
- epicureanideal 4y agoThis sounds like the “politicians picking the electorate” that is complained about in the US when amnesties happen, and about debate about mail in voting and so on. I think there’s a valid discussion to be had about this but it doesn’t seem completely unprecedented.
- hylaride 4y agocough cough https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolution_of_Dignity cough cough
- VictorPath 4y ago
- hylaride 4y agoOh please. Any direct US involvement was long after the movement was well underway. The Ukrainians picked who should run the country (then and since), and the fact that they picked somebody who the US could work with is testament who they want to align with. Any subsequent elections, as well as who Ukrainians are literally fighting now, is only more validation that the maidan revolution was organic.
- VictorPath 4y ago
- dane-pgp 4y agoEven if you believe that the votes in Crimea and Donbass were as free and fair as Ukraine's national elections (which I don't), there is still the small matter that those votes were illegal under Ukrainian law, and thus their outcome is meaningless.
- hylaride 4y agoYou think those elections were fair, that's cute. The 80%+ referendum rates sure are validated by the blue and yellow flags being waved when the Ukrainians return. Anyways, obviously no point arguing anymore.
- fsagx 4y agoIf you had left Donbass out of your argument, I think it would be a lot more compelling. In the aftermath of the USSR breakup, referenda in the 1990's indicated large majority of Crimea did not want to be part of Ukraine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Crimean_sovereignty_referendum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1991_Crimean_sovereignty_refer... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1994_Crimean_referendum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1994_Crimean_referendum
- lo_zamoyski 4y agoI'm not impressed by the fainting couch "oh, that authoritarian Vktor Orban" polemics for the same reason I find US political discourse obtuse and genuinely hateful. There is a consistent refusal (and inability) to engage with the topic intellectually and a tendency to dwell in emotionalism. It's intellectually shallow and lazy. Orban must be understood in the broader cultural and political context. Fixating on Orban is a way to ignore the problem, a convenient way to scapegoat someone for all the things you don't like, good or bad. Projection abounds. If Orban never was, someone else would take his place. The political rifts today are not merely over policy, but over basic ethical matters and norms. Scapegoating is just a way to avoid having to deal with your real problems by projecting onto someone often superhuman causal powers that would explain why things aren't the way you'd like them to be. Conspiracy theorists do the same thing.
- hdjjhhvvhga 4y agoYou are right in a way, but you can't ignore the influence of powerful individuals on the society in general. Yes, there are many conservatives in Hungary, but it's a whole different level if the person representing them repeatedly breaks the law and pushes things much further. An analogous situation is in Poland. The unofficial ruler of the country declared that Germany is the biggest enemy of Poland, playing on the feelings of the older generation, and is trying to build a narrative around that (the EU servers only Germany, hence EU = evil). That wasn't a narration among Polish conservatives a few years ago, it was constructed by a single person and spread by his minions and the media he is controlling. The biggest absurdity of the last days was when Germany proposed giving Poland Patriots, the Polish defense minister happily agreed as any normal person would, then the day after after the unofficial ruler got berserk he completely changed his opinion and refused to accept them (how can Germans protect Polish sky if we say Germany = Evil?). What a shitshow!
- amusedcyclist 4y agoIf any of you were looking to spew a bunch of pseudo intellectual nonsense while distracting from the point at hand. This is a fine example of how to do it
- 4y ago
- epicureanideal 4y agoWhat is he doing to win unfairly? Are the tactics different than in all other European countries, the US, Australia, Canada, etc?
- chpatrick 4y agoMainly using state assets to campaign for his party (incredibly biased state media/propaganda posters everywhere). He's also had a supermajority since 2010 and has used it to change the voting system in his favor.
- TrackerFF 4y agoHe pretty much controls (or influences) all of state media.
- Proven 4y ago
- kneebonian 4y agoThe government choose to use data that it had to further the interests of those in power in the government? Color me shocked, absolutley shocked, at least this doesn't happen in America where politicians keep their pinky promises and only use untapped sources of wealth and power for things they promised they would. I mean I rest easy knowing my government is keeping my social security money safe for me so it will be there when I retire.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoHa - right. I hear people say, “Save for retirement!” I’m sorry… but at this rate of inflation, and this rate of political instability, and this rate of national debt, I’m pressing X to doubt the US (or at least the economy of it) will still exist by the time I retire. At least not in its current form… In which case… I’ll probably have as many kids as I can afford and hope for the best at this rate. Worth remembering the US is the longest-running country with the same constitution (Britain doesn’t have one and has changed politically in significant ways compared to the US in the last 240 years). All good things come to an end. The US is statistically overdue.
- kneebonian 4y agoWell do save for retirement just in sheep, bourbon, ammo and land.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoMore important than all of that is probably investing in a network of people willing to defend you, who also have ammo. One person or one family can have all the ammo, but they are not going to be able to do much against a larger tribe.
- RajT88 4y agoDo make sure you are the only guy with sheep though.
- motohagiography 4y agoOrban's far right government is a great straw man for testing public outrage levels and narrative impact for what every other government did (and worse). I discovered that covid data is used in a similar way in Canada, where vaccination status data (name/dates/doses/addr/ph) was passed to a PR/oppo firm working for a politicians office. The data was sent to an outsourced call center to call people on behalf of a private PR firm that had the same name as an internal government department (a mere coincidence, surely). Given vaccination dates were and are a strong proxy for political leanings, this oppo research firm working for campaign offices is not only in posession of this medical information, but they shared it with call center contractors. I had a lengthy email exchange with the privacy office about it to get assurances of the privacy protections and recourse in the contracts, and they declined to provide copies of the agreements governing the relationship between this firm and the privacy protections for this medical information, and basically bumbled and delayed until I went away, ultimately yielding nothing. I didn't go to the press about it because the mainstream press could not be relied upon to be principled and investigate privacy breaches and other abuses during covid for fear of enabling hesitancy, and going the alternative media route would just set me up for retaliation by the government, so I let it go since as a privacy professional, I had got evidence of my suspicions about how egregiously the data has been handled. The rollout was one of the most cynical abuses of public trust in history, to the point where the Atlantic published a piece about "amnesty" for the people behind it - for what precisely, we are only learning now in trickles and spurts. If this is something you care about, contact the agency or the privacy officer of the government department that administered your vaccinations and ask them for the list of parties your data was shared with, and for copies of the privacy impact assessments they were obligated to do, and the contracts with those parties that presumably have privacy protections and recourse for breaches written into them. I've moved on, as my opinion about these actions is set, but if you want the story of what went on, ask for the privacy impact assessments (or lack thereof) for the data sharing of vaccination data. Further, you can ask for how your consent to vaccination was collected (it wasn't, and there wasn't a way to register that you were being subject to a medical procedure under duress either), and the picture of what the response was becomes clear. Sure, Orban's a hate figure, but he's also a test balloon for how much the Economist and its establishment colleagues want to admit about what they did, and a mirror for calibrating what your own governments almost certainly did as well.
- Reason077 4y agoWhy is it up to Human Rights Watch to police this? If Hungary has violated European privacy directives, and it sounds likely that they have, then why isn't the EU holding them to account?
- dane-pgp 4y agoThe EU generally delegates enforcement of directives to national governments, since governments like Hungary's would not vote to give the EU the powers and budget necessary to hold such governments to account.
- thinkcontext 4y agoPublished yesterday: EU seeks to freeze €13bn in funding to Hungary over corruption fears https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/nov/30/brussels-seeking-to-freeze-13bn-of-eu-funds-to-hungary-over-corruption-fears https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/nov/30/brussels-seeki...
- KurvaKing 4y ago
- astrea 4y agoWait until y’all hear about the amount of data points American political parties have on each citizen and use for targeted ads.
- halfjoking 4y agoHungary at least had opt—in checkbox. US political parties are so much worse… “Voter analytics firm PredictWise harvested location data from tens of millions of US cellphones during the initial Covid lockdown months and used this data to assign a “Covid-19 decree violation” score to the people associated with the phones. These Covid-19 decree violation scores were calculated by analyzing nearly two billion global positioning system (GPS) pings to get “real-time, ultra-granular locations patterns.” People who were “on the go more often than their neighbors” were given a high Covid-19 decree violation score while those who mostly or always stayed at home were given a low Covid-19 decree violation score. Not only did PredictWise use this highly sensitive location data to monitor millions of Americans’ compliance with Covid lockdown decrees but it also combined this data with follow-up surveys to assign “Covid concern” scores to the people who were being surveilled. PredictWise then used this data to help Democrats in several swing states to target more than 350,000 “Covid concerned” Republicans with Covid-related campaign ads.” https://reclaimthenet.org/us-analytics-firm-covid-19-decree-violation-scores/ https://reclaimthenet.org/us-analytics-firm-covid-19-decree-... Where was Human Rights Watch on that one?
- mzs 4y agoThe 85 page report is found here: https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/12/01/hungary-data-misused-political-campaigns https://www.hrw.org/news/2022/12/01/hungary-data-misused-pol...
- 323 4y agoIn UK it's much worse. To be eligible to vote, you need to register on the Electoral Register. But when you do that, all UK political parties get access to your information (name and address, maybe nationality). And there is no way to opt out. You can only opt out of commercial companies getting access. Credit ratings companies have access too. > The electoral register lists the names and addresses of everyone who is registered to vote in public elections. The register is used for electoral purposes, such as making sure that only eligible people can vote. It is also used for other limited purposes specified in law, such as: Detecting crime (e.g. fraud) Calling people for jury Service checking credit applications > Anyone can inspect the full register. Inspection will be made under supervision. They can take extracts from the register, but only as hand written notes. Information must not be used for direct marketing purposes, unless it has been published in the open register. Anyone who fails to observe these conditions is committing a criminal offence. > The Electoral Registration Officer has a legal obligation to share some of the information. This includes absent voter information and copies of the marked register (this is the register which indicates whether someone has voted, but no how or for whom they have voted), which can be supplied to the following people: Elected Representatives Election Candidates Political Parties The Electoral Commission Police forces and similar bodies https://www.birmingham.gov.uk/info/20097/elections_and_voting/1726/privacy_notice_of_electoral_registration/4 https://www.birmingham.gov.uk/info/20097/elections_and_votin...
- pjc50 4y agoIs this actually worse? It's not tied to the ruling party specifically. The UK is slightly weird in not having a single unified national identity system. Instead it has a number of critical ID checkpoints: you need ID to buy or rent a house, and to have a bank account, before we even get into voting for which ID requirements have just been introduced based on the US "fraud" narrative. But there isn't actually a specifically named "ID card" or "ID database". Instead we have all these para-ID schemes. The electoral register is one of them.
- 323 4y agoThe problem is not the electoral register existing, but that it's used for other purposes too. Basically any intern which works for a party election team has access to the complete list of UK voters.
- Fervicus 4y agoHighlighting Hungary here would make more sense if somehow Hungary was one of the few exceptions. Which country hasn't misused the pandemic?
- Archipelagia 4y agoHungary is particularly bad – they had a pretty strong turn towards authoritarianism and putinism over the last few years. Like, yeah, everyone did pretty poorly during Covid, but using the pandemic to strengthen Fidesz hold on their country is another level.
- kramerger 4y agoI was under the impression that Hungary was the only country ruled by a far right party that took covid seriously. Now, this explains a lot.
- heywherelogingo 4y agoAnd no other country did this? And yesterday people were arguing about the quality of The Economist?
- jtbayly 4y agoThis doesn't seem as bad as local governments using tax money to campaign for higher taxes... (See your local US school district asking for an increase in property taxes...)