9 ms·
I understand where you are coming from, and support you on that. On the other hand, I'm pretty happy with the default state of an iPhone. It just manages itself
by bayindirh 4y ago
I understand where you are coming from, and support you on that. On the other hand, I'm pretty happy with the default state of an iPhone. It just manages itself, and all that hard problems (backups, updates, ease of use, experience homogenity, etc.) are solved.
I manage more than enough servers at work, and I don't want to manage another server in my pocket, do nitty-gritty settings, allow selected apps background access, try to find what changed and what broke every update.
I'm using Linux for 20 years, and I'm not going to change that, however Android is not Linux and settings persistence on Android is just not present.
My parents use Samsung A9s, and I help them configure theirs from time to time, and seems like every important setting is either buried six levels deep or is not guaranteed to stick after an arbitrary time.
While iPhone's (or Apple's) ecosystem lacks control, it promises dependability, and this is huge in removing obstacles from your productivity. I can just get things done in my iPhone and never touch settings app ever, except the occasional "is my battery doing good" checks.
- bamboozled 4y agoExactly the same sentiment for me. I use both devices and I couldn't be more happy with the freedom this allows me. I own everything about the critical devices I work on, Linux. I have a magical device which "just works" in my Apple products. If someone breaks this, I'll be sad.
- shever73 4y agoThe "it just works" argument is what keeps me using an iPhone, even though my computers and servers all run Linux. Years ago, I replaced my trusty Nokia 6310 with an O2 XDA phone. It ran Windows CE, routinely crashed or froze and would be unable to make or receive calls. Since then, I've always wanted a phone that just works. The iPhone is the nearest thing to that for me.
- bamboozled 4y agoI "rooted" my Android once, it was a nightmare. Never doing that again...on my primary phone at least.
- Krasnol 4y agoI think it is about having an ADDITIONAL option to access things not about taking the "Lock me down, I don't care"-status away.
- mleo 4y agoThe unforeseen consequences of the former will break the latter. Schools, Test Proctoring companies, Game companies will "force" users to install the ADDITIONAL option to run whatever is required and then simply extend their reach beyond what is appropriate.
- onion2k 4y agoI find the "Apple's engineers aren't capable of doing this in a safe way" argument a bit hollow, because the option basically already exists in iOS. All people want is the option to jailbreak iOS in an official way rather than some sketchy hack. As for services that 'demand' you install something, the option exists on Android and no one demands people install things on their Android devices. Why would iOS be different?
- vineyardmike 4y ago> As for services that 'demand' you install something, the option exists on Android and no one demands people install things on their Android devices. Why would iOS be different? https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/mobile/android https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/mobile/android 1. It is used now. 2. Google is a lot less aggressive than apple (see meta vs ATT).
- heavyset_go 4y agoI don't see where Epic is forcing anyone to do anything.
- vineyardmike 4y agoIf you want to play Fortnite - one of the most popular games for a generation of people- you can’t use the play store. You need to side load or use a supported store. Sure it’s not “forced” like you go to jail or your phone doesn’t work, but you can’t use the way 99% of people will get their games.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>settings persistence on Android is just not present As opposed to Apple quietly changing airdrop behavior based on what opinions the CCP has on freedom of speech? I get why you like Apple and voluntarily submit yourself and all your private data to the comfort of the JustWorks (TM) ecosystem, but after their whole "we're gonna keep scanning pics on your device (actually our device) for CP", there's no way I'm trading my freedom and privacy for the sake of a little bit of comfort Apple's ecosystem offers. Also, If Apple would open up their OS/ecosystem more, it means other SW vendors could offer the same quality of life of Apple's own apps, such as easy backups, photos and music, etc. but since Apple has everything locked down in their favor, of course only their apps work the best on iOS and alternative are always second class. Microsoft was sued for this in the past for monopolizing certain app segments by shipping them as default with Windows (Internet Explorer, Media Player, etc). In the end, I trust no billion dollar publicly listed mega-corp to own my data and lease it back to me for a monthly fee, as they're beholden to their shareholders who demand constant revenue growth, and once they capture the majority market share (they already have in the US) and the users are locked in to their comfy ecosystem, there's nothing stopping them from selling users out to advertisers to generate the revenue growth demanded by the shareholders. What are their users gonna do, leave the ecosystem and 10+ years of purchases and backups behind and move to Android lol? Not being part of "The Ecosystem (TM)" in the first place, means I'm free to walk away to a competitor whenever I sense the vendor is shifting its behavior in ways that are not in my best interest, at the cost of more time and effort to manage my services individually. Basically don't put all your eggs in one basket should be the possibility on mobile devices.
- bigfudge 4y agoI think the “too many eggs in one basket” is really the only thing that persuades me. I don’t care that random developers have to workaround annoying restrictions and pay 30% to apple because it means it does just work and I don’t have to think — no one is trying to persuade me to do anything non Standard because there is no wiggle room. That’s a good thing. But it is a risk — I don’t like what apple is doing in China, and we are not that far away from that in the us and uk. If apple does start behaving poorly here I will be SOOL.
- jonny_eh 4y agoAny argument in favour of the iPhone being so locked down needs to contend with the fact that Macs are just as reliable, but far more configurable. All I want is the for the iPhone to be as open as a Mac. Let me run binaries signed by legit devs!
- klabb3 4y ago> Macs are just as reliable, but far more configurable Apple has been working tirelessly for years to retrofit the iOS model to Mac. It's probably just a matter of time, unfortunately.
- schipplock 4y agoTrue, they make it harder for the average Joe, but you can still do anything on macOS, even install 3rd party kernel extensions. But yes, it's quite clear they want you to use an iPad instead of a MacBook :).
- scarface74 4y agoYes HN chicken littles have been saying that Apple is going to force all apps to go through the Mac App Store since it was introduced in 2010.
- bayindirh 4y agoWe "HN chicken littles" were also saying that Microsoft is gonna force Secure Boot harder and harder to close the hardware ecosystem for Linux, and we're almost there. Being skeptical, and critical is important. This skepticism, criticizing and warning caused Apple to at least postpone their CSAM scan and reconsider their algorithms. We need to talk, and talk indeed openly about the things we don't like. Otherwise we'll be the real chickens at the end of the day.
- danaris 4y agoMicrosoft is not Apple. Their corporate culture is different, their revenue sources are different, and their incentives and motivations are different. "But we said Microsoft would do this bad thing, and then they did it!" is not a valid argument for why we should believe "But we've been saying for 12 years that Apple will do this bad thing Any Day Now™! They haven't yet, but it'll definitely happen Very Soon, just you wait!"
- rtpg 4y agoBut like... none of that is related to the App Store lock in! It's also not related to the 30% cut. Apple's OS and the API it provides for developing apps is what gets us here. Lord knows there are some real busted apps out there, but your system doesn't fall apart. Let's not even get into the fact that Apple itself was doing OS X stuff, which was able to have a high bar for software quality, and no "don't install random binaries" stuff to be seen.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> But like... none of that is related to the App Store lock in! It's also not related to the 30% cut. It’s related to the “one app source”. See… > no "don't install random binaries" stuff to be seen. Because it was a lot smaller target than windows in terms of uses and impact. Maybe you forget, but there was certainly crapware that would bog your system down. Meanwhile iOS is probably the single greatest target today. Statistically rich users, extremely important device to the user, and lots of users. Regardless of your view on if apple should open it up, if it were to happen, it would instantly be a massive target. Companies would flee the 30% fee (@epic/fortnight) or the privacy policies (@meta) and maybe even employers buying some Oracle/SAP junk for their employees and quickly bring legitimacy to sideloading. Everywhere would then fill with more of those “your Java is out of date plz download” sites, but instead it’d be apps. Now, for better or worse, no one has to question what they download (too much). If you could side-load then you’d soon almost be forced to side load and it would be heavily exploited.
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt isn't 2003 anymore, operating system vendors have been taking security seriously for a while now. Abuse and malware are not a problem on macOS despite barely anyone using the Mac App Store to install apps. Same goes for Windows, it isn't Windows XP anymore, and despite nobody using the Microsoft Store, abuse and malware are much less of a problem than they were in the past. Billions of machines use software distributed via package managers like Apt that have existed for decades, yet there is no epidemic of rampant malware proliferation via Linux package repositories despite trillions of dollars worth of assets being managed by Linux machines. This argument is typical FUD, and it's very common for App Store apologists to not argue based on what's happening today with other app distribution methods, but via Y2K-era fear and the classic "but what about Facebook!" refrain.
- theshrike79 4y agoExactly. I want my phone to be closer to a gaming console, not a full personal computer. I want all my problems on it to be solved by rebooting and I want it to just work and all the apps be safe by default.
- bobmaxup 4y ago> or is not guaranteed to stick after an arbitrary time I have never experienced this. What settings?
- bayindirh 4y agoApps background execution and battery use permissions get revoked randomly. It's generally confined to the Tasker and other tools which interface with Tasker, tho. However, as a result, the backup tasks I created my parents keep stopping randomly, and I don't like that.
- aussieshibe 4y agoWould giving people the ability to opt out of Apple's ultra-managed experience and take more control over their device harm your ability to continue to enjoy those benefits? I heard an argument like this a lot at the start of discussions about whether we should be able to choose to WFH in the longer term. "I don't want to WFH because..." Ok, sure, but nobody is trying to force you to. It might just be me, and I'll definitely fret about whether I'm being unreasonable for at least the next couple of hours, but this kinda frustrates me. I'm supportive of your choice, but you already get to do the thing you want, and nobody is trying to take that away. Expressing that you wouldn't behave any differently given more options is a distraction in a discussion about whether other people should be allowed to make a different choice.
- helsinkiandrew 4y ago> Would giving people the ability to opt out of Apple's ultra-managed experience and take more control over their device harm your ability to continue to enjoy those benefits? You can always Jailbreak your device? I think Apples response to your argument would be that it isn't the technically aware user that is trying to get control over their device that is the problem, its apps being used by those with no technical ability. Once an App is allowed to break out of the sandbox or be installed away from the AppStore the likelyhood of an average users phone getting into a broken mess at best and becoming infected with a virus at worse goes up my an order of magnitude.
- schrodinger 4y agoCouldn't someone just release their app on github, and the user could install it via xcode for free?
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoMacs allow installing apps not from the Appstore, and I'm hearing they are quite fine and not a mess.
- tobylane 4y ago
- flohofwoe 4y agoNothing of this would change if iPhones had a simple 'unlock' setting with an 'at your own risk' disclaimer. People who are happy with the default just keep the phone locked, others can trade Apple's "warm embrace" against the freedom to install any software they want on their own device. Tech companies really should stop treating their users like idiots who can't think for themselves. It's all about the sweet app store profits, nothing else.
- maccard 4y agoSure it would - apps with enough clout will do this: https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/mobile/android https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/mobile/android And tell you the only way for experience X is to follow these safe steps to unlock your phone and use their launcher.
- mgsk 4y agoAnd if you don't like it, don't do it.
- maccard 4y agoI don't like that argument at all. I can just as easily day if you don't like it, buy an android and use F-droid, but I won't because it's a lazy argument. A freedom of choice has to be a freedom to choose. As I said farther you the thread, this immediately becomes an "and" rather than an "or". "I can install this app via my preferred storefront" is a fine choice - but "I have to use all of the services that every third party wants to bundle in to use their specific service" isn't a choice, it's forced upon you and is no better than the situation we have now. We've seen this on android - try and install the Google camera app on a Huawei device and let me know how that goes for you, or use the Samsung app store on your Google device.
- flohofwoe 4y ago...and there's really nothing wrong with that. If it would, then PC gaming would have collapsed a long time ago.
- heavyset_go 4y agoThere's no reason you need to stop people from doing what they want with their devices just because you don't want to do it yourself.
- bayindirh 4y agoAre there any words in my comment stating or implying that such capability should not be included in Apple iOS devices, ever? I'm all for flexibility, but of the two choices we have today, I prefer Apple's proposition more. If they decide to add more flexibility without compromising their quality, I'd be more than supportive of the feat.
- drawingthesun 4y agoI agree. As my business become more complicated and I become less a tech oriented student and more a "have to get the paperwork done for legal reasons" type person I went back to iPhone and never looked back. I noticed many people I know running very time consuming business to be iPhone users too, not having the time to tinker with Android. I notice my tech friends working in support love android, as their job doesn't really let them tinker. How we for those running's servers and dealing with backend stuff I see iPhone ownership is about 50/50, far higher than in support. And most people I know that own their own business like I do are almost always iPhone users. We just do not have time to dig deep into our phones and tinker, we have too much work to do and we are already stretched for time with our families, why waste that on configuring yet another Android ?
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoThat's a lot of stereotyping. Has it occurred to you that not every Android user wastes time to "tinker" with their phone and they're just normal people who use it like you do your iPhone? Android is not like Linux were it's exclusive to developers, geeks and tinkerers. The market share also exemplifies that it's just as much for average joes as iOS.
- abstract_put 4y agoI have a hard time with threads like this because it feels like half the comments are straight out of an Apple ad. "It's simple", "It just works", "PC is some nerd twiddling bits but Mac is cool and gets things done". It feels like a cheap shot, but when "the nerds" are proclaiming Apple the one true OS the hacker ethic is really suffering. My wife switched from Android to Apple, then Apple back to Android a couple times. Turns out they're really not that different, and the "simple" one is the one you're used to (noting in the Android ecosystem companies like Samsung really do a disservice by trying to stand out from stock in a different-but-no-better way).
- nobrains 4y agoOk then, for you, do not enable that option. What am I missing?
- bayindirh 4y ago> What am I missing? The part that I'm not telling that my choice shall be default for everyone, which I repeated numerous times in this thread. Apple decides to add a switch to convert iOS to macOS levels of freedom? Fine. Apple enables sideloading? Fine, I'll applaud even. The thing is I'm not pro-"Apple's current stance". I'm pro-choice, but what I get today is satisfying my needs. If we can satisfy more users' need with one device (regardless of manufacturer), we should do that, and I support that.
- mgoetzke 4y agoSidenote: Backup is not solved at all. Neither my iphone 12 Pro max nor my new one have made a successful backup yet. Tried all the things and contacted support nothing so far, but no chance. Always stuck at "Estimating .. "
- saiya-jin 4y agoCan't agree on this. Also on Samsung, S22 ultra, I can't be bothered with any deep app settings because why would I do that? Device runs flawlessly, doesn't bother me with anything, has great battery life (and photos). On the other hand, my wife bought iphone 13 mini after being whole life on android and its a proper shitfest form her point of view - basic settings simply NOT possible by OS because Apple decided they know better than users what users want and users have no say in this apart form losing warranty via jailbreak, basic convenient features missing. The whole device can be summarized as 'basic for very premium price' - it looks very cheap, works cheap, not a single fancy or cool thing on it. Was about to give a chance to Apple myself but quickly rolled back after what I've seen. Plus all the scandals that show Apple is just another amoral non-privacy corporation just like the rest of bunch, despite their hard efforts at marketing. My wife will be probably rolling back to Android soon since its pretty bad experience overall. So completely opposite experience.
- bayindirh 4y agoWell, if the Android ecosystem is serving you well, and the devices you have are functioning the way you expect, more power to you. I'm not a person who takes hard sides, but support whatever works for people. There's plenty of evidence that Android fulfills needs of a lot of people, so let it be (except they're trying to replace Linux with Fuchsia in a relatively unethical way to lock down the devices even more than Apple, but let's not digress). > ...its a proper shitfest form her point of view You know what? That's perfectly OK in my book. Android and iOS are backwards with respect to each other, and they are built on different default modes of operation. However, I'll never call Android like that as an iOS user. > basic settings simply NOT possible by OS because Apple decided they know better than users what users want and users have no say Well, again this is a subjective view. I used many things before an iPhone. Android, Palm, Windows CE Casiopeia, Windows Mobile to name a few. People think PalmOS is dead, but it's very well alive and its name is iOS. Basic iOS mode of operation is a direct descendant of PalmOS, and evolved from there. When looked from that point of view, it's a perfectly capable device which provides all the settings I want. Again, it might not be providing what you or your wife's expecting, and that's OK. This is why we have choices, and I support that. > The whole device can be summarized as 'basic for very premium price' - it looks very cheap, works cheap, not a single fancy or cool thing on it. Well, again it depends on your view. Considering I can do anything I need on it, short of conquering the world (which I'm gonna publish an app for that), I don't call it a basic tool. It might not be as open as an Android system (for things which I call fancy, you need to root that system too), but seriously, calling it "incapable and basic" is inaccurate and laughable. > Apple is just another amoral non-privacy corporation just like the rest of bunch despite their hard efforts at marketing... Apple is just another company, which earns money in different ways. Just to be clear, I don't see them anything extraordinary.
- manigandham 4y agoWhat part of non-default optional customization for others changes anything for you?
- bayindirh 4y agoNothing. I've elaborated on other replies. Please take peek at them. I don't want to re-hash everything I've written here.
- foobarbaz33 4y ago> Android is not Linux It most certainly is linux. You probably mean it's not a GNU operating system.
- thewataccount 4y ago> You probably mean it's not a GNU operating system. He more likely means you don't manage it as a linux system. A lot of linux systems don't use GNU, especially embedded ones, or containers. Busybox is very common. But you don't really treat these systems any differently from GNU/linux other than some relatively mundane command differences.
- RHSeeger 4y ago> It just manages itself, and all that hard problems (backups, updates, ease of use, experience homogenity, etc.) are solved. My wife switched away from an iPhone an an Android device less than a year ago exactly because this _wasn't_ the case. - Restore from backup failed... pretty much impossible to solve as far as we could tell - Tell iTunes what songs you want loaded onto your phone and sync. Then leave the house and it downloads some of the songs off the internet, because it _didn't_ actually sync them to the phone. It just loads a placeholder. Pretty severe impact for someone not on an unlimited plan. - Ran into a problem and had to get the music library from itunes/phone. I don't recall the exact details (it was years ago), but every song had been renamed to some random alphanumeric string. It took a long time to fix them. Honestly, it was one long series of the system doing something that clearly wasn't what she, as the user, would expect (or exactly _not_ what she told it to do).
- koenvdb 4y agoTo be fair, most people using an iPhone don't download music onto their phones but instead just use Spotify/Apple Music/whatever other music service is hot at the moment. It still sucks, but this is a fairly specific usecase imo.
- RHSeeger 4y agoFor anyone that isn't on an unlimited data plan, being able to play music located on the device is critical.
- 4y ago
- sylens 4y agoI don't want to manage my iPhone like I do a Linux server. But I would like the ability to sign up for Netflix or other streaming services when I first launch the app. Or, failing that, I'd like a message on that app telling me where I have to go to sign-up. I'd like to be able to buy Kindle books directly on my phone and start reading them. I'd like to use a different web browser engine at times. All of those things have been taken out of my hands, the first two because those of ludicrous App Store rules and policies.
- smachiz 4y agoInteresting that you mention the kindle - wouldn't it also be nice to be able to buy Apple Books on your Kindle hardware? You also can't do that. You can root some Kindles and install other software, but is more or less like jailbreaking an iPhone. The issue I have with people going after Apple is that _everyone_ does this more or less. Broadly, I have the fewest complaints about the restrictions in Apple's ecosystem as a user.
- sylens 4y agoThe Kindle is not sold or marketed as a general purpose computing device with a robust third party app marketplace. That's the key difference here.
- smachiz 4y agoIt does have a robust 3rd party app marketplace... with fees. Amazon could sell books if they wanted to, they would just have to pay Apple.
- moogly 4y ago> all that hard problems (backups, updates, ease of use, experience homogenity, etc.) are solved This is a bit funny to me. I'll give you the homogeneity argument, but as for the rest, as someone who has owned both iPhone and Android since 2008 or so, it took Apple a long, long time to catch up to Android in the backup/update department. Remember having to do everything via iTunes? I remember. Now, they're essentially the same in that regard.
- neurostimulant 4y agoYou can still have those while opening up the device a bit more for enthusiasts. For example, Apple currently limit the number of sideloaded app to 3 apps total as well as 10 apps/week limit, and you'll have to re-sign the app after a week too. Relaxing that rule alone will greatly open up the device.
- quitit 4y agoFundamentally the argument for “i want to fully control my device” is flawed (actually it’s naive). We do not fully control our devices and haven’t for quite a long time. Especially so for devices that interact with other devices, or rely on integrations that lapse over time (eg 2G networks.) This type of person is just drawing a line in the sand then falsely labelling it as “full control”, then adding on the rather dangerous commandment: “…and everyone must have it this way because ‘slippery slope and apologists’” The fact is choice exists and consumer purchasing behaviours are also a demonstration of choice. The successful penetration of these smartphone/ similar devices relies on having different levels of control hard baked into the system - otherwise we are fracturing the ability to have something like the smartphone as a universal minimum. How many of you folks out there have parents that don’t really use their computer but carry their smartphone everywhere? That’s something to think about.