24 ms·
Estonia saved its citizens 820 years by moving public services online
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoPretty basic article but Estonia is a fascinating place, especially for e-government. There was a great longform New Yorker article on it a few years back https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/12/18/estonia-the-digital-republic https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/12/18/estonia-the-di...
- imwillofficial 4y agoThe e-citizenship stuff is super cool too
- vander_elst 4y agoSaving 820 years is great, but it would be nice to define it better. From the article I not sure if they mean 820 man years in total or man years per year or something else. It would be useful to know how much energy was spent to achieve this e.g. of they spent 8000 man years to achieve this it would change the perspective. Edit: grammar
- itake 4y ago
- concordDance 4y ago"Man" is an ancient word that means both "human" and "male human" depending on context. The former usage actually predates the latter.
- etage3 4y agoI think itake understands this and was making a point (an important one at that). Douglas R. Hofstadter made the same point (perhaps more eloquently) in "A Person Paper on Purity in Language"[0], which might be another avenue if you wish to understand what the parent comment was pointing at. [0]https://www.angelfire.com/rebellion/personpaper/ https://www.angelfire.com/rebellion/personpaper/
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt is not an important point in a context like "man-years".
- itake 4y ago
- reportgunner 4y agoSame reason you used "women" and not "other people".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rcarr 4y agoall men are pigs so our life spans are only 20 years joke obviously
- vander_elst 4y agoI didn't mean to gender, sorry if it was perceived that way. My understanding is that this is a standard industry term. Anyway, I'll try to use human years in the future.
- pbhjpbhj 4y ago"Human years" makes it sound like you're differentiating from some pseudo timescale like 'dog years'. Man years doesn't have any connotation of sex of the people involved. Ironically the person objecting is the only one projecting a gendered interpretation on to it; it's like punching yourself in the face and complaining that punching people in the faces shouldn't be allowed. "Man" is just Saxon/Old English for person (and is considered to be from at least PIE origins). My late mum used to complain about the term Chair instead of Chairman, "I'm a person not a piece of furniture", she was chairman on lots of committees.
- myroon5 4y agoEven without changing processes, hundreds of years of time could be saved by reducing the frequency we have to interact with government at all For example, almost 20 American states require license renewal every 4 years or more frequently: https://ballotpedia.org/Driver%27s_license_costs_by_state,_2018 https://ballotpedia.org/Driver%27s_license_costs_by_state,_2... When I renew, there's no test (not even vision), and they don't even retake my picture or let me update my height. They just print the same ID with new dates --- Obviously, Americans filing tax information the government already knows every year is another canonical example
- notch656a 4y agoArizona driver license don't expire until you are 65. The linked website is innaccurate.
- giantg2 4y agoThey do if they're REAL ID. By law they can only be valid up to 8 years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Arrath 4y agoRenewing online sure takes a lot of the burden out of the regular renewals. Of course, I'm now 33 and still using a picture of 21yo me on my license which gets me second glances from bar tenders, TSA, etc. But if it keeps me from having to go in to the DMV...
- orblivion 4y agoDid they somehow figure out online voting or are they courting disaster here?
- rcarr 4y agoUntil there's a solar flare and instead it's just cost them 1640 years. Or a catastrophic computer virus. Or any number of black swan disaster scenarios. I'm a tech guy and I do think that this is good news. I just hope that the people in charge of designing these systems have also thought about what happens if these systems catastrophically fail. And that measuring things like '820 years saved' are only really claims you can make after waiting a long period of time to ensure it's proven itself stable.
- scottLobster 4y agoBlack swan events affect non-digital information as well. How many paper records have been lost to fire, floods and simple decay over the millennia? At least with digital records there's the chance that they're backed up offsite somewhere
- rcarr 4y agoPersonally I think the ideal system would include both. Maybe a digital system that is periodically (say once a year) transferred to tape and stored in a secure facility like the Svalbard Seed Vault.
- culturestate 4y ago> Maybe a digital system that is periodically (say once a year) transferred to tape and stored in a secure facility This has been standard procedure (not at Svalbard, obviously, but at one or more secure offsite facilities) for every critical data system I’ve ever personally encountered in regulated industry, though rotations are usually weekly/monthly rather than yearly.
- kneebonian 4y ago> This has been standard procedure Are they testing the backups and restoring from them regularly, because if they aren't there isn't any backup happening.
- Reason077 4y agoI wonder how many years the US could save its citizens by modernizing and digitizing the IRS, DMV, etc. Tens of thousands? Hundreds of thousands?
- jeffbee 4y agoI recently discovered that the U.S. Social Security Administration has business hours ... for their website. They operate a website that is closed at night and on weekends. One is hard-pressed to imagine the level of IT dysfunction necessary to reach this point.
- eropple 4y agoI investigated that once, and I don't think it's IT dysfunction in that case. My understanding (because I found this odd as well) is that it's because the support load for that site is so high, and the likelihood of abandoned processes without support so high, that the best solution they had at whatever point in time they instituted that was business-hours operation.
- anotherman554 4y agoI have not researched this but rather than being a sign of IT dysfunction my guess would be the government contracts out the maintenance of the web site to the private sector and the contract specs happen to be written to say it will be closed on nights and weekends. In theory this makes the contract cheaper than if the government was buying 24/7 support.
- Eleison23 4y agoIt would seem to us that nights and weekends are the most convenient time for citizens to access government services such as this. But the things that are down for maintenance are not our publicly-accessible frontends, they're the backend databases that the administration uses internally as well. So it would seem that all the worker bees in government offices rely on having access to those backend databases during USA office hours, and the only time they can realistically be shut down is while the civil servants are off the clock.
- alberth 4y agoHomeless / Underprivelleged? How does moving things online work for those in poor economic conditions since they might not have online access (no smart phone, etc).
- dottedmag 4y agoThey can go to the local council / municipality and get the help there (either computers they can use for free, or from the clerks who can help them).
- giantg2 4y agoI think this just adds the option and doesn't eliminate the in-person version.
- skeletal88 4y agoCorrect. There are still physical offices where people can go to do their stuff, with clerks sitting behind desks, etc. Nobody is left out, doing stuff online is just an option 99% people use.
- Avamander 4y agoThere's basically always the option to use a library or its WiFi. In the case of voting, one can just do it in person.
- andrewia 4y agoIn addition to public computers and physical offices, smartphones are owned by a large portion of homeless people (especially if younger) because they're quite affordable. It looks like a basic Estonian phone plan, plus financing for a budget smartphone, is only 20 EUR/month. Estonia has no free phone plan (like the "obamaphone" program in the US), but low income people can submit 200 EUR of expenses per year for essentials.
- andix 4y agoYou can still go to the office and do it in person. It also comes with the benefit, that a lot of public offices can also provide you with different services they couldn't do previously. Before you needed to go to town A and get a document, add it to the paperwork and file at town B. Now town B can fetch the document in your name from town A, or town A can file the document in your name at town B.
- Juliate 4y ago+1. Careful still, public services are also a matter of human representation, of accessibility, to nurture the relation between (all) the citizens and the state (as it also is in the private sector, between a brand and customers). Moving public services online is great IFF it does not remove at the same time a satisfying option for offline/physical access to the same services, for those that are not able to use the online access (disabled, old, unused to computers or tablets, remote areas, etc. - those are still a significant part of the people, and even if, an equal access to public services is a must).
- skeletal88 4y agoCalm down, there still are physical offices where people can go and do their stuff, nobody is forcing people to use the online services.
- Juliate 4y agoI'm very calm thank you :) I'm just reminding, from a local experience (France), that in general, moving/reducing/replacing (public) services physical presence to online services has to be carefully considered & planned over quite a long period of time, especially regarding accessibility.
- kazinator 4y agoThat's the country from which Skype emerged; the first usable video calling experience, years ahead of everyone else.
- Proven 4y ago
- chungy 4y agoOnline voting is a terrible idea rife with flaws, intentional and unintentional. In-person paper voting is the only reasonable system.
- kristianheljas 4y agoI'd argue that a paper is much more easily tamperable/replaceable than a digital signature. That, of course depends on how much you trust the ID chip card security and mathematics around the encryption..
- Zanfa 4y agoWhile online voting isn’t perfect, in-person paper ballots aren’t magic. Estonians had some 60-odd years of paper-only voting experience under the Soviet Union, didn’t make one bit of difference when it came to the complete fabrication of the results.
- xwdv 4y agoUnfortunately this is hardly anything. Consider that people spent enough time playing Halo 2 online to cross the Milky Way galaxy and come back.
- ttobbaybbob 4y agoso at 27k gdp per capita theyre saving ~$22m per year in lost productivity, probably growing each year. Seems like a pretty solid investment
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoAlong the same lines, I found India's Aadhar system to be pretty extraordinary. If you can put your civil liberties concerns aside (and to be clear, I don't think you should), Aadhar has made govt services in India several orders of magnitude more efficient and fraud resistant. I recently sold a piece of property in India and it took literally 10 minutes to do the transaction at a local district office. You just go to a place and get a scan while signing a document that says you are transferring the property. That handles everything ... changing the owner in the public registry, etc. Compare that to buying a house in the US where you need to use all kinds of third party title insurers etc., because you can't necessarily be sure the person selling you the land actually has ownership of the land in the registry at the moment you are doing the sale. Also, payment systems in India charge merchants something like 0.1% or less, while credit card companies charge merchants 3-5% in the US. In India everything is cheap because online transactions are very secure ... your Aadhar identity allows you to generate one time codes that are sent to vendors to authorize payments. Even if the one time code is stolen, it can only be used one time. Contrast that with the USA where if someone just gets your social security number and address, they can often impersonate you and charge thousands of dollars against your identity. That insecurity has spawned billions of dollars of costs in the US economy and enriched Visa and Mastercard. Its dead weight on the economy.
- Avamander 4y ago> I recently sold a piece of property in India and it took literally 10 minutes to do the transaction at a local district office. You just go to a place and get a scan while signing a document that says you are transferring the property. That handles everything ... changing the owner in the public registry, etc. Even that is excessive. Digital signatures (if available) do the job.
- superjan 4y ago… and I bet they spent it on tiktok and instagram.
- jacooper 4y agoAnother country that is using E-goverment effectively is Saudi Arabia, almost everything is digital. As for privacy, What is privacy? Do you have something to hide?/s
- moffkalast 4y agoAs if any other authoritarian regime throughout history with analog paper bureaucracy ever had any problems finding anything they needed. At least with file encryption there actually isn't any way to bribe/threaten the clerk to show you the file.
- beorno 4y agoTime wasted filling in forms and talking to service staff should really be tracked and associated with the business or government agency, then it's possible to actually assign a "bureaucracy/red-tape tax" based on the hours they waste for people using the service. Without externalizing the cost of all the time wasted, it's just too easy to push time-costs on to the consumers/citizens. It's already a huge problem, and I suspect a major cause of loss of productivity in the western world.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoEven with the same amount of work or service provided, under-staffing absolutely consumes and destroys peoples productivity. What an awful waste it is to take the morning off work to go somewhere like the DMV, wait forever in line and see half the service counters empty. Sure, the government saved on some staff salary but society lost more in productivity.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoI bet you USAA's Insurance run DMV would be a lot more efficient and have good customer service, but hey, we don't want any Ayn Rands around here
- ambicapter 4y agoWhy do you think that? Businesses cut staffing just as much as governments do. They already got your money, why would they care about spending more money on you when they know it's a pain in the ass to switch to another "provider"?
- colechristensen 4y agoAAA does run some DMVs and the service is considerably better in my experience.
- whafro 4y agoThey do this here in Massachusetts, but they aren't full-service. I just bought out my lease, and have to go to a real DMV to process the title. When you only have to handle the simple stuff, it's much easier to make it a great experience. AAA is basically the EZPass lane for the DMV. That's not to say that a full-service DMVs shouldn't be significantly better in most cases, though.
- sdfhbdf 4y agoThe title is a litte misleading since > The Estonian government estimates that going digital has saved the state and its citizens, 820 years in time and resources It didn’t save it it just estimates it and we’re not sure how they arrived at this number.
- dghughes 4y agoI'm in Canada and all I can think of is how my Mom, uncles, other older relatives do not have a computer. They have no interest in anything on a computer and have never touched one. You could put one in front of them powered on, logged in, web browser open, and they'd have no clue how to operate it to enter info. We had a hurricane here and Mom applied to the Red Cross for disaster relief. She got a PIN for her online banking which she doesn't have or ever will. There are quite a few people without computers. It's maddening to see some or proposed government services only be offered exclusively on the Internet.
- germanier 4y agoIt's a chicken-and-egg situation. Estonia has a much higher than average number of elderly using such online services. If you for any reason don't want to, you can still visit a government office in person to do your business.
- skeletal88 4y agoMy 90 year old grandfather is doing lots of stuff online, needs help with the computer occasionally, but otherwise is doing ok. Well.. he finished the Technical University with cum laude in mechanics, that maybe helps.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoPerhaps we should consider it akin to literacy. In the past, and indeed present, plenty of people couldn't read and so would need to seek help to access government services that required, for example, completing a form or reading instructions. Nowadays most people read (in my country, UK), though completing forms can have high literacy/intelligence demands. Some lack computer skills but almost everyone (in my country) has some access to computers in free local government libraries and in other local community centres. It's not terribly convenient, granted. So should we avoid offering services that need literacy to access, or just those that require computer literacy? I'd argue neither, but people should have long transition periods (multiple years) when a system is moving to access only via computer and government should ensure all communities have ongoing access to computers where that's reasonable.
- 0x138d5 4y agohiiele? On a serious note, while the eID/digital gov system is great and all it does have some jankiness. The address search system everyone uses has been a PITA for a while and the tax system still keels over for a day or so when the possibility of submitting returns opens. Then we had the case of one dude scraping several hundred thousand ID card pictures [0]. Also the broadband part is so-so. Estonian internet is notoriously expensive and slow compared to our near peers [1]. [0] https://news.err.ee/1608291072/hacker-downloads-close-to-300-000-personal-id-photos https://news.err.ee/1608291072/hacker-downloads-close-to-300... [1] https://news.postimees.ee/7635673/estonia-s-home-internet-speed-is-lower-than-in-russia-or-moldova https://news.postimees.ee/7635673/estonia-s-home-internet-sp...
- Tade0 4y ago> hiiele? I live bits that give rare insights into other cultures. The description of the appropriate reddit page google-translates to "let's meet at the fire". Is that correct?
- Avamander 4y agoMore like "let's meet at the sacred forest" (to celebrate/rejoice). "Hiiele" is the allative form of "hiis" (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiis_(sacred_site) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hiis_(sacred_site) )
- Tade0 4y agoThat's even better, thanks!
- skeletal88 4y agoWhen finland is mentioned on the internet then people post "torilla tavataan" - "lets meet at the market!!". So we estonians started saying "hiiele!" - lets meet.. at the sacred forest on the same occasion.
- argulane 4y agoHiiele! X-Tee, the protocol that allows information sharing between goverment systems, is also a horrible pice of XML and SOAP with some crypto sprinkled on it.
- sdfhbdf 4y agoIt does sound great when it works. It’s awesome that Estonia succeeded. I do believe this is a really hard problem - digitising public services - to solve at scale. Whenever you have bigger countries you almost always have several levels of local governance - state, county or Land. These local governments often work with full autonomy and do not share date with the central government. In this case even solving such simple and basic thing as a centralised login solution is difficult since why would the owner of the centralised login solution should have knowledge of which citizen used which local governments service? I believe that’s why we see so many unfinished systems not working together because they have to be built completely separately by each local government since they operate in autonomy.
- germanier 4y agoWhich is why countries like Germany roll out federated decentralized login solutions – it's just a really slow process due to (among many other factors) the humongous number of stakeholders to involve.
- spaniard89277 4y agoIn Spain they're trying... but not really succeeding. > Whenever you have bigger countries you almost always have several levels of local governance - state, county or Land. These local governments often work with full autonomy and do not share date with the central government. Here this is particularly relevant with healthcare. In some regions I get full coverage with my regional card with no questions asked. In others I have to go through hoops, and apparently they have no way of knowing my clinical history. > In this case even solving such simple and basic thing as a centralised login solution is difficult since why would the owner of the centralised login solution should have knowledge of which citizen used which local governments service? In Spain they tried to solve this with DNIe (your national identity card has a chip) and cetificates. Turns out it's quite difficult to make it work for 99% of the people, and even if you're tech savvy some government portals make it SO HARD that you just want to give up. In a job I had before they used VMs with Windows XP and IExplorer for some services. It improved a lot in last years, but the improvement is in areas where you have to pay money, they've got fast for that. Everything else is still a mess. So in the end they'd come up with Cl@ave 365 with is a login/password solution you have to set up in person into some government office but it doesn't give you access to the full catalog of services, so you still need DNIe/Certificate. The thing is, they still get the money from you. Nobody gets fired. Friendly contractors still get money. There's no rush to improve. They have no incentives. But the worst thing is that they have this mess going on, and when old people goes to some government office they tell them to go online and do their own thing. Pretty much like companies. Feels nice to pay taxes for a service isn't being provided. There's people pushing to get this fixed, but the spanish state is... like an angry elephant.
- viburnum 4y agoArticle didn’t mention the best part: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once-only_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Once-only_principle Basically the government isn’t allowed to ask you for any information more than once. They already know!
- andix 4y agoThat sounds scary.
- skeletal88 4y agoCan you explain why? Why would having every government department, hospital, doctors/dentists office keep your data separately, probably in some unsecured excel file or whatever? When we have one registry for everything, they can keep it secure by having some proper security guys design and audit it, we can see who has accessed my data and when, etc. If a hospital would keep your health records in their own system then.. they'd probably have some low paid IT guy design something and leak it accidentally online.
- andix 4y agoBecause I don’t want them to connect all the data without my consent. I don’t want single government employees to have access to all my data at once.
- LinkLink 4y agohahahahaahahahahahahhaahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha 10 years ago people would have called you paranoid now you're already too late
- viburnum 4y agoCan't find the source now but I read somewhere that in Estonia anytime somebody accesses your info you get notified who it was.
- mendigou 4y ago
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoBS. It should be "820 years PER YEAR", and with a 1.3M people in Estonia, it equates to 5.4 hours per year. JUST 5.4 hours per year. Not impressive.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat's not impressive to you? Most of a day of dealing with government timewaste, every single year, is a lot to me.
- machinekob 4y ago5.4h more like 10+ h as older and younger population is not doing anything that require spending times in public que, and it is very impressive not waiting extra 6-10h per year + twice that for transporting to and out of the government buildings.
- andix 4y agoWhich is nearly one day of holiday people can save every year. So I would call it very impressive, as most people work during the opening hours of public services and would need to take time off to go there.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thsbrown 4y agoEstonia using KSI Blockchain for government networks seems relevant here. I would love to get more info on the nitty gritty of how it's being used specifically though. None the less it does seem like a good use case of Blockchain tech. [1] https://e-estonia.com/solutions/cyber-security/ksi-blockchain/ https://e-estonia.com/solutions/cyber-security/ksi-blockchai...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- some_random 4y agoIt felt like this was really low, but according to the most fun wolfram alpha query I've made in a while that's 5.68 hours per person! https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=hours+in+860+years+%2F+population+of+estonia https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=hours+in+860+years+%2F+...
- blibble 4y agopersonally I don't want voting done online or with any machine involvement at all, ever
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- efitz 4y agoMuch government interaction in the US (at all levels- federal, state, local, court) is ultimately about revenue. Adopting a single, simple (in terms of complexity) revenue model per polity would eliminate much interaction. For example a 20% flat income tax with a $25000 deduction would allow the IRS to pre-fill your return on a post card. Eliminating “fines as a revenue stream” would dramatically reduce local court and LE interactions. Reducing permitting, etc. Not only would the citizen experience improve but we would also need less government resources. Of course, there are reasons why we do all these things, but we rarely if ever revisit implemented government programs to see if they are meeting their goals and if their cost exceeds their benefit. Given that, I much more support “less government” rather than “the same amount of government but most of it online”.
- jFriedensreich 4y agoits part of why i moved there from germany. its crazy how especially germany treats its citizens time as an unlimited resource without any respect what that could mean for peoples lives. neurodivergence is especially amplified in such a system if you have strong adhd or depression like me, 1 or 2 hours paperwork per month is not just 2h but potentially weeks of dreading and self hatred. knowing what life could have been like it hurts to think of all the lost time but i am truly thankful i can finally experience it. there needs to be something like a human right to be left the fuck alone by your country if the task can be done automatically or semi-automatically.
- andix 4y agoIn a lot of European countries there is a system to legally sign documents with a digital signature. Either via SMS/App TAN - like for online banking - or a smart card/HSM (mostly used by corporations). I think Austria moved even more services to the digital age then Estonia. It is not fancy, nor modern. But a lot of documents primarily exist only in a digital form (all laws, court files, official documents, financial administration documents, ...). They are often printed out, but they are just a random piece of paper, just a "copy" of the original. The official and valid version is the digitally signed PDF. It is mostly implemented via some really boring and antiquated Java Server Pages HTML forms, that are not always easy to use. But they work nearly all the time, and once you send them you immediately get a signed and legally binding confirmation that it was filed. The roots of the system go back to the early 2000s, and used elliptical cryptography right from the start. Which was really hard back then to deal with, because most libraries or applications didn't support it yet. For example native Windows support came only with Windows 7. In Austria everyone and every company that has E-mail is required to accept digital signatures. If you cancel your phone contract with a signed PDF via E-Mail the company can't refuse to accept it, as every court will instantly decide in your favour.
- spicymaki 4y agoBe careful what you wish for. For the US if you automate public services you are going to eliminate Federal, State, and Local bureaucratic jobs as well as the support roles to interface to these services. For example if you automated taxing, you would eliminate IRS employees as well as accountants and software services such as Turbo Tax. In the US we don't have universal healthcare, universal free education, etc. so you be eliminating millions of jobs without a safety net. Automation would have terrible economic repercussions. The extreme level of graft and incompetence would mean the actual automated services would not be very good and would be horrifically expensive to produce and maintain. I will take my number and wait on line.
- skeletal88 4y agoWhat? You are advocating for inefficient bureacracy because otherwise the time-wasting bureaucrats would be laid off? Is this sarcasm or you are serious with this?
- Moldoteck 4y agoWait until americans advocate for possibility to fire somebody via mail... Oh wait...
- jen729w 4y ago“Oh but this requires a government ID card and I’ll never allow that! Liberty, freedom, something!” …later… “Hello sir, you’ve just started a new job. In order for that to happen I’m going to need copies of your passport, driver’s licence, medicare card, citizenship certificate, and one recent bank statement showing your full name and address.” [Actual experience of mine, recently. Australia.] “Sure! Here they are, which random web portal that I’ve never heard of would you like me to upload them to?”
- Genbox 4y agoEstonia has greatly embraced the digital identity through smart cards. They have been on the forefront of digitalizing governmental services. Website: https://www.id.ee/en/ https://www.id.ee/en/ Timeline of implementations: https://e-estonia.com/story/ https://e-estonia.com/story/ Github: https://github.com/open-eid https://github.com/open-eid
- tdiff 4y agoWould it be fair to say that 820 years is 0.3 days per Estonian citizen? Is saving that amount of time a significant achievement?
- aaron695 4y ago
- t0bia_s 4y agoWhat about security and privacy? Papers are harder to track or stole.