5 ms·
I suspect that a lot of people would be happy to be a "lifer" in the right situation. (Good company, good work, good colleagues, good respect, good TC.) A bar
by neilv 4y ago
I suspect that a lot of people would be happy to be a "lifer" in the right situation. (Good company, good work, good colleagues, good respect, good TC.)
A barrier is that situation doesn't occur often. I think it could, but not many companies seem to be run that way. The stereotypical tech company, for example, seems to be driven by growth at all costs, and there's a kind of mercenary thinking by both company and employees, towards each other. Which is intertwined with the weird dynamic in which folk wisdom is that companies will pay more to hire someone than they will to retain.
Another barrier is that a worker opting out of this -- to go to a mythical modest little oasis company run by a CEO with a heart of gold who will live forever -- can be difficult, due to the large number of high-TC other workers in the field. In the US, if a worker is making relatively a lot less than others, they're at a disadvantage for housing, healthy living in various ways, opportunities for their children, etc.
So even lifer-inclined people will be motivated to play along with our current situation of chasing FAANGs, hierarchies of people all targeting promo criteria and metrics rather than company and team success, job-hopping whenever the right bump of TC and title comes along, rehearsing for fratbro interview rituals, etc. (Maybe with a bust cycle of a lot of VC exit schemes, we'll start to get better, but a lot of workers and companies have known nothing else, and there's a lot to unlearn.)
- bigmattystyles 4y agoForgive my ignorance, what is TC?
- guyzero 4y agoTotal Compensation
- neilv 4y agoThanks, I should've spelled that out. I think of total compensation (TC) as salary, plus stock, plus bonuses. (The eventual actual value of the stock and bonuses can vary, but there's typical/expected numbers. And then usually the employer also contributes to health insurance and 401k.) Some examples of TC are on the excellent `levels.fyi` site: https://www.levels.fyi/?compare=Facebook,Amazon,Google&track=Software%20Engineer https://www.levels.fyi/?compare=Facebook,Amazon,Google&track...
- duped 4y ago> good TC Not to get too mopey but I went through the phase of "sell out and do things that make me unhappy and stressed for more money" a few years ago and while it put me in the position I am today financially, it came at great personal expense. I lost friends and partners by moving, lost years of close contact with family late in their lives, and the stress put a physical toll on my body and mental toll on my psyche. I think we're quite naive at a young age - our eyes glaze over at the massive amount of money we can make but don't value the non-monetary cost. Your youth is finite and you don't know what you've missed until it's gone.
- outsomnia 4y agoThere are reasons they have to offer the huge TC, you will be doing things that are not in your interest for it.
- eloisant 4y agoNot necessarily, the total comp is mostly because those companies are overflowing with money so they can afford it. And they're competing with other companies overflowing with money. There are not enough developers, and especially senior developers with experience in other FAANG (the skillset is different from your regular service IT company).
- kroltan 4y agoThank you for not using the initialism for total compensation, as a non-native English speaker I was quite confused in this thread.
- roland35 4y agoNot necessarily true! I've found that as TC has gone up the level of respect for workers has gone up as well. When companies don't pay well they generally treat workers poorly. Now of course, some mission-based companies are an exception to this! My most stressful job was my first, and it required a lot of late nights of crunch time and writing proposals which I hated. Now at a big tech company, I am making 3-5x more than before, more opportunities to lead projects, more respect from management, and more interesting and impactful work.
- novok 4y agoIMO your most likely to find 'lifer' types at a FAANG than many others. Job-hopping usually stops becoming an easy promo system once you've hit staff anyway.
- neilv 4y agoI could totally see lifer being great at Google, especially with FIRE being an option eventually. And maybe at an unnamed other FAANG. Some of the others seem to have had a relative ruthlessness baked into their founding DNA, and I wouldn't bet on them working out long-term. (Because leadership shapes lasting culture; and someone who's nice to you, but nasty to others, will eventually be nasty to you.) Also, for any duration at those places, I'd also need to vet whomever I'd be reporting to, for whether they'd have my back if/when daggers started flying around internally. Another one seemed to have good founding DNA, but I know less about that one.
- nvarsj 4y agoI think things are starting to heat up at Google lately - with increased pip quotas and top down pressure. But it’s also the only FAANG I know with people who have been there for 8+ years. Definitely seems like it was a very comfortable, low stress place to work for a long time. I’m guessing places like Bell Labs had similar vibes, but it’s a pretty rare thing these days.
- Aromasin 4y agoYou find a hell of a lot of lifers in the semiconductor industry from my experience. Intel, TSMC, AMD, Qualcomm, NVIDIA, IBM, ARM etc. It seems to tick all the boxes I guess. Fulfilling work, decent pay, good benefits, and plenty of room for growth both vertically into director role, and horizontally into other teams and domains. There's scope to make a global impact if you're good at what you do. I couldn't imagine staying at the company I'm at forever, but equally, I'm not particularly drawn to any other company right now.
- neilv 4y agoRegarding IBM, there's allegations that at least part of IBM can be not very nice towards headcount: https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-american-workers/ https://features.propublica.org/ibm/ibm-age-discrimination-a...
- mcv 4y ago> I suspect that a lot of people would be happy to be a "lifer" in the right situation. (Good company, good work, good colleagues, good respect, good TC.) Exactly. I think I could be a lifer in the right circumstances, but I'm not and probably never will be. I think I could have been a lifer at my second job; it was in many ways a great place, but eventually I realised I didn't like the content of my work much, I was constantly doing the exact same thing for a new customer, and all the interesting stuff was being done by new hires. It was time to leave. 48 now, and I'm currently at a project where I think I might stick around for a while, but it's undoubtedly going to end some day, and then I'll find something else again.
- stef25 4y ago> and then I'll find something else again. Do you feel confident about that? I'm a couple years younger than yourself and before starting this gig about a year ago I was considering doing something else (anything ... Apple Store, "IT guy" for a small 10 person company) but always got turned away for "too qualified". No desire at all to get in to management / team lead stuff. Thankfully this job is pretty cool but I'm quite worried about what to do after, when that time comes.
- mcv 4y agoI'm a freelancer. I hire myself out to various large projects, and so far, there doesn't seem to be any shortage in demand. I hope that demands stays up for another decade.
- kqr 4y ago> A barrier is that situation doesn't occur often. Also, unfortunately, that "this, too, shall pass". At one point in my life I was in a situation where I would consider staying, if not for life, at least a very long time. Then for external reasons, much of management was replaced and while at first it seemed fine, eventually I ended up going somewhere else.
- hutzlibu 4y agoI discovered that it is dangerous to have that exact thought. If I hapoen think: "ok, this is not so bad, this could last a while" the big bang blowing it apart, is usually not far away. If you found happiness, enjoy it, but better not think too much about it. (I might have to read Goethes Faust again)
- KineticLensman 4y ago> I suspect that a lot of people would be happy to be a "lifer" in the right situation. I twice stayed in a specific company for more than ten years (11 and 13 respectively). In both cases I left (retired in the second example) because the company concerned had changed around me. I'd also gone native with the customers, and was seen internally as a domain expert. I enjoyed this, but it meant that I began to be firewalled away from internal strategic decision making to avoid conflicts of interest. This in turn reduced my visibility to senior decision makers, and thus promotability.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoI’m similar, 12 years in one job, after a career of W2 contracts and 2-3 year startup positions. Sales and customers loved me, but I ran afoul of a manager and quit rather than be fired. Now trying to update my skills. Good luck!
- ghaff 4y agoI've stayed ~ 10 years at a couple companies. I won't say things were always smooth sailing the whole time. But that was the point where things had really changed, I was in some combination of doing the same thing in my sleep or there really wasn't a role for me any longer, etc. (And, yes, in one case I had really liked the work--which ultimately set me up for the next job well--but the small company couldn't afford market rates.)
- serial_dev 4y ago> companies will pay more to hire someone than they will to retain It's painfully true very often. I worked on a team where I was one of the most proactive people on the team and was one of the top performers (well, at least IMO). I joined the company with an already relatively low salary because in the middle of covid shutdowns, the the startup I worked for didn't look stable enough, so I joined the bigger company even if their offer was the same as my previous salary. After almost two years later, I asked what can I do and what's the process for salary increase, they told me that "sure, we can raise your salary"... BUT: * the company only raises salaries once a year, and that comes next year April, so I'll have to wait 7 months * usual increase is 5%, if I'm very lucky, I might get 10% * this increase is not given every year, so if I get it this time, I'll have to wait two more years for my next 5-10% raise * I'll have to go through a long evaluation process with HR, which means lots of extra meetings spent begging and explaining that I'm actually pretty good They think this is all acceptable while I had multiple offers with very little negotiation, all offering me 20%+ increase. In the end, I got a 50% increase and on top of that a significant amount of stock options from a company that really has a potential to grow and go public. Yeah, I can't be a lifer with those conditions.
- l2silver 4y agoYeah this x10 . The unfortunate reality of staying at one company is that unless you move through the ranks very very very quickly, and the company has significant raises for those vertical moves, you will very likely be underpaid, sometimes by incredible amounts. And it doesn't even take very long for that salary sacrifice to come in. Considering benefits, pension plan, etc, I'm making about 65% of what I could be making at another company, and I've only been there for a couple years. And it's not clear that the work life balance would be all that different either.
- oblio 4y agoRaises are like pulling teeth. Unless your current house is on fire, ALWAYS negotiate super high. NEVER give out current salary info, wait for the end of the interviews. When you pass all of them, ask for a double digit raise over your current salary. Early you are in your career, the first digit should be at worst 2 and ideally 4-5. Once you pass all the interviews, your market value for the new company skyrockets. You're no longer a potential candidate, just a CV, you're actually someone who made it through the interviews. Most companies will not turn you down, just make you the highest offer they can, and then you decide if it's good enough. * * * I've been exactly in your position in 2008, but I was stuck for about 18 months at the start. I missed the first raise round because I was too new, then they froze salary raises. And then I had to constantly pressure them to get what I should have gotten 3 years earlier (by the time my salary reached a level somewhat equivalent to what I had realized my market value was).