3 ms·
Especially places like Florida, Louisiana and Texas that continue to lose to hurricanes and continue to get bailed out despite being rebuilt in high risk neighb
by cyanydeez 4y ago
Especially places like Florida, Louisiana and Texas that continue to lose to hurricanes and continue to get bailed out despite being rebuilt in high risk neighborhoods.
Climate change denialism is expensive.
- sitkack 4y agoFor blue states. I wonder if you could calculate how much federal relief a patch of land has received over the last 50 years?
- TMWNN 4y ago>For blue states You mean "NY, NJ, CT, and MA". They are the states that provide the vast majority of the surplus in federal taxes paid by its people versus expenditures to them and their states.[1] Four other states also have substantial surpluses, of which two voted for Clinton and Biden, and two voted for Trump both times. Every other state either breaks even (CA among them) or receives more than their people pay in taxes. Of the ten states that get back the most, five and a half (of Maine) voted for Clinton/Biden and four and a half voted for Trump/Trump. Source: Rockefeller Institute's annual studies on the subject. [1] Yes, they are all Democratic states today, but this was exactly the same a century ago, when MA and CT were solidly Republican and NJ and NY were swing states.
- replygirl 4y agook inland cities, build up your housing stock and job market so people can move to you
- humanrebar 4y agoMost of Texas is pretty far inland.
- replygirl 4y agohey. i live in texas current data don't seem to be available, but pre-pandemic, texas had a housing shortage of over 300k units, the shortage having nearly tripled in less than a decade. that's likely to be worse now. it sure feels worse a good many of the people immigrating from coastal cities are in a group privileged to remote into coastal jobs. experience corroborates that as well
- richk449 4y agoThere are now places in California where the only fire insurance you can buy is through the state, because private insurers bailed out.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y agoThat’s because the state banned insurers from using up-to-date risk models: https://www.ecologylawquarterly.org/currents/californias-ban-on-climate-informed-models-for-wildfire-insurance-premiums/ https://www.ecologylawquarterly.org/currents/californias-ban... A bad policy, to be sure, but that doesn’t mean the homes are inherently uninsurable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- treeman79 4y agoThese places have had hurricanes for centuries at least. If humans didn’t exist at all. It would still be getting hurricanes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bumby 4y agoRemember, risk is most often measured across the dimensions of probability and severity. So even if probability is the same, total risk can be higher is severity increases. Risk is the currency of insurance.
- kelnos 4y agoSure, but look at the frequency and severity of them more recently, and it starts to get a little scary.
- adrr 4y agoFlorida is going to get interesting when the state won’t be able to purchase reinsurance for their state ran insurance company. Insurance companies have been running at a loss even during non hurricanes years and Ian will make them all pull out. You can’t get loans if you don’t have insurance.
- chii 4y agoi bet they will vote in someone to pass federal legislation with which they receive subsidies that gets spent on making insurance companies whole (aka, take on the losses). Then they will perpetuate the situation, until the coast line sinks.
- xenadu02 4y agoIf you want to live in a Hurricane-prone area you should build to hurricane-resistant standards. Yet what does every single new home in Florida have? A composite shingle roof, no built-in 100mph+ storm shutters, etc. No requirement for built-in backup power. This is one instance where insurance should be free to properly price risk. Make classifications of storm resistance and price each home based on what standard it meets. Frankly California has the same problem with earthquake insurance even though it's all sold by the state created (but supposedly not backed) authority. The rates mostly don't reflect any earthquake-proofing nor what standard the home was built to. If you retrofit a 1930s home to the best modern standard you still pay the same rate as your neighbor who did not.
- anfilt 4y agoThere are composite shingles rated for hurricane winds. Although for that rating nail placement is critical. Sadly the most common screwed up thing on roof installs is nail placement. This can lead to leaks in 5+ years generally. However, in the case high winds if the nail is not on the common bond the nail can pop through the shingle. Also most manufactures require a ring shanked nail for the hurricane rating. Again most roofers use only a smooth electro-galvanized nail because it's cheap. And once one shingle pops loose suddenly it's much easier for the wind to get under the other shingles near by and the failure can cascade like dominoes in a hurricane situation. Going from a simple repair to replacement of a section or to a whole roof replacement. Also an other aspect is double checking the shingles are properly placed otherwise the seal strip won't adhere in the correct spot on the shingle below making it easier for the adhesive to come loose and again same problem. The thing is if you have seen how fast most roofing companies put a roof on a house do you think they are going to do this right? Also sadly if the roof fails during a hurricane it just means more work for them in the future which means more money paid by insurance. So their incentives are not there. Like there are some roofing companies that will go door to door after a major storm looking for houses basically that have storm damage and get the homeowner to file claim. Looking for things like an out of production shingle so instead of a repair insurance has to buy a whole new roof since replacement shingles don't exist. It's really scummy. The sad thing is this scummy behavior had lead to insurance companies way more likely to deny claims that are valid. I remember seeing a video of roofer with an insurance adjuster acting like what the roofer said was not true or not comment or document it. It was kinda insane and sad at the same time. Last note: Although shingles without a hurricane rating in my opinion should not be installed in places like Florida.
- rayiner 4y agoI’d be curious to quantify the subsidy from hurricanes to the higher mortgage subsidies from higher mortgage limits in states that choose to make housing expensive.
- xyzzyz 4y agoOne reason why people talk about “hurricane insurance subsidies” in the first place is that it is hard to quantify, so it’s hard to call people on their bullshit. This is similar to introducing arcane metrics like for example “federal dependency” (https://sipanews.fiu.edu/2021/03/24/2021s-most-least-federally-dependent-states/ https://sipanews.fiu.edu/2021/03/24/2021s-most-least-federal...) with nonobvious methodology, and then pretending that the states that are high in “federal dependency” ranking are actually more meaningfully “dependent” on federal government, which doesn’t actually pass muster if you look at the methodology (for example, according to their methodology, a state that collects $1k in taxes per capita, and gets $4k from federal government, while spending $5k per capita, is more dependent on federal government than a state that collects $10k in taxes, gets $10k from feds and spends $20k, which is absurd). Basically, there is a lot of attempts at hoodwinking audience by giving impression that there is some deep quantitative analysis behind the claims, when in fact it’s all just partisan shenanigans.
- rayiner 4y agoYeah. Maryland and Virginia are never at the top of these lists, even though though their economies are totally built around adjacency to the federal government. These methodologies always seem to count a retiree drawing social security in Florida as federal dependency, but don’t count the northern Virginia employees of a DC lobbying firm as federal dependency.