3 ms·
So if Merck hires some actor to advertise a new prescription painkiller, and that drug later turns out to cause heart attacks, should the actor be held legally
by nradov 4y ago
So if Merck hires some actor to advertise a new prescription painkiller, and that drug later turns out to cause heart attacks, should the actor be held legally accountable?
- exabrial 4y agoYes, duh. Medical decisions shouldn’t be based on actors attractiveness… it should be based on efficacy and safety.
- HWR_14 4y agoI think we can distinguish between an actor playing a role and a famous person hired to endorse a product. If this means commercials revert to having all no-name actors because the law tilts towards endorsement, so be it.
- nradov 4y agoPlease explain how such a law could ever possibly comply with the constitutional vagueness doctrine, and with 1st Amendment protections on freedom of expression.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> explain how such a law could ever possibly comply with the constitutional vagueness doctrine, and with 1st Amendment protections on freedom of expression Fraud is not protected by the First Amendment [1]. This is old law. [1] https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12180 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12180
- HWR_14 4y agoFraud isn't protected, so that is how you would handle the 1st amendment. Whether the person was acting as an actor or was endorsing it as a celebrity is a matter of fact for the jury. It actually doesn't even sound that hard to demonstrate. Tom Brady wasn't paid 10MM (or whatever) because he is that much of a better actor. He was paid to be himself and endorse a product.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoBut how do you define "celebrity" in a legal sense. Why is Jimmy Noname not culpable but Chris Pratt would be? And what if Jimmy Noname did an FTX ad and the following year got the lead role in the most successful movie of 2023? Is he retroactively a celebrity endorsement? Mercedes' Formula 1 car had like 6 FTX ads on it this season. Why isn't Mercedes or Lewis Hamilton in this class action?
- HWR_14 4y agoYou wouldn't define celebrity. You would define endorsement. And you would let the lawyers present evidence and let a jury decide whether they thought the person was endorsing it. I'm not sure it's a good idea, but it's an interesting idea. And the follow on effects of making endorsements things that people actually believe in would be a nice world. I assume Mercedes/Lewis Hamilton weren't included because the lawyers went by whoever did it on the superbowl. Cause it was an easy list to find. And a lot of Americans don't know anything about F1 so it's under the radar.
- liber8 4y agoNone of the celebrity endorsers committed fraud. You didn't answer the question.
- HWR_14 4y agoYou mean, because they were merely negligently misleading instead of intentionally misleading? Yes, it's seems to not be under the current definition of fraud. I thought we were discussing a counterfactual that the OP suggested where negligent endorsements were actionable under a law similar to fraud. Fraud was used by me as an example of the 1st amendment being okay with certain commercial speech being actionable.
- edmundsauto 4y agoGood question. Fundamentally, I don't think pharmaceutical advertising should be allowed. Broadly, I agree that the implementation matters and there are lots of edge cases. My primary objective is skin in the game: when people capture the upside of their brand identity, they are also exposed to the downside. If someone isn't trying to use their identity to promote something, it is out of scope. In the "anonymous actor" situation, they are not trying to use someone's brand/honor so the perverse incentives don't appear to be present.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> if Merck hires some actor to advertise a new prescription painkiller, and that drug later turns out to cause heart attacks, should the actor be held legally accountable? Of course. Nobody is sending them to jail. But at the very least, their earnings should go the victims. (Analogy: if your employer perpetuates fraud, they go to jail and you lose your job.)
- function_seven 4y ago> Analogy: if your employer perpetuates fraud, they go to jail and you lose your job. My previous earnings aren’t taken. None of the contractors that did work for the company get their payments clawed back.
- acedTrex 4y ago> they go to jail and you lose your job You don't have to give your paycheck back though.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> don’t have to give your paycheck back You may if you’re senior enough. Public figures pushing nonsense are in positions of influence. It’s mind blowing that an emerging opinion on this forum is the beneficiaries of fraud should be immune from consequences.
- lvass 4y agoFrom a guy who laid bricks in a FTX office, to Tom brady, draw us a line. Let's see how deep guilt by association goes in your head, and how you would regulate this.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> draw us a line We have centuries of case law on this. If I lose money in a fraud, you can be sure as hell I’ll sue everyone who took cash out. Naïveté is not an excuse for misconduct.
- Larrikin 4y agoMaybe they should be. If no actor is willing to take the risk then would we be worse off with less ads for prescription drugs being advertised on TV.
- registeredcorn 4y agoDo you think it's reasonable to assume that actors wouldn't take the risk in order to get paid in an industry that is notoriously competitive to get paid in? I could see a lot of people simply chalking it up to "Well, hopefully nothing bad happens...?" That is also assuming they even fully appreciate the risk that they'd be taking on. It certainly doesn't seem like it would be in the interest of the ad agency to make them aware of their share of culpability.
- jerrysievert 4y agowhat about the person operating the camera? it seems there is some conflation between a "brand ambassador" and someone hired to film a commercial. if someone takes direct interest as payment for filming something, and they further go out and endorse it, then they are a brand ambassador. if someone gets paid once for doing a job (or some residual per play), but nothing further, that sounds like payment for hire.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- VirusNewbie 4y agoWhat if a famous person endorses an alcoholic beverage company and it later turns out alcohol contributes to disease or death?
- notch656a 4y agoShould be bidirectional. They pay me for the liver disease, I pay them for losing enough anxiety to get lucky.