4 ms·
> I’ve also noticed a weird tendency to downplay theft lately, either through projecting a theoretical moral justification on to the shoplifter or by insinuatin
by ryandrake 4y ago
> I’ve also noticed a weird tendency to downplay theft lately, either through projecting a theoretical moral justification on to the shoplifter or by insinuating that retail stores are evil corporations and therefore deserve no sympathy.
Let me try to convince you without defending the morality of the shoplifter or declaring corporations evil.
1. On the totem pole of crimes, petty shoplifting (without violence) is pretty close to the bottom when it comes to harm done the public. Jaywalking and smoking weed are lower.
2. These corporations that are being robbed already build shrinkage into their budgets. $300k of baby food is nothing to Walmart, a rounding error, and I doubt you can even see it in their bottom line. Even a smaller shop is not going to go out of business if someone walks out with all their toothpaste. It’s not analogous to stealing from an individual.
3. There are a limited number of police and I’d rather them be out there deterring violent and serious crime than protecting the inventory of companies. When every rapist, murderer, white collar fraudster, and drunk driver is behind bars, and the police have nothing left to do, then sure, go bust those dastardly deodorant thieves.
- raverbashing 4y ago> already build shrinkage into their budgets This is a shortsighted take. This is as stupid as the corporations buying "cyber insurance" not realizing the cases are going up and that prevention and processes are needed. Then comes next year their premiums shoot up. Who would have thought it?! Yes they "build shrinkage" for a forecasted number. If that number goes up and you get people swiping large amounts of products that number becomes meaningless. Then people wonder why did the store close or why a deodorant there costs $10 and is locked behind the counter
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 4y agoFrom the article: "Rite Aid, a pharmacy, closed a branch in Hell’s Kitchen in February after losing $200,000 worth of stuff last winter. And last week Target, a big retailer, reported that a rise in “shrink” (to use the industry jargon) had reduced its gross profit margin by $400m so far this year. The National Retail Federation says inventory loss, largely driven by theft, cost retailers a record $95bn last year." It seems that $300k is several orders of magnitude off. The harm to the public is when the stores find it unprofitable to exist in certain neighborhoods, which makes the neighborhoods even worse off. If the stores don't close, then prices have to rise to pay for the shrinkage, which the public has to pay for.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoIs it unprofitable or just not profitable enough for the capitalists who could get more return elsewhere? The cause in the increase is possibly an increase in poverty, or increase in wealth disparity?
- WalterBright 4y agoWould you invest in something that returns 1% when there are 2% returns elsewhere? That is called the "opportunity cost", and a business is misallocating capital if the expected return is less than the opportunity cost. > The cause in the increase is possibly an increase in poverty, or increase in wealth disparity? I don't understand your question. Businesses have to have a return on their investment, or they go out of business. Shrinkage is a cost, so the price on the goods has to be raised to compensate. Profit = Revenue - Cost
- midasuni 4y agoThe price will be increased until people stop buying (either because they do without, go elsewhere, or shoplift) The cost of shrinkage doesn’t factor into the price a business can charge. You don’t decide “I will buy X for $1 and sell it for $3”, you go “I can sell X for $3, where’s the cheapest I can buy it and does it make sense” Now if you have a competitor next door selling X for $2.50 you will struggle to sell for $3, even if your rent or your supplier is higher
- WalterBright 4y agoIf you can't raise prices, you go out of business. > if you have a competitor next door selling X for $2.50 you will struggle to sell for $3 Right, but your competitor next door is also suffering from shrinkage. There's no way that shrinkage does not impact prices. Having the government run it won't help, either, as even if the government doesn't raise prices, the money will come out of your pocket anyway as taxes or inflation.
- generj 4y ago
- monero-xmr 4y agoIt’s morally wrong to steal, and has been since the beginning of civilization. “Though shalt not steal” - Ten Commandments “If a man has stolen goods from a temple, or house, he shall be put to death; and he that has received the stolen property from him shall be put to death.” - Code of Hammurabi Private property is the foundation of civilization and pretending theft doesn’t matter undermines the basis of our world. All theft is wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 4y agoAnd yet, even the Bible has provisions for poor people [1]: > “If you go into your neighbor’s vineyard, you may eat your fill of grapes, as many as you wish, but you shall not put any in your bag. 25 If you go into your neighbor’s standing grain, you may pluck the ears with your hand, but you shall not put a sickle to your neighbor’s standing grain. [1] https://www.bibleserver.com/ESV/Deuteronomy23%3A25 https://www.bibleserver.com/ESV/Deuteronomy23%3A25
- afiori 4y agoI feel like this particular verse would not support reselling 300k worth of stolen baby formula on ebay.
- falcor84 4y agoWhile I agree that it's morally wrong to steal, you lost me at "All theft is wrong". I think there's a deep reason why stories about moral (or at least mostly ambiguous) thieves are so prevalent. Two major examples are Robin Hood and more recently Andor, both about stealing as a way to rebel against an overwhelmingly powerful and negative authority.
- t0suj4 4y agoPeople love retribution, especially when group of people they identify with benefit. It does not matter whether the cause for said retribution is real or not. You sleep easier when you don't know what happens to the people who won't receive the shipment a robbed grain merchant cannot pay for.
- leni536 4y ago> These corporations that are being robbed already build shrinkage into their budgets. Doesn't this just mean that it is priced in? So thiefs are stealing from paying customers.
- concordDance 4y agoTwo things: Shoplifting results in shops closing down in poorer areas or raising prices. This is quite bad for the poor. People getting away with shoplifting and seeing others get away with it makes them feel they are not in a law abiding environment and makes them far more willing to break other laws and do things like deal drugs, beat up/kill their enemies and take the law into their own hands. A look at the murder rate in poor areas is suggestive.
- exitb 4y agoIm sure that Walmart is the gold standard of cost optimization, but it's not universal. Many stores operate on very low margins, so it's easy to imagine that just a few missing cans of baby formula actually brings down the profitability of the entire shelf down to zero.