7 ms·
CEO pay skyrocketed 1,460% since 1978: CEOs paid 399 times as much vs. worker
- 28304283409234 4y agoYes, but those men work really hard.
- lm28469 4y agoIt's just a matter of time before people revolt, we went from something like 1:6 employee:employer comp ratio to 1:400 (and much more for a lot of companies, up to 1:5000+) If we could harvest energy from the hardcore early capitalist theorists rolling in their graves we'd have infinite energy at that point
- walkhour 4y agoWhat does a revolt look like? People can live in unimaginable conditions and not revolt. The idea that if things get bad enough "people" are going to do something about it can just occur to someone that hasn't seen enough of the world.
- lm28469 4y agoCEOs getting insane pay doesn't exist in a vacuum. You can't use the "trickle down" economy as a proverbial carrot when people can't put gas in their car or heat their home while Bezos&co buy a new yacht every other day > The idea that if things get bad enough "people" are going to do something about it can just occur to someone that hasn't seen enough of the world. Or I'm French, who knows ;) Continue selling ports to China, continue selling sport clubs to Qatar, apartments to Emiratis, continue to delocalise industries to third world countries to save on labor, continue to force people into precarity, to force them into shittier and shittier jobs while asking them to work longer hours and retire at 67 for less and less quality of life. I'm telling you, at some point people won't have anything to lose and heads will start rolling
- whatshisface 4y agoLast time heads were rolling in France people were starving.
- lm28469 4y agoWell we have 10m people living under poverty, even armed with forks and spoons they'd take the Elysee in a day. Even the 42 000 homeless children living in France could take care of it
- ttoinou 4y agoPoverty definition is a relative definition. Hence you're measuring inequalities, not wealth
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lm28469 4y agoWell that's what the discussion was about in the first place wasn't it ? The inequalities between CEOs and workers grew, one side lives in absolute poverty, the other in absolute opulence The poor are still too poor to live properly and the rich are too rich to count, that's not how they sold us capitalism is it ? Wasn't it supposed to even out inequalities ? Money trickling down to the poorest ? Why are there still people in ultra advanced countries who can't afford to heat their home ? > Poverty definition is a relative definition. Criteria such as: "can't afford clothes" "can't go out with friends/family at least once a month due to financial reasons" "not having access to internet" "can't pay water/electricity bills" "can't heat apartment above the minimum temperature determined by the law" "can't afford one week of vacation out of their own place" "can't afford meat/fish every other day"
- Firmwarrior 4y agoOur patron saint has this to say about it > For example, let's attack poverty, and if necessary damage wealth in the process. That's much more likely to work than attacking wealth in the hope that you will thereby fix poverty. [9] And if there are people getting rich by tricking consumers or lobbying the government for anti-competitive regulations or tax loopholes, then let's stop them. Not because it's causing economic inequality, but because it's stealing. [10] > If all you have is statistics, it seems like that's what you need to fix. But behind a broad statistical measure like economic inequality there are some things that are good and some that are bad, some that are historical trends with immense momentum and others that are random accidents. If we want to fix the world behind the statistics, we have to understand it, and focus our efforts where they'll do the most good. http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html
- klyrs 4y agoI'm not sure about a revolt, but this is what we're seeing: People mobbing into stores, grabbing things off the shelves, and just walking out. Sleeping in tents in massive encampments, turning parks and sidewalks into shanty towns. Pissing and shitting on the street in broad daylight. The richest are driving up rents and housing prices in cities. Gas is increasingly unaffordable, driving up cost of living in rural areas. People who cannot keep up will find other solutions. It might not involve guillotines, but the US has more guns per capita than anywhere else in the world. edit: what I've described above is not a revolt, per se, but it is revolting.
- api 4y agoPopulists have so far been able to focus all that anger at immigrants and LGBT people.
- lm28469 4y agoBecause they're part of it, the other side of the coin, what we need is a new coin
- tomp 4y agoYou got it the other way round. After the 1% protests, media started publishing social justice articles to divide & conquer the population. The percentage of woke words like “racist”, “sexist” and “gender” rose rapidly!
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoBecause billionaires own the media and they don't want anything to affect the status quo.
- germinalphrase 4y agoIt’s eminently clear that identity politics is the name of the game across the political spectrum.
- sanedigital 4y agoSure, but if we're talking about co-opting the anger around wealth inequality, that particular fight ended with Occupy Wall Street becoming Black Lives Matter.
- germinalphrase 4y agoI actually disagree somewhat. A great of MAGA rhetoric was/is about elites abusing their positions at the expense of regular folk. Trump was viewed as an insider telling people the truth about how the sausage gets made.
- rosnd 4y agoWhy revolt when your quality of life keeps increasing? Some fucked up obsession with "fairness"?
- lm28469 4y agoWho's quality of life ? Having a 4k TV and a smart fridge doesn't balance the degraded day to day working conditions, pays, longer hours, later retirement Quality of life peaked somewhere in the 90s in the west, now it's all non essentials, people are giving up on the idea of owning their home and retiring healthy, &c.
- naasking 4y ago> It's just a matter of time before people revolt Trump was the first warning sign IMO, and some are still not taking it seriously, blaming the voters themselves for being so dissatisfied with the status quo that they would take a chance on someone like that.
- krapp 4y ago>blaming the voters themselves for being so dissatisfied with the status quo that they would take a chance on someone like that. It is the fault of the voters. Especially after it was obvious Trump was just a grifter who couldn't care less about the common man, and they voted for him again because they were scared of the immigrants and black activists with whom they should have had class solidarity. And it will still be the voters' fault when they vote for him a third time in 2024, based on whatever batshit QAnon lunacy their conservative truth-bubbles drip into their eyeballs. And Trump wasn't the first warning sign by any means. Arguably Occupy was the first warning sign in recent memory. We don't recognize that because the current narrative is that "the left" supports the status quo of the elites, neoliberalism and capitalism while "the right" are the anti-capitalist, anti-statist underdogs.
- naasking 4y ago> It is the fault of the voters. Especially after it was obvious Trump was just a grifter who couldn't care less about the common man You mean like most other politicians? > and they voted for him again because they were scared of the immigrants and black activists with whom they should have had class solidarity This racist trope is propaganda. Also, "class solidarity" is not a thing anymore thanks to the dominant parties who have been squashing it for over 50 years. > Arguably Occupy was the first warning sign in recent memory. Occupy didn't accomplish anything, it was a weak protest. Electing Trump definitely accomplished something and proved the discontent runs deep and can affect the cushy established class. Then came the messaging about baskets of deplorables and ultra-maga threats to democracy.
- esarbe 4y agoVoters in the US have very little actual influence when it comes to national politics. Yes, they have one final vote, but their vote is highly distorted due to systemic issues, like e.g. first-past-the-post. There are 300 million people in the US. How come the voters only get to make a binary decision? Simple; because the two parties have designed everything so that the voter only gets to make that decision. So, I'd say that blaming the voters is a bit short-sighted when it comes to a quasi-aristocracy like the US.
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> This escalation of CEO compensation and of executive compensation more generally has fueled the growth of top 1% and top 0.1% incomes, leaving fewer of the gains of economic growth for ordinary workers and widening the gap between very high earners and the bottom 90%. I ignore every article that separates the top 1% from ordinary workers. In the UK, to be in the top 1% of earners you need to earn 120K GBP gross a year, or 74K net. Don't tell me you are anything other than an ordinary worker with that. As a side note, you will also earn less net than a household of two earning 50K gross each, are they also not ordinary workers? I don't give a single fuck about the salary of the 0.0001% of the population that is billionaire CEO, that's not the problem. The problem is that basic necessities have been turned into a profit-printing machine and you pay 2K a month for a 500 square feet apartment in London.
- lucisferre 4y agoIt's more like 170k. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1224844/monthly-pay-of-employees-uk/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1224844/monthly-pay-of-e...
- itsdrewmiller 4y agohttps://ceoworld.biz/2020/02/07/how-much-the-top-1-of-worlds-richest-earn-in-different-countries/ https://ceoworld.biz/2020/02/07/how-much-the-top-1-of-worlds... has $248k or ~205k GBP.
- fistfucker3000 4y ago> I don't give a single fuck about the salary of the 0.0001% of the population that is billionaire CEO, that's not the problem. The problem is that basic necessities have been turned into a profit-printing machine and you pay 2K a month for a 500 square feet apartment in London. Interesting that you don’t see those things as part of the same problem but rather two separate unrelated issues.
- holbrad 4y agoHow are they directly related? Is Bezos, Gates or Musk at fault for high UK house prices ? No, it's a failing of government policy. Straggling house building for decades, leads directly towards rampant land speculation. (70+% of a houses value is the land...)
- DaveExeter 4y agoIf that pay didn't go to the CEO, who would get it? The shareholders. And who are the shareholders? The wealthiest 10% own almost 90% of stocks.
- adamedw 4y agoIt could go to the people who produce the value in the first place: the workers.
- friedman23 4y agoAt what point should someone's creation be confiscated and given to employees?
- germinalphrase 4y agoWhat proportion of CEOs are also the founders of the company?
- pessimizer 4y agoAt what point is something with somebody's name on it that they never touch, but is completely created and maintained by others, considered not their creation anymore? I would think it would be death, but it's probably 70 years after death. Thousands of people, laboring day and night on the creation of a dead man who even when he was alive may have never quite known how it worked.
- kaibee 4y agoGradually over the course of ~12-36 years, depending on the number of employees. If you started your business, say, Bamazon, 25 years ago or whatever, and its year 26, you're a trillion dollar corporation, etc, most of the new value add happening at Bamazon isn't down to the CEO's brilliance anymore, just because of the sheer scale of Bamazon. So by then most of that new value add should be going to the workers. Bezos would still have become a billionaire or whatever. And you can implement this pretty straight forwardly actually by just printing new shares for workers as part of their total comp.
- _fat_santa 4y ago> CEOs are getting ever-higher pay over time because of their power to set pay and because so much of their pay (more than 80%) is stock-relate This is the key to their high compensations, and in some ways it has to be like that because how else are you going to incentivize a CEO to raise the value of the company? Say a CEO was paid exactly what the engineers at a company were paid, it doesn't matter to him if the stock goes up or down because his pay stays the same. By tying the CEO's salary to the stock price, you're telling them that they can make a killing if the company makes a killing. It's unfair but it's necessary.
- derac 4y agoHow about you fire them if they don't perform and only hire people who perform well. Even with this incentive most CEOs don't perform well and many gut their companies to raise the stock price and leave.
- uoaei 4y agoThis is a really important point. Seems like the people who are justifying pay imbalances are doing so on the basis of conflating a company's value with its stock price. Ultimately the question comes down to your ethics around money, but it is interesting to get a peek behind the psychological veil. People who worship CEOs for being able to pull big buxxx do so because they assume that more money in existence is better, period, without thinking about where that money goes and what it funds.
- jakupovic 4y agoWow, really? The CEO needs to be incentivized 399 times? Pretty sure anything more than 0 would work. Wow, just wow that someone can actually think and better yet write it out. Nobody needs a 399X incentive. That is just stupid.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoYou're not competing with normal employees but with other CEOs and with other companies.
- loandbehold 4y agoMaybe Karl Marx had a point? Sure, communist revolutions of the 20th century produced suboptimal results, but only because violent psychopaths were in power. We need democratic socialism. Maybe Bernie Sanders has right ideas.
- ilyt 4y agoPsychopats have unreasonably high efficiency in convincing people they should lead them tho
- whatshisface 4y agoTaken alone that sentence applies equally well to any system of government.
- sebastiansm 4y agoSalvador Allende in Chile wasn't a violent psychopath, but also produced suboptimal results during his short period. Then came a real psycho, but that's another sad story.
- conradfr 4y agoWas it Salvador Allende or the CIA and the IMF?
- jandrese 4y agoOne of the biggest weaknesses in highly centralized authoritarian regimes is that it creates enormous incentives for the largest assholes to lie, cheat, steal, and kill to get into power, because one they're in power they will be free of any consequences. This also means they have to be exceptionally regressive towards the population because they know the next huge asshole will be itching to do the same to them. With decentralized power you can have checks and balances to punish people like that.
- dmix 4y ago> but only because violent psychopaths were in power. There were way more problems with socialism than just the fact it breeds dictators. If you're starving your people in the time of greatest abundance of food in history it might be more fundamentally flawed.
- burn_cycle 4y agoI would be interested to see the stats on what percentage of the profits of top companies went to all administrative employees(managers, hr, execs, etc) not just CEOs over the same period.
- arcturus17 4y agoLike most people I think that this is ludicrous, but could someone give a shot at playing devil's advocate and justifying this? Are competent CEOs so much harder to get, do they really produce a 1,460% more value compared to '78, etc.?
- squaredot 4y agoThe scale linking cost to quality of a good is not linear. People often pay twice as much for something that is only 10 percent better. Prices are a matter of allocation, not value.
- wpasc 4y agoMy devil's advocate take is that this is downstream of corporate consolidation. Corporate consolidation IMO has become easier with greater economies of scale achievable with far better communication, shipping networks, and generally global connectivity. If CEO's of today on average leading companies that are orders of magnitude larger than in the 70's (CEO has 100-1000 people in the company in 70's vs 1,000-100,000 today), then the jump in pay isn't surprising. If the CEO is driving the direction of a company and those decisions affect orders of magnitude more workers and orders of magnitude more revenue, then it follows that they can get a higher salary. They might not be any better, but the stakes of their decisions are bigger.
- hotpotamus 4y agoCorporate consolidation may be easier now, but monopolies are nothing new. Theodore Roosevelt was famous for being a "trust buster". Some part of the story has to be regulatory.
- paulgb 4y agoI’m partial to the Lake Wobegon explanation, which gets a mention in the article: > Alluding to the fictional town in the radio program A Prairie Home Companion, Clifford (2017) describes the Lake Wobegon world of setting CEO compensation that fuels its growth: Every firm wants to believe its CEO is above average and therefore needs to be correspondingly remunerated. In other words, CEO pay isn’t just a way of attracting CEO talent, it’s also a way of signaling to investors that you have a good CEO. After all, who wants to invest in a company whose CEO (by the compensation committee’s own reckoning) is worse than average! This is rational for an individual company, but has the aggregate effect of inflating CEO compensation for everyone.
- nell 4y agoCapital allocators are always paid top dollar. CEOs are only a small part of it. Wall street bankers are paid top dollar too? They find investment opportunities that can generate returns. Traders make a lot of money too. What value do they add to society? They help in the price discovery of assets. Are they paid fairly, who knows? From a job complexity standpoint, CEO jobs are more challenging than bankers since they have to manage a real business to generate a positive return. Bankers have no skin in the game and yet make millions.
- brian-armstrong 4y agoThanks for the whataboutism argument. It really opened my eyes to workers deserve less money.
- nell 4y agoIf you want to really understand why it is that way, you have to dig deeper, and you'll find they are much more deep-rooted and has tentacles everywhere. It's simplistic to point to one job function and call it out as unfair as the system is set up so some key positions accrue value.
- cbsmith 4y ago"Capital allocators are always paid top dollar." That seems to be unrelated to the subject matter. I could just as easily say, "senior employees are always paid top dollar over junior employees". Presumably, "capital allocators" were paid top dollar in 1978. Somehow though, their wages have grown 1460% relative to the people who actually put the capital to work.
- nell 4y agoIn 1978 GE was the largest by revenue. They made 54B in revenues ~13B in a quarter. In 2022 Apple is the largest. They made 124B in a quarter. Revenues are up 1000% The larger the capital you manage, the the higher the compensation. Btw, I am not justifying, just trying to understand what could lead to this.
- squaredot 4y agoThese remarks about the salary of the last percentile of the population only serve to raise controversy. If you want to see how people's well-being has evolved, you have to make somewhat more intelligent comparisons: for example by looking at what people can afford today compared to 50 years ago, or through quality of life indexes. The only thing that has changed for the worse seems to me to be the cost of real estate in the big cities, because of an obvious concentration of the population in them and not because the 1 percent of the population has bought everything. But outraged people will always find something to be outraged about.
- jrm4 4y agoYou seem to have missed that the thrust of the article could more be about overpaid CEO's than it is about underpaid workers.
- squaredot 4y agoOverpaid with respect to what? The comparison CEO-worker is not explicitly stated, but it's not very hidden either.
- dmix 4y agoHow likely are the odds their proposed solutions will result in better pay for workers? Rather than just higher tax rates? Only one mentions workers pay: > setting corporate tax rates higher for firms that have higher ratios of CEO-to-worker compensation Even that doesn't seem like a good incentive to pay workers more. It's also not clear how the IRS is going to evaluate CEO pay -> yearly tax rate when this study uses 'realized gains' which often happen well after the fact, since CEOs are paid with stock/equity. The study mentions almost all of the growth has been via the % of stocks CEOs now get, not their actual salary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 5544ffee 4y agoBecause CEOs are 399x smarter and work 399x harder! Plus they take all the risk! /s
- ApolloFortyNine 4y agoI feel it's not a stretch to say your average ceo has more than 399x impact however. A 'simple decision' such as do I approve this product or not can make or break a company. The iPhone is a great example, it was far from considered a slam dunk money printer at the time. You can still find old articles from people wondering why you would want to browse the web on a phone.
- soperj 4y agothat impact can be very negative.
- brian-armstrong 4y agoThe seat itself is more impactful yes, but the human sitting in it not necessarily. We have brought 2000 muskets and 1 tank to war. We find the musketmen are not very effective, so we have chosen not to pay them very much. They just deserve less.
- wpasc 4y agoI see a lot of revolution and socialism vs capitalism comments here, but isn't this a not surprising finding given corporate consolidation and increase in CEO:total worker ratio? Sure, there's debate about pro's and con's of corporate consolidation and market failures surrounding monopolies and oligopolies. But, with the increase in connectivity between regions via telecom, internet, mobile, etc; wouldn't there be an expectation of increased economies of scale from more frictionless communication? If we note increased economies from scale for companies, it would naturally follow a CEO's wage would rise given the weight CEO's decisions when compared to results of company and number of workers affected. The CEO of walmart vs the CEO of 5 general stores would obviously change. All I'm noting is that perhaps this is downstream of consolidation and that's the pertinent discussion, not deciding on socialism/revolution.
- cbsmith 4y ago> I see a lot of revolution and socialism vs capitalism comments here, but isn't this a not surprising finding given corporate consolidation and increase in CEO:total worker ratio? Sure, I guess that makes sense, except... given what corporate consolidation and increase in CEO:total worker ratio? Sure, you hear lots of news stories about mergers and worries about competition, but the likes of US Steel, GM, etc. used to have way more employees. Tech companies generally have fewer employees that comparable sized (by revenue) companies of yore. I'd sure need to see some evidence that the CEO:total worker ratio has actually increased...
- smitty1e 4y agoMOVIE PLOT: Refined hedge fund/blackmail ring whisks potential CEOs to private island, gets candidates all liquored-up, at which point children engage in 'activities' with them. This is all recorded. Later, CEOs invest large chunks of their salaries in the 'hedge fund'. Evidence never quite leaks, as the 'hedge fund' has quite a few customers in various public offices. Oh, never mind. Too far-fetched. Couldn't be happening. Right in front of everyone. Now.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI'd be interested in how this compares to, say, sports stars or celebrity actors. That is, the growth of markets in the past 35 years means that people at the top in "winner take all" markets are able to take a lot more from the bigger pie they command. I'm not saying this is fair or good for society, but I think comparing to things like sports stars would shine a better light on the dynamics that allow all of those at the top to rake in disproportionately more money.
- impulser_ 4y agoMight have to due with the fact that the typical company is a lot larger than they were in 1978. Largest company in 1978 was GM they did about 53b in revenue, and 4b in gross profit. Largest company in 2022 is Apple they did 400b in revenue and 170b in gross profit. The list of people that can run and manage Apple is one, Tim Cook. The list of people that can work at Apple is millions.
- baron816 4y agoYeah, there really wasn’t much global competition either. So we have much larger companies competing all over the world against other huge companies.
- DietaryNonsense 4y agoWhat about ones perception of being able to improve their life? What of opportunity? hope? These are human beings after-all, they perceive such concepts as integral to their reality. In the post-war period prior to the 70s, it was (more) common and reasonable for a high school educated factory worker (in the US) to have optimism in their ability to work in that role and improve their state of affairs. Afford to buy a home, pay off the mortgage, buy a car, provide for a couple of kids, send one of them to college, drive to a national park for an annual vacation. Nowadays, one can be both lucky in terms of their upbringing and be highly educated (post secondary or even advanced degrees), and yet very easily find themselves in a position where the above "life staples" (house, car, family without poverty) are meaningfully out of reach. And in many cases, not even conceivably within reach. It's not merely that housing in major cities is objectively less affordable, it's that the stage upon which life is lived has changed in it's nature. It's a perpetual sunset rather than sunrise, optimism is either for suckers or for those who mischaracterize a certain degree of background luck as merit. I'm in the lucky category. But I think when we boil down the collective subjective experience of hundreds of millions (billions?) to broad metrics and indicators, our models lose the fidelity they need for the subjects to feel they are being taken seriously. I understand why we have these models and tools for better navigating the civilizational state-space, but they're obviously imperfect, and they're of little comfort when serious concerns go unacknowledged (let alone unaddressed) for decades. Now it's possible that CEO pay is orthogonal to all of this. Perhaps as a measure it's one of the metrics that loses too much descriptive power in it's generalization... but it certainly does reek of something.
- latency-guy2 4y agoI had a much longer comment detailing my problems with this article, but it got quite unwiedly by the end being confused about various statements and representations of data. I won't touch upon those things as it seems others have already given some thought into a portion of the same topics. I'd like to talk about Josh Bivens in general, this article appears to be a continuation of a similar one done in 2019: https://www.epi.org/publication/reining-in-ceo-compensation-and-curbing-the-rise-of-inequality/ https://www.epi.org/publication/reining-in-ceo-compensation-..., and another one from 2013: https://www.epi.org/publication/pay-corporate-executives-financial-professionals/ https://www.epi.org/publication/pay-corporate-executives-fin..., yet another in 2011: https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-ratio-average-worker/ https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-ratio-average-worker/ I find it interesting that the key numbers rarely change, beginning years are deliberately used (1978), even though there is nothing really significant about 1978 in particular for economic terms. But why keep using that as the same starting year through so many articles through the years? It also appears that Josh Bivens is Keynesian in beliefs. Previous articles support this beginning from ~2009 onwards, and becoming more apparent through to the 2012 US Presidential election. Bivens has rather strong support for Occupy Wall Street, numerous articles stating as much.
- csharpminor 4y agoThe issue here is that power among people tends to concentrate rather than diffuse. CEOs are comped disproportionately because the top 1% have an exceptionally better network and power structure over others. Why? Because people bandwagon onto known entities. There’s a similar phenomenon with authors, actors, and musicians. A-list actors command an order of magnitude more in compensation over B-list because they have concentrated a much stronger hold over an audience. This isn’t only true of “celebrity” CEOs like Jobs, Musk, etc. CEOs can develop their own mini fiefdoms of celebrity within a niche industry. This network and power gives them access to opportunities that can be pivotal to the success of a company. I think in order to equalize exec pay, you’d need to figure out how to stop the bandwagoning that consolidates exec power.
- snapplebobapple 4y agoThis article is extremely incorrect in looking at inequality as the reason to try and address this. What the ceo is paid has nothing to do with what the average worker is paid and it is incorrect to look at this as problematic from that perspective. What is important is that both the worker and the ceo get paid what they would get in a competitive market and that competitive market is completely different because it is completely different work. This kind of splitting indicates two potential things here and only one of them is concerning/needs addressing. First of all, the wages could be splitting because the labor market characteristics of the two jobs changed. This is completely reasonable given the increased foreign competition faced by the lower 3/4 or so of the labor force, as well as the increasing immigration pushing labor prices down for that labor cohort. The second thing that could be going on, and is concerning, is ceo board capture being abused to increase compensation beyond a competitive ceo wage. This is also believable because most of these big companies have no single large shareholder to push back on ridiculous wage proposals and the mechanics of how voting the shares works means management suggestion is very likely to be approved so the board is often at the whim of the CEO far more than they should be. Only this second cause needs some action to resolve (although I don't have a good recommendation on what that action would be).
- etempleton 4y agoIt is largely because there is much greater salary transparency for the C suite. Everyone walks into the negotiation with a clear understanding of what fair market value is. This is not true for most positions. The worker is at a disadvantage. I believe every job ad should have a minimum salary listed with other compensation and benefits.