5 ms·
The U.S. Needs More Housing Than Almost Anyone Can Imagine
- neilwilson 4y agoNot just the USA The housing situation in the UK is beyond critical.
- LatteLazy 4y agoThe UK's problems are about distribution not supply. We subsidise OAPs to sit alone in 4 bed houses in areas that need workers, then there is no space or money left for working families...
- davidf18 4y ago
- tmnvix 4y ago> ...distribution not supply This is true in more than just the UK. It's also not simply old people living in oversized houses. Think holiday homes, AirBnB, second homes, land-banked properties, etc. Any government that truly wanted to address it's accommodation crisis should start by conducting a thorough survey of residences and determine how many are actually being used as a primary residence.
- chrisseaton 4y agoI think it’s still possible to actually get housing in the UK, it’s just more expensive than you’d like. (There’s lots on the market near me.) Look at somewhere like Ireland where it’s getting to the point where there almost literally just isn’t any housing available at all. Lines of hundreds of people applying to get any property that comes onto the market.
- rcarr 4y agoIt's absolutely ridiculous now. It was also in the news today that net migration was 504,000 this year. I absolutely think it was the right thing to do (mostly refugees from Ukraine and Hong Kong) but if you're going to have these migration policies and you've got a housing supply and affordability crisis, you've absolutely got to implement mass house building policies at the same time. This government is an absolute joke but I have very little faith that Starmer is going to be much better. My plan is to leave whilst I still can. Source: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/net-migration-at-record-levels-as-1-1-million-arrive-in-britain-zfs0xvp6t https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/net-migration-at-record-l...
- Aeolun 4y agoBut where will you go? Housing is ridiculous everywhere (except maybe Japan).
- rcarr 4y agoAt the minute I’m leaning towards going to Australia to take advantage of the new 3 year Working Holiday Visa for uk citizens. I’ll probably get a campervan over there and do the whole nomad thing for a while or just rent for a bit. After that I’m not sure, options I’m weighing up atm: - study German over the next few years and then study in Germany (free or extremely low cost tuition) - as above but in Argentina or another Latin American country (have already been studying Spanish for a couple of years so not far off the standard required) - rent in Ireland for five years (can live and work there visa free as UK citizen), become a naturalised citizen then move anywhere I want in the EU - move to Glasgow or Belfast where property is cheaper and the people are friendlier. - do the whole digital nomad thing in more affordable countries like Thailand, Bali, Mexico etc The only thing I know for sure is I am absolutely done with England and don’t want to be part of it anymore.
- fy20 4y agoA better way to look at it is how much is immigration of wealthy people propping up the UK economy? If you look at the number of new £1m+ apartments in London (which even if you are a couple of well paid engineers you probably could not get a mortgage for), then it paints a pretty stark picture.
- out-of-ideas 4y agomore housing? need water sources ect for existing housing, not to mention new housing..
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoThe full picture gets worse the more you look into it. The largest home builders in the nation aren’t building homes at budgets that most can afford. So you’d say to yourself, well clearly they’re targeting the affluent then. Except there are only so many high income Americans you can sell to, and not all of them want expensive homes. So what do these builders do? They build-to-rent! Yep. Those single-family homes you see in many large developments you can just think of as so-called “luxury” apartments by a different name. I suspect most developed nations experiencing this issue are effectively stuck and growth capped markets. Truly only dedicated policy targeting this problem will make a change, because the capital required to obtain land, rezone it for traditional residential building, then sell it requires either institutional capital, or small builders doing one-offs for select clients.
- zbrozek 4y agoIt's a stifling regulatory environment that's landed us here. Zoning is restrictive, planning commissions are slow and restrictive, councils are slow and restrictive. All of the agencies involved want to capture value from construction projects. The net result is that very few projects pencil out, and the ones that do are expensive. We need to fix the root cause, which is lack of property rights.
- yummypaint 4y agoThe claims about zoning and property rights can be examined in the US, as Texas has no zoning. Housing costs are not remarkably different there. The "capturing of value" that is actually happening is a net transfer of land and wealth from the general population to a handful of massive corporations and the people who control them. Once they own everything and have dismantled the market they can charge whatever they want.
- froggychairs 4y agoZoning for who? America has no issue with single family zoning. I’m assuming you’re speaking about middle and high density zoning. Since the issues you're describing are extremely common for those zoning projects.
- _zfxr 4y agohttps://archive.ph/2pfx8 https://archive.ph/2pfx8
- jasonjamerson 4y agoThere's no situation in which the NYC subway can accommodate a 50% increase in riders. Just building housing isn't enough. I do think this article is right about a lot of things, but I think that if we could magically increase housing, we would find what NYC found building highways: building them actually created traffic, and they could never catch it. If a city's infrastructure can't dramatically increase, the city's full. New York would need to double transit infrastructure to make current use comfortable.
- ttcmuni 4y agoOne key thing to keep in mind is that, even if the population's stagnant, young people want to move out (and live in an apartment, later upgrading to a house when they have kids) while their parents and grandparents want to age in place in their existing home (occupancy goes from say 3-4 to 2). This is why housing production actually has to outpace population growth just to keep prices stable.
- tmnvix 4y ago> The best evidence for how much housing we need to build lies in the prices that people pay today. No. The best evidence is the total number of households in the US compared with the total number of residences. How has that been tracking? Demand for housing has been going up. This demand is not always for a primary residence (or even for properties intended to be rented out as a primary residence). Ireland learnt the hard way that rising demand (as evidenced by rising prices) does not mean a shortage of residences that people could live in. Their shortage quickly turned to a surplus when the GFC hit (though they've somehow managed to engineer another accommodation crisis in Dublin since).