16 ms·
Mercedes locks faster acceleration behind a $1,200 annual paywall
- mentos 4y agoCould probably position it has insurance for wear and tear
- DefineOutside 4y agoHow do you justify BMW also charging $18/month for heated seats?
- dijit 4y agoI don't believe that justification for one thing necessitates justification of another, tangentially related thing. I don't agree with either thing being paywalled, but I also can see nuance on things being paywalled; if there is a legit service cost to the manufacturer associated for example.
- trollied 4y agoYou also have the option of paying up front for the optional heating. This has long been a pay-ahead-of-time option that you had to specify before the car was manufactured. They are now giving you the option of having a subscription instead, and putting the hardware in the car. In reality, nothing has changed because the same pay-ahead option is still there. Does that answer your question, or is my answer not clickbaity enough?
- funcDropShadow 4y ago> In reality, nothing has changed because the same pay-ahead option is still there. That is not true. In the past you have owned a car you bought. Who is going to pay for seat heating if a seat has to be replaced? Who is paying for the fuel caused by the extra weight for stuff you didn't want. What happens if you decide to modify the car you own and run the seat heating yourself?
- prvit 4y agoThis is complete nonsense. In the past it was normal to have that extra weight in your car and no seat heater button because you didn’t pay for it.
- Bancakes 4y agoWhat's changed is now I physically have heated seats and can't use them.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThat business model isn't new. It is common for cruise control modules to be installed in all vehicles and "enabled" with a certain steering wheel having extra buttons.
- adav 4y agoHaving the functionality restricted behind a missing button etc isn't new. For example, it's the same with engines where the same block is used across different performance variants when used with the uprated parts... The new bit is being charged monthly for access. If you don't pay, they remotely disable the functionality.
- prvit 4y agoThat’s been common for like… the past 50 years?
- falcor84 4y agoI'm not the OP, but it doesn't answer my question - what's their excuse for preventing me for using an existing feature in a product that I purchased?
- thesuperbigfrog 4y agoIt's not fully "your vehicle" if they control the software: https://youtu.be/Ag1AKIl_2GM?t=57 https://youtu.be/Ag1AKIl_2GM?t=57 You can pay a recurring subscription fee to access features that they own.
- falcolas 4y agoGreed. “Why get some of your money when I can get all of it?”
- DavidPeiffer 4y agoDifferent type of insurance, I wonder if anyone would underwrite with better insurance rates if you don't have the faster acceleration? Easier when random features aren't subscriptions that can be turned on/off on a monthly basis.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoDoubtful. There are tons and tons and tons of things that HN type crowds like to think are good predictors of something but are really way below the noise floor. There's way lower hanging fruit, like buying access to ALPRs data for "problem" stretches of road. IDK if insurance companies have openly admitted to doing that yet but the ALPR data sellers market as though it's a use case their customers have...
- lupire 4y agoDupe from 2 days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33692285 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33692285
- Workaccount2 4y agoThe hardware world has been taking notes from the software world the last few years.
- Ajedi32 4y agoI think it's more that as software continues to "eat the world"[1], problems that only exist in the software world are becoming more and more pervasive in other areas of our lives. Even though this paywall affects hardware, I'll bet it's implemented in software. [1]: https://a16z.com/2011/08/20/why-software-is-eating-the-world/ https://a16z.com/2011/08/20/why-software-is-eating-the-world...
- funcDropShadow 4y ago> I'll bet it's implemented in software. That would be an accomplishment if they did it in hardware. ;-)
- inkcapmushroom 4y agoI'm picturing a dollar bill slot on the dash like a vending machine.
- Ajedi32 4y agoAlso, food for thought: this means that any effective legal solutions to these problems in the hardware world could probably also be applied to solve those same problems in the software world. The "right to repair" movement, for example, seems on the surface to be closely analogous to freedom 1 of the Free Software Foundation's four essential freedoms[1]. [1]: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#four-freedoms https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html#four-freedoms
- treis 4y agoIt reflects the continual lowering of manufacturing costs compared to design costs. When we're talking about heated seats there's maybe $2 worth of a resistor + wiring to heat them. At some point it's cheaper to make them all heated and reduce your SKUs & design cost. In the long run customers aren't going to pay more. The auto industry is highly competitive and that competition will keep profit margins in check.
- jokoon 4y agoIt's an awful reality, but there is more money to make when targeting rich people than there is money to make products than benefits normal people. You often see this in startups and business plans and models. Same for whale users. This says a lot about capitalism.
- adam_arthur 4y agoEh, there’s money to be made everywhere. Costco and McDonalds make a lot of money too. Certainly adding arbitrary “upgrades” or higher end models specifically to milk less discerning consumers has proven to be a good business strategy. I could see laws against arbitrary software gates limiting hardware gaining traction though. I’d like to hope that the manufacturers who don’t use these tactics win out naturally though
- stu2010 4y agoEconomies of scale mean that it's frequently less expensive to manufacture only the top configuration with the most features, and then turn features off in software. Broadly, I think that price discrimination is good because it allows the cheaper version of things to exist and be sold at a lower profit margin than a company would otherwise be willing to sell for. For example, the 2022 Ford Maverick XL was not available with cruise control, but it's only locked out in software. All cars have computer controlled throttles now, so cruise control is a software-only feature with no additional hardware. Some other hardware that's commonly limited by software is CPUs, GPUs, and such. I had a triple core AMD CPU that I unlocked into a quad core, and an ATI GPU that I reflashed into a higher model. This has become less possible as manufacturers start using lasers to destroy parts of their own product instead, so that hackers can't re-enable disabled functionality. If laws came around to prevent software from being used to limit hardware functionality, that's what we're going to start seeing: more money and effort spent to intentionally remove or destroy things from products. That sucks compared to just switching it off in software.
- robertlagrant 4y agoYes it does, but not in support of your thesis. Angry Birds made a fortune by targeting every phone user for 79p. Apple far more so by putting a phone in millions of pockets. Amazon makes money based on lots of small transactions by non-rich people. Bugatti makes money by targeting a few rich people. You can go big, but have a few customers, or go small and have loads. This is why we have any products to buy - you can do well selling to all sorts of income levels. You just need the right product at the right price.
- evo_9 4y agoI wonder when Tesla, Mercedes, etc will figure out that micro transactions for this is a way more lucrative approach. I’m way more likely to pay let’s say $300 to enable this feature for the weekend to impress a visiting friend or hell at a light next to an annoying BMW M owner that you suddenly need to smack down. Make it a more affordable impulse buy, they’ll make a ton more money that way.
- elevaet 4y agoWhat about $8 to peel out of this intersection?
- grogenaut 4y agoWith the tires on that car it's at least that already
- michaelbuckbee 4y ago"You're about to crash into a semi truck. Pay $25 one time 'advanced braking' fee to avoid crash?"
- mlac 4y ago“Sorry your payment has been declined. Airbags and seatbelts have been reverted to the default economy mode and 911 auto-call has been disabled. Your engine will be shut off if you fail to update your payment information.“
- CorrectHorseBat 4y agoThis sadly already exists: https://www.vice.com/en/article/93yyyd/this-motorcycle-airbag-vest-will-stop-working-if-you-miss-a-payment https://www.vice.com/en/article/93yyyd/this-motorcycle-airba...
- ceejayoz 4y agoThat sounds like a wrongful death lawsuit waiting to happen.
- AlexandrB 4y agoRobust "right to repair" legislation can't come soon enough. Giving owners the right to load aftermarket software/firmware on their car will "fix" these kinds of business models.
- dchichkov 4y agoSomething that touches power-train needs to be ASIL-D grade. For a good reason.
- aftbit 4y agoWhen sold by the manufacturer, sure. When modded by the final consumer, I am less convinced. Sure, a misbehaving car can be a hazard to those around it as well as its driver, but we already accept a huge amount of that in the name of personal freedom. Why not a bit more for those among us who choose to tune and hack their vehicles?
- horsawlarway 4y agoI'm firmly on this side. The single most dangerous part of the car is the driver. You can do basically the exact same damage with a standard car at highways speeds using nothing but the steering wheel and accelerator. And it happens all the time. Functionally - I don't see much difference between a misbehaving control module and a driver having a stroke. You can also solve both problems with a single stroke by making public transportation effective and preferable in places where density is likely to make this a problem (cities).
- georgyo 4y agoI'm incline to agree, but the driver is the most dangerous because we _assume_ that the when the driver pushes the gas or the breaks they will work. In the age of the accelerator and break going to software systems instead of mechanical systems, it is 100% possible to crash that software and all the sudden you cannot break.
- 4y ago
- shanebellone 4y agoAre these OTA updates or paywalls? If the latter, it's time to hack.
- knodi 4y agoNever buying a Mercedes.
- stfp 4y agoF*ck faster acceleration though. The 0 to 100 kph in 2 seconds trend is absurd and dangerous. We should lock all that behind a regulatory wall.
- gadflyinyoureye 4y agoEverything that’s possibly dangerous should be taxed! Only allow the technocrats to determine what the masses should do.
- _jal 4y agoDamn right! Why can't I burn my garbage in downtown San Francisco, instead of having to pay The Man? And if my homebrew wiring job torches down the neighborhood, well, my house, my rules, bucko.
- quantified 4y agoWhat the masses have to pay. Taxed means you gotta have more wealth.
- sfe22 4y agoGoing outside or even climbing my stairs is possibly dangerous, so you mean the government should get a cut of everything? Oh wait…
- celtain 4y agoI always understood speed to be the main problem, not acceleration. If you're going to lock something behind regulation, shouldn't it be speed?
- Scalestein 4y agoSpeed will make accidents worse (deadlier). Acceleration will make accidents more likely. Sports cars flooring it from a stop, losing traction and hitting a telephone pole is like a whole genre of YouTube videos.
- bmacho 4y agoIsn't this common practice literally everywhere in the software industry? They spend additional engineer hours on a feature that isn't generally needed, then they sell it only for the people that need it, and want to pay for it?
- criddell 4y agoOr the functionality is there because of physics so the spend additional engineer hours to build a pay wall around non-critical but desirable characteristics because the amount of money they will collect annually will exceed the amount they spend building the paywall and associated support infrastructure.
- Delphiza 4y agoFunctionality of your PC is also there 'because of physics'. You paid for the RAM, CPU, and electricity to run it. There is a lot of software in cars and ECUs. The mapping and tuning industry exists because there is a lot of knowledge and expertise to extract the most out of the 'physics'. There could be an argument for open source ECU mapping tables and other software. But, the reason is the same as reasons for OSS, not that the customer has paid for the 'physics' that already exists.
- ww520 4y agoSoftware has subscription because software usually puts out new versions periodically with new functionality and fixes. Car companies’ subscriptions seem to be rent on existing features that never change. It would be easier to swallow if it’s a rent-to-own model.
- willbes 4y agoOn the one hand, this causes a deeply ingrained negative reaction in me. On the other, people have been paying hundreds (thousands?) of dollars for digital tunes to reflash their ECU to add more horsepower/torque for years now. That is a one time fee as opposed to a subscription, so maybe therein lies the problem.
- jollyllama 4y agoAs long as the car manufacturer isn't selling the tunes, that doesn't really offend my sensibilities. Arbitrarily restricting capability just so the manufacturer can make more money is the problem.
- necovek 4y agoThis is what Volvo does with their Polestar upgrades already, with the only difference that it's a one time fee.
- Rallen89 4y agothink there is an underlying fundamental difference here, the factory tuning of an ECU is meant to work okay for most conditions, that be the car and weather or whatever, that process is adding on something, fine tuning combustion but for an electric car, it's totally subtractive, the car would have that acceleration if they didnt arbitraraly block it
- sdwr 4y agoIgnoring the cost for a second, I don't want max possible acceleration all the time. Modern gas pedals are already sensitive enough, no reason to need an even lighter touch in stop+go traffic.
- mrguyorama 4y agoYou fix this by putting a setting in the infotainment system that says "Eco mode". My mom's Rav4 has this functionality, it's not exotic.
- jmclnx 4y agoWell if I could afford a Mercedes, they would be off my list now. With all these subscriptions and other crap being added to autos, seems I will be only buying very old cars. My current auto is pushing 20 years
- princevegeta89 4y agoExactly the reason I've always avoided European luxury cars. Imagine buying a full car for a hefty price and having to keep paying extra to use the features you already bought
- l33tman 4y agoLike Tesla might do with their upgraded autopilots and seat heating? They have also started talking about subscriptions for these, don't know if they actually have implemented it yet.. I think all luxury manufacturers will experiment with this unfortunately. Best you can do is don't buy into it...
- masklinn 4y agoHaven't they already done something along those lines where some options are per-owner and transferring the vehicle will remove the option?
- forgotpwd16 4y agoNo, but it's considered. What you may have heard is car returned and feature being removed when sold to someone else.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoIf you sell private party, or trade it to a non-Tesla dealership, then all options will follow the vehicle. If it ever gets back into Tesla's hands, they have the option to remove the features. There WAS a case where someone bought a used Tesla from a non-Tesla dealership that was sold with FSD and Tesla then removed the FSD, and there was a lot of outrage behind it, but like many cases of outrage, it was based on a misunderstanding. That car was never supposed to have FSD. There was a bug at some point that gave FSD to cars that weren't supposed to have it, and that car was sold before the bug was fixed, removing FSD, but the dealer sold it as having FSD because at the time, it did. Of course, IMO, Tesla should have just gone ahead and granted FSD in order to save face instead of generating a ton of negative PR and creating a massive amount of misconceptions.
- trabant00 4y agoMost premium brand cars are leased, not bought. In this scenario it makes perfect sense to tax an increase in performance as it will increase the wear on the car. This is another copy paste article on the subject that offers no details just to spark outrage and clicks. If the tax also applies to bought and payed units feel free to rage. But until some real journalism clears that up...
- oldskewlcool 4y agoThis applies to owners and is an attempt to redefine 'ownership' of vehicles such that 'ownership' becomes a debt-like instrument entailing a stream of cash flows to Mercedes after you have 'purchased' your vehicle. You can see the option for yourself here: https://shop.mbusa.com/en-us/connect/pdp/Acceleration-Increase/709 https://shop.mbusa.com/en-us/connect/pdp/Acceleration-Increa... It would also apply to leased vehicles but to your point is not nearly as offensive there given you already have car as a service as the underlying model.
- ThePhysicist 4y agoI think it's OK to experiment with new forms of monetization, as long as you're not ripping off customers. Here in Berlin VW e.g. operates a car-sharing service using a fleet of ID.3/ID.4's, where you simply pay for a car by the minute, with two different prices for driving (20-30 cents/minute) and parking (9 cents/minute). You can simply drive and then leave the car on any public parking spot (no payment necessary). Often, cars are located just 2-4 minutes walking distance away. I used that so much, but unfortunately VW seems to have decided it's not profitable enough and they recently sold it off to a competitor with worse pricing. So I guess subscriptions alone don't cut it, you still need to sell the car as well. That said I heard from multiple people that car manufacturers earn most of their money with the service and spare parts for cars (not sure if this is still true) and that the buying price is even slightly subsidized. So from that perspective adding a subscription on top of the purchase price makes sense. In the end people will decide whether it makes sense to pay for that, and I think there will be enough competition in the premium segment, so consumers can just chose to take their money somewhere else if an offer is not good.
- peterkos 4y agoThey used to have this in Seattle (Car2Go (Merc), and ShareNow (BMW)) but they had a messy back-and-forth acquisition, shutdown, then apparent resurgence?
- MivLives 4y agoI'm not sure which is running the car rentals near me, but they keep getting tagged like the scooters do which is sorta a bad look.
- makestuff 4y agoI used to love Car2Go. I read that the only reason it was around was so BMW/Merc could meet the fleet emission requirements in the US, and once they were able to meet that without selling a bunch of cars to Car2Go/ShareNow there was no reason to keep losing money on it.
- analog31 4y agoAt first blush i'd be happy to save the money. But I could save even more, and save on gas, by having a less powerful motor in the first place.
- frankbreetz 4y agoYou could save even more money by not buying a Mercedes
- philjohn 4y agoIf we "assume good intent", what if this is akin to overclocking in the computer world? Yes, the motors can physically do it, but it increases drivetrain warranty repairs 15%. At that point, this seems like simple hedging "Sure, you can go faster, might burn out the motors, but we'll replace them under warranty".
- r_singh 4y agoThis is the only circumstance in which it would be acceptable to me as an owner of that hardware.
- horsawlarway 4y agoWhy can that not simply be captured as a cost to the user at time of purchase? Why does it need to be a subscription? Why do they need a fucking green man (circuit chip) in a car I own that obeys only their remote services to unlock this feature? Basically - Either I own the fucking thing, in which case I have all the keys, or I'm just licensing access. Let's not fuck around with this awful gray area where companies try to weasel out of consumer protections.
- philjohn 4y agoBecause most people don't sit there doing 0-60 in 2.2s, but would like a car they don't have to drop off prematurely at the garage for a drivetrain overhaul?
- lelag 4y agoFor sure if you own the car, you can modify it. Tesla has been doing something similar for a while on the extended range model 3 where you can pay a one time fee to get a boost in performance. Interestingly, there is a Canadian company that has reversed engineered what happen when it is unlocked and is selling a device that you plug on the car CAN bus and you get the same performance boost. They obviously sell this for less that what Tesla charges and as far as I understand, the only risk is that you might void your warranty if Tesla "catches" you doing it. So I kind of agree that it seems similar to getting a factory approved chip tuned. When you chiptune your ICE car, you will often pay several hundred euros for a shop with the right hardware to modify your car (and loose your warranty). In this case, if the setting change is increasing failure rate but your warranty is not affected maybe it's not such a bad deal.
- sam0x17 4y agoI predict this will get regulated away within a few years. Some states are already doing it, as they should.
- xbar 4y agoRight. New Jersey made news a week ago by drafting regulation against such nonsense.
- LinuxBender 4y agoOne thing I do not see being mentioned, perhaps I missed it, is the potential for 3rd parties to financially benefit from this in the future. I envision insurance companies running batch queries against Mercedes future API to determine which drivers have unlocked higher speeds and then adding a "High Risk" fee/tax to their policy. Mercedes could charge for access to this API and who knows what it could be used for. Even more dystopian would be a future where governments can access some API that allows them to Geo-fence drivers into an approved area after a traffic conviction or limit the drivers speed. The more evil side of that coin would be access to a secret encrypted application API bug to stuck throttle accident dissenting voices.
- sokoloff 4y agoWe already have some sentencing that allows drivers with a series of DUIs to be allowed to have a limited license which permits them only to drive to/from work, medical appointments, and specific categories of shopping and to, if stopped, breath-test below epsilon BAC at all times. Having technology aid in enforcing those sentences (such as the breath-test ignition interlock required by some sentences) seems OK to me. I think I'd include geo-fencing into that same level of balancing society's interests and the freedom of someone convicted of multiple DUIs.
- homonculus1 4y agoIt's not going to be for people convicted of multiple DUI's.
- californical 4y agoIf you have multiple DUIs, you should absolutely not be allowed to drive until you’ve been proven sober for a long time (many years). And honestly, even one DUI is enough to remove your driving privileges for years in my opinion. There’s no excuse for driving once you’ve had alcohol. You can just choose not do it, it’s not like you can accidentally drive after having too much alcohol. We should have significantly better public transit, to make this more humane. But so many people drive dangerously and cause huge amounts of deaths. I think a better long-term fix is to have good public transit so that people have better options and don’t feel like they need to drive everywhere.
- barathr 4y agoThis sort of practice is soon to be disallowed in New Jersey, if I understand correctly: https://www.thedrive.com/news/new-jersey-legislators-aim-to-ban-most-in-car-subscriptions https://www.thedrive.com/news/new-jersey-legislators-aim-to-...
- Kukumber 4y agoTesla is doing the exact same for years, where are the Verge articles about it? Interesting that it is not even mentioned once, on the other hand the accent on "German auto manufacturer" is loud and clear Also Intel shamelessly wants to join https://www.theregister.com/2022/11/22/intel_reveals_paid_xeon_features/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/11/22/intel_reveals_paid_xe... I don't understand why these companies try to sabotage themselves, do they want to buyback their stocks for cheap?
- josephcsible 4y agoAt least with Tesla it's slightly less bad. Their acceleration boost is a one-time purchase, not a subscription.
- prvit 4y agoI own a bunch of AMGs and this seems fairly reasonable to me. It’s always trivial to squeeze more power out of these cars with software modifications. The cars do not come out of the factory like that because of reliability concerns. To me this just reads like manufacturer-warrantied chiptuning. The interesting question will be whether or not this can actually compare with external chiptuners when it comes to performance. HN doesn’t like subscriptions, but 1.2k/yr for a warrantied high quality tune from the manufacturer would be a great deal compared to what is available right now.
- colordrops 4y agoThis is how it starts. Look at the game industry for how it ends up. Usually not good for the consumer.
- prvit 4y ago“Slippery slope” is generally a poor argument, especially without strong evidence regarding it’s existence. If they fuck this up and piss off their customers, that’ll just mean that BMW or VAG will take the sales instead.
- nequo 4y agoNo. Because of market power, if they can rake in more money with pricing strategies like this, BMW and VAG can also raise their prices.
- bluGill 4y agoNot really. They can try, but there is also the used market which is much less likely to fall for this. The used market will probably demand to know if this was ever enabled so they can pay less for your abused car. The used market will probably bypass cars with heated seat subscriptions (at least where it gets cold) to the point where they have to make it permanent just to keep the trade in value high enough that the old owner can afford the next car.
- 4y ago
- HelloNurse 4y agoApart from the choice of burning goodwill in their engines, if controlling the accelerator is technically possible then ridiculously lethal remote hacking is also possible.
- idontwantthis 4y agoIf I just want an (electric) car that gets me to work and back home safely, I think I should like optional subscriptions. Hopefully it makes the base model more affordable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cupertino95014 4y agoIt's already the case that driving a newish Mercedes is like having a bumper sticker: I Have Too Much Money and Not Enough Taste Buying one is like opening a vein. You've given permission for them to take all they want.
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> Not Enough Taste Debatable...
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI'll enter the debate. For those that do admire the reputation of Mercedes for being tastefully done, if they can actually afford the newish model of their dreams, wouldn't it show even better taste to purchase a vintage model instead? Made back when the company was profiting from selling its own brand of luxury & performance rather than renting it out directly. Makes you think there must be other designed-in compromises that would never have been acceptable when the executives were still focused (by tradition if nothing else) on making the major purchase itself be as satisfying as possible. It may be the same company, and technology has certainly advanced, but today's executives themselves are not as advanced as people used to be in previous decades. This is a plain ordinary decision-making deficiency. Remember at one time a Mercedes plant was doing extremely well simply manufacturing the vehicles and letting any aftermarket leasing be handled by third parties. Now it's plain to see they're struggling to squeeze the consumer in ways that are simply distasteful compared to higher-class operation under more respectable higher-performance executives in earlier times at the same company. It's a slippery slope, first you're raking it in simply building luxury homes and selling them for market price. If that's not enough then leveraging what's built by renting out the same asset instead of parting with it is a consideration but it involves a lot more financing arrangements. There's always been more to be made through financial work without having to build anything new, so eventually you reach peak time-sharing. I like executives and engineers who are effective enough to prosper without any predatory shenanigans, whether financial or not. That's something I just never developed a taste for.
- 4y ago
- dibt 4y agoAre there other products that were traditionally a one-time purchase that transitioned to subscription model successfully besides software? You can at least make the case that an online service requires an on-going cost.
- everdrive 4y agoI have now been convinced to put the work into keeping my 25 year old truck running.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoI will be contrarian and say that I’m fine with this. Fewer skus is better for efficiency, labor shortage issues, and the environment; if software enabled components enables this, so be it. We don’t get upset when adobe or Apple hides software features behind pay walls, we shouldn’t be surprised if everyone starts doing it.
- sentientslug 4y agoI would argue we do get upset when other companies do this. You wouldn’t want apple to give you a phone with 1TB of storage artificially limited to 256GB unless you pay a subscription fee.
- josephcsible 4y ago> Fewer skus is better for efficiency, labor shortage issues, and the environment Sure, but if it's cheaper to only make the better model, then they should just only sell it as such, rather than making something you own withhold features from you. > We don’t get upset when adobe or Apple hides software features behind pay walls Yes we do. Don't you remember the Pantone Photoshop story from less than a month ago?
- psadri 4y agoNon ICE cars have far lower service needs → lower revenue for dealers → expect to see more subscriptions to offset.
- bluGill 4y agoThat is mostly a myth. The ICE doesn't have regular oil changes, but you still need to rotate the tires at the same intervals. There are a few oil leaks and such that you miss out on, but the shocks will still wear out over time (maybe sooner as EVs tend to be heavier). Odds are the body of the car will wear out before the engine/transmission will need major work. Even ignoring that, by the time the engine needs expensive maintenance it is old and likely to go to an independent mechanic. While there is warranty issues, there will be such with electric motors and their controllers as well.
- vel0city 4y agoOil changes in my ICE are now about $100 almost everywhere I go, other than Walmart which is like $75 (probably more these days, haven't been in years). 6 quarts of synthetic plus an oil filter. Two oil changes a year means $200/yr on oil changes. Not massive, and I agree with the EV cost premium it'll take a lot of oil changes to offset the price of the EV on oil changes alone. However, the ICE is about to need a valve clearance adjustment this year or early next year. It is not that old of a car, but it still supposed to be done every 60,000mi on my car. There's another $300. It should probably also have a coolant flush and a transaxle fluid drain/fill/inspection. Another $400ish in maintenance. This year's ICE-exclusive maintenance budget is now at $900, assuming everything's fine with things like vacuum hoses and fuel lines and what not. It is not guaranteed they're fine; there's a reason why the manual tells you to inspect them every so often. And I imagine most people probably have no idea what they're looking at, so unless they're paying someone to inspect it that work probably isn't being inspected right. If you're only getting oil changes on your car, you're probably not following the OEM maintenance schedule on your car. My EV-only maintenance cost for the life of the car so far? $0. I'll need a gear oil and coolant drain and fill at 130,000mi, but other than that there's nothing scheduled other than things the ICE will need too (tires, suspension, wipers, brakes, etc.)
- ozzythecat 4y ago> As global sales for new cars have fallen in recent years, car manufacturers have pivoted toward selling software updates and features as subscriptions to generate a continuous revenue stream long after a car has been purchased. Are we surprised here? MB’s leadership has one primary goal: satisfying shareholders and the broader market. We’ve been in a race to the bottom for a long time now. Inferior construction, cheap parts, overseas labor (or for the car market, labor in the US, Canada, or Mexico but also because of cost optimization). This is the latest in a long line of cost cutting measures and patterns where the customer ultimately loses. I’m not even mad at Mercedes Benz. They know the game they’re playing, and this is what it takes I suppose. My son in law bought a new C Class a few months ago. He and my daughter were very pleased. Now me, I’m an old goat, and so when I saw a massive iPad on the center console instead of buttons, I’d tell you that car wouldn’t be my first choice. And they had me sit in it and try it out. It is certainly a nice looking interior, but I pressed on the passenger side dashboard area and on the armrest between the front seats. I heard plastic crackling noises. It’s all plastic, even though it looks like some much superior metallic material. It was just some skin/vinyl on top of plastic. How well will it hold? Time will tell, but it goes to show you the generation gap. I think he said he paid upwards of $50k for the car. With all the plastic, I can never see myself paying that much money for a vehicle. But hey, Mercedes Benz has a market for these things, and so it’s reasonable to believe that no matter what I think of the $1,200 subscription, there’s a market for that too.
- coolbreezetft22 4y agoI used to feel the same way as you about large touch screens in cars as the main interface in place of physical tactile buttons but I've come to accept that's just the way it is now and if you're looking to buy a new car it'll be hard to avoid. I think some cars (like bmw) have found decent compromise with physical buttons for frequently accessed things like climate or seat warmers. Don't even get me started on Teslas which is essentially a tablet with a large car-shaped case around it.
- leetcrew 4y agobmw has also removed physical buttons for climate and heated seats in idrive8. it's an unfortunate step backward, but it's also not as bad as people on the internet will tell you.
- whatgoodisaroad 4y agoI'm optimistic about electric cars, but pessimistic when the companies producing them are the most craven financializers like this. Sometimes I wonder if there would be a market for a "maximally analog electric car" where, for example, the accelerator pedal is a potentiometer.
- carlmr 4y ago>"maximally analog electric car" where, for example, the accelerator pedal is a potentiometer. What else do you think is being used for accelerator pedals?
- mysterydip 4y agoI think they're referring to the end result mimicing user input. Right now most cars are "drive by wire" where your pedal input is just one of many factors in the computer's "input by committee" before the final acceleration is sent to the motor controller.
- whatgoodisaroad 4y agoI'm probably referring to the wrong component, yeah, but what I'm imagining is a car with no digital intermediaries between the pedal and the power going through the wheels.
- kube-system 4y agoNobody uses a potentiometer as a throttle pedal because they may fail in any position. 2 or 3 potentiometers are used, and only upon agreement of the signals do they propel the vehicle. That's why the pedal has digital electronics in it, and you don't have some dumb potentiometers wired straight to an ADC input on the ECU.
- fiat_fandango 4y agoYou know, this is why I'll basically never have interest in the cost, anxiety or headache of owning a "nice" car. Paid software features that add basically no value are another reason I continue to not care. Current VW from 2012 is going strong, other than a bit more oil and some paint fixes I haven't had to put much money in. My next car will likely be a Hyundai or Toyota in the "gold" tier suggested for the Comma 3. Props to MB for finding another way to grift rich people and suckers who are financing the car to pretend to be rich!
- andy_ppp 4y agoI think the next question is, forget battery life, how long do I get security updates for and will the newest releases slow down my car’s functionality like a new iOS update…
- kevinventullo 4y agoThe only reason this doesn’t bother me is because I don’t care about faster acceleration. Now if they start charging for Apple CarPlay it’s a different story…
- flandish 4y agoIt’s part of the plan to describe the class divide with the auto market - the rich get new cars and can afford the paywalls, the working class gets used 20+ year old models.
- bluGill 4y agoThe poor have always got old cars though, so what difference does this make?
- kjkjadksj 4y agoImagine having to pay this in 20 years when its a $5000 used mercedes
- midjji 4y agoIts obviously retarded, but I'm not so worried, most cars are gargantuan 10M+balls of decades old C that no one understands, and no one has ever audited or gone through to fix warnings. Almost everything is communicated along joint databuses typically can, which sends everything everywhere by default. They are so ridiculously easy to hack you can do it over wifi or bluetooth it should not have in the first place, but the sound system is no doubt connected to the airbag. However, if you have physical access to the system the opportunities are endless, and for every engineer that tries to fix security issues, you have three like the guy who tried to argue that his fantastic innovation of partial self implemented 16 bit encryption would make the can secure. For these reasons I dont expect a single one of the old car companies to achieve secure code in our lifetime, meaning sure, it will be a little inconvenient, but when was the last time you used a browser without an adblocker.
- ok_dad 4y agoI guess I should buy that old project car I want, it might be my last chance to have a car where I don’t have to drink a can of verification Mountain Dew!
- Matthias247 4y agoActually there's less new to it than it seems like. Even in the past multiple models shared the same engine with minor modifications to offer different performance at different price points. E.g. a C180, C200 and C250 all used the same 1.8l engine. You paid more to get its full potential - and the extra cost was far more than the number of modifications to the base engine. Now it seems like the extra cost just moves from a one-time bump to a subscription model.
- sangnoir 4y agoDevil's advocate: this is market segmentation, similar to Tesla limiting range using a software toggle[1]. Having a a capability engineered into a product but making it unavailable to a subset of consumers in the lower price bucket has a long history. I do not endorse the practice, but there's a tendency to sell things at prices the market will bear, with little basis on unit production cost. I must say, the HN crowd is typically more sanguine about SaaS and the virtues of recurring revenue when the subject is a software company. I'm more of a boxed-software/buy-it-once guy, but that ship seems to have sailed. 1. I became aware of this when Tesla temporarily unlocked additional range for Florida residents so they could flee a hurricane
- UltraViolence 4y agoMost people fail to see that BEV's will eventually be much cheaper than ICE cars. This in turn will mean a huge drop in revenue and profits for car companies. They know this and are therefore (trying) to switch over to subscription based schemes. Obviously these will all fail. I suspect the Chinese will make dirt cheap BEV's which have very finite lifetimes (in the order of a decade or less) to offset the drop in revenue and for Western car makers to follow suit in making similar junk-cars. Just the other day the Ford CEO exclaimed that a BEV would require 40% labor to make [1]. Think of the savings that would bring! [1]: https://cleantechnica.com/2022/11/16/ford-ceo-40-less-labor-to-build-electric-vehicles/ https://cleantechnica.com/2022/11/16/ford-ceo-40-less-labor-...
- fuzzfactor 4y agoWith a gasoline engine you can always use higher-octane fuel whenever you want, and that full-performance feature being included with the original purchase price is a part of the automotive experience since like forever. Anything less is bound to be despised as an anti-consumer effort.