17 ms·
Voice assistants are not doing it for big tech
- samwillis 4y agoI think it's fairly clear now that the only time a voice based UI is better is when the user is unable to use their hands. Driving or in the kitchen when cooking seem the be the most successful. The are barely any other strong use cases. On top of that the general distrust of the privacy of these systems has stoped a significant number of people (myself included) from wanting to us them at all. I don't have an in home device, and have turned off Siri on my Apple devices.
- dmitriid 4y ago> Driving or in the kitchen when cooking seem the be the most successful. Since the voice assistants are incredibly stupid I find it extremely stressful and distracting to ask them for anything while driving.
- swores 4y agoFiguring out what works well or not while driving isn't a great idea, but using the ones that work well seems fine for most people. Saying "Hey Siri, text Fred <pause> I'm on my way but stuck in traffic, eta 4 o'clock" or something along those lines nearly always works fine for me and is no more distracting than having a conversation with somebody in the car with me. If Siri gets some of the message wrong I'll either send a new one using clearer speech or wait until I'm not driving to fix it if the mistake isn't important. Sure, it would be possible to then allow myself to get distracted by focussing too much on some weird aspect of it, but equally it would be possible to get so emotional in a conversation with somebody sat next to you that you stop paying attention to the road. And we (most people at least) don't say "it's not safe to talk at all while driving", we just make sure not to go over that line of getting too distracted by the conversation.
- dmitriid 4y ago> or something along those lines nearly always works fine for me and is no more distracting than having a conversation with somebody in the car with me. Until you have several Freds in your contact list. Until you have friends with foreign/uncommon names. As long as you have near-perfect American pronunciation. As long as... There are too many variables to consider and think of. Sometimes I can't get Siri to reliably understand what music I want (and my Engilsh is pretty darn good), much less anything more advanced.
- scarface74 4y ago> As long as you have near-perfect American pronunciation. There isn’t a such thing as an American accent. Ask anyone who is not a native speaker and either hasn’t been to US that long and tries to understand my natural deep southern accent. I can adjust my accent if needed and if I think about it.
- simiones 4y agoThere is an accent that is typically called "standard American" or something along those lines, which is what you'll hear on things like national news programs. I'm not sure how many Americans actually speak with this accent, but it's usually the one that all of these devices target initially.
- dmitriid 4y agoYeah, I was thinking along the lines of "General American"/"California English": - General American https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/united-states-of-accents-general-american https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/united-states-of-accents-... - California English https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/the-united-states-of-accents-california-english https://www.babbel.com/en/magazine/the-united-states-of-acce...
- JohnFen 4y agoThe "Standard American" accent is the west coast (mostly California) accent. It is far from universal.
- enobrev 4y agoGoogle (android auto) was significantly better at this early on than it is now. I used to be able to search random topics by voice while driving, and it would read me excerpts and results. I used it often. Now it's map-specific, messaging, or music-specific and nothing else.
- gcanyon 4y agoI disagree: a voice based UI is better IFF: 1. The command set is broad enough or user input is complex enough to make other UIs inefficient. 2. The voice UI is up to the task of correctly interpreting the voice input correctly most of the time What "most of the time" means for the second item is somewhat personal and use-case specific. For item 1, examples where voice is better right now, or could be with reasonable NLU improvements: "Text my wife that I'll be there in five minutes." "Get me driving directions to the nearest Indian restaurant with at least 3 stars on Yelp." "Order six rolls of paper towels and a bottle of Windex from Walmart, delivered to my home address, for delivery by Saturday" "Remind me tomorrow morning to review this web page" "Create a shopping list with the items from this recipe" "Create a basic presentation with one slide each for each entry in the table of contents for this book" Voice can be better. As others have pointed out, as long as it's like playing Zork where half the time the response is "you can't do that" or "I don't understand", voice interfaces will continue to flounder.
- goosedragons 4y agoI don't think that's true. It's way faster for things like smart lights and playing music. The problem is it's still so limited for other things. For example I can tell Alexa to play The Simpsons on Fire TV, it will do so on Disney+ but always the first episode even though the last watched one was in Season 15. It also can't seem to find my purchased episodes from iTunes (watchable with the Apple TV app on Fire TV). Simple searches also have a high chance of being misunderstood still with poor results. I think if the accuracy was better and more content/things were available through voice it would be a pretty good input method for any scenario where you don't need visual feedback.
- samwillis 4y agoSelecting content via voice only works when you can either name exactly the content you want, or you are choosing a general category to play. Browsing content, or looking it up, via voice is slow and playful, it always will be. Who what's to be saying "next", "scroll down", or have a full on conversation with an AI to try and work out what you want to play? Our fingers on our hands have evolved to be incredible at interacting with things, we are good at using them. Touch screens or physical UIs will never be superseded by voice. So yes, there is a small use case for voice for controlling music/tv, or controlling a few things in the home (heating, blinds, lights) but thats it, I don't believe there is this massive opportunity to expand it into our everyday lives where we are constantly interacting with devices via voice.
- goosedragons 4y agoYou don't need to name content exactly. Saying "Alexa, play the sandwich song from Frozen" for example will correctly play Love is an Open Door. Ideally this kind of thing would work for TV and movies too, web searches as well. Humans evolved language to communicate ideas, wants and desires to others for thousands of years. Obviously voice UI is not there now but maybe someday the experience won't be much different than asking the movie rental store clerk for their recommendations for a romantic comedy.
- samwillis 4y ago
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago>the only time a voice based UI is better is when the user is unable to use their hands. Driving my observation of people on the road has led me to conclude that Driving is an activity where people think they can do absolutely anything else while engaged in it.
- bluGill 4y agoWhen you put it like that you will get a lot of upvotes. However for almost all specifics you will get a ton of downvotes when you name them, and probably someone saying no that is okay. (these days if you say "you can't drink alcohol while driving" you are safe, 30 years ago if there had been an internet people would have said you are wrong)
- bryanrasmussen 4y agothings I've seen I think are probably not ok. 1. sending messages on phone while driving, one hand on steering wheel. 2. having sex / receiving oral sex. 3. turned around, yelling at kid in back seat to not fight with other kid in back seat. 4. girlfriend having argument with boyfriend, slapping him on arm some, about how she was smart too just a different kind of smart while swerving back and forth in fast merging traffic near the Haight (I was in back seat) 5. it's getting hot in here, time to take my jacket off! your mileage may vary of course.
- fxtentacle 4y agoFully agree on the privacy distrust. BTW, another use case for speech recognition is when you're carrying a baby around.
- newaccount74 4y agoI've gotten pretty good at doing chores one handed...
- maweki 4y agoI'd say my baby preferred me playing around with my phone than speaking up. Doubly so when they were carried around sleeping.
- kevsim 4y agoTotally agree. "Hey Siri, start a timer for X minutes" and "Hey Siri, play Y on Spotify" are the entire extent of my voice assistant interactions.
- aflag 4y agoAnd I’m always annoyed that it doesn’t tell me how long I set each timer to when I have multiple timers, just the remaining time, which makes it hard for me to know which is which.
- cmckn 4y agoIt’s not encouraging that even the most common use cases for these systems still have rough edges. The Google ones do support named timers, so you can say “start a pasta timer” and later ask “what’s left on my pasta timer” etc. I thought Siri added this at some point, but I wouldn’t be surprised if not.
- sbuk 4y agoIt does. "Hey Siri, set a timer for 45 minutes called pasta bake", "Hey Siri, how long left on pasta bake?" works.
- aflag 4y agoActually, it seems that google is now able to cope with things a bit better. I've just tried and I can now ask for "how long left on my 45-minute timer?" and it does finally answer. It actually also shows up in the UI. That is sort of recent, though, as I've had that problem earlier this year. It seems that siri is now unable to set multiple timers, though. Anyway, it does seem to have improved, but I wonder why that stuff wasn't in from day one. It seems pretty obvious to me.
- sbuk 4y agoNope, Siri can also do multiple timers. It asks for an name if an unnamed timer of the same length already exists.
- red_Seashell_32 4y agoOr in countries where we get snow during Autumn. Getting messages read-out loud, and responding with voice-to-speech is great too
- algesten 4y agoAnd then it typically interacts and fails without feedback. I've tried so many times to tell Siri "Send a message to x that I'm 10 mins away", only to realize much later that "message delivery failed". No clear feedback, a weird timing issues where it just stalls and show the message it' about to send in case it got it wrong. It's just a terrible UX all around.
- causi 4y agoI've had to stop using Google Assistant to send messages. It used to ask the user to choose the correct word when it misheard something. Now it just makes a wild-ass guess and sends it on. It's caused me to send some very odd messages to people and/or look like an idiot.
- thiht 4y ago> Driving Siri never triggers when I'm driving, it just doesn't hear me. I think it's because of the noise of the car or because of my music, but it doesn't work. I have to move my face closer to my phone so that it can hear me, but that's even more dangerous than using the controls. Same when I'm in the shower and I ask it to change the music, it doesn't hear me, I have to shout and get angry every time.
- balfirevic 4y agoIs your phone mounted close to the air vent? Siri hears me perfectly in my car, even when the phone is in my pocket but it doesn't hear me at all when I mount the phone on the air vent.
- thiht 4y agoYes, it is. Maybe it doesn't hear me because of that. For what it's worth, it doesn't work either when it's my pocket. When I come home and ask it to turn the lights on, it doesn't answer if it's not in my hand.
- Tagbert 4y agoYou might try blowing the microphone holes with a can of air. It may be clogged with pocket lint.
- balfirevic 4y agoThat might be a separate issue - you have to specifically enable a setting which will make the phone listen for Hey Siri when it's face down (or in the pocket). See here: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/iphone/iphaff1d606/ios#iph4a9e2c917 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/iphone/iphaff1d606/ios...
- college_physics 4y ago> when the user is unable to use their hands this is still potentially a huge domain. one could imagine a benign scenario where voice assistants enhance people's abilities to interact with each other (and digital devices) when a more potent UI is not within reach privacy concerns (->controversial business models) and technical ability to deliver a desirable service (that people would pay for) might indeed prevent this vision from catching on in the short term another factor that may complicate adoption might be just cultural / perceptions. It is a somewhat odd thing to be shouting at devices - especially in the presence of other people. User interfaces that interfere strongly with communication habits and behaviors established over millennia (see also wearing VR goggles) might have a harder time seeing adoption outside very specific scenarios
- wintermutestwin 4y ago>Driving While driving, I wanted to have Siri read a lengthy webpage to me. I pulled up the page, got in the car and asked Siri to "speak screen." Siri says it can't do that when I am driving! What idiot thought that was a necessary safety measure? What if I were the passenger? Overall, I am stunned at how bad Siri is at things that don't even require AI. It's almost as if this insanely profitable company failed to invest a tiny bit of money into researching ways that people would like to use Siri.
- JCharante 4y ago> What if I were the passenger? I often go places with my sister (she drives). Her car doesn't allow pairing or swapping bluetooth connections to the car's entertainment system while it's moving. If we want to switch to my phone we have to come to a complete stop.
- genocidicbunny 4y agoEven while driving, it's useless past basic commands. My most egregious example of this for me is that there's a grocery store near me that the Google assistant is incapable of finding because of a few people in my contacts list. Whenever I try to ask it for directions to that store, it picks (at pretty much random) one of three of my contacts instead. This is despite the only common part of said contacts' names and the grocery store is that their names all start with the same letter. Basically, imagine asking for directions to Albertsons, and the assistant giving you directions to Andrew.
- Semaphor 4y agoI think Amazon is one of the worst platforms possible for voice shopping. For something that can barely understand what you want, you want a small store, that doesn’t have multiple products or sellers per type. I could imagine using voice ordering at my low-carb store, when I ask for "white almond flour", there will be exactly one product they can deliver. At Amazon? I might as well order from AliExpress, it’s a marketplace, you need human-level intelligence to order something, not a robot that can’t even figure out what band to play if there are 2 similar-ish sounding ones.
- gw98 4y agoIt's useful for trivial unambiguous tasks where you have your hands full or don't want to touch your device or it's dangerous to. That's all I can muster mine for. "Hey Siri, add more toilet paper to the shopping list" (while pooping) "Hey Siri, shuffle my music" (while driving) "Hey Siri, countdown 10 minutes" (while shoving a pizza in the oven) Anything else is a shit show. Anything where trust or accuracy is involved i.e. mutating data, spending money, absolutely no way can I trust it at all and never will.
- jayelbe 4y agoMmhmm, I never handle my phone while pooping, no siree.
- Shank 4y ago> "Hey Siri, add more toilet paper to the shopping list" (while pooping) This is the main reason why I have an Echo in my bathroom! The one advantage Alexa has over everything else is that you can voice shop -- "alexa buy more toilet paper" solves the problem that much faster than a reminder for later.
- gw98 4y agoI don't want that to happen because the price variation in toilet paper is huge based on deals and offers available, and Amazon is rarely the cheapest provider these days, so it's actually worth me spending a few minutes on it to save some money. The reason Alexa exists is to sell you Amazon's prices, not necessarily a good deal.
- aflag 4y agoAlso, I think I'd rather just add stuff to my shopping list so that I can at a later time order everything together, rather than have multiple deliveries.
- ghaff 4y agoThe sort of consumables I might order on Amazon on a regular basis--like those that the Amazon Dash buttons were intended to address--can vary a fair bit in price and quantity. I'm not going to have Amazon just ship whatever. And it's not even a very frequent thing. Mostly, every few months, I look through what consumables need replenishing and I fill up the car with plus-size packages from Walmart.
- Shank 4y agoVoice assistants are basically just mainstream non-visual command-lines, and it's unsurprising to me that something that relies heavily on memorization and extremely specialized "skills" isn't quite taking off in the way it was imagined. A voice system that can do literally everything one can do with a keyboard and a mouse would be magical, but no system offers that. Instead, it's a guessing game about syntax and semantics, and frequently a source of frustration. There are many failure points: it can "hear" you wrong, it can miss the wake word, it can hear correctly but interpret wrong, miss context clues, or simply be unable to process whatever the request is. In my experience, most normal people either relegate voice commands to ultra-specific tasks, like timers, weather, and music, and that's that. Google and Alexa are relatively good at "trivia" questions, but Siri is a complete failure. All systems have edge cases that make them brittle. I think there's potential here. Cortana was the most promising: an assistant that's integrated into the OS and can change any setting or perform anything on-screen would, again, be really awesome. We just don't have that. I think maybe OS-wide + GPT 4 (or later) might get closer to what we expect, but it's just not great right now. I really want to be able to say something as unstructured as "hey siri, create alarms every 5 minutes starting at 6am tomorrow" or "hey siri, when I get home every day, turn on all of the lights, change my focus to personal, and turn on the news". There /is/ power to-be-had, but nobody has really tapped it.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoYeah, the whole idea has a lot of potential that seems like it should be within reach, but somehow it's 2022 and my phone still can't handle "hey Google, play my driving playlist on Spotify."
- antupis 4y agoIf I would be in this space I would just build voice assistant to very specific situations where you cannot type like driving, cooking, doing some sport etc. There is lots of potential but big players are kinda trying build generic tool for every situation which is super hard problem.
- dmitriid 4y ago
- derN3rd 4y agoI personally use Alexa for some light control as well as smart blinds I have installed. Sometimes some basic questions ("What is XY?") and besides that nothing more. The amount of wrong answers or just telling me something it has found on the web, which has nothing today with the topic is just annoying. Even basic questions seem to not work reliably and looking at the whole Alexa ecosystem it doesn't even feel close to "smart" home. Lack of context awareness, connection to basic things like parcel delivery, washing machine and similar that would make my life a little easier (because I'm to lazy to open an app to look when my parcels will arrive or when the washing machine will finish) just ruin the whole thing for me. Besides that, I've tried setting the male voice, but for some responses it just switches back to female Alexa??
- nunodonato 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33662020 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33662020
- thrwawy74 4y agoWhat annoys me the most is this: "Hey Google, turn off the den light switch in 30 minutes" "Sorry, for safety reasons we cannot...." It's a light. Because it heard "switch" it thinks there might be some power tool connected to it and won't let me set delayed actions. I want to be intelligent with it like "Hey Google, turn turn the lights on when the sun comes up everday" but no one has gone to that next step. Or how about "Hey Google, turn off the tone played when you say Hey Google". These settings aren't accessible from the voice interface itself. Can't wait for Alexa to fail so my SmartTV will stop nagging me to use integrations I will never use. Anti-competitive but whatevs.
- thethethethe 4y agoYou can change the device type in Google home to work around the scheduling issue
- twelvedogs 4y agosome of the stuff google don't put effort into is super weird, like the whole if the device is in a different "room" it has to loudly announce what it's doing but if it's in the same room it turns down the volume on all of the devices for 10 seconds really makes me think they almost want to discontinue it but it's so integrated with android and the chromecast they can't really kill it
- joncrocks 4y agoI think you can set 'routines' now, might be able to help with sunrise actions - https://support.google.com/assistant/answer/7672035?hl=en-GB&co=GENIE.Platform%3DAndroid#zippy=%2Cways-to-start-a-routine https://support.google.com/assistant/answer/7672035?hl=en-GB...
- thrwawy74 4y agoI have explored those, but I ran into many many issues when i wanted to build routines of routines. I wanted to compose a routine from others. I couldn't simply/directly invoke a routine from others without voice interpretation, and it led to strangely phrased triggers just to get it to work. It's frustrating that I should be able to make these explicit actions in the app, but it's just very clumsy. In the ideal scenario I should be able to configure all of that through the voice interface itself. "Hey Google, create a routine that initiates from "It's dinner time" that turns on all the lights in the dining room and sets them to 50% with the 'candlelight' color" I hate how many products need to be configured from apps nowadays. You gave me the voice assistant and I can't use the voice assistant to manage the voice assistant. I shouldn't even need an iPad or phone to set it up. Give me a minimum local processing/interpretation so I can get it online and it can begin interpreting more articulate requests. We are so far away from zen.
- imdsm 4y agoAs Shank said, there needs to be a GPT element to voice assistants. At the moment, Alexa is a voice interface, but is "dumb" essentially, there's no understanding, intonation, memory, etc. A voice assistant that would would be a fully fledged AI that grows over time, as with most Sci Fi smart houses. I think it's possible — that we'll receive units that have base AIs that then grow with time, but we're not there yet, not close. The current problem with GPT-like AIs is that you can't trust what they're going to say. They're interesting, useful, but there still lacks that feeling that it's anything except mathematical probability based auto-completion.
- nailer 4y agoI use Alexa on a house filled with Sonos speakers every day. She barely works and is the worst advertisement for Amazon. "Alexa turn on my FireTV" (doesn't work, weirdly FireTV and Alexa speakers don't seem to get along) "Alexa play The Killers" (responds with "Playing the killers on Spotify" then silence) "Alexa play The Killers on Spotify" (works) "Alexa play The Killers" (sometimes tells me to start scanning devices and install a skill for Sonos) "Alexa wikipedia 'history of Bulgaria'" (works but asks me if I want to continue after every sentence, so I give up) "Alexa stop" (doesn't stop for some apps, Amazon should have support for silencing as a minimum requirement for apps and implement worst-case scenarios if an app doesn't respond to stop in time) "Alexa rewind 30 seconds" (doesn't rewind for some apps, Amazon should have support for rewinding played recordings as a minimum requirement for apps)
- andrewstuart 4y agoThey managed to control the tech so tightly that no potential is fulfilled and they’re boring. Truly opened to developers they could have been really interesting and fun. This is what happens when big companies develop technologies and think they are too valuable to share.
- lixtra 4y agoThis also pissed me off. Why not start the day with a weather report, short news and some trivia. When I checked long time ago I didn’t find any way to integrate stuff like that together.
- laidoffamazon 4y agoIt's possible to do that with a morning routine in Alexa. I know this because it tells me the weather (and other things) after I kill my alarm in the morning.
- stirlo 4y agoIf you check again now this is a out of the box feature on Google Assistant. You just say “good morning” and it tells you the time, weather, news, and more.
- aaron695 4y ago
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoIt reminds me of the chatbot fever there was a few years back, it seems like every company wanted a chatbot. Even though as a user I much prefer a normal menu. I think voice assistants will continue to have good use cases in cars, kitchens etc. where you can't use your hands so the trade-off is worthwhile.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoNot surprising. What we were promised: a personal well-trained butler. What we got: a voice input field that you know will be incorrectly interpreting your intents far too often.
- anon20221123 4y agoVoice assistants are the most useful new UI to me since smartphones. I use them to get travel time estimates, reference facts, music and podcasts, rewind / forward / pause / resume / next / previous, timers, lights, and occasionally broadcast messages on home speaker devices. I use voice UI while cooking, running, mowing, raking, driving, changing diapers, putting on my kids' clothes, and while sitting with my wife. My two young children (5 and almost 2) love voice UI. We ask about the animal of the day, what does this animal sound like, play that song. My older child is beginning to set timers with it. My wife recently said having a nearby voice assistant is important in a home configuration discussion. My family and I sometimes have frustrating experiences with voice UI, like failed hotwords, shifting syntax, answering on an unexpected device, and slow responses. But we still use it frequently, and our overall sentiment with voice UI is positive.
- bambax 4y agoIt's quite funny that none of the things you mention involve shopping, or any activity that would bring revenue to the voice assistant provider.
- anon20221123 4y agoVoice UI could be a decisive feature for profitable equipment, or generate advertising revenue. Because it lacks VUI, my family recently didn't buy a new ~$400 product. We bought an older version that was marked-down and otherwise inferior, but has built-in voice assistant.
- ageitgey 4y agoThey still just don't work very well unless you memorize very specific exact commands. The other day, we had to remember to book a school thing for the kid. I said "Hey Google, set a reminder for 9pm to [book the thing]". Google replied "Here are web search results for set a reminder...." When they fail constantly at the most basic tasks, usage is going to drop way off.
- hengheng 4y agoThey also refuse to ever show a reference so that you can learn what you can say, or teach you any other way. Refusing to show and teach your users feels arrogant to me. They had to promise that you can "just speak naturally" and now they can't roll it back. Meanwhile my success rate for the way I speak is below 20%.
- willhinsa 4y agothey do chime in and tell you all sorts of things "by the way, i can also play music while you're getting ready for bed" while i'm trying to concentrate and live my life lol. just compile a list of all commands into an email and send that to me. i don't actually want to hear you talk, siri
- shellfishgene 4y agoI've had Google home for quite a while now, and, apparently like everyone else, I only really use it to start and stop music, as a kitchen timer, and to make animal noises when kids are visiting. There was no obvious improvement over the years. However with GPT3, DALL-E and all the other amazing stuff coming out I had just assumed Google/Amazon must be working on a big update that really makes Assistant/Alexa 10 fold better. Is this hope in vain?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anothernewdude 4y agoI'd be full on board for a voice assistant, but I control the server and the traffic, so Amazon is a non-starter.
- draugadrotten 4y agoTry https://mycroft.ai/ https://mycroft.ai/
- rndmio 4y agoConversational interfaces just aren't any good, and until they're perfect they won't be useful. The primary issue I've seen (having worked with slack bots) is discoverability, how do you find out what a bot can do without asking lots of open questions? The most useful bots I saw were those that didn't try to be conservsational but had a fixed grammar for commands and questions (along with a good help response). And at least with chatbots you've got the textual context you can scroll back on and read as opposed to trying to keep track of what's happening in a conversation with a non human who you can't see.
- ggm 4y agoVoice assistants are shit. The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero. And, they don't really explain the syntax constraints. Which are massive. Try ab initio without knowing how to do it, to get OK google to open an arbitrary google authored app and direct it to do something. Compared to learning how to use the OS UI keyboard shortcuts or applescript. (Which btw like Windows is basically fully documented because all the libraries are self documenting for their call structures) The voice interfaces are universally badly designed because spoken command sentences are not well understood as a modality of command, distinct from mouse, gesture, touch or keyboard. Until voice is baked in with a documented syntax in "man" format, i won't believe its first class. How do I even know for any arbitrary app what voice directives it uses? How do they correlate to any other command input? How consistent is this with other commands in other apps? Does "stop now" always mean the same thing between a mapping routing app, and a tape backup app? Isn't "stop" contextually defined in a way ^C isn't?
- dmitriid 4y ago> The number of times my friends have got alexa to turn the light on first time is functionally zero. I have a room called "Study" and the only lights there are called "Main Lights". - Hey, Siri, study lights 100% - Did you mean these lights: "Study: Main Lights" :facepalm:
- ggm 4y agoYea, a single member set shouldn't require full enumeration, it's detectably the only operating device in context. If it was the only "main light" across all rooms I'd hesitate to say the same mind you, nesting scopes should be respected. What would you want it to do when you add a second light bulb? Tell you the old command is no longer unique or turn on both?
- dmitriid 4y ago> What would you want it to do when you add a second light bulb? Tell you the old command is no longer unique or turn on both? I think when the command is generic "lights" it should turn on all lights. But both are valid behaviours.
- wiradikusuma 4y ago"consumers were just as happy to sit down and click away until they had the basket they wanted" — same reason why although many people hate lifting their butt to go shopping, some would happily do. Nobody likes checkout lines though, that's universal.
- licebmi__at__ 4y agoAt least for my family, the voice recognition seems to be getting worse and worse with each update. Nowadays google doesn’t seem to turn off the alarms or the music after several tries so my son just comes and unplugs it (touch controls are also a fucking mystery), my wife tries to make her phone ring so many times she can find without help in the meantime. Alexa doesn’t understand what I try to order and it’s easier to just find my phone and type it. I thought that somehow the devices were just having physical issues with time, but even a new one has the same problems. So far it seems like I would get a better experience by rolling my own stuff and training it with our specific voices.
- jleyank 4y agoAdmittedly I only skimmed the comments but “how will they make money from it?” wasn’t acknowledged. Hell of a lot of effort to build up an inference engine for natural language processing and they’re going to want to profit from it. Unless, as some have noted, surveillance will be their funding.
- 2sk21 4y agoDespite the tremendous amount of effort that's gone into creating large language models, there is still no way to hold a goal-directed conversation with voice assistants. There is a lot of implicit context in normal human speech that needs to be inferred or clarified. None of these speech assistants can do handle anything more than the most rudimentary clarification dialog.
- kybernetyk 4y agoVoice assistants are infuriating. Every day I feel like Siri and Alexa would understand less and becoming worse.
- taviso 4y agoI got into the habit of asking things like "what is the weather like today" every morning before work, it worked fine for months and I quite liked it - while I'm occupied with something else it can give me some useful information. Then one day it started giving me the dictionary definition of the word "weather". That continued for over a week, so I just lost the habit and don't think I've really used it since.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoMy hot take is this is the start of vastly (better/worse) surveillance- that can be a force for good or bad. Let's start with business meetings - the tech is close enough to be able to record, transcribe and summarise all decisions and action points - which sounds great and may get put into place. Then it can assess how well a manager was "coaching" the meeting - getting appropriate feedback from all participants - then were all necessary participants there ? Then we can see training sessions geared specifically towards manager A and their problem in encouraging positive performance from their team with vague goals. Wouldn't we all like better managers with clearer goals? Roll this out to a doctors bedside manner, or the mistaken command given to a nurse that was a perhaps misheard and the wrong medicine given or ... We can surveil all our waking lives - and almost the only thing social sciences get right is large population statistics- we can find out who leads happiest best lives and be taught how to do it better. Or we can stomp out individuality and live on a totalitarian nightmare. But we don't get to not play the game
- antirez 4y agoIt's not the technology. Voice transcription works great, and from the point of view of extracting meaning, even pattern matching would do better than the embarassing failure of today's voice assistants. It's a matter of product. We are living in an IT world where there are no great people able to turn the technological potential into useful things.
- ggerganov 4y agoI agree, but I think things will likely change soon. The main thing holding progress in this field seems to be privacy issues and sending data to the cloud. However, we already have human-level voice transcription that you can run on a low-to-moderate hardware at home, so all it takes is for the average developer to be able to run GPT-like LLMs on their machine. At this point I think the quality will improve really fast.
- meindnoch 4y agoSpeaking to a voice assistant is like speaking to a toddler. They have limited vocabulary, limited comprehension and limited ability to perform what you’ve asked them. The only difference is that a toddler stops being a toddler after a year or so, while voice assistants stay perpetually dumb.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lvl102 4y agoI think it has to do with privacy and the limitations on training data. Or am I being naive?
- backtoyoujim 4y agoi don't want my voice assistant to be a sock puppet for a corporate identity proctologist. can you imagine hiring a production assistant that gave everything you asked them to do to a corporate competitor ? Why would I want to do that with my life and Amazon and Apple ?
- eschneider 4y agoI find Siri mostly useful for things like taking messages and playing music when my hands and eyes are occupied with other things, but as many people have pointed out, figuring out what exactly one has to say to get Siri to do it's thing is often hard, even when you realize you've got a parsing problem. I mean, ever try to get Siri to play a song by "Them"? Unpossible by band name. :/ What I wouldn't do for a manual or keyword guide...
- stephc_int13 4y agoThe harsh reality is that the AI powering those assistants is simply not smart enough to converse with. Using voice to send commands to a machine is not practical or pleasant for everyone. This should not be a surprise and it could have been easily predicted, but hype and FOMO pushed big companies to sink billions into this tech. This is not the first time, and it will happen again, especially because anything touching AI leads to highly inflated/magical expectations.
- pmontra 4y agoI'm really not surprised. Some sample items I bought in the last months in order of difficulty both for me and (I think) for a voice assistant: 1. Hey Alexa/Google/Whatever, buy me a saddle, Selle Italia SMP Extra, white. I expect to get a proposal for the best price + shipment and that's it. Easy. 2. Buy me a replacement head for my Parktool pump. Oops, it's a PFP-3 pump. Ah, the shop selling the saddle doesn't have one... I eventually discovered that that shop has an identical part for a pump of a different brand, probably the same Chinese manufacturer. I think this would be hard for an assistant, borderline to impossible. 3. Buy me a magnetic mosquito screen of at least X x Y cm, not adhesive or velcro. Oops, I need a frame to mount it on? I spare you with the discoveries I made along the process. Either the voice assistant is equivalent to a professional installer and can see my door or I'll always do a search with a browser, and watch many videos too.
- tinus_hn 4y agoPerhaps it would be a useful experiment to pick a representative group, couple them to real human assistants with complete control to complete requests and collect all the requests that are made.
- robg 4y agoLove the utility, but there’s clearly little business value. Great example where “making something people want” doesn’t alone support the bottomline.
- OtomotO 4y agoI use voice assistants for one task: Setting a timer. The oven is in another area of the house, so when I come back to squeeze in some work, I often just said "Voice Assistant, set a timer for 10 minutes!" And that's about it. Apart from that I worked on some chat-bots in the past and it's the very same thing to me, just even a bit worse because of audio. Natural language processing simply isn't there AND there is just a few very niche use cases in my eyes. So if they go away again, I won't cry or rather my tears will dry fast.
- jhoelzel 4y agoI think, or at least for me, one of the major frustration points with voice ai is how dumb it has been for the last two decades. When you tell a mercedes navigate me to "exact road and adress" it barely gets half of it right. and usually that just the number. Now i don't have a speech impairement and have tried in 3 languages, none of them work to my sophistication. The worst thing though, personally, is all the shitty patents around voice activation keywords. It's disgusting. Finally i am also an IOT guy with a lot of toys, and i would have written my own personal assistant if it would not be for the patents. After all the hardware is surprisingly cheap. All the problems are solved too. but if you believe i would write free code for megacorp amazon without pay, you might be heavily mistaken.
- craigmcnamara 4y agoNo matter how free they make it to use, I just do not want a robot listening to me all time.
- twstdzppr 4y agoMuahahaha, there's no escape! Maybe dial down the paranoia. It's a bit unhealthy.
- butterNaN 4y agoWhat are some privacy respecting voice assistants?
- exabrial 4y agoVoice assistants are useless tech that has been shoved down the users throat to attempt to gain adoption. Google attempted to hold me hostage to this with android auto. Previously: voice recognition worked just fine. At some point they decided to integrate their stupid voice assistant, which probably was the same back end anyway… but now it required all sorts of permissions (like web and search history) just to do basic things like send a text message. Lost yet another another use to ios.
- scotty79 4y agoNo wonder it's not doing great. There's zero progress in this sphere. Google Assistant if anything, feels worse today than many years ago.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jfoster 4y agoThey're half-baked and I sense consumers starting to lose interest. Third party developers have to do a big deal with Amazon to have a "skill", rather than having an open marketplace where consumers can choose what their device will do? The devices don't really cover all the things consumers might want from them. Years ago, I had assumed Google or Amazon would launch a marketplace akin to Google Play and whoever got there first would be the category winner. Instead, the category became a race to the bottom. Big tech cynically chasing the big deals rather than opening up the platforms.
- omega3 4y ago"Someone has to say it:" It's weird that they are pretending to do some cutting edge/against-the-grain journalism/research in this article.
- kozikow 4y agoI have voice assistant for a few years (Google Home). I tried to use it for many things, but in the end I settled only for playing music, setting alarm, find my phone, what's the time, and "what sound does a monkey make" when I am holding a baby.
- harshaw 4y agoThere is a monetization path, but not likely easy like selling direct to consumers. As others have commented - voice (and google glass!!) are useful when you don't have hands. For example, a dentist frequently needs to look at the computer screen or have the computer screen change a display while they are in the chair working on a patient. Making a command via voice seems useful (change to the next screen, etc) and/or also potentially showing some data in a heads up display. Another vertical could be hospital - being able to use a generic voice UI to turn on the lights and summon help seems useful. Is the monetization path hard - yes. Trying to break into specific industries takes a ton of work. Additionally - you already have staff in these cases. Would a dentist get rid of her assistant for some voice commands? not likely. A hospital still needs nurses.
- OtomotO 4y agoI feel like voice assistants sound super awesome in theory and a lot of nerds, me included,first think about "Computer, replicate me some Wiener Schnitzel", but reality is really something completely different, even when ignoring the replication part.
- headsoup 4y agoPerhaps what value they're getting out of voice services is not what you think it is. Data, training, pattern recognition, language.
- Sakos 4y agoBut then you have news articles talking about how Alexa lost $10 billion and I'm wondering if these companies even know what they're getting out of it.
- zmmmmm 4y agoI find it perplexing that voice assistants actually seem worse at basic functions than they were ten years ago. I remember being amazed how well it could interpret requests to set reminders with flexible language options. Now google gets it wrong so often I've nearly stopped using it.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoI don't like the centralized nature of them. If I could download it and run it on a private server in the basement, without any ties to the cloud, and with my own settings for privacy, then I'd be more willing to use the things.
- sramsay 4y agoThis is exactly how I feel. On the one hand, this technology seems completely miraculous (I remember watching Star Trek TNG back in the day and thinking the "computer" was about the coolest thing imaginable). Now it's here, it works amazing well (considering what it's doing), and . . . I'm talking to Apple, Google, and Amazon? No thanks . . .
- encryptluks2 4y agoSame. I actually really enjoy using it for basic functions but I am too concerned about privacy to use one for anything more advanced. I don't know if I would ever trust a Siri or Alexa or Google Assistant even if they claimed to work offline because all providers have had a terrible track record. If the Linux Foundation or reputable open source project had a solid open source solution that promised to work 80% as well and had a fairly straightforward installer, then I'd be more apt to interact with it regularly. One other issue I've found with Alexa and others is their integration with proprietary lock-in ecosystems for calendars, reminders, lists, etc. Ideally with an open source solution you could do things like set a write only calendar that uses your CalDav calendar and CardDav for contacts, or some non-invasive solution for messaging and calling.
- troyvit 4y agoMycroft.ai has some of what you need. They still host some functionality but it's on their road map to make their voice assistant offline capable.
- yashg 4y agoI own a 3rd gen Echo Dot. I am not sure where it is right now. It needs to be plugged in, so useless as a portable speaker. I don't control anything via voice in my home. The only time I use voice commands is while driving to tell my phone to play some specific song or call someone. I have a few smart lights in my home and I always find it much quicker to change color etc by using the app since the phone is always within reach than call out a voice command.
- cik 4y agoI've been using these ever since they came out. I've tried.. enough of them, including the open source, self hosted things. I have a tonne of them all over the place, and after almost 8 years of this, here are all of my use cases. To be clear, I just don't get why people care: 1. Play me music or a podcast (this fails a shockingly high amount) 2. Call person X 3. Covert unit to unit 4. Turn devices on or off 5. Timer set 6. Reminder set 7. What time does Shabbat (my Sabbath) start. All of the above can be done with my phone, so there's really no point in them - for me.
- deafpolygon 4y agoComputer, earl grey, hot.
- Crosseye_Jack 4y agoMy issue with trying to use voice assistants to purchase items for me is that I’ve found the experience not that great when doing so and had to resort to using my phone/computer anyway, so it wasn’t really worth it for something other than adding an item to my cart as a reminder that I wanted to purchase that item when I wasn’t at my desk. For me, the utility I get out of my echos are home automation control to control heating, lighting, audio when my hands are full or their control are out of reach. But you are never going to make a fortune out of house voice control when you sell the voice assistants at or near cost (don’t think I’ve ever paid full price of any of my Echo’s, and I tell people considering getting on to wait till they go on sale as Amazon always seem to be offering a deal/discount on them every few weeks. But what does frustrate me if that Amazon don’t seem to uniformly “monetise” things across the Alexa platform, for example when I found out about the Samuel Jackson voice for Alexa I wanted to buy it even if it was just a novelty, but it’s not available in the U.K.
- DevX101 4y agoA lot of the more useful information retrieval tasks involve a feedback loop. If I’m shopping for a product, I may enter a generic term. Then the system sends me images of products matching that term. Then I tell the system which product image is closest to what I want. Then the system sends me reviews of that product. Then I read the reviews and realize this is not what I actually want…repeat until I’m satisfied. I can’t do this loop with modern voice assistants. A voice assistant with contextual conversation skills, and access to an “always on” visual monitor (home projector or AR glasses) would definitely increase utility by 10x or more
- vintermann 4y agoThat's right, they're doing it for big surveillance. Though, as much as these services are apparently bleeding, the in-kind payments from big surveillance had really be worth it.
- jacooper 4y agoGood, I hate these spyware devices.
- albertzeyer 4y agoFollowing the argument that the biggest problem is natural language understanding, I wonder what happens when you put in some GPT3-like model, give it all relevant context like past conversations, other user information, etc. That should be much more capable in understanding what the user wants than current systems. There are obviously still many open research questions. Like how this is then combined with actually performing the commands. But there are also solutions to this. This is still somewhat open active research. But given such powerful models, I think in principle we could make such devices much more useful.
- inferense 4y agoThe reason for voice assistants not taking off is quite simple imo. You don't know what it's capabilities are beyond the well known use cases ("set up a timer for 15min") but are well aware of that it's not going to understand everything. It's limitations are obscure and you've been misunderstood in the past, why waste more time. Compared to a human who understands everything you say, you have the full confidence of using voice.
- iandanforth 4y agoThe only thing missing from the experience is occasionally being eaten by a grue.
- nkrisc 4y agoI wrote off Siri when I was driving and said “play episode 6 of XYZ podcast” and was completely incapable. If it can’t do something like that, then what’s the point? It’s no different than those hands-free Bluetooth adapters for your car that my dad uses for his old android phone. There are many other seemingly simple tasks it has failed at. All I use it for now is sending texts and turning in navigation when I’m driving.
- aflag 4y agoThe main issue for me is that they are not stateful. Perhaps the main thing in the role of an assistant is to keep state. You want someone or something that understands you and what you want, so that you don't have to put too much thought into it. If you tell it you want more coffee, it should know what you like and suggest a mixture of brands you bought before and new ones you may enjoy. If you tell it you're hungry, depending on the time of day it could suggest you some takeaway you've ordered previously or something else you may like. If you say the same some other time it may suggest recipes based on what you have at home or it may suggest nearby restaurants. It should keep track of your friends and otherwise and tell you when their birthdays are coming and it would be nice if it could even suggest some presents based on things you've told the assistant before, or their wishlist on amazon or something else. There are a lot of things assistants could do, but it needs to know you. The model where everyone has the same assistant doesn't quite work out.
- somehnacct3757 4y agoComplicating the situation is that I don't trust any of the companies making virtual assistants with this level of personal data; so the first thing I do on a new device is block the assistant's access to my location or any other behavior learning functionalities.
- rubyfan 4y agoI believe tech companies are aware of the creepiness factor associated with surprising customers with too much context about them. I think they cripple some of the more context aware features that they could be doing because it draws a lot of attention on just how much data they have about you.
- aflag 4y agoThat could maybe be gradually introduced like that story about the frog which doesn't feel the water getting warm. What put people off is having it knowing everything up ahead through inference on data you were not even aware you had shared. Instead, you could go easy, by first suggestint the user to set up your assistant by linking it to amazon, deliveroo/uber eats/etc, facebook, and verbally sharing information as it asks. Then, over time, it could spread its inference further and further and you won't be sure or not if you already shared that information or not, but you will just assume you did, as you share everything anyway. For people who are not so open, it could stick to inferring less and being less useful.
- totalhack 4y agoMy favorite part is when my Google Home stops the music upon my request and then tells me in a complete and unnecessary sentence that it has stopped the music.
- djhworld 4y agoI bought the original Echo back when it first came out. It was a neat internet radio device and Bluetooth speaker but outside of making it play the radio I never really used the voice functionality much. I remember one of the places where I buy groceries from offering an incentive if you ordered your shopping via the Alexa skill, it was so painful to use that I added everything to my basket using the website and then just added 1 unambiguous item using the skill and checked out. They gave me the discount/incentive but I never used it again. I moved house but never plugged it back in and don't really miss it. I also remember going to AWS re:invent in 2016 and they gave every attendee an echo dot, with a lot of fanfare to encourage Devs to make skills. I tried to make one but it was so convoluted, I gave up in the end and just gave the Dot to my parents. It broke after about a year, they never replaced it either
- jbverschoor 4y agoWell there are so any problems with it (Siri). 1) Doesn't always understand what I'm saying (voice recognition) 2) If it does understand (voice recognition), it actually changes it it something else (super dumb, no, idiotic "AI", changes someone I call almost daily into someone I never call) 3) If it asks me what I want to do with a contact, it doesn't understand "call" 4) There's no way to 'correct' what has been said. 5) I can't open "podcasts", because it will open Deezer (I don't use Deezer anymore, but it's still on my phone). It's really just really really a dumb command line interface. And if it would just be that without the 'smart' things, it would be a lot more helpful. There are only a few things I use it for: 1) Call XXX 2) Alarm at XXX 3) Open google maps. Sometimes I say "route to xxx using google maps", and that works Even these three common use cases fail about 10-20% of the time. When I'm in the car and want to change route or add a poi, want to open an app, or text something, I try, but I get so frustrated which is more distracting than just typing it in your phone. So that's what I do. Google's voice recognition is a lot better and faster. Also their search understands more context. Voice assistants are like a skinner experiment. Solution: make it very rigid in terms of operations. People are quick to adapt this. Somehow the ai-crowd doesn't understand that a UI works best when the things you operate with are at the same location and always respond and work in the same way. I'd compare the voice assistant experiment as a GUI where the buttons, their function, and labels always change.
- rmac 4y agoThey did take off. Everyone in here uses them. People all over are using transcription (speech to text) to dictate instead of typing on the terribly small mobile phone keyboards. The issue apparently is no one knows how to make money
- pgrote 4y agoAlexa is an important tool for our family. My hope is amazon doesn't abandon Alex, but limit what it does and charge a subscription. We use it for alarms, timers, drop ins (inside home and outside), announcements, weather, news, music on Amazon prime and making calls. Simple things that don't require add on skills or advanced commands. Works solid for our needs and it would be difficult to replace. We never buy anything using voice commands. The problem is a family like us. We haven't bought a new device in 2 years and still use some of the original pucks. Amazon will need to make money somehow so I think a yearly subscription would work. Then again, if it isn't a growth segment I cannot see a tech company keeping something in today's world.
- ghaff 4y agoFor me, subscriptions need to really earn their keep. I suppose I'd miss my devices if Amazon started charging a subscription, but I certainly wouldn't pay and maybe I'd replace them with something else simpler.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- silon42 4y agoI would never choose to talk to the machine unless there's no alternative... There's a reason voicemail has largely been replaced by email, etc... Then there's the spying issue.
- bhouston 4y agoI love Google Assistant but it doesn’t recognize well my wife or daughter voices. Thus they find it annoying and do not use it. I use it primarily to turn on and off the lights (multiple times per day), play music, turn off the TV (but not to play things on TV, too unreliable) and to raise/lower the temperature on the Nest. We have tried to use the Nest Cams with the Hubs as a baby monitor but the cameras feeds freeze and don’t tell you so it is actually dangerous.
- booleandilemma 4y agoThe technology just isn't there yet. A lot of progress has been made, but I still need to repeat myself too often. It's more frustrating than using an app. We'll nail it in another 20 years though, and the voices will be indistinguishable from human ones.
- Robotbeat 4y agoI wish voice assistants like Siri could just do functions that are obvious, even if it requires learning commands. Actually especially for in-car voice assistants. I should be able to do any of the critical commands like turning on wipers, etc, via voice commands without looking at a screen or even feeling around for tactile controls with a free hand. If this was reliable and consistent, even if being reliable required learning a list of commands, that’d be a big help while driving.
- nmca 4y agoWhat's entertaining is that they were just too soon. Give it at the very most a couple more years and the state of the field will be very, very interesting.
- ericol 4y agoThis (for me) just shows a normal trend in tech. Somebody develops something, gets a lot of buzz, doesn't deliver, buzz dies slowly, and then several years in the future somebody else actually builds the tech stack needed for it, and it takes off again. Voice assistance, chat robots [1]... the metaverse. [1] Several years back I attended a chat in my city where some people from IBM showed us how to implement a chatbot I think with Watson. Beyond the trivial examples, it was nearly impossible to implement anything (Or the people giving the chat didn't know how to implement those) but the documentation was nowhere to be found beyond those trivial examples.
- CrypticShift 4y agoConversational Computing is just not ready. Even a better AI, alone, will not solve it 100%. But because of the 2010s meteoric rise of FAANG (in the public imagination and stock market) they think they can quickly push into mainstream all these immature paradigms like IVA, AR and now VR. All these technologies exist since decades, but they are not ready! billions of dollars of investment and marketing are not enough to make them so. As small a Leap as a tactile portable device took us almost 20 years to reach a conclusive mainstream form (iPhone) We need to accept that IVA/AR/VR are exponentially larger leaps and should remain side-shows for a very long time to come. For example, Microsoft is finally acknowledging this, with HoloLens being now just "to help you solve real business problems".
- mark_l_watson 4y agoWhile I get it why Amazon, Microsoft, and Google (?) might want to reduce development costs for voice interfaces, it seems like Apple is locked in to supporting Siri since one of its products, the Apple Watch, really needs Siri to get full value from it. I like to go about my day without carrying a phone (if I don’t need to take pictures) and the Apple Watch is a great compromise that allows getting calls and text messages, but at the same time is not intrusive as an iPhone. No one sits in a restaurant staring lovingly at content on their Apple Watch, ignoring nearby people and their environment. Pardon my getting a bit off topic, but it is interesting to see the “belt tightening” by FANGs: it seems like everyone is cutting excess staff and looking hard at which products make money and which are money losers. This may seem like a good thing except for newer product categories like AR/VR that will need a lot of experimentation to get right.
- transfire 4y agoWell guess what happens without open platforms? We need open tech to allow anyone to create voice driven “skills” — like websites. Not everything can live on ad dollars.
- mordymoop 4y agoA huge source of subjective user frustration with voice assistants is the lack of responsiveness to both commands and interruptions. Siri in particular will wait as long as a full second to “ding” letting you know she’s ready to process a command … often interrupting your attempt to give the command. Alexa will very often fail to hear me say “Alexa” despite the audio conditions being quite favorable. Both Siri and Alexa will misunderstand what you asked for and be completely indifferent to your attempts to correct them unless you interrupt them correctly. Afaict Siri can’t be interrupted by voice alone and Alexa can only be interrupted by something starting with “Alexa”. Once you are already “in” an interaction session with either of these tools you should be able to simply say “no, not that” or “no, <correction>” and the assistant should stop talking immediately, instantly, and not continue to blather on with the previous wrong interpretation. No matter how useful these tools are in the hands of a power user, Siri and Alexa give the impression of being morons largely because of unresponsiveness, not lack of capability.
- JCM9 4y agoI’d argue this space was technically successfully but not commercially so. We love our “smart speakers” and have integrated them into home automation. Does anyone make any money when we use them? No.
- asim 4y agoThey were too early. A decade from now when NLP is bullet proof and AI has made significant advances we'll revisit this. Pragmatically it makes sense at this juncture to focus on the API behind the voice interface that lets you issue commands. That's the true power. That's effectively a global catalog of services that can do anything, driven through one API. We can revisit voice but this is where the starting line is IMO.
- corobo 4y agoI hope this means people will be looking at jailbreaking these devices. I'd do it myself but that stuff is beyond me at this time. I'd love to repurpose my Alexas into satellite Rhasspy[1] devices if Alexa retires. 1: on HN the other day https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33705938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33705938 & direct link to the satellite info https://rhasspy.readthedocs.io/en/latest/tutorials/#server-with-satellites https://rhasspy.readthedocs.io/en/latest/tutorials/#server-w...
- eunos 4y agoNow this is not the most politically correct statement. But I wonder what is the similar situation say in China or other major non west countries? I think in China voice AI is more hyped.
- martythemaniak 4y agoIt's really shocking how bad all voice assistants are considering how amazing LLMs are. There must be major effort underway in all companies to upgrade all of them to LLMs in the backend. OpenAI charges 2 cents per about 750 words (for their best model), or roughly 1 cent per minute of talking. Maybe they can add LLMs as a premium feature, $3 a month for an actually smart home assistant seems like a deal.
- adamsmith143 4y agoThey just can't do useful things for me. I can do things like turn off a light or get the weather which are only marginally better than just flipping a switch or pressing one button on my phone. It's not a large gain in efficiency.
- billbrown 4y agoI liked Gary Marcus' post about this - https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/how-come-smart-assistants-have-virtually https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/how-come-smart-assistants-...
- jaysinn_420 4y agoi have seen a lot of people with physical challenges and disabilities discussing how critical these devices have become. they may not solve mainstream problems, but they have contributed materially to the quality of life for a marginalized community, and i hate the idea that they will disappear because big tech hasn't found a way to monetize them. i hope that the remnants of these projects can be open-sourced or sold to companies that will run with them and build and maintain products to support those who may have mobility or physical manipulation challenges, that are benefiting from voice control.
- JamesGriffin 4y agoU
- woeirua 4y agoCan we lump chatbots in with this too? Chatbots have totally failed to live up to their hype. It seems like we spent billions of dollars chasing chatbots and voice assistants only to realize that you need strong AI to have something truly useful.
- MarkLowenstein 4y agoVoice assistants do have a lot of potential due to the fantastic ergonomics. "Voice command line" is used as a pejorative here but it's true and a good thing. The original visionaries were right to pursue this idea. To me where it's gone wrong is that like many other things the A team conceives it but the B team is responsible for its development. The A team will ask "what will users want to say to it"? But Team B says "well if they say 'blah' how do we know that they mean 'blah'"? Mediocrity creeps in. As an example, here is a typical dialog between me and my Alexa. "Alexa, play Brahms C Minor Piano Quartet." "Playing: music like Coldplay." "NO" [music like Coldplay] "Alexa NO" [music like Coldplay] "STOP" [music like Coldplay] "ALEXA STOP STOP"
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoJust don't think they have improved in any meaningful way since launch and in fact some of the experiences have gotten worse. At launch I could reliably "Hey Siri" a timer across the room, now it just doesn't work because presumably Apple have downgraded the long range microphone tech at some point to save costs. Eventually just stopped bothering and just set them manually.
- kwash 4y agoI worked in a project where some funny guy was trying to sell voice assistant for a company selling LPG for housewives in Brazil, and of course nobody ever used this.
- kwash 4y agoI worked in a project where some funny guy was trying to sell voice assistant for a company selling LPG for housewives in Brazil. Nobody ever used this
- locusofself 4y agoI have a stereo pair of OG homepods, and it never ceases to amaze me how stupid they are. Songs I played yesterday are mysteriously unavailable, or I'll ask for a song I've played a million times for my daughter and it will decide to play a totally different, highly innapropriate rap song just because it also has the word "toothbrush" in the title or something. I use my Alexa as a timer only, and when it started saying things to me like I have notifications or "did you know you can use Alexa to order such and such" when I would say "Alexa, stop the timer", I almost threw it out the window.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoThe problem is simply that voice is a 1-D (linear) interface whereas computer screen is 2-D. So when I interact with the screen it can show me all my possible choices at the same time at each situation. I click a menu-item and a sub-menu pops up. With a voice-assistant I would have to wait for the assistant to list all possible choices but if they are many that takes a long time. You can only hear one word at a time. Combine that with inaccuracies of voice-recognition and it is clear that a computer screen + mouse is a much better interface. Hey it's the same difference as with Radio vs. TV. A computer screen-interface might be usefully augmented with voice recognition. But working with voice alone is like working blind. Gee who could've thought voice is not the killer-tech of 3rd millennium.
- psychomugs 4y agoI've been dabbling with Talon to reduce the burden on my precious arm tendons. It's the most useful voice interface I've used due to its customizability, but with that great customizability comes a great learning curve that it seems only techies would bother with.
- ozzythecat 4y agoThis is an interesting thread :) I see lots of conjecture on the nature of voice assistants, or why they haven’t taken off. As someone who was at Amazon, and close to this area, let me offer a simpler explanation. Alexa has stagnated because its leadership has little to no direction. The incentive structure driving the product teams and tech falls under two categories: 1. rest and vest 2. or write documents to build your promotion portfolio and get promoted. Then leave the org to find a job in AWS. In fact, Alexa could be used as a text book study in empire building. * Myriad teams that maintain or increase head count each year, with absolutely no meaningful deliverables. * Services that could be maintained by a 2-3 person on call that have an entire team of 6-8 engineers. * Tech directors, Sr. SDMs, and SDMs in a race to build their empire to get promoted to the next level. SDMs solemnly hiring head count for the sake of having more reports. Other SDMs hiring SDMs below them, even though there’s no need for additional management (team is idle), so they can show a larger footprint and get promoted to the next level. Voice assistant tech may as well be hitting a brick wall for technical or human computer interaction gaps that need to be thought much more in depth. But saying this was just an insanely hard technical problem is misleading and missing the bigger picture. If you build an organization as a pet project and then throw money at it to do whatever the hell it likes, with practically no accountability, of course you won’t get meaningful results. In recent years, Alexa became a place to chill and wait for your RSUs to vest. I personally know great engineers in Alexa, who are now stressed out of their mind about their work and visa situation because of the layoffs. But look - you decided to join a team where you basically just hang out at work, have a series of useless meetings, or half the time, your manager is complaining for some reason that his team doesn’t all show up to daily stand ups. A ton of extremely talented folks became extremely lazy, and so here we are. To root cause: misaligned incentives, lack of accountability and a poor work ethic, shockingly poor given at least some other parts of the company are still on the other, opposite extreme.
- userabchn 4y agoThey may not be very useful at the moment, but if progress in large language models continues at the current pace then I can imagine that conversational AI might be useful in several years. Investments by companies to establish and maintain voice assistant market share might thus eventually pay off.
- PeterCorless 4y agoHas anyone also considered that people have voice recognition systems in their smartphone and thus a standalone voice recognition device isn't necessary? Or that the results on a smartphone can be visual, whereas these home devices don't have direct IO apart from voice? [And yes, while they can be hooked to exogenous devices like a television, that's an extra step of configuration to finagle...]
- pipeline_peak 4y agoYeah, cuz it’s not 2011 anymore… Kids in India have smartphones now, no one’s impressed
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]