10 ms·
Tumblr to Add Support for ActivityPub
- valeg 4y agoTumblr's second wind. They seem to be on the right track.
- SeriousM 4y agoIn addition with allowing porn on their site again...
- manchmalscott 4y agoThey still don’t allow sexually explicit material. From their most recent policy: Visual depictions of sexually explicit acts (or content with an overt focus on genitalia) are not allowed on Tumblr. That includes pictures, videos, GIFs, drawings, CGI, or anything similar. Historically significant art that you may find in a mainstream museum and which depicts sex acts—such as from India’s Śuṅga Empire—are now allowed on Tumblr with proper labeling. Nudity and other kinds of adult material are generally welcome. We’re not here to judge your art, we just ask that you add a Community Label to your mature content so that people can choose to filter it out of their Dashboard if they prefer. https://www.tumblr.com/policy/en/community https://www.tumblr.com/policy/en/community
- ryanbrunner 4y agoTheir definition of sexually explicit is pretty narrow though in practice, there's still a significant chunk of Tumblr blogs that are 100% focused on sexual images and content without issue (and frankly were throughout the time when porn was banned since in practice Tumblr didn't put a tremendous amount of effort towards enforcement).
- bjtitus 4y agoGood luck finding anyone who gets significant traffic from Apple’s App Store allowing this.
- alpb 4y agoAnyone remember PubSubHubBub?
- samwillis 4y agoPrevious brief discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33694096 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33694096
- college_physics 4y agoIt feels like activitypub is the true web 3.0 or at least the start of a road towards it? but is it too tied to "social" web platforms as we have come to know and dislike? I mean its got explicitly hardwired the concepts of "followers" and "liking" and all the inanity that this has unleashed upon us. Now of course these are just "words" representing underlying software functionality but the mindset of designers and the constraints or blind spots they embed on software plays a huge role. consider the possibility that a more democratic / federated model of a broken concept will not deliver us from the social media fiasco.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoDoes it actually have that, or has this been added on top of it by Mastodon and PeerTube (and not some of the others) ?
- none_to_remain 4y agoActivityPub includes the social media concepts of liking, following, and sharing
- rkangel 4y agoIt's something I'm trying to understand too - what concepts does ActivityPub embody. My current version is "the general concept of someone posting some information that other people might be interested in, and the ability to get updates about it if you're interested". Fundamentally it's what "blog+RSS" gets you. I haven't had a chance to go through the spec properly, but all of the other bits like liking, replies etc. seem to be more application specific.
- stevenicr 4y agoI am glad for this in general, but wonder how it's going to work and scale - given that tumblr censors more than twitter.. if activity pub is a two way thing - what it going to happen to naughty bits shared between the two.. comments and posts that are outside the allowed bounds of tumblr? Will this be bot blocked? will there be a notice sent to the post-er and post-ee? Very interested to see how this actually works, and how it works at tumblr.
- tga_d 4y agoIt's already pretty common to choose federation status based on moderation policies. Many instances will only federate with instances that require content warnings for NSFW content, and some won't federate with instances that allow NSFW content at all. This information is machine-readable (see https://instances.social https://instances.social for an example of how it gets used), and lying about it will get you on lists for defederating pretty quickly.
- stevenicr 4y agoThis I understand from a [Popular Servr X has Y rules] - vs other server possibly being different.. and essentially a server admin or moderator group being choosy about broadly banning Z type of servers, and particular AA and BB ones as issues arise. What I am having a hard time figuring out, is what would tumblr do? If people from twitter servers post stuff via activity pub - (comments?) - and it's against the prude TOS they adopted some years ago - will they be blocking twitter servers outright? Find a way to block individual twitter users from cross posting? Will people on tumblr side be notified that a comment reply was attempted but X was blocked and so whatever.. will there be a fail notification send to the activitypub person from server V ? There is often confusion when comments are written directly to a blog - did the blog owner delete it? Did akismet (wp/automattic's spam filtering thing for comments and more) kill it and no one ever saw it? Was it punted to the spam comments section based on a server it's from or a word in the comment field? I just don't see how tumblr or similar could possibly scale this without a bunch of moderators - and I also think the ux for the tumblr users and those who would communicate with them via activity is going to go well as people find big holes in communication (no warnings and no info as to what is blocked, how it is blocked, etc)
- ramesh31 4y ago
- Alifatisk 4y agoWell, can’t you just switch engine from mruby to jruby? I believe Mastodon was compitable with jruby.
- traverseda 4y agoSurely the actual work is mostly being handled in the database, with the ruby code mostly acting is glue code? I'd expect to run into database scaling issues (or data model issues) long before running into issues with the relatively easy to scale horizontally ruby code.
- kstrauser 4y agoNope. The biggest bottleneck is in the async Sidekiq workers. I have 7 Sidekiq processes using a total of 5GB of RAM and as much CPU as they can get, but my database server is at around 5% CPU and IO. If the Rails part scaled as well as my DB, I believe I could trivially handle 10x the number of users I have today.
- vidarh 4y agoThat's a Mastodon and Rails architecture issue first and foremost, though, and far less of a Ruby issue. Mastodon is indeed a resource hog, so that part of the complaint I agree with. I've run queue processing on servers a fraction of a modern server CPU, less memory than that total, and with Ruby 1.8.x. It's not hard. It's hard to do with a naive Rails-based design based around Sidekick workers and ActivityRecord.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- asddubs 4y ago>Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg — whose company acquired Tumblr from Verizon in 2019 — suggested the user “come to Tumblr” as the site would soon “add activitypub for interconnect.” I'll believe it when I see it too easy to say this kind of thing in the hopes it will lure people in and get some press, and then to just quietly never do it and when asked about it again say "it didn't work out because of technical reasons"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stryan 4y agoTumblr infamously had a lot of spagetti code back in the day, with both new and old features breaking all the time. Last I checked (within the past 10 months), my tumblr accounts still shows -1 likes. I think Automattic has been good for the site code quality-wise, but also very much believe it when I see it. Plus, what happens when porn federates over to someones Tumblr dashboard?
- brigandish 4y agoI think it’s fair to be sceptical. I’m not aware of other services having retro fitted activitypub (are there any?) so it’ll be a good test of the protocol and any claims it will lead to more interoperability beyond Mastodon instances.
- codetrotter 4y agoAutomattic are pretty serious about open source software. https://automattic.com/about/ https://automattic.com/about/
- throwaway894345 4y agoDoes anyone know of any good writeups documenting the Mastodon/ActivityPub server-server protocol? Ideally a tutorial?
- rakoo 4y agoCheck out this reading guide made by the creator of Hometown, a pleasant fork of Mastodon: https://tinysubversions.com/notes/reading-activitypub/ https://tinysubversions.com/notes/reading-activitypub/
- friend_and_foe 4y agohttps://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/#server-to-server-interactions https://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/#server-to-server-interact...
- cetra3 4y agoHere's a blog I found had an easy introduction: https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/06/how-to-implement-a-basic-activitypub-server/ https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/06/how-to-implement-a-bas...
- alisonatwork 4y agoSomeone posted that link here recently and it was very useful, but unfortunately the blog doesn't link to the next one in the series. Here it is: https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/07/how-to-make-friends-and-verify-requests/ https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2018/07/how-to-make-friends-an... It sounds like the series was intended to continue, but I painstakingly clicked through the blog and couldn't find any more. From my side, the thing I am most interested in is some kind of micro-plugin that could be used to ActivityPub-ify an otherwise static site, maybe a bit like the old guestbook functionality from Geocities days. It would be cool to be able to just upload your site in a static way and have a hook that publishes that update out to your friends, and catches any of their comments in an iframe on the page.
- technojunkie 4y agoThis is great. Now, who can we contact to get this integrated into WordPress Core? I know there's a plugin but it'd be great to get something into Core. https://github.com/pfefferle/wordpress-activitypub https://github.com/pfefferle/wordpress-activitypub
- hn_20591249 4y agoTumblr is now owned by the original developer of WordPress, so not outside the realm of possibility.
- tiffanyh 4y ago> owned by the original developer of WordPress What do you mean by “original developer” of WordPress? I don’t think you mean the developer of b2/cafelog, which is what WordPress is a fork of. [0] I think you just mean that WordPress acquired Tumblr. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WordPress https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/WordPress
- russellbeattie 4y agoWhat sort of pedantic geek with a grudge do you have to be to think you're making some sort of point by stating the absolutely irrelevant fact that 20 years ago there was a crappy abandoned PHP project that was initially used by an ambitious teenager as a starting point to create the world's most successful publishing platform and one of the top open source projects of all time? Seriously, what do you think your point is? That the past 20 years of WordPress success is somehow the result of some nefarious teen fraud back in 2003? That Matt shouldn't get credit for creating WordPress because he started with a few hundred lines of PHP from an - again abandoned - open source project? The bitterness and stupidity on the Internet will never cease to amaze me.
- michelv 4y agoHi, developer of b2 here. Can't believe I finally have to create an account on HN, but here we are. First of all, Matt and Mike (along with Doug, Alex, Donncha, and other devs from that time) deserve all the credit for WordPress and its success. Often I get way too much credit from friends and people who mean well. I have mixed feelings about calling b2 a crappy project though. When I started writing it, I only had one month of PHP behind me, and no computer science background. It was a time when Blogger was flaky and a lot of bloggers were tired of the frequent downtime. There was a demand for blogware that could be installed and customized easily, and most existing blogware fell short (those written in Perl required specific hosting, others were not easy to use or customize). What I brought with b2 at the time wasn't technical prowess, but software that could be installed on super cheap webhosting plans by just editing a config file and uploading. I take pride in the documentation that allowed folks who only knew HTML to customize their blog's markup without having to know PHP or a custom template language. (Keep in mind we're talking about a time when bloggers would hand-write their site's HTML, ready-made themes weren't a thing.) I have fond memories of the dozens of fine people who contributed ideas and code to the project; among those contributions were the first opensource implementation of PingBack and perhaps the first of TrackBack too (not so sure about that one, but at the time there wasn't a lot of GPL blogware). The relative success of b2 (among those who self-installed their blog) was not due to the intrinsic quality of its code, but to those important things. It was mostly crappy PHP, but there is more to projects than just code. I would keep on talking about what blogs looked like in 2001, but if I recognize your name correctly, I believe you were there too. Finally, yes, it was abandoned. I was suffering from depression following the loss of my job at the time, and took time away from the internet. It was just not physically possible to open a code editor, or even reply to email, for a few months. It's not like I decided that I had enough and decided to explore greener pastures. If I could go back in time, I would hang on to the community we had, instead of abandoning the users and contributors. TL;DR: Matt, Mike, and the team deserve all the credit for WordPress's success, and it's a bit harsh to judge a 20+ years old project created by an enthusiastic newbie coder.
- donatj 4y agoI misread Tumblr as Twitter at first and thought that was really interesting. Be really neat to make Twitter a one stop shop.
- gonzo41 4y agoThat would be a smart and strategic move for twitter if they did. Along the lines of an embrace, extend, extinguish move against the fediverse.
- ilyt 4y agoI have a feeling that would just make most of the server owners ban it
- glenstein 4y agoTwitter apparently was working on their own protocol, under a project named BlueSky. I personally feel this was unnecessary and redundant because w3c had put forward activity pub. However, this project existed just the same. As far as I can tell, the Twitter and blog for the project have not been active since late October and I'm not sure if there's any life to it anymore. https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog https://blueskyweb.xyz/blog
- technojunkie 4y agoHere's a contributor's (pfraze) reason for not using ActivityPub. https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto/issues/255#issuecomment-1287953987 https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto/issues/255#issueco...
- arglebargle123 4y agoWell I certainly didn't have "Tumblr becomes culturally relevant in 2023 after adding federated content cross-compatibility with foss platforms" on my bingo card, but here we are I guess.
- musk_micropenis 4y ago
- scheeseman486 4y agoFederation is broad. Email, Usenet, IRC and the web are federated and at least two of those remain relevant and all four continue to exist.
- judge2020 4y agoBut can you really say that "because it's adding federation, it'll regain its popularity"? Also, where is this federated IRC you speak of? There's no cross-server identity or data transfer baked into the protocol.
- avian 4y ago> where is this federated IRC you speak of? IRC has the ability to form networks of servers which share identities and chat channels. There used to be a few large networks and many popular servers were part of one of them. Back in the 90s "being on IRC" commonly meant having a nickname on one of these networks.
- charcircuit 4y ago>Also, where is this federated IRC you speak of? Freenode is one. >There's no cross-server identity Your identity is your nickname.
- stonogo 4y agoYou don't get to redefine 'federation' because you prefer an approach different than IRC undertakes. It's very much federated and always has been. Data transfer is in the RFC: 2.3 Messages Servers and clients send eachother messages which may or may not generate a reply.
- kuramitropolis 4y agoStill no standalone ActivityPub client anywhere. Strange.
- vidarh 4y agoLikely because ActivityPub alone provides just a subset of what a typical social media client needs, and requires far more logic in the client than using the Mastodon API. E.g. if you use those APIs you don't need to care about webfinger and can treat the local server as the only API endpoint. There are few compelling reason for client writers to talk ActivityPub to the servers unless/until there's a far larger number of servers which does not support the Mastodon API
- rakoo 4y agoAndStatus definitely speaks it
- dsr_ 4y ago... what does that mean? It sounds like you are saying "there are no standalone SMTP clients", after which we would all start listing software that speaks SMTP.
- Kye 4y agoCan you imagine You log into your Tumblr dashboard All your friends on Mastodon making posts, your favorite bloggers on Write.as/WriteFreely instances, your favorite artists and photographers on Pixelfed Mingling with the people you follow on Tumblr. And it's all neatly tied together through ActivityPub. This was the original promise of the tumbleblogs Tumblr was inspired by. https://kottke.org/05/10/tumblelogs https://kottke.org/05/10/tumblelogs I see people worry that it'll be quickly blocked the moment it steps on to the Fediverse. The matt in Automattic lived through the same decades of web and internet we all did. I hope he has the good sense to slow walk it and make sure Tumblr is a good citizen of the Fediverse rather than flipping a switch one day to open the floodgates.
- no_wizard 4y agoWhy is flipping the switch bad in this context? Isn’t that actually what the protocol needs, a major visible platform adopting it with open arms all at once?
- notatoad 4y agoi think right now the protocol and the people who run popular mastodon instances are being treated as the same thing - mastodon.social and various affiliated servers are trying to build a community based around a certain set of values and type of content, and feeding all of tumblr into that might cause some drama. it's unquestionably good for the protocol to have more people using it. but it might not be good for mastodon.
- simfree 4y agoMastodon.social and other large instances certainly aren't working to build the same focused, higher quality communities that smaller instances thrive on. This is part of why many instances block the large, poorly moderated instances.
- lmm 4y agoPivix did exactly that, becoming the majority of the fediverse overnight. The result was a huge concerted effort to block them.
- joshuanapoli 4y agoWhy is ActivityPub better than RSS?
- jillesvangurp 4y agoRSS is a loosely specified document format with many implementation variants that basically represent a list of items with links, titles and a few other fields. ActivityPub is a W3C protocol and API specification for basically a generic federated social network with client server, and server to server API calls to create and manage activities and activity streams (a related specification).` It's not about being 'better' but about being something different. Representing an activity feed as an RSS feed is easy. Mastodon in fact has support for RSS. So, you don't even need to use mastodon to follow mastodon users and their micro blogs. For example, this is how you get Neil Gaiman's RSS feed curl -H 'Accept: application/rss+xml' https://mastodon.social/@neilhimself
- mariusor 4y agoIt's not really comparable, because ActivityPub describes a two way communication channel between entities, while RSS is just one way. ActivityPub is similar/comparable to email but built for social networks interactions.
- fallat 4y agoActivityPub is built for events. It's way more general than email.
- vidarh 4y agoYou can push whatever you want over email. I have used email as a federated queueing system... It worked fine.
- mariusor 4y agoI'd be very curious what gave you this idea. The ActivityPub vocabulary contains a number of social network related activities that can operate over a decently large vocabulary of object types, events being only one of them.
- berjin 4y agoThis reminds me a lot of OpenID over a decade ago. The idea was anyone could setup their own identity provider on their own domain and login anywhere. Unfortunately it became "login with google/facebook" which is a real shame. I hope sites don't restrict ActivityPub usage to only a few big players.
- suprjami 4y agoThere's been talk about Embrace Extend Extinguish coming to the Fediverse, with the counter-argument that anyone who tried it would find themselves almost universally de-federated and just building their own walled garden. I actually expect most Masto and PixelFed instances will block Tumblr pretty fast.
- toastal 4y agoLook at what happened with chat when everything was using XMPP, and then it didn't and now everything is a proprietary silo again
- serverholic 4y agoThis is wishful thinking. People will use whatever is easiest even if it means centralization. There are two routes we could take to fix this. One is building social pressure and a social consciousness around federation. The other is to bribe people, like how crypto social media rewards people for making popular posts.
- lrem 4y agoI’d posit there’s a generic way to assess the hope: Does the protocol come with inherently good way to deal with spam right in the core design? If not, it’ll eventually end with delegating trust to corporations.
- Avamander 4y agoApple ID login seems to be on the rise, GitHub is very popular for tech stuff, so these tendencies change over time.
- 4y ago