4 ms·
I agree that this proves nothing. I agree that the US financial system or market in general was never free in a sense that would appease a libertarian but.. Yo
by netcan 18y ago
I agree that this proves nothing. I agree that the US financial system or market in general was never free in a sense that would appease a libertarian but..
Your sentiments are interestingly similar to what a lot of Marxists/Communists had to say (not too many left though) when that 'failed':
That is, point to the Soviet Union & say: 'That was never true communism. So it failed. If it was truly a Marxist regime, this never would have happened.'
As I said, I wouldn't personally take this as a 'proof' of anything. But what seems inevitable is that this is causing a swing (in public opinion) away from deregulation of financial markets. I think it's very likely that there'll be a wholesale swing against the suite of things associated with 'libertarianism.' That's a shame in a way. Whether or not financial regulatory policies are optimal or not, has very little to do with the moral theories of libertarianism for example.
Anyway, there seems to be a big shift in the sway these ideas hold.
- dood 18y agoI wasn't entirely aware I was conveying sentiments ;) As far as economics goes, my creed tends toward mysterianism (though you correctly deduce I have a soft spot for libertarianism). I don't think we will make much progress in the field until we make and analyse many actual experiments. Even then I doubt that economics can be usefully understood. It is simply too complex. I think the best chance of real progress (i.e. something other than rhetoric) is in simulation, or even better, massively multiplayer games. Eve Online is an interesting step in this direction.
- eru 18y agoWe have a lab for experimental economics at our university. The let people play little games for money.
- dood 18y agoFrom the little I know about these kind of experiments, they're a good start and useful groundwork, but in my opinion too simple to reveal much about the real thing as a whole. I don't think real insight will be gained until we start to model and analyse large(ish) complex, dynamic systems. I'd be interested to hear if anyone knows of any such attempts.
- eru 18y agoThere has been some analysis of eBay, MMORPGs and related online markets. I know of one study that compared eBay's rules that encourage late bidding to Amazon's rules that manage to get people to bid early. (Amazon extends the deadline after late bids so that at least 20 minutes remain for other bidders to react. This removes the advantages of late bidding.)
- huherto 18y agoCheck "The Origin of Wealth" One of the conclusions is precisely that economy is a very complex dynamic system and advance techniques and models need to be built to understand it. Also, our capacity to make predictions is very limited. Free markets can be efficient but sometimes they are not the best mechanism.
- johnm 18y agoBah! This knee jerk hysteria is exactly the same as the reaction to 9/11... A major shock to the system freaks people out because the work isn't conforming to (comfort-oriented) expectations and so they instantly look to someone who looks good who promises them a return to mindlessness. The abrogation of responsibility by the many for their own lives and the arrogation of authority/magical-ability/etc. by the few (and the selling of that to increase power/profit at the expense of everyone else) is exactly the underlying mechanism that created the emergent, systemic failures. An example people might want to look at is the examples in traffic management whereby busy, dangerous intersections have been redone so that there's less separation and therefore more required of all of the participants to pay attention. I particularly like that example but there are plenty of other good examples from the driving and traffic world if you look around. Sigh.
- netcan 18y agoMy knee jerk hysteria? The public's? The article's?
- johnm 18y agoAh, sorry for the confusion... The public and the article.
- 0x44 18y agoThe abrogation of responsibility by the many for their own lives and the arrogation of authority/magical-ability/etc. by the few[...] That's a collective abrogation of responsibility by the public at large, not one by individuals within it. The constituent members of the public do not have (or feel they have) the responsibility or power to effect any sort of macroscopic change to the economy. In that sense, it's not surprising that the public nominates someone to have that power and responsibility.
- johnm 18y agoThat's a collective abrogation of responsibility by the public at large, not one by individuals within it. Ptui! How, exactly, do you think such "collective" behavior comes about? By the collective, emergent behavior of the individuals! The constituent members of the public do not have (or feel they have) the responsibility or power to effect any sort of macroscopic change to the economy. That's the point... The masses of individuals give it up and few take advantage by taking it up and extending their own power by manipulating people with FUDGE (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt, Guilt, and (the hope for self-) Enrichment). Doesn't anyone else find it odd that the "educational" system in the US doesn't actually teach anything about how the political system really works? I.e., it's all the pablum puking pap of the simplistic notion of checks and balances and what not but doesn't actually get into how it's been gerrymandered over the centuries, how people manipulate the (non-) voters in so very many ways, and especially not how to approach, think, and act to responsibly and effectively participate? Sigh. In that sense, it's not surprising that the public nominates someone to have that power and responsibility. Indeed. What's surprising is that people believe they are more free and that the overwhelmingly vast numbers of the so-called "thinkers" buy into the he-said, she-said games rather than going at the underlying issues. The simplest example for this group would be the debate of Creationism "versus" Evolution.
- Prrometheus 18y agoThe government is currently creating a great deal of moral hazard by bailing out irresponsible lenders and decreasing the amount of perceived risk in the market place. Libertarians are generally opposed to this. When the next crash comes because of this moral hazard, I'm am sure the public will still blame libertarians for it. I still won't think it a fair accusation. I fail to see how it is analogous to the blind Marxists who deny that every Marxist society was really Marxist. Our economy is evidently mixed. Our government controls the money supply and has an explicitly activist macroeconomic policy. Our financial markets are the most regulated markets in any industry except medicine. The two largest mortgage entities in the United States were formerly government agencies. There are plausible reasons why libertarians can deny that the credit crisis is due to markets that were too free. A facile comparison based solely on the structure and not the content of the arguments of the libertarians and the Marxists is not fair.
- netcan 18y agoI think the analogy is a little deeper the just a veneer. At least that is the accusation made here. For one thing, the concept of 'communism' according to Marx is a stateless, classless society. Since communist states were 'states' & ruled by parties which were very similar to a ruling 'class,' I thnk we can call this grounds for appeal. The problem is underlying. Any political theory that needs to be implemented completely, can't be judged based on its components. This means that unless you have a perfect specimen, you can't draw conclusions about its validity from reality. To the communist in question, abolishing individual ownership, collective production, land reform, command economy, etc. might fail, but that doesn't disprove communism. It doesn't even disprove those strategies. They are only expected to succeed within a perfectly Marxist state. The fact that a state would have been better off not implementing any of those policies, is no deterrent. To the libertarian in question, deregulated financial markets, corporate autonomy, free markets, etc. etc. might fail, but that doesn't disprove libertarianism. It doesn't even disprove those strategies. They are only expected to succeed within a perfectly libertarian system. The question is: would the US/Iceland/UK have been better off under more regulated financial markets? If your answer is 'yes, but...if only they were even more regulated & trade was unrestricted &..,' then the analogy is about as strong as these sorts of analogies can get.
- kingkongrevenge 18y ago> a wholesale swing against the suite of things associated with 'libertarianism.' I don't think the pendulum can swing any further that way without going over the top. People are probably much more cynical about government now than in most of modern American history. I don't think people will swing towards more statism and there's a good chance they'll swing towards libertarianism, even if only out of disgust with the current ruling elites rather than a philosophical libertarianism.