11 ms·
FTX’s Sam Bankman-Fried cashed out $300M during funding spree
- metadat 4y agohttps://archive.today/eMyNR https://archive.today/eMyNR
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- leet_thow 4y agoHow common was it for founders to cash out on common shares in the Series C-E rounds the last decade?
- twelve40 4y agoif the investors are willing to buy your shares from you, then why not? I've done secondary sales as early as seed. Unless you hide it from the board somehow, or you are explicitly prohibited from doing this, it's just a business transaction.
- leet_thow 4y agoNot an ethics question of why or why not, I'm just curious.
- slap_shot 4y agoIt was certainly much more common the last few years. However, those transactions are more of "hey investor, let me sell you some of my shares in this round" and not whatever complex behavior is described in this article.
- adrr 4y agoSo execs don't bounce. I left a company because they didn't offer a secondary and i was 3/4 vested with no exit in sight. I had a job offer to another company that promised an IPO in a year. If i would have been paid, i would have stayed but its hard to turning down a "guaranteed" 7 figure pay out. It's a numbers game, 1 out 10 startups will have an exit that makes people money.
- sarahowen62 4y ago
- wmf 4y agoPretty common. With startups waiting ten years to IPO, many founders and employees would "take money off the table" along the way.
- Schnitz 4y agoVery. It's usually not this egregious though. Founders might want stable finances for their family or the ability to buy a reasonable home, but VCs want them to keep going, so VCs allow founders to cash out some of their equity so that founders don't go for an exit for the sake of their personal finances.
- leet_thow 4y agoMakes sense, thanks.
- kkielhofner 4y agoAgreed but it's never this significant. In the world of "real companies" investors, boards, teams, etc are not OK with providing a founder with "F U money" (which this certainly is) so that they can go on and do nothing, leave for another venture, etc. For the others involved from investors to employees it's never good to be working with someone who could (theoretically) stand up from a meeting and walk out to go on and do whatever they want forever.
- wmf 4y agoI'm reminded of the "Grouponzi" round from 2010. https://venturebeat.com/entrepreneur/groupon-fundraising/ https://venturebeat.com/entrepreneur/groupon-fundraising/
- kkielhofner 4y agoBingo. It could be argued the relative failure of Groupon was largely driven by key stakeholders/insiders cashing out way too big way too early.
- dmitryminkovsky 4y agoThanks for this. Love the end: > And this stealth IPO has one more advantage: There’s nothing preventing Groupon from doing a real IPO in 2011. If anything, the reassuring cash pile makes it a more attractive investment.
- deleted 4y ago
- Dwolb 4y agoIt’s common to sell secondary, but usually limited to something like 10% of vested shares per person.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoThe article: "Mr. Bankman-Fried’s cashout was large by startup-world standards, where such sales historically were taboo because they allow founders to reap profits before investors."
- slap_shot 4y ago> the concentration of control in the hands of a very small group of inexperienced, unsophisticated and potentially compromised individuals. The most fascinating part of this whole story to me is just how few checks and balances there were in this company. Even without a board, did major investors not get his quarterly financials? If the leaked balance sheet was any indication of their level financial engineering capabilities, it's hard to imagine there weren't major red flags through most of 2021.
- wmf 4y agoGiven what we know now, those financials were probably completely wrong.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoYeah I’d venture a guess based on what we’re hearing that they just wrote up whatever they wanted it to look like.
- kjs3 4y agoI thought that was the whole point: unregulated (or at least extremely minimally regulated, preferably in a jurisdiction that has a looooong history of looking the other way and in a perfect world with no extradition treaties), decentralized, anonymous financial systems. It doesn't surprise me in the least that these clowns were running across the high wire without a net using other peoples money. The fascinating part to me is that anyone didn't think this was the inevitable outcome. But then I spent an hour this morning with some banking industry blockchain folks spinning this as "well obviously this debacle is great because it finally will shake out the bad actors and leave just us good-guys taking crusty old banking into the glorious crypto future". Just like they've said about every debacle since Mt Gox.
- anticrisis 4y agoThe whole circus is a mass delusion. I would really like to see some academic studies on the phenomenon.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoI don't know if it will happen, but a potentially good outcome here would be some regulation on the business practices of sufficiently large private companies in order to ensure they meet some basic level of corporate governance. Maybe they don't need the same level of scrutiny publicly traded companies have, but establishing minimum standards of conduct would help avert crises like this that can spread across entire sectors.
- oldgradstudent 4y agoFraud ands theft are already illegal.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd it's becoming more and more apparent that the "investors" had no desire to look closely at their golden baby.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoYes, but the total lack of corporate governance that contributed to it is totally legal, and could have possibly prevented the fraud and theft.
- luckylion 4y agoNot investing into companies that are obviously either frauds or extremely incompetent is the investor's job. We don't need a lot of new regulation to make it harder for you to buy bridges from people you meet on the subway.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThe idea behind the lack of regulation is that the impact is contained to the investors. It's obvious that in sufficiently large cases, that's not true. If these actors are able to do damage to entire sectors, they should have to do some minimum stuff: keep track of their money, have board meetings, submit to audits, etc.
- yieldcrv 4y agoFor people looking for prosecution like embezzlement or something else, these things usually rely on a violation of company policy then enabling a violation of a criminal law FTX/Alameda had no company policies and in this case disclosed what they were going to do to investors. “Buyout binance’s stake”. There is only so much the governments do to prevent you from wiring money to a sketchy opaque shadow bank in the Bahamas.
- kieselguhr_kid 4y agoThere are likely other charges that they could face. I don't think this rises to the level of embezzlement (although IANAL), but the missing customer deposits, lack of strict segregation between Alameda and FTX, and the use of company assets for personal loans and purchases will probably lead to indictments.
- yieldcrv 4y agothat I agree on, just commenting on this specific article
- trompetenaccoun 4y agoIt goes much deeper. They clearly stole a lot of customer money and SBF is supposed to have had a "backdoor" he could use to move funds between the exchange and Alameda to avoid detection by auditors. It doesn't get much more criminal than that in finance. https://www.reuters.com/markets/currencies/exclusive-least-1-billion-client-funds-missing-failed-crypto-firm-ftx-sources-2022-11-12/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/currencies/exclusive-least-1... Of course, with the way he and his family are connected, it wouldn't surprise me if he eventually walks free.
- sarahowen62 4y ago
- jaspertheghost 4y agohmm is this effective altruism, seems like they used it to cover massive fraud.
- sillysaurusx 4y ago> Three months earlier, in July 2021, Mr. Bankman-Fried bought out the roughly 15% stake owned by Binance, FTX’s first outside investor. Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao tweeted this month that the amount totaled $2.1 billion, paid in a combination of FTT, FTX’s in-house cryptocurrency, and BUSD, Binance’s stablecoin, whose value is pegged to the U.S. dollar. Hmm. Binance triggered FTX's downfall by dumping FTT, causing the domino effect. Does this mean that Sam was the one who sold Binance the FTT which Binance subsequently used to cause FTT to collapse? I just assumed Binance bought a bunch of tokens themselves for some reason. That's quite the turn of events!
- wmf 4y agoDoes this mean that Sam was the one who sold Binance the FTT which Binance subsequently used to cause FTT to collapse? Yes exactly. Binance triggered FTX's downfall by dumping FTT I don't know if they actually dumped; they just announced it. It doesn't matter now.
- sillysaurusx 4y agoIt matters! Because that'd be hilarious. Is that really true that an announcement of a pending large sale (but no actual sale) was enough delta to topple the house of cards? Fascinating.
- kjs3 4y agoWell, of course it's true. How could it be otherwise. If you see an 'announcement' and you wait for consummation, you've already missed any market move you could have taken advantage of.
- wmf 4y agoCZ announced that he was going to sell a certain amount of FTT and people could see that there wasn't that much liquidity on all the markets combined which implied that the price was going to near zero eventually, so other people completely rationally started selling FTT before CZ.
- 4y ago
- engineer_22 4y agoFBM is a loon, and everyone knew it, but as long as they were making money they looked the other way. The crypto bubble crash was directly driven by the COVID bailout. People had pockets full of money from day trading on robin hood, money flowing out of Blackrock like it was the big rock candy mountain. Nobody should be shocked, and the professional pension fund managers should be ashamed.
- tedmiston 4y agoFBM?
- engineer_22 4y agoSBF
- thepasswordis 4y agoJust a general statement on people commenting on this saga: Sam wasn't doing effective altruism. He was lying about doing effective altruism. It's weird to me that people talk about this as an indictment of EA...but this rings similar to me as claiming that this is an indictment of DeFi or cryptocurrency generally. Sam/Caroline weren't doing DeFi, and neither were they really doing anything related to cryptocurrency. This was just a pretty staightforward scam.
- Tenoke 4y agoHow was he not doing EA? He was lying AND donating to causes. I'm very pro-EA but that's a weird claim.
- balozi 4y agoDoesn't altruism literary mean selflessness-ism? Can you be selfless with stolen property?
- wmf 4y agoProminent EAers like McAskill have said (before this scandal) that EA is only valid if the money is earned honestly. They say that they never intended EA to be "steal to give".
- spywaregorilla 4y ago
- doesnotexist 4y ago> The amount raised contained numerical references to marijuana and oral sex: $420.69 million raised from 69 investors. An article published by one of FTX’s investors, Sequoia, called that fundraising a “meme round,” referring to the embedded jokes. Is Sequoia going to need to rebrand itself after this? Sure does raise some questions about their judgement and professionalism. Hey Investors, we're raising a round of almost half a billion dollars and the theme is...
- jasonwatkinspdx 4y agoThat freakin novel of a fawning profile of SBF on their website sure hasn't aged well.
- threeseed 4y agoSequoia was also backing Musk's takeover of Twitter. Not sure if they ended up investing. If they did then their record is looking pretty poor right now.
- 0xy 4y agoTwitter is at peak MAUs and according to previous financial statements should be cash flow positive after personnel changes. Seems like they invested in a business which was almost immediately switched into a profitable enterprise on an upward trajectory. What am I missing? Or are you making a prediction that is the opposite of available evidence?
- LeafItAlone 4y agoPeak MAU means nothing if they can’t keep investors or get those people to pay (to make up for the advertisers they may be losing). It is likely at peak MAU because a lot of people want to be “in” during what they _think_ is the crash (think of crypto a year ago when it was a peak, but now it’s way down). Current MAU may or may not be reflective of MAU in a month or two since the reason is so weird. The old financial statements are probably meaningless at this point given how much has changed and how many advertisers have reportedly pulled out. Not saying that I think Twitter will “fail” or even that it won’t be profitable. Just saying your metric is likely meaningless and is just a snapshot of a weird time.
- sarahowen62 4y ago
- skizm 4y agoThe amounts of money we’re talking about here are sort of staggering. I know they did a pretty good job of not keeping any records of depositors, but do we have any sense of depositor demographics, total number of depositors, or average account size? Any KYC at all? Like did retail “investors” really pump close to $16B into this? Could the scam here be crypto whales used this as an off ramp to turn their crypto into fiat, and then burn the ramp and all evidence of who used it behind them?
- DennisP 4y agoApparently some hedge funds had money at FTX, which is why there's talk about "contagion."
- codehalo 4y agoClients had to log into FTX to witness their account balances and history, so it is impossible that the data was never captured or available.
- vivanvu 4y agoHow can i log in to see my history
- jliptzin 4y agoDump your life savings into a crypto exchange based in the Bahamas, sure. But god forbid you invest $20k in a startup without being an “accredited investor”
- acjohnson55 4y agoI'm not sure what your point is. You can invest in whatever you want in the Bahamas without being accredited (as far as I know). If anything, the blowup of FTX seems to justify why investments in unregistered securities in US-based companies aren't allowed to be marketed to unaccredited investors. Are you saying we should allow companies with the level of oversight FTX had more free reign to operate and market their equity in the US?
- jliptzin 4y agoI am saying the whole “accredited investor” thing should be abolished
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoSo, USA makes some effort to stop ripoffs of unwitting "unaccredited" investors within the USA. Because this cannot stop ripoffs outside the USA, you propose ditching the within-borders effort?
- tedmiston 4y ago> So, USA makes some effort to stop ripoffs of unwitting "unaccredited" investors within the USA. The problem is that it's a dubious premise to begin with to assume that someone's knowledge or competence is tied to their salary or net worth. It's just baseless gatekeeping.
- Arainach 4y agoIt's not baseless. Those who are least able to tolerate loss and have the least time to do due diligence are precisely those most attracted to get rich quick schemes and most susceptible to deceptive practices.
- tppiotrowski 4y agoSBF sold a portion of his shares in the company for $300M instead of selling other outstanding shares. This meant he got to cash out before investors which is frowned upon because it signals that SBF believed that a $300M investment in another place was more valuable than keeping his $300M invested in FTX.
- AustinDev 4y agoI wouldn't say it's frowned upon. I think that determination depends on the context.
- smcl 4y agoHe's gotta be eyeing that Elizabeth Holmes sentence nervously
- isitmadeofglass 4y agoNha, he spent a good couple of billions on buying favor of politicians. He’ll end up with a slap on the wrist and a “boys will be boys” sentence compared to Holmes.
- EricE 4y agoWhat's really nuts about this fiasco is the amount of (US taxpayer) money from Ukraine that got funneled back into FTX.
- mhh__ 4y agoHow much exactly?