38 ms·
Exec who cleaned up Enron calls FTX mess 'unprecedented'
- angrygoat 4y agoHere's the administrator's filing with the Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware: https://d1e00ek4ebabms.cloudfront.net/production/uploaded-files/fdd-52615f0a-fb09-41ce-a398-b97b20bc1c36.pdf https://d1e00ek4ebabms.cloudfront.net/production/uploaded-fi... Page 22 is exciting: "The Debtors did not have the type of disbursement controls that I believe are appropriate for a business enterprise. For example, employees of the FTX Group submitted payment requests through an on-line ‘chat’ platform where a disparate group of supervisors approved disbursements by responding with personalized emojis." .. and: "In the Bahamas, I understand that corporate funds of the FTX Group were used to purchase homes and other personal items for employees and advisors. I understand that there does not appear to be documentation for certain of these transactions as loans, and that certain real estate was recorded in the personal name of these employees and advisors on the records of the Bahamas."
- pjc50 4y agoIt's a fun read, in a sort of True Crime sense. They had no financial controls whatsoever and just got people to wire them billions of dollars.
- Alex3917 4y ago> It's a fun read, in a sort of True Crime sense. It sounds like it was purposely written to be the cold open of the inevitable Netflix miniseries.
- retube 4y agoMatt Levine's piece yesterday also mentions a $1bn loan ("loan") from FTX to SBF
- foostepsndpics 4y agoIt's interesting that, under every silo's balance sheet shown in that document, there is a footnote saying that customer crypto deposits are not represented in the balance. Is that his way of saying that they haven't been able to figure out where the customer crypto deposits were represented in the ledgers?
- pcl 4y ago> employees of the FTX Group submitted payment requests through an on-line ‘chat’ platform where a disparate group of supervisors approved disbursements by responding with personalized emojis This seems like a totally legit approach to me -- ChatOps for expenses, essentially. The usability of "an on-line 'chat' platform" (presumably Teams / Slack / Discord / equivalent) is much better for the employees than most finance tools, and most chat apps these days should have pretty great auditability capabilities. (Of course, the rest of this FTX fiasco is a total disaster.)
- exo762 4y agoAFAIK they were using Signal with auto-delete turned on. If true, this is a great way to avoid auditability.
- ninjin 4y agoWell, they are learning from the “best”: politicians [1]. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/dec/17/tories-switch-to-messaging-app-signal-to-curb-whatsapp-leaks https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/dec/17/tories-swit...
- gruez 4y agoThis is actually standard within financial institutions and big corps. It's not implemented as "signal with auto-delete turned on", but rather as retention policies on emails or whatever.
- hermitdev 4y agoExcept the retention on emails, for instance, is usually 7 years. Not exactly the same as auto delete after read... It's an apples to oranges comparison.
- compiler-guy 4y agoAnd the relevant transactions and approvals get recorded in other media for even longer periods in auditable forms. A slack exchange saying, "Hey, would you approve this expense?" "Sure" isn't a problem. It's the lack of formal follow ups in an auditable medium that is.
- deeblering4 4y ago> For example, employees of the FTX Group submitted payment requests through an on-line ‘chat’ platform where a disparate group of supervisors approved disbursements by responding with personalized emojis. So... the payment system was a discord bot?
- kneebonian 4y agoHonestly having had to deal with the hell that is a purchasing request in large corporations I think I'd rather go with a discord bot than have to spend 6 months justifying why I need to purchase a $50 piece of software to do my job.
- ceejayoz 4y agoYeah, but the next paragraph indicates disbursements included entire houses.
- klyrs 4y agoI mean, who wouldn't want that? Aside from that whole "embezzlement" issue.
- prepend 4y agoSimilar. The best reimbursement system I’ve worked with was for a company that just automatically approved everything under a few thousand dollars (never states a hard threshold) based on individual professional judgement to spend funds to advance company goals. And they audited every purchase ever made when you went for partner. It was both liberating and terrifying to have that much freedom. The audits weren’t widely available so it’s hard to know how effective this was, but it was pretty rare to hear about people not making partner because of it and they were super thorough about every charge, frequently asking for detail.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- edf13 4y agoOne of the biggest mistakes in this whole fiasco is from the people who enabled this - how (why?) on Earth were they given such ridiculous sums of money… with 0 oversight!
- lupire 4y agoOnly true if the investors weren't sharing in the embezzlement.
- Havoc 4y agoI see one can buy FTX risk management department mugs on Etsy already lol
- CoastalCoder 4y agoIt would be meta-funny if they never sent you the mug you paid for.
- eqmvii 4y agoI'm surprised anyone is surprised. The selling point of crypto always seemed to be the ability to elude regulation, and so they did, and so the obvious temptations were tempting... A vocal community has been calling out the blatant scams and corruption for years. The information was readily available to anyone doing even the most basic due diligence.
- indigodaddy 4y agoDoes/will the lack of regulations infer milder criminal penalties?
- gkilmain 4y agoI like this question. Do we then base the penalties purely on pain suffered by the scammed?
- from 4y agoEven if they can’t establish securities fraud it seems like they have wire fraud based on the deleted tweets alone. Plus whatever internal accounting manipulations he had going on are likely some form of honest services fraud. Plus they were handling some international withdrawals through a front company in California that pretended to be an electronics wholesaler called North Dimension Inc which from what I can tell did not register with FINCEN so they have unlicensed money transmitter and potentially some other fraud because they likely misrepresented the business to banks too. For sentencing you basically get a score that increases with loss amount, increases with whether any victims faced financial hardship (in this case obviously yes), and decreases with things like cooperation and acceptance of responsibility. See https://www.sentencing.us/ https://www.sentencing.us/. But IANAL.
- HWR_14 4y agoProbably not. Enron actually may have steered clear of violating any regulations. At the very least, the government lawyers were afraid to subject a jury to months of accounting regulations and debates over not black or white issues. So they just made the case that the sum of all the actions was an accounting fraud. And they got the CEO/CFO/CFO's wife (who helped/would have gotten the Chairman, but he died and several others in jail for it. I would put money that SBF is going to prison for decades -or- evades US prosecution by managing to avoid extradition.
- kyleplum 4y ago> Never in my career have I seen such a complete failure of corporate controls and such a complete absence of trustworthy financial information as occurred here. From compromised systems integrity and faulty regulatory oversight abroad, to the concentration of control in the hands of a very small group of inexperienced, unsophisticated and potentially compromised individuals, this situation is unprecedented. Are these filings typically full of quips? This seems pretty damning but I don't read enough court filings to know whether this sort of language is typical
- lazide 4y agoIt is not only not typical, it is definitely raising eyebrows from the clerks office to the judges. Language in these filings is usually so dry that it makes the Sahara look like Tahiti. The cleanup CEO is mad. And he’s seen some shit. The financial equivalent of ‘somehow folks with PhDs mixed cleaning chemicals together for no apparent reason and gassed a bunch of kindergartners’.
- that_guy_iain 4y ago> The cleanup CEO is mad. I think he is also laying the groundwork for "This is going to never be fully accurate or clear what happened."
- pjc50 4y agoHe's said as much in other parts of the filing. All sorts of accounts for subsidiaries that should exist apparently just can't be found.
- curiousllama 4y agoI think this is it - he's looking for publicity as reputational CYA (which is a big part of his job). If you take a look and go "I can do this" and can't, then you look sketchy. If you take a look and go "nobody will ever be able to do this completely, but I'll try" then you look like a hero.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI read a thread from someone reviewing the books, showing all the issues. One conclusion was, “where did all the actual money they took in from people go? It’s missing as an asset.” And I wonder if they’ve been hacked or otherwise extorted one or more times.
- jmyeet 4y agoWhen the fishy balance sheets leaked I wondered who the CFO was who signed off on them. There was no CFO. Beyond any regulation or regulatory failure it’s shocking the investors let this happen. You shouldn’t give someone billions of dollars without an adult in the room ensuring there are adequate processes in place to track and manage that money. The GPs at the various VCs investing in this should honestly be fired. But as story goes on the story just gets so much worse. This is theft of company and customer assets pure and simple. SBF and his cohorts are about to discover just how far reaching the long dick of the US government really is. Like how can anyone think blindly spending customer assets wasn’t going to end in spending the rest of your life in prison or on the run? Because that’s where this is going.
- glitchc 4y agoThis is effective altruism at its finest. They will finally give Congress and the SEC the egregious case they need to craft (and enforce) new laws governing DeFi. The industry as a whole will become safer due to their malfeasance. If that's not altruism, I don't know what is!
- angio 4y agoHow is FTX related to DeFi in any way?
- marcus0x62 4y agoWell, clients believed their money was centralized at FTX. They now realize it has been decentralized to many other places.
- VLM 4y agoThe FTX business model was to initiate regulatory capture, spend a flood of money on the usual DC insiders to make all competitors DeFi illegal in the USA, then they just happen to soak up all the profits. It would have worked out fine if they had just held it together until after they hired the US Gov to put all their competitors out of business. They would have been too big to fail and these smaller numbers could all be swept under the rug by larger numbers. Well, startups lose money until they make money of course. One of the guys who's company was about to get shut down by the legislation FTX was purchasing, decided to out FTX's questionable balance sheet (if he's taking us out, then we're taking him out first...), and the rest is history. If you pay the right people, the us government strongly supports anticompetitive policies. That side of the story was going to be very profitable.
- throw_m239339 4y agoSo which one is it? Incompetence or Malice? These ultra-smart people from MIT and Jane Street, the "elite", couldn't possibly ignore basic accounting, or the fact that they were operating a Ponzi scheme and defrauding both their investors and their clients. It would be like calling Enron leaders "incompetent".
- thirtyseven 4y agoThere are a wide range of other options here, including negligence and magical thinking.
- bcrosby95 4y agoWhy not both? They did some things that were clearly illegal (malice). But they lost the money because they thought they were smarter than they were (incompetence).
- anonymoushn 4y agoWell, they'd like us to think it's incompetence because in the US you aren't guilty of fraud if you are just unbelievably dumb.
- canjobear 4y agoWhat's clear is that FTX didn't have any real corporate structure in the usual sense. It was a handful of people sitting around on bean bags doing stimulants and trading crypto all day. It's amusing to read about the clash between the bankruptcy CEO's expectations of what a corporation looks like and what FTX actually was.
- ameister14 4y agoThe thing is, it's incredibly unusual for a corporation to just ignore the massive legal risks like this. They commingled assets and used the corporation in a way that totally breaks the veil and means the directors are likely personally liable. That's honestly just moronic of them to do. No idea why people invested in this, clearly nobody did their due diligence.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI wonder if that's how people will get out of lawsuits, by convincing the judge that no serious investor doing their due diligence would ever give these amateurs a single dollar.
- usefulcat 4y ago> no serious investor If they wanted to mitigate legal risks, it probably would have been better to take advantage of 'serious' investors, as opposed to less knowledgeable investors. I believe the latter group generally enjoys more legal protections.
- prepend 4y agoThere’s a scene in the Hulu show about Theranos where an investor was trying to do due diligence and they kept getting the runaround with crazy excuses. Like a comedy. They eventually walked. I guess the FTX investors didn’t walk. Makes you think how lucky we are that the financial system even exists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skizm 4y agoMy favorite bit about the FTX fiasco is the spreadsheet with assets and liabilities has an entry for negative $8B: > hidden, poorly internally labled ‘fiat@’ account
- teeray 4y agoIs there a good start-to-finish summary of this? I don’t really pay attention to crypto at all, but this keeps coming up.
- justapassenger 4y agoFTX was one of a biggest crypto exchanges (think - stock market), ran by bunch of smooth talking friends/lovers, who were more interested in playing games and Harry Potter than running a company. They amassed hundreds of millions of dollars in investments, from serious companies (who were impressed by their recklessness) and billions of dollars in deposits from customers. They donated millions to politicians and spent even more on ads (including Super Bowl). They stole those money, and partially pocketed it/moved it to their hedge fund (which they managed on a principle of “you don’t need to know math or finance” and “risk management is dumb”) that lost majority of it and triggered their fall. They did all of that, while being run with less financial and corporate discipline than a neighborhood dog walking business by a teenager.
- justusthane 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FTX_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FTX_(company) does a pretty good job, I think.
- kyawzazaw 4y agohttps://newsletter.mollywhite.net/ https://newsletter.mollywhite.net/
- hackerlight 4y agoFTX embezzled customer's deposits by giving it ("loan") to Alameda. Alameda then lost it.
- woeirua 4y agoWho thought that giving a bunch of 20 year olds with no experience, and most importantly _no_ oversight hundreds of millions of dollars was going to end differently? Everyone involved with this deal at Sequoia capital should be fired. Did they do _any_ due diligence?
- 0goel0 4y ago
- papito 4y agoMaybe we should stop lionizing VCs as some sort of investment prodigies. All it is is some people already with money gambling on a large scale and occasionally winning - mostly because there is a bigger sucker somewhere downstream that buys into the promise of future mega-profits. They are no different than some 20-year-old being all aflutter at the guy who just pulled up in a lambo and whispered "crypto & nfteee". And, by the way, if you've already proven that you can break some hearts by doing borderline fraudulent stuff and conning people out of billions, that goes in your favor. https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/08/why-is-anyone-still-betting-on-adam-neumann.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/08/why-is-anyone-still-...
- nradov 4y agoVC fund general partners are usually not employees that can be "fired" in the traditional sense. However, they can be forced out in certain circumstances and the limited partners are probably asking some hard questions about fraud and cancelling future capital commitments.
- Macha 4y agoBrian Cantrill recently did a talk on this exact motive: https://redmonk.com/videos/coming-of-age-bryan-cantrill-monktoberfest-2022/ https://redmonk.com/videos/coming-of-age-bryan-cantrill-monk...
- bbayles 4y agoI don't really doubt that he's right about this, but doesn't he have a pretty big incentive to play up how bad the mess is? If he successfully unwinds it then he looks like a genius. If he can't do it, we can't blame him, because it was worse than anything anybody had ever seen.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis guys has been cleanup CEO a bunch of times, including the former biggest US bankruptcy ever. He doesn't need to worry about improving his reputation. Plus, it's easy to compare his filings here with his filings in previous cases and reasonably conclude that FTX is just much, much worse.
- bmm6o 4y agoIt really shouldn't be surprising that FTX is worse than Enron. Sure, Enron was run by crooks, but they were adults operating in a highly regulated industry. I've seen kids run a lemonade stand with better bookkeeping than FTX.
- bena 4y agoAdults operating in the US. They needed to have books. Now, the fact that those books were apparently a work of fiction is a different matter. But they did have to make the effort to have the numbers reconcile. Which is why FTX wasn't headquartered in the US.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoI don't think he's been involved in a startup. Usually people like this get involved in big bankruptcies. Usually startups aren't big bankruptcies. Most startups work like this(minus the fraud). It is what it is. Approving things via chat is completely valid, for example. Several bot products have flows for approving expenses etc. All kinds of things are approved via chat these days.
- kyawzazaw 4y agoIt's more than that.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoBut it's not less. Chaos + scam, chaos + future trillion dollar company, chaos + zero, and so on. Chaos is always there.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoMalarky, and I say this as someone that works in a fintech startup. This excuse that somehow because you're a startup you don't have to follow the most basic rules of accounting is nonsense, especially when you're handling billions in assets.
- danielmarkbruce 4y agoWhat does "follow the basic rules of accounting" mean? Have rigorous systems in place such that you can close your books within a day? See a real time view of your financial position at any minute? Show a set of financials which meet GAAP requirements but are hand done in excel and complete 8 weeks after qtr end? Get audited? Are you in the finance function at your startup? I'll guess no, and if you go ask someone there if it feels rigorous they'll laugh.
- bunderbunder 4y agoThis Gish gallop of questions strongly suggests that you don’t have a lot of experience in the financial industry yourself, and are trying to cover for it with bluster.
- TechBro8615 4y agoIs there anyone on HN who lost money from FTX? Can you describe how it happened from your perspective?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoWhat's there to explain? Customers put money into their accounts, and now all withdrawals are blocked (because the money isn't there and because assets are frozen in bankruptcy).
- TechBro8615 4y agoI'd just like to hear from one of the reportedly million people affected directly. Is there a subreddit or something? One person tried to open one but was called out as a scammer [0], and commenters in that thread are also asking if there is any FTX victim even on the subreddit. [0] https://old.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/yvqyji/i_have_created_a_reddit_community_for_ftx_victims/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Buttcoin/comments/yvqyji/i_have_cre...
- kranke155 4y agoI must've lost like 20$ on FTX. I used it to buy a lot more than that but never left anything there. I believe @cobie might've lost money.
- TechBro8615 4y agoLost fiat deposits? What happens when you try to withdraw it?
- Animats 4y agoIt's an interesting read. Step 1, finding the cash that's left and putting it into big banks with tight controls on authorizing withdrawals, seems to be going OK. Step 2, finding the employees, not so much. "At this time, the Debtors have been unable to prepare a complete list of who worked for the FTX Group as of the Petition Date, or the terms of their employment. Repeated attempts to locate certain presumed employees to confirm their status have been unsuccessful to date. They thank some of the employees who stayed on trying to clean up the mess. Step 3, "Digital Asset Custody", is not going well. "Unacceptable management practices included the use of an unsecured group email account as the root user to access confidential private keys and critically sensitive data for the FTX Group companies around the world, the absence of daily reconciliation of positions on the blockchain, the use of software to conceal the misuse of customer funds, the secret exemption of Alameda from certain aspects of FTX.com’s auto-liquidation protocol, and the absence of independent governance as between Alameda (owned 90% by Mr. Bankman-Fried and 10% by Mr. Wang) and the Dotcom Silo (in which third parties had invested). The Debtors have located and secured only a fraction of the digital assets of the FTX Group that they hope to recover in these Chapter 11 Cases." A few little prison-term sized problems: (a) at least $372 million of unauthorized transfers initiated on the Petition Date, during which time the Debtors immediately began moving cryptocurrency into cold storage to mitigate the risk to the remaining cryptocurrency that was accessible at the time, (b) the dilutive ‘minting’ of approximately $300 million in FTT tokens by an unauthorized source after the Petition Date and (c) the failure of the co-founders and potentially others to identify additional wallets believed to contain Debtor assets. They're working the problem. Chainalysis has been retained to find where those coins went. "...investigators to begin the process of identifying what may be very substantial transfers of Debtor property in the days, weeks and months prior to the Petition"." That's preparation for "clawback", where transfers that occurred prior to the bankruptcy are undone. Anything in the 90 days prior to the bankruptcy gets looked at hard, and the bankruptcy can go back further where fraud is involved. The Madoff Recovery operation used clawback heavily. Which is why the Madoff recovery took so long, but got a sizable fraction of the money back. Lots of lawsuits against people who thought they got out in time. Expect that here. "Finally, and critically, the Debtors have made clear to employees and the public that Mr. Bankman-Fried is not employed by the Debtors and does not speak for them. Mr. Bankman-Fried, currently in the Bahamas, continues to make erratic and misleading public statements. Mr. Bankman-Fried, whose connections and financial holdings in the Bahamas remain unclear to me, recently stated to a reporter on Twitter: “F### regulators they make everything worse” and suggested the next step for him was to “win a jurisdictional battle vs. Delaware”. Some news reports indicated that Bankman-Fried was still somehow involved, or "assisting", or something. He's not. He has zero authority at this point.
- vaxman 4y ago“Are you smoking crack?.” (This was the infamous “Enron Moment” when the question was asked of Ken Lay by a random employee at an all hands meeting where Lay was espousing optimism even as Enron’s collapse was imminent. https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/comments/uv47l2/so_i_was_watching_enron_the_smartest_guys_in_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/comments/uv47l2/so_i_was... @1:12 —Downvoters here are always showing their ignorance ROFL)
- outside1234 4y agoNeed to perp walk Bankman-Fried ASAP and put him in thumb screws until we have an employee list.
- at_a_remove 4y agoSBF's admissions come off as kind of "lol yeah," like a dumb junior high prank or something, and they just keep finding new things. I am expecting an accusation like "Is it true that you smuggled a bunch of crypto wallets across the border, on thumb drives inside of the abdomen of a dead infant?" SBF: o haha SBF: yeah that SBF: so many border searches SBF: but good ventriloquists will do anything for money SBF: crying baby sure SBF: got a burial stateside at least right?
- rossdavidh 4y agoUnstated subtext: "Who the heck gave these bozos this much investment $$? Your whole job is basically to check for this kind of basic corporate structure and organization before handing over hundreds of millions of $$." I am wondering how Sequoia or SoftBank explain this to their investors.
- bmitc 4y agoI still cannot understand what investors were thinking and doing. I thought those people were extremely demanding? You always here these stories of people being nervous even to present an idea to investors, but here is an example of a company with not a single shred of professionalism or even attempt at doing things properly. Yet, investors were throwing money at them and writing coronation articles about them. Is there a way where investors are held liable for some things? Their investments and marketing material for FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried, etc. are a large part of what lended credence to FTX and this people putting money in. Will the investors be investigated as well? They are partly responsible, in my opinion. I am not crazy about this world where investors give all this money and see nothing but upsides (aside from losing money that really doesn’t matter to them), but then have no downsides, even when funding fraudulent or incompetent enterprises.
- topspin 4y ago> I thought those people were extremely demanding? Their demands are inversely proportional to the size of whatever profits they're anticipating.
- dahdum 4y ago> I still cannot understand what investors were thinking and doing. Dumb money (like pension funds) was just following "smart money" like Sequoia. Smart money was investing based on his political, media, and regulatory connections and not the financials. They'll say different publicly, but I doubt anyone really cared if the books were cooked and it was all a house of cards, as long as they stood a good chance of getting out before it crumbled. VC's have been riding crypto pump and dump schemes for years now.
- lrvick 4y agoAs a security engineer and advisor that has had access to the internal practices of dozens of crypto-asset companies, I can assure everyone this level of negligence is -so- normal that if you actually behaved responsibly in this space it would be very hard to compete with those that are not. Almost no one bothers with even the most basic of security controls, often connecting to production systems containing billions of dollars with compromised personal use laptops. There are several more MtGox, QuadrigaCX, and FTX style events cooking right now. Also, here is your daily reminder that decentralized assets stored in centralized third party systems are not yours, and will probably be abused or stolen. Learn to use a hardware wallet or stick with low-tech asset classes like precious metals.
- varelse 4y ago