3 ms·
To me the source of the apple matters a lot more than the breed itself. Put another way: there is a high variance in the quality of apples independent of the b
by dekhn 4y ago
To me the source of the apple matters a lot more than the breed itself. Put another way: there is a high variance in the quality of apples independent of the breed.
The absolute best apples I've ever had were pick-ur-own at a well-regarded apple orchard in Connecticut. I believe they are McIntosh although it could also be macoun. Every apple is crisp (not mealy), sweet and tart, with a thin skin and lots of flesh.
The big disappointment for me was moving to california, in an area without pick-your-own. How do I put it? The vast majority of apples in supermarkets here are abysmal. The granny smiths were often mealy and not tart at all! It wasn't until I went to a boutique grocery (Monterey Market in Berkeley) that I finally tasted apples in the same category as the ones I grew up with.
Reading the descriptions on this site, I don't really recognize their descriptions. Mcintosh has a thick skin? Ummmm.
- guyzero 4y agoHit Berkeley Bowl or farmers markets which will have much fresher apples.
- dekhn 4y agoI shop at Monterey Market more since it is closer to my house. But yes, BB also has quality produce.
- CoffeeOnWrite 4y agoMonterey Market is just as good or better than Berkeley Bowl for apples. (Incidentally Monterey Market has quite a better mushroom aisle than Berkeley Bowl..)
- erisinger 4y agoThis is the truth. A Fuji apple in Japan is life-changing. A Fuji apple in Minnesota is flavorless and either hard as a rock or mushy and granular. It’s all about the source.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- theonething 4y ago> he vast majority of apples in supermarkets here are abysmal. And here I thought I just didn't like apples (California resident). Will need to expand my geographic apple boundaries.
- nckslvrmn 4y ago+1000, Macouns from Rogers Orchards in Southington CT are the BEST apples on the planet
- theobeers 4y agoI never thought I would see mention of Rogers Orchards on HN. Some of my family members live within biking distance of there, and I love stopping by for a bag of apples or a pie.
- marze 4y agoThis is so true. Thinning, tree health, soil health, all make a huge difference.
- wrycoder 4y agoApples in season at the orchard are not comparable to apples at the local big chain market. The latter are picked green and ripened with ethylene gas when needed. The varieties of apples best eaten fresh at the orchard differ from the best orchard varieties to save at home, and those are in turn different from the varieties used in general commerce, which are chosen for survival, not taste. And, pie apples are not eating apples, nor are they cider apples. The rating listing is laughable.
- zhynn 4y agoIf it has thin skins, it is not macintosh. The thick skin is one of the hallmarks of the cultivar. Macoun are my favorite, though they don't store for long. My favorite storage apple is Empire.