7 ms·
Aerobic exercise can reduce the risk of metastatic cancer in mice: study
- Markoff 4y agoWouldn't be much easier just restrict sugar/glucose consumption, so you don't need to burn it by exercise? I feel this is trying to solve consequences instead of the cause, if I read the article correctly.
- rollo 4y agoNo, that's not about sugar. The body needs glucose to function. It is produced from carbs (and other sources) in your food.
- canucker2016 4y agoYes. That's why keto is used by some cancer patients. Not all cancers are glucose-sensitive though. See the Warburg effect - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warburg_effect_(oncology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warburg_effect_(oncology)
- loceng 4y agoAlso, water-only fasting.
- gregwebs 4y agoKeto is a successful form of cancer treatment mostly for brain cancers. Low carb/keto haven't shown dramatic benefits for cancer treatment (like most treatments, it helps some people) or for cancer prevention. Exercise seems to fix cancer at the source as indicated by studies showing it dramatically reduces cancer risks. So IMHO restricting carbohydrate is trying to solve the consequence of excess energy through diet whereas exercise solves it at the source. Exercise causes a variety of changes in the body beyond just altering blood sugar levels. Not all cancers are glucose driven. There is likely a larger grouping of cancers that are facilitated by excess energy in the body (glucose being one form of that), all of which might be helped by exercise. But exercise has many other downstream effects. Rather than restricting carbs, an approach to requiring a bout of exercise before eating would be much more in line with evidence.
- boplicity 4y agoNote, this isn't for all types of aerobic activity. They're specifically saying that high-intensity aerobics, such as sprinting, are beneficial. > "Our results indicate that unlike fat-burning exercise, which is relatively moderate, it is a high-intensity aerobic activity that helps in cancer prevention," adds Dr. Gepner. "If the optimal intensity range for burning fat is 65-70% of the maximum pulse rate, sugar burning requires 80-85% - even if only for brief intervals."
- zagrebian 4y agoIs a daily 7-minute workout enough? I perform it at a very high intensity (40 jumping jacks, 16 push ups). https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/09/the-scientific-7-minute-workout/ https://archive.nytimes.com/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/0...
- imnotlost 4y agoFor 80-85% of maximum pulse rate... If your lungs are burning and you're about to collapse after 30 seconds of activity the intensity is about right. Do 30 seconds high intensity, then 90 seconds low intensity (don't sit down or stand still), repeat 8 times. Rowing and sprinting works really well.
- mrleinad 4y agoWould swimming work as well? I can see myself doing some laps really fast that will leave me panting by the poolside after 50 mts.
- nradov 4y agoSwimming can work as well, but only if you have good technique. I'm not a great swimmer so when I'm panting by the poolside it's because I wasn't breathing correctly, not because I was exceeding my aerobic capacity. Highly trained competitive swimmers don't have this problem.
- nanomonkey 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- idlewords 4y agoIN MICE link to full paper: https://aacrjournals.org/cancerres/article/82/22/4164/710131/An-Exercise-Induced-Metabolic-Shield-in-Distant https://aacrjournals.org/cancerres/article/82/22/4164/710131...
- clusterhacks 4y agoFrom the abstract: Epidemiologic data from a 20-year prospective study of a large human cohort of initially cancer-free participants revealed that exercise prior to cancer initiation had a modest impact on cancer incidence in low metastatic stages but significantly reduced the likelihood of highly metastatic cancer. Data was gathered from a large cohort via questionnaire. Looks like the study then used responses to classify high vs low intensity. From the article: The total study population included 2,734 participants; 243 new cancer cases were recorded during the 20-year follow-up period. It reads as if the study then had to reject data from 95 of the 243 patients due to not having a SEER score. From skimming the article, I can't find any analysis of metastatic disease incidence in the remaining patients? Am I just missing it?
- idlewords 4y agoThe chief result being reported here is in the mouse model, it's not 100-some people filling out a questionnaire that got them on the cover of the journal.
- pimterry 4y agoIs that true? The headline here comes straight from the human study. From the article: > The human data, obtained from an epidemiological study that monitored 3,000 individuals for about 20 years, indicated 72% less metastatic cancer in participants who reported regular aerobic activity at high intensity, compared to those who did not engage in physical exercise.
- idlewords 4y agoThat figure comes from examining 148 people in that cohort who got cancer. The authors don't state what proportion of that number is metastatic cancer. They also state: "As our focus was on the relationship between exercise and cancer, we used a propensity score of multinomial logistic regression to control for key variables in the diet assessed using a validated questionnaire." So the 73% figure is drawn from a small number of cases that were significantly weighted. I'd be interested to hear what people who know this field think about this result separate from the mouse/human exercise stuff.
- twawaaay 4y agoI am layman but can somebody explain this? Even if blood sugar level dips during the exercise it comes right back immediately after. Even if you exercise a lot, for majority of the day your blood sugar level should be nominal because nobody can exercise at the effort needed to dip your sugar for very long. So does this mean cancer cells are so hungry for sugar that they can't survive even a short term dip in sugar availability?
- hallway_monitor 4y agoSurely there have been studies on simple carbohydrate intake correlated with cancer incidence? I suppose it's hard to do a multi-decade study on something like this but it may be possible to gain evidence.
- pimterry 4y ago> So does this mean cancer cells are so hungry for sugar that they can't survive even a short term dip in sugar availability? It's not a short-term dip, according to the article: > "Examining the cells of these organs, we found a rise in the number of glucose receptors during high-intensity aerobic activity - increasing glucose intake and turning the organs into effective energy-consumption machines, very much like the muscles. We assume that this happens because the organs must compete for sugar resources with the muscles, known to burn large quantities of glucose during physical exercise. Consequently, if cancer develops, the fierce competition over glucose reduces the availability of energy that is critical to metastasis." > "Moreover," she offers, "when a person exercises regularly, this condition becomes permanent: the tissues of internal organs change and become similar to muscle tissue." I.e. exercising lots appears to change the makeup of your organs, so they absorb sugar more aggressively _all the time_ and so cancer cells have to develop in a far more sugar-competitive environment.
- ferrumfist 4y agoI'm no doctor, but it makes sense why exercise is also prescribed for countering diabetes in that case. If organs and muscles are "hungrier" for glucose when routinely exercising it seems like it would regulate blood sugar levels.
- ck2 4y agoI know of so many life-long runners that have gotten or even died from cancer. So not sure what to say otherwise but this paper is wrong and needs to be challanged.
- carl_dr 4y agoMany non-life-long runners die from cancer too. The paper suggests you need to be at 80-85% max effort to get maximum benefit, the runners I know tend to concentrate on distance and the social aspect (so are running at an effort where they can sustain a conversation), rather than getting to the end of the run as quickly as possible.
- nathan_compton 4y agoExtremely weird take. 1) the paper refers to high intensity activity like sprinting which which many lifelong runners don't do. 2) your personal experience is a random sample which is probably not representative.
- aliqot 4y agoanybody who lives long enough succumbs to cancer. anybody. not one exception. you can have the fittest heart and safest lifestyle, but your cells will always replicate with less and less accuracy, the sun and other sources of genetic damage will keep inundating you.
- ttmb 4y agoYeah, I wouldn't be surprised if more runners do die from cancer. Because they're not falling victim to all the other things that are improved by cardio fitness, etc.
- adamredwoods 4y agoAnecdotal, but related: https://seema.page/ https://seema.page/ Related HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30597187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30597187
- stevenwoo 4y ago
- anerdib 4y agoUnless you live in an area with high air pollution.
- canucker2016 4y agoThis method is attacking the Warburg effect - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warburg_effect_(oncology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warburg_effect_(oncology) and https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26778478/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26778478/ Some cancers are glucose-sensitive which use glucose to grow. Some cancer patients go on a keto diet instead of/as well as aerobic activity (a keto diet is probably better tolerated than lots of aerobic activity for many cancer patients). from https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/01/180126095312.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2018/01/180126095312.h... This dependency on sugar distinguishes cancer cells from normal cells and is often used as a treatment option to kill cancer cells. In reality, the results have not been encouraging. Not all cancer cell types are sensitive to the removal of sugar, and even for the cancers that are sensitive, sugar depletion only slows down the rate of cancer progression. The pathways that sensitise cancer cells to sugar deprivation remains poorly understood.
- nradov 4y agoLow carbohydrate diets may be a good option to improve general health for many people, however they haven't generally proven effective as cancer treatments. The clinical trials have been disappointing.
- canucker2016 4y agoThat's probably why the article says the reduction of metastatic cancer is only 72% versus 100%.
- jcims 4y ago>proven effective as cancer treatments When you're in the midst of trying to find your way through a cancer diagnosis, this statement can be incredibly frustrating. It basically turns into a cop out that medical providers use to wave off any discussion or exploration of a topic. And even if it's been proven to be effective, there's some way to slice your specific case such that it wasn't tested in the trial. Oh, you're BRCA positive? Somatic? Platinum resistant? Recurrent? Have or have not undergone this very specific therapy? Well, the trial didn't cover you so its not proven. I totally understand why, few doctors would likely want to talk about phase of the moon or rubbing crystals...but in the context of cancer treatment, the lack of any clear guidance or recommendation about diet beyond basic USDA recommendations is maddening.
- marricks 4y agoPretty great thing to read coming back from a tempo run! I just go into it this year, and I'd like to say, it's more fun than I thought. Every aspect. If you get a heart rate monitor and dive into what you're doing even difficult high intensity runs are enjoyable. It's all about expectations and if you go into it thinking - "I'm going to run at 75% of my max heart rate" you know you're going to be winded, but at the end feel great - "I'm going on an easy run 60% of max heart rate" you know you'll be able to have a nice conversation along the way and get some good thinking in etc etc, it's great. Don't start with a heart rate monitor but after a few months it adds a lot of fun for those who like geeking out on numbers and planning.
- kritiko 4y agoHave you actually tested your max heart rate? I work out with a HRM for Zone 2, but I'm just going off of Polar's zones. From what I understand going more in depth requires either maxing out your HR (Steve House describes how you can do this in Training for the New Alpinism - basically sprinting uphill until you collapse, seems really unpleasant) or doing lactate testing in a lab.
- macNchz 4y agoGetting an accurate HR Max can be useful…I got into running several years ago and struggled early on with the zone based training recommendations until I realized it was just because my max HR was higher than the various apps estimate by default. After running my first 5k race all-out, I recalculated my training zones based on a max of 205 instead of the 190 that the apps had estimated for me, and things started to make a lot more sense.
- canucker2016 4y agoA max HR test can be done on a treadmill in a gym too. Unless you're used to reaching your max HR during exercise - something I don't suggest - it will be painful, but you're not supposed to hold your heart rate at this level for long either, just long enough for the heart rate sensor to register that level.
- hypersoar 4y ago
- boc 4y agoIf anyone is looking for an easy way to get their heart rate up to max + exert themselves at max effort without doing anything too crazy, I highly recommend a C2 rowing machine. Set the program to a 5K (or 2K) and do the first half as a warmup, then go all-out for the second half. You'll easily hit your max heart rate and can try to sustain it for a minute. Doing this only takes 10-20 minutes depending on the length of your warmup, and you'll be working your entire body + cardio + lungs. Just make sure you are using correct form - start slow before going all out. I run and road bike, but rowing is easily the most efficient way to get into that HR zone quickly. You can do sprints but that's pretty hard on your legs if you aren't an active athlete. Rowing is low impact by comparison.
- Fricken 4y agoI occasionally sprint stairs. It's less impactful on the legs than flat ground sprints.
- candiddevmike 4y agoIMO, do not expect to do this right after unboxing. Realize that figuring out (and strengthening your muscle to use) the correct form takes a bit of time, and if you jump into a 5k row and you aren't feeling it in the right places/it's super easy, you absolutely are not using the right form. Rowing targets muscles most people never use, especially in your back, and it should be quite fatiguing.
- eggsmediumrare 4y agoMax effort 500m row on a C2 is a special kind of awful
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jamesgill 4y ago"...Intense aerobic exercise increases the glucose (sugar) consumption of internal organs, thereby reducing the availability of energy to the tumor." Interestingly, this is a key part of the medical argument for low-carbohydrate diets--that most human diseases are metabolic ones, including cancer, and that modern human diets are at the root of them. One discussion: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6375425/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6375425/
- msie 4y agoI get mixed feelings whenever I see one of these reports. It's nice to get more data in the fight against cancer but it doesn't look like any progress in directly attacking cancer. And there's doubt about the data too. I wonder about how much money and effort is going into such studies which is not being invested into novel techniques for attacking cancer.
- itsoktocry 4y agoI consider it a weak form of Pascal's wager. You could do cardiovascular exercise which, in theory, might possibly have a beneficial reduction in personal cancer rates (among many other potential health benefits attributed to persistent exercise). Or you could not do cardio. Seems like a no-brainer for most people.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoI’d go as far as to say that the burden of proof is on anybody claiming that exercise is not as fundamental as eating, sleeping or breathing. So this study seems obvious or at least reasonable to me.
- tux3 4y agoThe burden of proof is generally on the person standing up and making a claim, no matter how obvious the claim is or which side they're trying to prove. But even when two people make opposite claims and there's no good consensus either way, trying to assign burden of proof by what seems obvious or reasonable isn't a solution. That just takes you back to two people disagreeing about what is obvious or reasonable, it's just going in circles. Something you can do instead is put burden of proof on the person deviating from the null hypothesis, because everyone can agree on that. Crucially, the null hypothesis does *not* mean the obvious thing, or the expected thing. In the case of whether breathing is fundamental and healthy, the null hypothesis is that breathing does absolutely nothing. And of course it's not very hard to reject that one, the null hypothesis is clearly wrong here. If it really is obvious, then you shouldn't have a hard time rejecting it and all is right in the world. But trying to make a claim that's not so easy to prove, and at the same time trying to escape the burden of proof because it 'seems obvious or at least reasonable' harms your ability to notice when you're wrong. It's dangerous and it's bad epistemology.
- Unity99 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong but you can state the null hypothesis arbitrarily: "Breathing does nothing" / "Not breathing does nothing." "Aerobic exercise does not increase the probability of developing metastatic cancer" / "A sedentary lifestyle does not increase the probability of developing metastatic cancer." So, in fact your null hypothesis already has a bias of what you consider the baseline, i.e. yes-cancer or no-cancer. So in essence, you are trying to scientize for the sake of argumentation.
- tux3 4y ago>"Breathing does nothing" / "Not breathing does nothing." Right, but that's because those two are actually the same! The null hypothesis in this case does not directly say whether breathing is good or bad, instead it's a statement about the correlation of breathing to anything at all. If the null hypothesis is true, then breathing or not breathing doesn't have any effect. So the null hypothesis is not pro-breathing or anti-breathing, the null hypothesis is that it just doesn't matter either way and doesn't correlate with anything (like the person staying alive) >"Aerobic exercise does not increase the probability of developing metastatic cancer" / "A sedentary lifestyle does not increase the probability of developing metastatic cancer." With both of those, you can also reformulate them to be a statement about correlation. "What is the correlation between the amount of aerobic exercise that you do and the rate of development of metastatic cancer?" So the null hypothesis doesn't depend on whether you think exercise is good or bad. That's the subtlety. It just says that everything is neutral and nothing has any effect until proven otherwise. That doesn't mean the null hypothesis is always what makes sense, or that it's what you should believe in. Obviously breathing keeps you alive, and exercise has a lot of benefits. It's just a way to keep people from disagreeing about what's obvious and who should prove what. The null hypothesis is really dumb, and it only says that anyone who claims they found a real effect, either good or bad, should prove it. If one person is saying red wine causes cancer, and the other person is saying red wine prevents cancer, then they're both rejecting the null hypothesis, which is that you can't claim red wine correlate with anything until proven otherwise. And I promise this isn't just for the sake of the argument. There's a real difference between the mindset of trying to claim "X is good" or "X causes cancer" because it seems so obvious that someone else should just prove the opposite instead, and the much more boring idea that if something is actually kind of obvious, then you should be able to measure whether it does anything AT ALL in either direction (good or bad), and force the person actually making the claim to reject the null hypothesis.
- bob234 4y ago
- 1letterunixname 4y agoI'm sure almost anything that increases cellular stress, including calorie restriction, exercise, sleep deprivation, and chemotherapy, are adept at killing cancer cells that should theoretically be slightly less fit than healthy cells.