5 ms·
>and the fact that Wall St. will cry and have a meltdown if the apple cart is flipped Does Wall St include people directly invested in equity and debt markets
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
>and the fact that Wall St. will cry and have a meltdown if the apple cart is flipped
Does Wall St include people directly invested in equity and debt markets via 401k/IRA/defined benefit (DB) pensions/etc and indirectly via being taxpayers of jurisdictions that have taken on those DB pension liabilities?
- trgn 4y agoLol yeah. The apple cart has already flipped. The "rich" are seeing their balance sheet completely melt down right now, and may even get worse still. People get what they want, and it's still not good. In this case, triumph of labor, high wage growth, low employment, and rentiers scurrying to eek out any kind of gain.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoOr anyone buying a home, or working for a company that uses debt to bridge cash flow, or anyone who uses infrastructure like roads. What I’m curious about is what component of inflation is the fact even with shipping rates dropped a ton they’re still twice what they were pre pandemic and fuel costs, which drives a marginal cost of any physical good, being so high? Maybe it’s a war disrupting energy prices and food? Inflation is caused when demand is higher than supply can meet. Given the worlds ability to produce JIT it feels implausible that supply can’t meet demand if inflation were just left alone. I don’t know that making everyone poorer to reduce demand is the right answer. Maybe just let inflation happen for a while and keep capital cheap so we can invest rapidly in expanding supply?
- danuker 4y ago> Given the worlds ability to produce JIT it feels implausible that supply can’t meet demand if inflation were just left alone. Just as you can not deliver a baby in one month with 9 pregnant women, you can not grow food faster than it takes. Also, there is no "leaving alone". As a central bank, you have to choose an interest rate, and this affects bond yields, stock prices, and financing costs (such as to produce said food).
- fnordpiglet 4y agoYou can grow more food with more money as long as we have land to grow food on. As food becomes more expensive more food will be grown. If it gets expensive enough vertical farms and other capital intensive growing capacity would be viable (as long as capital is cheap). Your analogy is false because you’re measuring latency and calling it bandwidth. If I want more babies in a shorter amount of time then absolutely 9 pregnant women wins over trying to make one woman pregnant 9 times. With food we want more food and plants grow in parallel. It’s not about the first grain of rice, it’s about the trillionth. Leaving alone in what I said means “don’t mess with the cost of capital and let people borrow to expand supply as fast as we can.” Eventually as we grow capacity to produce and people compete for higher prices we will overshoot supply, a consolidation will occur, and prices will drop. Trying to decrease supply expansion by making it more expensive to borrow to fund expansion will not improve supply. It will indirectly reduce demand by inducing savings and inducing a decrease in economic activity and a recession and unemployment, and therefore suffering.
- matwood 4y ago> Given the worlds ability to produce JIT it feels implausible that supply can’t meet demand if inflation were just left alone. I mostly agree. We see a clear supply problem right now. China's covid lockdowns mean any new iPhone Pro ordered today will not be here until next year.
- delusional 4y agoLeaving inflation alone disproportionally affects the people who don't have a lot to begin with. 10% inflation is much more palatable when that's your coffee budget than when it's your rent.
- scythe 4y agoThe petit bourgeois are indeed included in the investor class in this hypothetical. Bailouts of defined-benefit pension plans would probably only be necessary if the high-interest regime continues for many years. The fact is that real wages have declined substantially YoY [1] for the working class due to price increases and this is a typical impact of a high-inflation environment. Protecting homeowners by bleeding the people who still have adult roommates is morally decrepit. 1: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/realer.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/realer.nr0.htm
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Bailouts of defined-benefit pension plans would probably only be necessary if the high-interest regime continues for many years. In my perspective, the bailout has been happening for decades, every time the federal government steps in to prevent broad market prices from substantially declining. Not only have politicians been keeping labor costs low by using high ROI assumptions, they have been underfunding DB pension plans even with those rosy assumptions providing low costs for budgeting purposes. For this reason, I think it is safe to assume the government will backstop equity prices over the long term (5+ years). It would not be politically popular amongst the voting population to let them fall. https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/2022/07/07/states-unfunded-pension-liabilities-persist-as-major-long-term-challenge https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/...