8 ms·
The thing that this piece really got me thinking about is how many other crypto companies are the same ponzi scheme because they are counting made-up things as
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
The thing that this piece really got me thinking about is how many other crypto companies are the same ponzi scheme because they are counting made-up things as assets on their balance sheet.
In other words, suppose I create token SCAMMER, and I say its supply will be capped at 1 million tokens (or 10 million, or 100 million - that's the "nice" thing about crypto, I can kinda choose whatever number I want), and then I'm able to sell 10 of those tokens for $100 each. According to FTX math, I now have $99,999,000 of assets on my balance sheet, but of course if I actually tried to sell a lot of my "kept" tokens I would tank the SCAMMER price.
Even better, and I think what is probably more common in the crypto industry: suppose I get my buddy to create a SUX2BEU token. I tell my buddy I'll by 10 SUX2BEU tokens for $100 each if he buys 10 of my SCAMMER tokens for $100 each. Now suddenly we can both say we have huge assets on our balance sheets! Until, of course, someone decides to pull aside the curtain covering the wizard.
So many ponzi schemes on top of ponzi schemes...
- rossdavidh 4y agoPaul Graham wrote an essay years ago in which he described the moment when he realized that most of the dot-com companies in the late 90's were selling their ads mostly to other dot-com companies, who were buying their ads in turn. It looked like growing revenue for everyone, but once it came time to show a profit, all of it came crashing down...
- hef19898 4y agoThe lesson drawn, and a good one as an investor, was the YC advice that start-ups should build stuff for other start-ups.
- jgalt212 4y agoIt worked like a charm for AWS.
- justinator 4y agoIn what world is AWS a startup?
- lazide 4y agoWhen AWS was starting?
- Nowado 4y agoYou mean when they separated internal infrastructure of the largest ecommerce in the world to the point when it was possible to sell it in commodified pieces to other businesses?
- vasco 4y agoThat is not what happened and is a fake myth origin story. AWS was started from scratch with a small team in south africa. The best description of all the myths and the real thing I've heard is here: https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/amazon-web-services https://www.acquired.fm/episodes/amazon-web-services It sounds good to perpetuate the "but Amazon.com had extra capacity they could sell" but it's not true.
- smachiz 4y agoI mean... a little disingenuous. AMZN was a $10-20B publicly traded company at that time. When is it a startup vs a product offering of an established company?
- loeg 4y agoSell shovels in a gold rush?
- hef19898 4y agoWhich is a solid plan. Unless, of course, you buy the shovels with futures on potential gold finds and expect the resulting shovel rush to go on forever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hintymad 4y agoBut aren't startups doing the same thing as PG said nowadays? That is, portfolio companies use each other's products to boost their revenue and user base.
- timkam 4y agoStill, in B2B you typically want to show you have some megacorp logos (in particular due to larger deal size and up-sell potential), are attractive to different industries, et cetera. So this may be a known issue, but it's also considered when assessing startups.
- jonny_eh 4y agoSpaceX just bought a bunch of ads on Twitter. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/14/spacex-just-bought-a-big-ad-campaign-on-twitter-for-starlink.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/14/spacex-just-bought-a-big-ad-...
- belval 4y ago> According to internal documents viewed by CNBC, SpaceX has spent more than $160,000 on the Twitter ad campaign for Starlink in Australia and Spain so far. Your definition for "a bunch" is a bit questionable, but good on you for posting the source.
- freejazz 4y agoAll this without your own definition of a "bunch"!
- belval 4y agoYou got me. I wonder if we did a poll, how much money is "a bunch of money" and how much money is "a bunch of money on ads" for people. I think if it had been $500k or $1M I would've called it a bunch, but $160k seems low.
- 4y ago
- pewter_wiz 4y ago
- physicsguy 4y agoI do think of this a bit when I see startups being the main customers of other startup’s products. For e.g. I’ve never in my career at big orgs and small orgs alike had authority to just go and purchase $50/dev/month on productivity tooling for my teams, so I’ve never quite worked out who is paying for these
- mcintyre1994 4y agoAd-supported mobile games seem to work like this too, all their ads are for other free ad-supported mobile games. Also I downloaded a QR code scanning app and every time I tried to scan a QR code it showed me an ad for another QR code scanning app lol.
- fvdessen 4y agoThat's because the easiest to get new customers for a mobile game are the ones who play similar games but not yet this one. The customers then play the game and buy more in-game currency than was paid for the ads.
- gloryjulio 4y agoThe whales foot the final bills though. Unlike the vc's money which goes through economical cycles, there will always be suckers for those gacha gambling games
- conviencefee999 4y agoThose whales are something else. That's all I'm going to say.
- robswc 4y agoI will _never_ understand sinking money into a mobile game like that. Blows my mind. Couldn't even be worth the effort.
- HWR_14 4y agoThere are two types of whales. Those who plow an objectively large but relatively (to them) small sum into the game are fine. Those who fell victim to psychological programming to feed every dollar in are not.
- conviencefee999 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hammock 4y agoThe housing market was the same way in 2008… in fact the entire global financial system is built that way. It’s what they mean when they say there are $60 trillion (or whatever) in derivatives out there, a long chain of the same assets rehypothecated over and over. It works though, mostly
- kodah 4y agoI somewhat disagree with this on the surface. 2008 was a byproduct of banks holding ratings companies (Moody's and Standard and Poor's) hostage. The banks gave completely fraudulent ratings to loans, the ratings companies falsified ratings on packages, and eventually the house of cards came tumbling down when enough people tried to pull their money out. There is a way to rate and classify derivatives appropriately, you just can't hold the ratings people hostage. I don't think there's a way to do that with crypto.
- highwaylights 4y agoThis. The banks weren’t to blame for 2008 any more than were the hoardes of FOMO buyers - in that they were both pretty culpable but neither of them were the real problem. Lax regulation of the rating agencies was the real smoking gun. I’m not even sure it was ever addressed given all the banker witch hunts that ensued, and will next time too. Dave Chappelle was on Saturday Night Live this past week and did a bit in the monologue about why we can’t have good regulations. Worth checking out: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_m-gO0HSCYk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_m-gO0HSCYk (Starts at 8:50)
- fortran77 4y agoA lot of those "FOMO Buyers" lied on their mortgage applications and suffered no repercussions. In fact, many of them ended up doing quite well despite crying "Boo Hoo! I lost my house." The spent their HELOC and never had to pay it back, they took the "first time homebuyers tax credit", and many of them lived in the house they "bought" for a year or two without paying any mortgage payment until the bank finally took it back. They never paid income tax on any forgiven debt, and they never paid income tax on the imputed income from living in a nice house for a couple of years rent-free until the bank finally was able to take possession of it.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoIOW reference counting cannot detect circular garbage.
- forgingahead 4y agoThis is a rich observation, since (anecdotally) it seems like all the initial customers/traction for YC companies is from other YC companies. Nothing wrong at all, it's good to bootstrap an initial customer base and get some user-feedback, but until the chasm is crossed to "real" customers, one could argue that this is the same case nowadays. So the dotcom time was no better nor worse than right now in terms of startup viability.
- drexlspivey 4y agoThat’s a common problem when dealing with illiquid assets and not a characteristic of just crypto. For example a VC firm buys 10% shares of a company valued $1B at their latest round. Then the market tanks but no one really knows what these shares are worth because they are not trading anywhere so you don’t have a price to mark them. As a result you mark them in your books with the latest round price at $100m even though they might be worth much much less.
- cykros 4y agoIt boggles my mind that lenders aren't all wise to this nonsense, and severely mark down these assets, if not completely refuse to allow them as collateral. I suppose that at least many banks got very hard up over the last 10 years of next to zero interest (next to on one side or other of it depending on where in the world they operate), so they were probably more willing than usual to lend money for the chance at getting a return on it. Curious to see which banks are getting hit hardest for exposure to FTX loans -- that hasn't been something I've been hearing much about yet.
- Chyzwar 4y agoCompany have valuation would be based on recorded revenue, profit or at least growth rate. When buying a stake in a company, there is a whole legal framework and due diligence. Crypto token just have the bunch of wash trades to support theirs valuation and no transparency.
- codyb 4y agoAlthough, according to Matt Levine who writes Money Matters, that can sometimes be a feature instead of a bug whereby private firms are better able to ride bad market conditions than public firms are. In some cases you could see it being positive not having your stock price drop everytime the Fed announces a new rate increase or jump everytime they don't (or etc etc with other events) if your primary goal is to continue at a steady pace to achieve some goal.
- am3101 4y agoSmall note: it’s Cliff Asness from AQR who came up with the illiquidity “premium,” though Levine does report it a lot. This matters a bit bc AQR is a large hedge fund that trades in liquids and therefore is marked frequently… there’s a bit of self-serving bias here (although may still be true).
- twblalock 4y agoIf you made a coin that was actually called ScamCoin people would buy it, because they would believe they could sell it to someone else for a profit.
- yojo 4y agoEmpirically true. See: PonziCoin https://techweez.com/2018/01/26/ponzicoin-crypto-scheme/ https://techweez.com/2018/01/26/ponzicoin-crypto-scheme/
- twblalock 4y agoDogeCoin was supposed to be a parody and people actually bought it. Also my phone does not flag DogeCoin as a misspelled word. Anyone who invests in this stuff is either really dumb, or morally impaired yet smart enough to exploit people who are really dumb.
- pram 4y ago
- smsm42 4y agoDid Elon seriously invest in Doge? I was assuming he was just having fun, in his own way.
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- Anon1096 4y agoYou're not describing a Ponzi scheme, you're describing wash trading and fraudulent accounting.
- advisedwang 4y agopeople pay in, and that money is spent on (making the project look good|delivering a yield|paying execs|propping up a trading company|whatever) and then the money is not there anymore for withdrawals. That's the essence of a Ponzi scheme and this meets that criterion. Sure, there's fraudlent accounting, and wash trading, and other bullshit, but that's all just the some and mirrors that allows the ponzi scheme to work.
- basch 4y agothats not what a ponzi scheme is. a ponzi scheme reports a profit, and pays out that profit to early investors. (the payout is actually later investors inflow.) the only one of the ones you mentioned that is actually a ponzi scheme is the "delivering a yield." its the yield delivery, aka dividend, that makes it a ponzi scheme, not just fraudulently running away with the money. the scheme works because people get paid out regularly, and have no reason to believe their money isnt working for them.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoYou are wrong. In a ponzi people are often encouraged to reinvest their gains. You only take the money of new investors to pay out early investors if really necessary (that is to maintain the illusion that the money is still there) otherwise you use the money for something else or yourself. exactly how crypto works.
- felipellrocha 4y agoJust because that is a common feature of ponzi schemes, that alone doesn't make it a ponzi scheme. A ponzi scheme takes some sort of initial investment from new investors and gives that back to old investors in form of "return". Meaning, the system itself doesn't rely on any sort of growth in order to return, only the sign up of new people into the scheme, which is why they can seemingly deliver such reliable returns to early investors. Eventually you run out of new people to sign up, and the entire house of cards falls apart very quickly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mgraczyk 4y agoThis isn't a ponzi scheme as others have pointed out. This is well understood and goes on all the time in NFTs, it's usually called wash trading. People in crypto know this is happening. The reason they still speculate is because it's hard to predict when it will collapse, and some people think they have an edge predicting that sort of thing.
- waynesonfire 4y agoI think artwork also works this way. I have 10 piece of art drawn by Mr. Artist. My friend buys a piece for 1 million dollars, I now have ~9 million dollars of "assets". These shenanigans have been going on for a long time in wealthy groups.
- smsm42 4y agoThat's why you see all kinds of fintechs trying to push art investment into the masses nowdays. They want the stupid money.
- pseudo0 4y agoAnd then you donate the art to a foundation or charity and pocket a fat tax credit, thus avoiding the problem of having to actually find a sucker to pay $1 million. Some jurisdictions have cracked down on this, but for a long time it was a popular way to game the system.
- at-fates-hands 4y ago>> So many ponzi schemes on top of ponzi schemes... Isn't this what happened with Quadriga exchange? The regulator said Thursday that Vancouver-based Quadriga's late founder Gerald Cotten committed fraud by opening accounts under aliases and crediting himself with fictitious currency and crypto asset balances, which he traded with unsuspecting clients. On Thursday, the OSC attributed about $115 million of the $169 million clients lost to Cotten's "fraudulent" trading. Another $28 million was lost when Cotten used client assets on three external crypto asset trading platforms without authorization or disclosure. The OSC said he also misappropriated millions in client assets to fund his "lavish" lifestyle and because he was in sole control of the company ever since 2016, he "ran the business as he saw fit, with no proper system of internal oversight or controls or proper books and records." https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/osc-quadriga-gerald-cotten-1.5607990 https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/osc-quadriga-gerald-cotten-...
- gruez 4y agoThat's just regular theft/embezzlement, not a ponzi.
- aqme28 4y agoYou don't even need a buddy for that. Just make another anonymous address to buy your token from yourself. Or a dozen, it doesn't matter.
- nemo44x 4y agoIt's shitcoins all the way down.
- ignoramous 4y agoSee also: Basecamp valuation tops $100,000,000,000 after bold VC investment (2015), https://archive.is/A0Wb1 https://archive.is/A0Wb1
- tacheiordache 4y ago> In other words, suppose I create token SCAMMER, and I say its supply will be capped at 1 million tokens (or 10 million, or 100 million - that's the "nice" thing about crypto, I can kinda choose whatever number I want), and then I'm able to sell 10 of those tokens for $100 each. According to FTX math, I now have $99,999,000 of assets on my balance sheet, but of course if I actually tried to sell a lot of my "kept" tokens I would tank the SCAMMER price. Anybody can do that, true. What you also need is credibility and willingness to destroy that. Look at Fried Bankman, he had had tons of pedigree and knew what ears to wisper too. He apparently wasn't saying anything smart and yet people believed him. He was even rude and playing videgames during meetings and yet people believed him. It's easy and yet it isn't. I think scammers have qualities normal people don't have and when all those line up we get a super bankrun like what happened in this case.
- mikodin 4y agoOne thing to note is that this is distinctly the differentiator of AMMs (automated market makers), Uniswap for example. Here are the docs for V1 (V3 is different, but the core pieces remain) https://docs.uniswap.org/protocol/V1/introduction https://docs.uniswap.org/protocol/V1/introduction. V2 docs have fun diagrams if that is useful for you https://docs.uniswap.org/protocol/V2/concepts/protocol-overview/how-uniswap-works https://docs.uniswap.org/protocol/V2/concepts/protocol-overv... It's quite interesting, and essentially what happens is that a pairing pool is created, ETH <> Shtcoin for example. So now for that shtcoin to have "value" it needs to be liquid within the pool, ie can go into ETH. The cost of the coin is determined mathematically based on the ratio each side of the pool.