10 ms·
It's super funny that identity verification of authors of things published was basically more than half of the value twitter provided to its users, both readers
by scotty79 4y ago
It's super funny that identity verification of authors of things published was basically more than half of the value twitter provided to its users, both readers and writers and the first thing Elon did was to destroy it.
Just to replace it with what he calls "payment verified", which basically means you have 8$ and means to send it to twitter. Which apparently is worth less than nothing.
It kind of reminds me how a while back somebody posted proposed redesign of stackoverflow to make it more nice from UX perspective. However this person wasn't a user of stackoverflow and didn't understand how much value which features provide and suggested changes that would make very valuable features removed or made less easily accessible while bringing to the front features that are not very useful.
I think it just helps to be a user of the product and have a deep understanding for it before you make any changes. Elon used twitter a lot, but in pretty unusual fashion (because he's world famous billionaire) so he really didn't understand what's most valuable part and took it for granted.
It's really a bit surprising that noone told him that his tweets are worth anything only because people reading them can know they come from Elon not some guy who paid 8$ to call himself Elon on Twitter.
- tablespoon 4y ago> I think it just helps to be a user of the product and have a deep understanding for it before you make any changes. Elon used twitter a lot, but in pretty unusual fashion (because he's world famous billionaire) so he really didn't understand what's most valuable part and took it for granted. And it also doesn't take a genius to make changes a little slower and more conservatively. For instance, in this case they should have at least added ID verification (of the kind Facebook sometimes forces people to do), and only allowed people to verify their real names for $8. It seems like Musk also got too used to people cutting him slack for his crap at Tesla and SpaceX, but those companies have mission narratives that people can "believe in." That's not the case for Twitter, and it's looking like Musk is going to slam into the ground without that net to catch him. It also doesn't help that there's a Twitter replacement (Mastodon) waiting in the wings. IIRC, Bad decisions like Musk's killed Digg, because Reddit was there to take the exodus.
- ryandvm 4y agoThe biggest difference between Twitter and every one of Musk's successful companies is that his typical ventures absolutely depend on US federal largesse to survive. Unless Twitter can start selling carbon credits or secure some bloated federal contracts, there is no chance in hell that Twitter is going to be in the black any time soon.
- willcipriano 4y agoCharge the US government to censor posts like they are currently doing for free?
- georgeg23 4y agoCould be like Palantir and provide a bunch of citizen tracking analytics to govt. If you don't already know Elon's govt scheming, read about Mike Griffin and Elons missile defense contracts with the US DoD. https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin#Career https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin#Career
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoThis is just completely untrue for Tesla. Carbon credits make up less than 10 percent of Tesla's profit. They had 250 million in carbon credits last quarter and 3.3 billion profit.
- midoridensha 4y agoGovernment incentives helped them get to their current level of profitability. Not just in the US either: in Norway, for instance, there's a huge environmental tax on gas-burning cars, but EVs are exempt since they don't burn fossil fuel, so Teslas end up being quite cheap by comparison and are therefore very popular there. You're being disingenuous by claiming carbon credits are the only form of government largesse or incentive.
- DoesntMatter22 4y ago
- blindseer 4y agoIf you asked Elon (atleast before he stepped into Twitter HQ) I'm sure he'd disagree with you, and he'd claim good ideas can come from anywhere and it shouldn't matter who they are or if they are important. It remains to be seen if learning has occurred.
- danudey 4y agoIt's classic "If I don't understand it, then it must be easy" syndrome. Oh, Twitter is full of bots! So when I'm in charge I'm going to press the "no more bots" button and save Twitter! Also, the company only needs half this much staff, so we're going to spend a few days firing half of them and then the company will be better off! Elon's not gonna learn because that would tarnish his image of someone who has any idea what the heck he's doing.
- watwut 4y agoAnd the company is doing too many RPC calls. And we will take down overbloated "microservices" (where the apostrophes kinda give suggest he is not at home with the concept).
- philjohn 4y agoOne of those appears to be the SMS verification one.
- regpertom 4y agoRPC calls is like ATM machine. Musk’s tweet says RPC’s. The person quoted everywhere arguing with Musk over it’s tweet says RPC calls. Does that count as apostrophe misuse suggesting not being at home with the concept as well?
- glhaynes 4y agoAs the classic Twitter meme says: "I would simply…"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kadutskyi 4y agoYou can have a fake ID. I would calculate that "payment verified" is way cheaper than full identity verification. But it's easier to create several iClouds with the same cc, so you still need to check IDs, but you can compare newly created accounts (or ones that changed their name) with existing accounts and check for similarities and flag those accounts. The thing is that you can automate that and you need to do that only for a small percent of subscribed users. Instead of fully checking everyone's identity you check only flagged accounts.
- danudey 4y ago> Just to replace it with what he calls "payment verified", which basically means you have 8$ and means to send it to twitter. Which apparently is worth less than nothing. 1. Create a new Apple account 2. Buy a $10 iTunes gift card 3. Use that to pay for Twitter Blue Would I pay $10 and twenty minutes of my time to knock $20bn off of an insulin profiteer's stock price? Absolutely. Put me down for a recurring subscription.
- partiallypro 4y agoYou can block gift cards in most payment gateways, I imagine you could do similar with Apple's system. There also is mixed evidence that Eli Lilly's stock actually went down from the tweet, given it reacted hours after the tweet and never recovered (usually fake news items effecting price will immediately correct back to the previous trading level.) Several articles I read about it bury this deep in the article, basically alluding to "we'll never actually know why the stock went down." I would imagine their new Alzheimer's drug looming had more to do with it, but idk. It also becomes slightly questionable about if a quant, etc fund would not know the difference between accounts, when you really think about it...it sounds improbable.
- duskwuff 4y agoIf you're accepting payments for in-app purchases through iOS, all the billing for that happens through Apple. The app developer has no control (or knowledge) of how those payments were funded.
- techsupporter 4y ago> You can block gift cards in most payment gateways, I imagine you could do similar with Apple's system. What GP means is to go to a grocery store and lay out 10 American Dollars for an Apple-branded services gift card (what used to be called an iTunes Gift Card). One of these: https://www.apple.com/shop/gift-cards https://www.apple.com/shop/gift-cards You apply it to the brand new Apple ID you've made and use those virtual funds to make the in-app purchase in the Twitter app that, at the time, was the method of paying for Twitter Blue. (The purchase page even said/says, "You can only subscribe on the Twitter iOS app (for now).") No blocking of prepaid or gift cards here; you're doing exactly what Apple wants and it's not Apple's problem that Twitter takes IAPs for a "verified" service.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoHe's turned a useful service into an opportunity to pay real money for a little blue gif. Like NFTs, except you don't even get a unique monkey pic. Extremely Fungible Tokens.
- sytelus 4y agoThey should have done actual verification like many financial accounts do (you upload your ID and answer questions on your past). Musk is ex-payments professional and should have known that gaming payments to adversely attack verification was bound to happen. His assertion that lords and peasant system needs to be dismantled is absolutely correct, however. Twitter has largely turned into message distribution system for 1% and that's limiting its growth. Blue checkmarks bestowed by some opaque priesthood at Twitter is not 21st century.
- themitigating 4y ago"Twitter has largely turned into message distribution system for 1% and that's limiting its growth. Blue checkmarks bestowed by some opaque priesthood at Twitter is not 21st century." But at least the blue check system was mostly correct. Imagine how much a blue check would cost if it was opened to the public and the level of verification pre-elon was used . Right now the $8 was just a code change and let's just call it 100% profit. With actual verification you'd need a bunch more people and one of those identity verification services and now that $8 isn't pure profit
- strangattractor 4y agoThey need an extra 1 billion per year. 1,000,000,000.00/($8X12 months) = 10.5 million verifications of pictures and IDs. Work force slashed in half. Questionable management decision making. Seems like the head winds are pretty strong for not being really successful or getting true verification implemented.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> His assertion that lords and peasant system needs to be dismantled is absolutely correct, however. Not such a great system when a bunch of peasants convince themselves to believe in lies. "Everyone gets a voice to say damaging things" is the road to ruin.
- shapefrog 4y ago> His assertion that lords and peasant system needs to be dismantled is absolutely correct, however. But what if the entire business model was/is actually a lord and peasant system. Whereby lords can, while verified and identified as lords, communicate with the masses of pesants without any other gatekeepers. The peasants having their chit chat on the side isnt the point, that is the noise and the lords are the signal.
- partiallypro 4y agoUnverified accounts provide most of the good content on Twitter, so I think you're wrong there. What should have happened is you do have an $8 (I think $8 is too much, but alas) verification, but you simply make the badge different. Some people say that defeats the purpose, but it doesn't. You then know you are talking to someone with a vested interest, and since credit cards are now linked to the account you can do more high value advertising to those customers. You also get the ability to edit, have slightly less ads, etc. It's such a simple solution. I don't know why Elon is being stubborn about it being the exact same, or why people are totally against the idea of new verification methods. Getting verified previously with a small account was cumbersome and took ages.
- blackoil 4y agoBlue tick was something that was seen as authority and was coveted, Musk wouldn't have got one tenth of people to subscribe for golden tick.
- partiallypro 4y agoThe blue check isn't coveted by most, there's even a meme about it being a mark of shame. I really think people that don't use Twitter often overestimate the importance of blue check accounts. If anything, they are the butt of a lot of jokes/content vs creating it. I am interested in the new Twitter Blue, but actually don't want the checkmark, but think it needs more features. That being said, a normal user shouldn't have the same mark as an official Microsoft or government account. A secondary mark make sense, especially imo if only other paid and verified accounts can see the mark (I would just make it a hollow verified icon vs it being a different color.) Then it creates a network "in crowd" effect (similar to the green v blue text bubbles.) You also need to pair that with better tools and features.
- Haga 4y ago
- scotty79 4y ago> Unverified accounts provide most of the good content on Twitter, I don't think good content is the core value of twitter. In my perception value of twitter is who said what. Good or bad. I don't use twitter and have contact with twitter only when it's cited elsewhere and bulk of most popular citations are mostly not "here's interesting thought someone had on twitter" but rather "this celebrity/politician/office tweeted that".
- lawn 4y ago> It kind of reminds me how a while back somebody posted proposed redesign of stackoverflow to make it more nice from UX perspective. However this person wasn't a user of stackoverflow and didn't understand how much value which features provide and suggested changes that would make very valuable features removed or made less easily accessible while bringing to the front features that are not very useful. To be completely fair, this is my feeling about the web Twitter and especially Reddit UI.
- Ra8 4y ago> Just to replace it with what he calls "payment verified", which basically means you have 8$ and means to send it to twitter. Which apparently is worth less than nothing. I keep seeing this everywhere, that the switch from being verified to "payment verified" made that possible. It was possible to do this attack before the change. It just made it easier but also traceable with the payment info.
- user_named 4y agoNo, it literally had not happened before.
- hysan 4y ago> It's really a bit surprising that noone told him that his tweets are worth anything only because people reading them can know they come from Elon not some guy who paid 8$ to call himself Elon on Twitter. Given how obvious it is, a more logical premise might be to assume someone did and Elon chose to believe otherwise.
- theshrike79 4y agoThe only thing they had to do was have someone's nephew draw a different symbol for the $8 tier and use that instead of the very well known Verified badge. That's it. This whole debacle would've been instantly avoided.
- sangnoir 4y agoTrue, but who wants the dollar-store version if the verification mark? Twitter is/was selling the prestige of the badge and what it represents to some, specifically "I am a notable individual". Any other symbol would only mean "I paid $8 for this", and my guess is that isn't quite as compelling.
- theshrike79 4y agoThen take the old blue mark and make it ... green like the money you paid for it? :)
- sangnoir 4y ago> It's really a bit surprising that noone told him that his tweets are worth anything only because people reading them can know they come from Elon not some guy who paid 8$ to call himself Elon on Twitter. I'm aware of no less than 3 formerly verified individuals who did tell him[1] before the feature launched, and he responded by banning them for impersonating him and instituting a "no lying about who you are" rule that empirically works on an honor system, or upon pain of forfeiting $8. 1. "Showed him" would be more accurate, but he shockingly failed to grasp the point they were making.
- regpertom 4y agoMusk didn’t institute that rule, the rule was already in place. Musk’s change was to ban without first giving a warning.
- widforss 4y agoExcept for obvious parodies. And Mario giving the finger is an obvious parody.
- regpertom 4y agoGiven a list of all twitter bans, there would surely be many that we would both agree are obvious parodies. So, obvious is relative, or, a grey area/high weasel potential area to do what you want. So it’s not obvious that anything has changed there either. That’s besides the point though that, while widely reported and repeated, Musk, as far as I’m aware, did not institute the rule about impersonation.
- freejazz 4y agoIf you seriously think that Nintendo would tweet a picture of Mario "flipping the bird", you don't come across as a neutral arbiter, you come across as someone ridiculous.
- 4y ago
- ahMath8 4y ago
- DoesntMatter22 4y agoIn general I'm a fan of Elon, not his crazy political stuff, but just the cool businesses he does. But this twitter thing beginning to end has mostly been a disaster. I think he's mostly unfairly hated, in that almost any CEO is as bad or worse but he's his own worst enemy with twitter. He's alienated a lot of people and then alienates them more by saying people should boycott thier products.
- andrei_says_ 4y ago> Which apparently is worth less than nothing. It’s much worse than that. Selling the verification check mark to anyone with $8 poisoned the platform instantaneously. It’s a bit like the DMV suddenly starting to sell driver licenses without any proof that you are who you say you are. Immediate erasure of the trustworthiness of any driver’s license, forever. I cannot imagine that Musk was not aware or made aware of this consequence. He did it anyway. Possibly after firing the people who warned him.
- hayyyyydos 4y ago> a while back somebody posted proposed redesign of stackoverflow to make it more nice from UX perspective Interested in reading more about this, do you have any links?
- Jiro 4y agoTwitter itself pre-Musk started killing the meaning of bluechecks back in 2017, where they officially changed their rules from "this person is who he says he is" to "this person is who he says he is, and is politically correct". It was a controversy at the time: https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/11/twitter-our-blue-check-marks-arent-just-about-verification/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2017/11/twitt... I'm amazed that people have already forgotten this.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoIt's really a bit surprising that noone told him that his tweets are worth anything only because people reading them can know they come from Elon not some guy who paid 8$ to call himself Elon on Twitter. How was that not obvious? The current situation Twitter is in is the most naive prediction. If Mr. Musk needed someone to point this out to him and ask why it wouldn't go down this way, I'm not sure what to say. Hell, a bunch of comedians actually pointed this out by changing their names and avatars to Elon Musk and impersonating him. Elon banned them. It really should have clicked at this point.
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> suggested changes that would make very valuable features removed or made less easily accessible while bringing to the front features that are not very useful I see this a lot in redesigns, and it's always "oh people aren't using this thing that I think they should, it must be because they don't know about it" and not "it must not be what they want". It's like that thing that people do when they come into the room and say "oh why are you sitting in the dark" and switch on the lights, without stopping to check why you're sitting in the dark. I know how to switch on a light, it's just that right now I'm loading a camera.
- cactusplant7374 4y agoIs anyone really fooled by fake profiles? I thought twitter verification is a way to get boosted by the algo? I see many influencers with less than 10k followers that are verified. Who is going to impersonate them? No one.