13 ms·
FTX fiasco sparks billions of dollars of outflows from exchanges
- jefb 4y agoSure looks like a bank run. I'll set the line on an official entry here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_runs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bank_runs at 4.5 days.
- criddell 4y agoBank run doesn't seem like the correct term since the exchanges aren't banks.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoBut they've been acting like them, leveraging reserves into even riskier coins.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoIt's the same dynamics, though, and "bank run" is the historical term used for these dynamics, i.e. institution takes depositors funds, institution loans out funds to other parties (the difference in the crypto case is that it appears this was done illegally, while in banking it's the underpinning for our financial system), and then there is a crisis of confidence where people run to take their money out, with the fear that you don't want to be last in line when the run starts.
- c7b 4y agoi) that's not how banks work [0] ii) that's not how these exchanges work. if they are non-fraudulent, they'd have to hold cryptocurrency and cash on behalf of their clients. they'd never have a problem meeting withdrawal requests (the critical element of bank runs) iii) crypto exchanges, if they are non-fraudulent, would be an equivalent to stock brokers, not banks [0] https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2019/12/20/Money-Creation-in-Fiat-and-Digital-Currency-Systems-48843 https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/WP/Issues/2019/12/20/Mon...
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThat absolutely is how banks work. Yes, there are fundamentally complexities under the covers, but banks take deposits and make loans - that is their fundamental purpose. Your points about "that's not how these exchanges work" is just a rephrasing of the point I made where the assets were loaned out illegally.
- c7b 4y agoHave you even had a look at the article that I linked? You are making a claim without providing any backup whatsoever for your position, after it's already been pointed out to you with a scholarly reference that your belief is wrong.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoSuggestion: if you're trying to make a point, state it. Linking to 40 page article about the theory behind monetary creation in the modern world is not exactly a good way to make your argument against the statement that "banks take deposits and make loans". I honestly don't know how one can argue against that, it is simply true to anyone who has used a bank. I did not make any larger statement about the mechanics of modern-day money creation.
- c7b 4y agoIt's in the abstract already: money creation is a result of bank's loan creation - the two are connected. Banks don't take deposits that they then lend out, they instead create those deposits ex nihilo when they make a loan.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThe difference is still useless pedantry for the purposes of a discussion about bank runs. If a bank makes a lot loans, and those loans go bad, and then depositors are fearful for their money and make a run on the bank, it is the depositors who are still shit out of luck unless their deposits are insured. You can argue all you want that the traditional model of fractional reserve banking isn't how today's money creation works, but at the end of the day there is a direct line between the quality of a bank's assets (its loans) and the ability for it to service its liabilities (its deposits).
- chasd00 4y ago> since the exchanges aren't banks These aren't anything though, they're made up by the founders. They don't behave like any typical financial institution. These things are just implementations of functionality, the fact that they are trusted with large amounts of money by random people on the internet is really good marketing and promises of riches.
- ktta 4y agoWell maybe we should find a new term, because atleast in the US, bank runs on actual banks aren't possible anymore due to the fed mandated reserve requirement being 0% and banks being able to print new $ These events are the closest we can get to bank runs today
- bandrami 4y agoIronically historical bank runs were mostly on thrifts or savings & loans, which also aren’t banks.
- bragr 4y agohttps://archive.ph/U3Veb https://archive.ph/U3Veb
- boringg 4y agoI mean if FTX was being held up as the highest quality this should absolutely cause fear that there are worse actors on fringier exchanges.
- headsoup 4y agoOr over at bitfinex
- headsoup 4y agoI'm sure the article means attempted outflows from Exchanges. They have a funny knack of pausing outflows in times like these because of system issues, aside the outflows through the also coincidental hacks.
- hamiltonians 4y agothis is bullish only because coins that are not on exchanges cannot be sold
- AkshatJ27 4y agoIs this satirical? P2P exchanges exist.
- hamiltonians 4y agovolume is tiny and does not impact market
- cma 4y agoNo one really connects decentralized P2P though: https://cryptobriefing.com/metamask-opensea-blocks-expose-centralization-in-web3/ https://cryptobriefing.com/metamask-opensea-blocks-expose-ce...
- z9znz 4y agoFTX is just one input. Seeing that Crypto.com has 20% of their reserves stored in a pointless sh-tcoin (SHIB) is just further proof that people running cryptocurrency exchanges are idiots or greedy fools. One or another variation of this story has played out many times already. Then the whole sand castle crumbles, and a lot of fake money gets wiped away. The entire cryptocurrency space is just an unregulated gambling arena. There may be some solid, well-intentioned efforts within it, but they are completely overshadowed (and overcapitalized) by the purely insane gambling ones.
- gghhzzgghhzz 4y agoI'm not trying to defend them, but if 20% of the customer assets are in SHIB then that should be the pct they are holding in reserve?
- z9znz 4y agoIndeed, my assumption was probably wrong. In one of the two articles I read, I didn't see the quote about it being 1:1 analysis against customer holdings. I believed it included general hedging assets of the exchange. As long as the exchange is not loaning or collateralizing against these SHIB holdings, then it's nothing of concern. It does still paint a pretty bad picture of the exchange or its customers based on the huge percentage of "value" stored in a coin which has absolutely no point in even existing (but that's beside the point of my original inaccurate post).
- SpaceManNabs 4y ago> It does still paint a pretty bad picture of the exchange or its customers It just paints a bad picture of the customers. If that is what CDC users wanna buy, then the exchange needs to have enough to support the liquidity needs of their customers. CDC might be doing a lot wrong, but that probably isn't one. Wish you would edit your comment now that you understood the context of your assumption.
- berberous 4y agoCrypto.com has 20% of their reserves in SHIB since that’s what their users own 1:1. That’s the correct approach; you would prefer they gamble with their customer’s assets by swapping a portion to more blue chip crypto like ETH?
- woeirua 4y agoNow we get the cascade of exchange failures, followed by the absolute collapse of all Crypto prices. If you have any money on the exchanges now is the time to get out.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoAnything aside from BTC and ETH is worthless. It'll be interesting to see what happens to their prices. I suppose it will depend a lot on interest rates.
- kranke155 4y agoPolkadot and Algorand are worthless ? Maybe they don’t have the ecosystem yet but they are serious projects that didn’t get ridiculous VC backing.
- bookaway 4y ago>that didn’t get ridiculous VC backing. 144 mil on an ICO off the bat is not ridiculous? Whatever its technical merits are, if Polkadot skyrocketed more than other altcoins (10x in 15 months) the reason was probably due to the cult of personality around Gavin Wood. If you're "a co-founder of Ethereum" in a crypto boom, you're probably riding the wave at the top.
- kranke155 4y agoWas that a private or a public ICO? Just saying that Polkadot actually works, true it could be super centralised that way I’m not sure about it’s history. But the Kusama / Polkadot combo has delivered, its not a memecoin with no utility. And of course there’s always Tezos, which has imo the only organic NFT market out there.
- glofish 4y agoCrypto will never be worthless! People mistakenly believe that the two option you have are valuable or zero. Instead it is a scale from positive to negative value. For example a legislation to have bitcoin "pay for" the environment damage could lead to it having a negative value. Working with and spending effort on a coin that goes to zero is a loss of productivity and opportunity of not doing something useful. Again the real cost is non-zero.
- thedangler 4y agoIt's getting even crazier. Some researchers are thinking hedge funds used FTX wrapped securities to fake stock locates for collateral. If this is true... everything is about to blow up.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoDo you have any evidence or sources for that? IMO major allegations like that deserve to be downvoted unless there is something backing them up.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoWhat does "FTX wrapped securities" even mean? Everything I've read says they invested in crypto-related stuff, not publicly traded stocks in unrelated industries.
- paulproteus 4y agoIn May, FTX.us announced stock & ETF trading: https://www.investopedia.com/ftxus-launches-stock-brokerage-5295707 https://www.investopedia.com/ftxus-launches-stock-brokerage-... I don't know anything about how it worked or who used it, etc. I wonder if it relates somehow to this idea of wrapped securities though.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y ago> The exchange will provide no-fee brokerage accounts and commission-free trading. CEO of FTX, Sam Bankman-Fried, recently acquired a 7.6% stake in Robinhood, which also provides fee- and commission-free brokerage services. Sounds like it was to allow people to move funds from crypto into US stocks. If that was the case and that business also went bankrupt then I think people lose whatever stocks they "bought" via FTX Stocks because they likely just tracked prices and made it look like people "owned" a security by updating a record that says they bought it. If there were huge numbers of purchases of stocks through FTX by their customers but then FTX didn't actually purchase those stocks (like the recent findings that they didn't actually purchase the crypto) then I don't see how this makes any bit of difference to whatever stocks are in question. Its not like they were ever actually purchased and FTX is in bankruptcy so any FTX customers are left with legal avenues to get money back but it appears there's no money to get.
- rwmj 4y agoNotional billions because unless new real money comes into the system, the BTC taken out are worth very little.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> unless new real money comes into the system, the BTC taken out are worth very little There is a lot of wealth and money being destroyed. These assets were pledged. People made spending and savings decisions with them in mind [1]. In a farcical way, crypto is doing a good deal to alleviating the pain of monetary tightening by concentrating it on its holders. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_effect
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoHey, if all the exchanges die, BTC won't be able to go down any further!
- jmyeet 4y agoWhatever your opinion of crypto (disclaimer: I think it solves no problem and probably never will) you cannot deny that the FTX collapse has done massive damage to the integrity of the ecosystem. It is so large it may well take years to recover. What's interesting is that trust and confidence here is just as important as it is for TradFi. Regulation is not just important. It is required. SBF & his polycule cohorts are probably going to spend decades in prison. What astounds me is the lack of oversight from investors (regulation can be slow to catch up). The company literally has no CFO [1] and its books are prepared by a Metaverse accounting firm [2]. While I have sympathy for the customers who will bear huge losses from this. I have absolutely none fodr the investors. [1]: https://www.ledgerinsights.com/ftx-warning-signs-no-cfo/ https://www.ledgerinsights.com/ftx-warning-signs-no-cfo/ [2]: https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/11/11/meet-the-metaverse-night-clubloving-audit-firm-that-presided-over-ftxs-financials/ https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/11/11/meet-the-metave...
- blueprint 4y agointernational remunerations and payment censorship avoidance in tyrannical regimes are two obvious and virtually unarguable problems a genuine cryptocurrency solves
- jmyeet 4y agoThis falls under the banner of "breaking the law", which is the only use case people foresaw in the last decade. Now you might consider that ethical (eg in totalitarian regimes). I make no judgement about that. But the fact remains the use case is avoiding the law and that has negative implications too (eg ransomware, funding various illegal activities).
- blueprint 4y agointernational remunerations does not fall under 'breaking the law' and there are plenty of failings of the security of various centralized information storage and processing systems as we have seen; they can become vulnerable to attacks by bad actors. some of those bad actors are trying to target specific people to harass, stalk, or otherwise harm them. you're not going to convince me that blanket surveillance of all financial activity is remotely optimal from a safety standpoint. and we have obvious human rights questions about mandated surveillance of financial activity. so, no, just because someone is in government does not mean i trust them not to abuse the immense power they've legislated for themselves. i can be doing absolutely nothing illegal and argue for the legitimacy of taxation and AML controls while still holding the above views about human rights, and for good reason.
- driverdan 4y agoGood. The only secure way of owning cryptocurrency is to have it in your own wallet. You should not be storing it on exchanges.
- nathias 4y agoThis kind of cascading failiures are great to see, it's making the whole space move towards defi and makes it more resillent. We can only imagine if anything in the legacy financial sector was allowed to fail this hard, how much better we would be in the long run if we werent forced to bail out banks.
- wins32767 4y agoWe'd all be vastly poorer because there would be much less capital available for future investments.
- Loughla 4y agoIs this honestly a "this extreme failure of [super common aspect of crypto] is good for crypto" argument? Or am I reading this incorrectly?
- roland35 4y agoNonl, you're reading it correctly. Apparently the more catastrophic billion dollars scams that come crashing down the better crypto will be. I am not sure if most people will have enough patience though!
- nathias 4y agoyou seem to think crypto is going away, but that isn't ever going to happen, the question is will it be completely centralized and made into a distopian nightmare fuel by states and corporations, or can we make good tools for people to resist this path
- TremendousJudge 4y agoWell, the financial crash of 1929, while resulting in some good financial regulations being enacted, also created such levels of misery and want that people ended up thinking it to be a good idea to engage in the deadliest conflict in the history of mankind. Those who survived were left scarred for the rest of their lives. I think we should be wary of trying something like that again.
- paulpauper 4y agoAny attempt at BTC going higher is quickly sold off. I think we're a loong way from any hope of recovery. When one considers that every asset class has failed, combined with high inflation, 2022 has been probably the worst year ever for investors, possibly worse than 2008. 2008 had a deeper bear market, but bonds and gold did well and inflation was low.
- me551ah 4y agoSince a lot of exchanges maintain fractional reserves, we are going to see a lot more exchange going bankrupt or hacked very soon.
- bogomipz 4y agoIs there a correlation between the knock-on effects of the recent collapses and an increasing in exchange hacking? Is the idea that hackers would prioritize these targets while there are still those fractional reserves left?
- stuxnet79 4y agoI think the italics indicate that these hacks are premedititated and engineered by the founders to look real when in fact they are a clever way of explaining away a liquidity trap.
- NKosmatos 4y agoI still don’t understand why people keep their crypto in Exchanges… Is it that difficult to have a secure private address where you keep your crypto? I get it that if you want to exchange and play with the markets you need to have your crypto in a shared wallet, but why for f** shake would you put all your money there? That’s the whole point with crypto, you don’t need a bank (exchange) to store them for you. Not your keys, not your coins :-)
- stingrae 4y agoWhy? It is what people are used to with traditional stores of value. Banks, brokers, etc.
- yellow_postit 4y agoExactly this coupled with ease of use. How often for stocks purchased via a broker do you go and reregister them to direct registration so the certificates are in your name? At this point I’m beginning to think the “not your keys” group is arguing in bad faith every time an exchange fails for failing to see why a retail investor would prefer an exchange.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoI'm far from a crypto pusher but I've been around it for years... The issue is that exchanges are pretty much guaranteed to be frauds, by market dynamics. There are only a few routes to profit, 1) charge users or 2) use user's funds to trade, or 3) trade against the user but with more knowledge. One of those is limited to maybe $20 per year, the other two are crimes. Every single crypto exchange picked one or both of the crime strategies because it was the way to make an exchange wildly profitable. People who did use exchanges are people who were doing things they were warned were not a good idea, and were doing it for the obviously unrealistic gains and imho would have simply mailed their money to a Ponzi scam if that was all that was available. Everything has some weakness and crypto is like cash here - if you let someone hold onto it for even a second they can refuse to return it. I don't think you can blame a community of honest developers who described and detailed the risks for intentionally self-deluding investors. A 100%+ yearly return is a better indicator of something wrong than of a great untapped opportunity and these investors tried betting against people who they were assured were scammers and when that failed they blame the currency. It's like trying to win a rigged game against a carnie and then blaming the bus driver who gave you a ride to the carnival.
- stephc_int13 4y agoWhat we're experiencing seems to be the reversal of an overly optimist neo-futurist trend that started in full force in the wake of the Subprime crisis. It can be dangerous when it happens, alas the accumulation of greed/bullshit and delusions is calling for it. Winter is coming. For some reason I tend to rejoice when I see bullshit finally exposed, but I sincerely hope this one won't last too long.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoYou rejoice because of schadenfreude. It's painful to watch a bunch of lemmings make 200x their original investment while you are lucky to squeeze out 8% per year.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 4y agoGood! You should not keep cryptocurrencies on an exchange. We have been saying this since the early 2010s. Ten years, minimum. This is exactly the point of cryptocurrency. If you're not doing that, you're messing about with IOUs.
- nly 4y agoYou realize much of the billions of crypto at these exchanges belong to market makers and quanty hedge funds at this point right? Their capital is there because they use instantaneous electronic trading venues to make money. Most of them would rather trade on swap than have to settle in cash. And they couldnt give a shit if they're trading Bitcoin or magic beans. They don't care about the Blockchain.
- throwaway22032 4y agoThen they might lose a ton of money, because they didn't understand what they were buying. Want to buy a Ferrari? Buy a Ferrari. Not a photo of one, not an "NFT", not red paint and some axles, and not a promise that someone has it in their garage - the real thing. IOUs are the entire problem cryptocurrencies aim to solve. You can trade without giving a third party full access to your funds. Hedge funds should _demand_ this.
- nly 4y agoYou seem to be missing the point. If you want to trade crypto in a 10 microsecond window then the exchange, or a trusted broker, needs to be a custodian of your crypto. What you're suggesting just doesn't fly. This is why the regulated markets brokers have to stump up collateral and we have clearing houses. You can buy Facebook shares in a microsecond but it takes days to settle and become yours. During that time, you're at risk. Likewise with crypto, even if you settled every few hours on the Blockchain (hideously expensive), there is still a risk window.
- jrm4 4y agoYes. Treating crypto like a high velocity stock exchange gets you exactly the same thing that you get from a high velocity stock exchange; aka a system that just generally screws little guys.
- Silverback_VII 4y agoBillions of dollars? I don’t believe that so many real dollars are left in the ecosystem. And who is buying one bitcoin for $15,000 at the moment so that another guy can withdraw his money?
- skinnymuch 4y agoLots of automated trading by firms is still happening. There could be enough people trying to buy the dip. Or doing manual day trading/active trading. Crypto communities still have a huge number of believers. Or take a look at the EA community and their cognitive dissonance over SBF and the general issue of bootlicking billionaires when it comes to altruism. Not everything is rational now. Or you’re right and it’s wash trading keeping the price afloat.
- djbusby 4y agoHaving sign in issues on Coinbase. Anyone else?
- twstdzppr 4y agoGood luck to the crypto peeps out there. Seems like a strange world!
- areoform 4y agoIt is striking to me that the crypto community is re-enacting a classical bank run in a "decentralized" system where such a thing wasn't supposed to happen. What's even more impressive is how quickly the crypto community is speed-running the history of financial fraud from penny stocks to bank runs. From Wikipedia, > Several leading Wall Street bankers met to find a solution to the panic and chaos on the trading floor.[14] The meeting included Thomas W. Lamont, acting head of Morgan Bank; Albert Wiggin, head of the Chase National Bank; and Charles E. Mitchell, president of the National City Bank of New York.[15] They chose Richard Whitney, vice president of the Exchange, to act on their behalf.[citation needed] > With the bankers' financial resources behind him, Whitney placed a bid to purchase 25,000 shares of U.S. Steel at $205 per share, a price well above the current market.[16] As traders watched, Whitney then placed similar bids on other "blue chip" stocks. > On October 28, "Black Monday",[17] more investors facing margin calls decided to get out of the market, and the slide continued with a record loss in the Dow for the day of 38.33 points, or 12.82%.[12] > On October 29, 1929, "Black Tuesday" hit Wall Street as investors traded some 16 million shares on the New York Stock Exchange in a single day. Billions of dollars were lost, wiping out thousands of investors. The panic selling reached its peak with some stocks having no buyers at any price.[18] The Dow lost an additional 30.57 points, or 11.73%, for a total drop of 68.90 points, or 23.05% in two days.[19][20][21][22] ... > Many people blamed the crash on commercial banks that were too eager to put deposits at risk on the stock market.[49] > In 1930, 1,352 banks held more than $853 million in deposits; in 1931, one year later, 2,294 banks failed with nearly $1.7 billion in deposits Does any of this sound familiar?
- pamplemoose 4y agoFTX was a completely centralized entity. The decentralized aspects of crypto ("defi") has been operating just fine through this entire shit-show.
- Gwypaas 4y agoDecentralized exchanges are equal to public bug bounties. https://beincrypto.com/top-ten-defi-hacks-2022-hackers-daring/ https://beincrypto.com/top-ten-defi-hacks-2022-hackers-darin...
- rufusroflpunch 4y agoThese things come in waves. Every cycle is the same: People come in for the gains and pump and dumps, then they get wrecked when the tide goes out. Some of them learn their lesson and move from a trading model to a savings model. They withdraw and hold for the long term in a wallet they control. Then we start again with a new generation.
- cwkoss 4y agoI hadn't heard of FTX before it started imploding. I think a lot of people are overestimating the impact of this. Sketchy foreign crypto companies explode all the time. This one is more exciting and salacious because it seems like prominent investors, US regulators and politicians bought the lie (and the whole c-level polycule thing). The rest of the crypto ecosystem will continue marching on. I think it's likely this is the cycle bottom: doom and gloom feels like its probably a local maximum. I predict history will repeat itself: BTC price will be boring for another two years until the run-up to block halving in 2024. If you want to own crypto, now's probably a good time to set up DCA. My personal advice to friends is to DCA (buy fixed dollar value each ~month) on Coinbase (least sketchy exchange) until 1% of your net worth is in BTC and ETH (2:1 ratio). Pull any accumulated funds off the exchange to coldwallet quarterly. DCA out when it exceeds 5%.
- beambot 4y agoYou admit that you were completely oblivious to a Top-3 CEX, and then proceed to prognosticate about crypto cycles and investment timing...? Respectfully: doesn't inspire much confidence.
- cwkoss 4y agoIt has been a notable exchange for barely over a year.
- twelve40 4y agoit had a Superbowl ad and a stadium in Miami named for itself for a year and a half now. It's been making such an obscene amount of hype that saying "i personally have never heard of them so this must be overblown" is not a very convincing argument.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- next_xibalba 4y ago
- bloomingeek 4y agoI mean, seriously, who didn't see this coming? Hope and hype aren't the same thing. Can you really expect to trust any entity who you can't sue/call on the phone/read reviews on?
- codehalo 4y agoJust to be clear, they are withdrawing tokens, not selling them.
- thelock85 4y agoI have no real philosophical or financial -besides a few BTC bought years ago- stake in crypto's success or demise, but it seems that there is an unsolvable marketing problem in this space: how to nudge considerable behavioral changes needed to move a critical mass of retail investors/users from traditional banking/finance to "defi". This kind of shift is more like a social movement but VCs don't fund education and organizing (hallmarks of societal shifts), they fund growth (if not for a single company then for a sector). So crypto should really be more hobbyist than mainstream right now (which is what I think I hear crypto enthusiasts screaming about amidst all the fallout). But the current reality shows us that crypto-as-a-hobby market would not be big enough to realize the crypto-as-a-new-paradigm vision, hence the celeb endorsements and positioning value propositions against centralized banking features to raise the money/interest needed to build out the vision. It's the standard startup journey, except that marketing for growth/adoption naturally places the business at odds with the ideals of the technology. Just my two cents!
- elango 4y agoWe have seen multiple firms and individuals breaking rules and regulations in a heavily regulated capital market. How do can things go by rules in a unregulated environment?