4 ms·
> They've probably decided it's not worth their effort. I think The Information's intel is probably true — that Apple is years away from launching web search p
by CharlesW 4y ago
> They've probably decided it's not worth their effort.
I think The Information's intel is probably true — that Apple is years away from launching web search product — but I don't think that means there's been any loss of momentum. Building a generalized search engine better than Google is hard.
We know that Apple absolutely bristles at dependencies for core capabilities. For now they'll continue to begrudgingly take Google's $15 billion/year, but Google will not be the default search engine for iOS by 2030. I can understand core team members not wanting to wait that long.
- bombcar 4y agoYou don't have to build a search engine that is better than Google's - you may only need to build one that is roughly in the running and keep it around until such time as you have to divest from Google. And working for years on a project that may never see the light of day can be hard.
- dewey 4y agoWith them working so much on building up their ad business, having a search engine and switching the iOS default search to it might make up for the loss in Google money they get right now. Just like with Google Maps / Apple Maps it doesn't seem very Apple-like to depend on a partner this heavily for such a core feature.
- guyzero 4y agoThe money doesn't come from search quality, it comes from selling ads and Apple is a long way away from building up ad inventory and an ad salesforce like Google's. They absolutely are making money on ads today, but they're a long way from swapping out Google.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, I suspect part of it is keeping an emergency option if Google were to not only stop paying them but actively blocking them (it's unlikely to happen, but if you have infinite money you're going to be paying to reduce unlikely risks). Apple will start using their own search tools in smaller places that they can monetize better, I suspect, things like "Siri find a good restaurant".
- sfe22 4y agoThere’s plenty of other search engines eagerly waiting to take googles space on ios, should google decide to block ios users
- CharlesW 4y ago> You don't have to build a search engine that is better than Google's… You're right, of course — most companies would be happy with a "perfectly fine" DDG-like offering. I'm presupposing that "best" is Apple's bar for an M1-like slam dunk launch, since an underwhelming launch (think Apple Maps 1.0) can be hard to recover from. > And working for years on a project that may never see the light of day can be hard. For sure! Moonshots require a level of faith that I'm not sure could maintain for a decade either.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI think, much like maps, a search engine requires an iterative development process. I don't think you can reasonably launch either product (search nor maps) and surpass the quality of Google on day 1 because there is so much user feedback on both products which you can not capture without actual users. Apple, with Maps, has shown an ability to stick with things and iteratively grow them to be really great (Apple maps IMO now far surpasses google maps and except for some specific data layers it's far and above OSM).
- CydeWeys 4y agoIt's a great point. Apple Maps was pretty rough when it launched but they've stuck with it and iteratively improved it. It's not like this is a self-driving car where you have to get it right and any mistake from the get-go can be fatal, so there's no reason not to apply the same iterative approach to search.
- user_named 4y agoTesla certainly didn't feel the need to get their Fake Self-Driving right from the get go.
- saimiam 4y agoA colleague who trusted Apple Maps 1.0 a bit too much once found himself driving towards the edge of a cliff because his actual destination was at the bottom of that cliff down a mountain road. So yeah, maybe not at the same level as self driving cars but Apple Maps 1.0 could have been fatal for people less situationally aware than my colleague.
- jayd16 4y agoFirst impressions matter. Has Apple Map's reputation caught up to the reality after the initial launch was underwhelming? Apple might be trigger shy.
- bombcar 4y agoGeneral consensus in this thread seems to be it's better than Google now, and for me (at least) I never bother opening Google Maps anymore; I did often early on.
- novok 4y agoAlthough apple maps has had the better client for quite a while, it can still be whack sometimes in actual directions.
- edgyquant 4y agoI have not found this to be the case in my couple of years since I moved to Apple and would never have guessed Google was better at some point. Google maps had been a pain point coming from a pretty rural area, Apple does not have this problem.
- bombcar 4y agoRural is a huge issue and Apple surprisingly seems to actually respond and fix issues - I reported one once and it was fixed the next time I bothered to check, so good on them. Google still routes you to the middle of a cornfield there, and I don't know how to get that fixed.
- Xylakant 4y agoThat may be true in the US, but for example in Berlin, cycling directions are still unavailable and POI search is still behind google maps. I would prefer to use Apple Maps, but it’s lacking. There’s also no way to share a route with someone else.
- sitkack 4y ago
- hnuser123456 4y ago>Building a generalized search engine better than Google is hard. True, however, through a combination of advances of general tech/stack accessibility over the long term, and regressions in Google's feature set in search in respecting a user's specific query, and falling victim to its own SEO-anti-SEO cat-and-mouse, the thirst for a search input box that can respect the anything more than the very most basic "advanced options" grows. I'm sure I'm not the only one who feels the growing gap between "show me 10 links that have something vaguely to do with <str> that have been hyper-gamified with next-gen DL personalization" and "SQL for the whole internet". This feels like a ripe field for apple. Probably the hardest part would be branding. Apple search could imply just local or user-uploaded files. Apple web search sounds like it's for geezers. iSearch is too on the nose. Binoculars would tie it too much to Safari.
- ehzy 4y agoIdk, maybe they would just call it Spotlight like they do currently?
- bqmjjx0kac 4y agoThen what is Finder?
- idiotsecant 4y agoWhile I think the HN audience is definitely on the 'SQL for the internet' side of that gradient I don't think very many people (on the scale of the whole internet) are at all interested in that. I think if you were to graph the level of 'nuts and bolts' level interest among internet users it would follow an exponential decay and I don't see that turning around any time in the future. The internet is not for tinkerers any more, it's for regular humans with regular human interests. We had our brief, glorious time when the internet was for people who liked to know how things work. That time is over and I don't think there's much money to be made targeting that market in general search. The average person not only doesn't mind if they see listicles in their results, they often look at them!
- 4y ago
- spoils19 4y ago> Google will not be the default search engine for iOS by 2030. Definitely going to put this on my quote wall for later, thank you! I love seeing inspiring confidence.