9 ms·
Does Apple maintain APFS in older macOS?
- chrisseaton 4y agomacOS very clearly is not designed to be long-term, legacy software, sitting on a machine for a decade like old servers did. That's just not the model they have. It’s not what they’re offering. I don't know why you'd attempt it therefore.
- ghusto 4y ago> It’s not what they’re offering. I don't know why you'd attempt it therefore I'm not saying you're wrong, but how did you conclude that? Not from the marketing ("And one more thing; we're not going to support this long-term!" — to rapturous applause), not from their specs, website, release notes, or anything like that. No, my guess is you read between the lines that Apple is a disposable-consumer-product company. Of course they'd never admit this, and _that's_ the problem here. It is not unreasonable to expect long-term support for software, and brushing that under the carpet with "ah well, you know what Apple's like", just gives them license to never have to _admit_ what they are.
- msh 4y agoEhmm, from the article: Evidence from version numbers of APFS, a critical sub-system in macOS, is entirely consistent with Apple’s claimed support policy, of only fully maintaining the current version of macOS, and only providing security updates to superseded macOS for two years after that.
- chrisseaton 4y agoApple's support policy is I believe explicitly to only fully support the current version. But I can't find anything to quote right now. I know this, so I update immediately, and get on with it. If you do something else then you're just denying reality. > It is not unreasonable to expect long-term support for software It is unreasonable to expect that, if that is not what has ever been promised to you or delivered in practice.
- ghusto 4y ago> But I can't find anything to quote right now And you never will. Part of my point was that they want all the benefits of saying they're not going to provide long-term support, with none of the downsides of saying it. Hence you _know_ this to be true, but can't find it written down. > I know this, so I update immediately, and get on with it. If you do something else then you're just denying reality. "My boss treats me like badly / my internet service is poor / none of the software I paid for works two years from now / [any other endless examples of being treated like a shmuck]. I know this, and just get on with it. If you do something else then you're just denying reality" > It is unreasonable to expect that, if that is not what has ever been promised to you or delivered in practice. I don't need to be explicitly promised reasonable terms to find the way I'm being treated unreasonable. "Well, we never _said_ it would still work in a few years" is not going to cut it. People, we used to have standards. Some of you are too young to remember — and I do _not_ mean to sound condescending, it's just true that some of you weren't around back then — but people had expectations of products, and they were high (in comparison to today). You bought things for life. We've been frog-boiled through iterations by companies like Apple to accept throwaway culture.
- vbezhenar 4y agoI'm not sure about support policy, but they definitely release security updates for old operating systems.
- chrisseaton 4y agoYeah, hence 'fully'. Getting a new file system version isn't security (unless it's specifically a security flaw.)
- highwaylights 4y agoYeah this argument is getting more and more tenuous every time it's rolled out. "It's just the Apple way" has been used to defend just about everything at this point. Unclear support terms and unsupported software for machines that were sold brand new at retail just a couple of years ago at premium prices is just plain wrong. EDIT: I've changed "a few months" to "a couple of years" as I can't find the link that explains which of the languished SKUs was still being sold on the Apple.com site as new shortly before being axed in Ventura. It also doesn't include refurb Macs or those that are still in retail channels which would make the support life even shorter from new. This is a far cry from Windows 10 to Windows 11, where blocking old machines (while still allowing a workaround) due to genuine security enhancements was met with uproar. Thankfully no T2 Macs have been dropped yet but I suspect despite having great hardware and being perfectly capable (and supporting enclave security and encryption hardware), they'll be axed unceremoniously in a couple of years anyway.
- petemir 4y agoObviously. Yet people keeps buying from them.
- chrisseaton 4y agoThere are benefits to getting on with version updates. When I do software for macOS I know that the culture is I don't have to test on 10 old versions that people might be running. It's reasonable in macOS to just say 'you obviously have to be running the latest version' which simplifies so much, and allows me to get on with more of what matters.
- highwaylights 4y agoBut the rest of that sentence is “.. unless your machine is slightly older in which case just throw it in the Bin and drop another $2k on a new one like it’s no big deal.”
- chrisseaton 4y ago
- harha 4y agoThen they shouldn't sell at all, only rent out.
- chrisseaton 4y agoYou’re not forced to do either. Everyone knows their approach to support. If it’s not for you pick something else.
- urthor 4y agoMacOS is designed for the point and click majority. You can see this in the lack of any functionality for such a simple task as window tiling. Power users should decamp, rapidly, to Vivaldi + Linux Distro.
- least 4y agoThere is built in window tiling in MacOS, it's just not very good. There's also competent third party applications that can tile windows for you that aren't baked into the operating system. Window tiling on fully DEs on linux are not very good. Gnome, KDE, XFCE, Cinammon don't have very good window tiling, either. They're very basic and tend to mimic Windows. The automatic tiling WMs lack even very basic functionality, like a login manager, a status bar, a clock, or volume controls, so I don't see how that's acceptable when compared to MacOS.
- acdha 4y ago> MacOS is designed for the point and click majority. You can see this in the lack of any functionality for such a simple task as window tiling. It also has more complete and consistent keyboard shortcuts than most of the alternatives since that’s been part of the HIG for decades. Similarly, I do most of my window management using the keyboard so I’m skeptical that you’ve done enough research to speak so authoritatively, or considered that possibly power users might have more than a relatively minor feature factoring in to such a big decision.
- dmitriid 4y agoAfter Federighi claimed that they needed to re-write Messages in Catalyst because otherwise they wouldn't have the resources to implement such complex functionality as message editing [1] I've lost all my remaining faith in Apple being able to develop and maintain any kind of software. There are extremely tiny pockets of brilliant engineering (seamless Rosetta on M1/M2 Macs), but the rest of the company seems to be fully devoid of even competent developers. And maintaining software? Get out of here. [1] In Gruber's post-WWDC talk show
- rock_artist 4y agoI still believe there are great things with Apple. and sadly I'm into their eco-system because in the 'mainstream' which is macOS/Windows iOS/Android. They provide me more functional/productive products. I do hope they'll improve but one can hope. > After Federighi claimed that they needed ... That's seems like Jobs's legacy holding it wrong done wrong. This is the guy claimed Stage Manager *needs* M1... https://www.macrumors.com/2022/06/13/craig-federighi-stage-manager-interview/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/06/13/craig-federighi-stage-m... Which ended up getting with the exact same quirks to older models. So I'd loose faith on this guy marketing hypes rather than demote all Apple's team with talented people like Johny Srouji.
- donatj 4y agoThe people who wrote NeXT as well as early OS X and its underpinnings were hyper-competent. As they’ve gotten older and cycled out they’ve been replaced by people who seemingly don’t even understand what made early OS X so amazing let alone how to create reliable software. There was a time in the mid aughts where Apple software was some of the most well built, most reliable software in existence. Those days are long gone. Part of me blames the yearly release cycle. Rather than a rock solid OS every couple years, we get incremental junk where they haven’t had the time to refine anything, just rushing to meet the impending yearly deadlines.
- vbezhenar 4y agoHonestly I think it's all about priorities and budgets. Apparently even most rich company don't want to spend money to fix bugs. There's nothing that would prevent Apple to hire thousand developers who will just spend their time fixing old bugs and clearing bugzilla. You don't even need much skill for that, only determination and particular kind of character to enjoy this activity and there are people out there who like it. You can provide full support and backporting fixes for 3 years, for example, so people might choose level of stability by delaying upgrades and without fear of being left behind.
- hoistbypetard 4y agoThis certainly validates my instinct. I haven't used APFS on any drives that I intend to move back and forth between machines. By that I mean that I cheerfully use it on internal drives. And I don't worry about things like external time machine drives which are basically tied to one system. But I don't use it on a drive that I might need to take both directions between different systems on a regular basis. An investigation that would be more interesting, I think, than this version number probing would be testing what happens if you plug drives from systems with new APFS versions into systems with old APFS versions. Do the old systems take the drives into read-only mode? Is there some flag on the filesystem that indicates a minimum version that may write to the drive, which might make an older system mount the newer formatted drives read-only? That's not how I use Mac OS generally, but I could see it coming up in my house. My wife is happily using a 2015-ish MBP, which won't get Ventura and probably won't be upgraded for a couple of years given the light usage it sees. It's entirely possible (if somewhat unlikely) that I could find myself wanting to plug in a drive formatted by a newer Mac.
- Someone 4y ago> if you plug drives from systems with new APFS versions into systems with old APFS versions I think it’s more likely that the newer drivers fix bugs in the drivers, make them support newer disk controller hardware, speed them up, or make them more reliable than that they change the on-disk format. Having said that, the reference (https://developer.apple.com/support/downloads/Apple-File-System-Reference.pdf https://developer.apple.com/support/downloads/Apple-File-Sys...) lists quite a few on-disk fields that store a version number. There may be bug fixes that necessitated changes to the on-disk format.
- hoistbypetard 4y agoI agree. I was just wondering if there's some signal (versioned format, etc.) that Apple put into place which would tell an old one not to write to a new one where the on-disk format changed.
- Someone 4y ago
- vouaobrasil 4y agoIt's hard to believe that file system incompatibility is still a thing in this day and age. I wish you could just plug a drive into a computer and not worry about which filesystem it's using, whether it be EXT4, APFS, HFS, NTFS, etc. Seems like FAT/ExFAT is still the only option and as someone who uses multiple operating systems, having to worry about filesystems drives me crazy.
- jojobas 4y agoI wonder how you think this could work. Everyone converging on The One Filesystem, and miraculously supporting all filesystems from the past? Something new is invented in the area every few years, would you have that stop, so as not to break compatibility?
- mikepurvis 4y agoLinux support for NTFS is pretty good these days; that's one candidate for it. Another would be if Windows adopted ext4 or btrfs. The latter seems most likely since it offers interesting user-facing features around snapshotting and integrity.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoExFAT works for removable drives, and you probably don’t need OS drives to have the same filesystem.
- Gigachad 4y agoRead only access would be nice. Sometimes you might want to copy out some files stored on the other OS drive.
- jojobas 4y agoAt the very least you'd have to forgo all the benefits of ext4 in terms of fragmentation and performance, zfs seamless volume management and countless other things, all for the ability to once in a decade swap a hard drive from one machine to another?
- nippoo 4y agoIs this just the FS driver, or are there backwards-incompatible changes to the on-disk format when you upgrade? (ie, if I format a disk as APFS on current macOS then try and read it on Catalina, is it still designed to work?)
- thedanbob 4y agoOne of the reasons I switched away from Macs was their file systems. I simply can’t trust them. The HFS volume storing my Time Machine backups got corrupted so often that eventually I turned them off, because what was the point? I had high hopes for APFS but it turned out to be even worse due to the extra complexity of containers. On the other hand, since switching to Linux I can’t think of a single instance of file system corruption that wasn’t caused by me doing something stupid or a hardware problem. I just don’t have to worry about file systems on a daily basis anymore and I like it that way.
- urthor 4y agoSecond this. I used a time machine backup to load my dotfiles and other settings from my personal laptop to a new work machine. Never, again. I was manually scripping ACL permissions from folder after folder, reinstalling Docker, all sorts of rubbish. The current set of Mac hardware is brilliant. Once Asahi Linux has the GPU and power management configuration, I'll hopefully never use a MacOS again unless work forces me to. Certainly I'll never buy a Mac laptop again after the current supply chain issues are gone in 3-5 years. Horrible experience as a power user. Linux power user features have come so far. The Linux desktop is so much better than 15 years ago it brings a tear to my eye.
- xenonite 4y agoFor TimeMachine backups, the file system problem can be alleviated. A possible destination is a Linux/* based Samba server that accesses, e.g., a ZFS or ext4 file system.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoNAS boxes (e.g. the ones from Synology) work great for this ever since Apple discontinued the Time Capsule. You can get a cheap box for €100-200, configure it easily via a GUI web interface, and it will work for years without having to touch it (if you turn automatic updates on). In fact, Apple even lists this option in their Time Machine documentation: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202784 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202784
- tinus_hn 4y agoClearly Apple is not rolling out new features in old operating systems. Unless they found some critical bug, which would probably be on the news, why would they update APFS in an old operating system?
- dangus 4y ago> On Sunday, in my article Home truths about macOS, I made some bold and important assertions that Apple doesn’t normally maintain even critical parts of macOS once a version has been superseded as the current release. On Sunday the author also blew some anti-vax dogwhistles in that same article. > It’s a similar argument to that concerning vaccination of younger people against Covid or other generally non-fatal conditions. Most people under the age of 70 who are in reasonably good health should be safe from serious or prolonged illness or death. I'm not sure why the author threw in that nonsense in the last article but I'm calling it out once again because I think people need to be accountable for tossing around FUD and misinformation around subjects that have factual truths. The scientifically verified truth is that people of all ages benefit from getting the Covid-19 vaccine and boosters when it comes to Covid-19 outcomes, which don't just include the possibility of death but also include lingering or permanent negative affects. Back to the subject at hand, I don't understand the point of this exercise. Apple never claimed to maintain "critical subsystems" in previous OS versions, and I think the author of the article is using the "critical" verbiage to make it sound like a problem that Apple isn't maintaining APFS in previous versions of macOS. Is Microsoft maintaining NTFS in Windows 10?
- manuelabeledo 4y agoThe author adds right after the quote: > But the only way to tell whether you are most people is in retrospect. Meaning that one should take the necessary precautions, i.e. get the vaccine.
- dangus 4y agoWell, it confused an idiot like me, so maybe it wasn't the best analogy to go with.
- jzl 4y agoNeither the article nor any responses I see have mention the fact that Apple updated a billion live iPhones to APFS in 10.3 and there was nary a peep. Certainly that’s a testament to its stability. Anyway, the real test would have been to take an APFS drive from Ventura and test it on High Sierra and see if there are any issues. I’m guessing that APFS was written with forward compatibility in mind. If a new version writes some additional bits that the old one doesn’t know how to take advantage of, I would hope it silently ignores them without affecting any basic functionality. This article uses a lot of words to talk about writing version numbers without any thoughtful analysis on what those versus numbers might even do.
- dmitriid 4y ago> Apple updated a billion live iPhones to APFS in 10.3 and there was nary a peep. This was an insane engineering feat. Oh to be a fly in the room when the go ahead decision was made. And the stories from teams who tracked the rollout.
- ectospheno 4y agoI keep a windows vm on every machine I use. Makes reading any external drive trivial. Surprisingly useful OS for getting work done...