7 ms·
Qualcomm vs. Arm: The bizarro quotient just went off the scale
- jabl 4y agoReally hard to imagine Arm would be so adamant about running its own business into the ground. Requiring Arm designed IP to go together with an Arm core in a SoC would destroy a large part of the Arm ecosystem. Whatever the truth may be, this kind of shadow lurking over Arm can only be good for RISC-V.
- philliphaydon 4y agoHow would this affect Apple and its M lineup? As apple uses its own GPU. Would arm attempt to extort apple ?
- jjtheblunt 4y ago> Would arm attempt to extort apple? not sure if that would happen since ARM was a joint venture of Acorn, Apple, and VLSI. perhaps current organization of IP is very different.
- amelius 4y agoApple pays 30% of their revenue for the privilege of using ARM. /s
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoIt is interesting to think about the actual number, because it wouldn't be zero
- amelius 4y agoThe number gets smaller the more Apple sells ...
- masklinn 4y agoApple is both a chip designer and a device manufacturer, and it already has a very special relationship with ARM (as in, it can do things literally nobody else can like extend the ABI or drop mandatory features they don’t care about). So that seems unlikely.
- rkangel 4y agoThere are two levels of ARM licensee: * IP licensee - this is what most people are. You are allowed to "photocopy" the design of a CPU core and attached bits into your chip * Architecture licensee - in this case you are licensing the underlying concept of the ARM instruction set (the software's interface to the processor). This means you are allowed to design new cores that use the ARM instruction set (usually based on existing ARM work) I don't doubt that Apple has a special commercial relationship, and they do seem to be able to go further with the architecture licence than others, but most of what they do is just normal architecture licensee stuff.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoAs an early ARM funder (via Apple Newton) dont they have a special architecture license into perpetuity that allows them to do the M1 and basically whatever they feel like ???.
- jjtheblunt 4y agothey're a joint founder (besides funder) : Acorn + Apple + VLSI --> ARM
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mdasen 4y agoIt wouldn't impact Apple because Apple isn't acquiring Nuvia. The article doesn't do a good job of talking about the case. I will try to summarize what is at issue (IANAL nor an expert on this case). I'm going to start by telling ARM's side of the story (since they're the ones suing). Nuvia got a license from ARM. Part of that license was a requirement that any transfer of Nuvia's tech developed under these licenses required ARM approval. Nuvia agreed to this, presumably to get more favorable rates. Qualcomm bought Nuvia to jumpstart their custom-core business. ARM didn't consent to the transfer. Therefore, Qualcomm must destroy the Nuvia tech or reach an agreement with ARM. Why would ARM want to do this? Let's say you're ARM. You're the king of mobile, but you have very little presence in the datacenter. Nuvia comes along and says, "we think ARM can conquer the datacenter." Awesome, you now have a company that will start rolling some sweet datacenter money your way. But what if Nuvia is just a trojan horse? What if they're just a smokescreen to create some custom cores and then have one of the companies that licenses your cores switch to only licensing your architecture? That would be terrible for your revenue. That's not Nuvia's strategy: they genuinely want to do their stated mission. Nuvia and ARM agree that ARM will have veto power over transfer of their IP. Fast forward a few years and it turns out that chip startups are hard and Qualcomm has lots of cash and the potential to bring your dreams to life - and more. Qualcomm's lawyers believe they will be able to get around the agreement - they've been able to bead back FRAND patent claims for decades, even against Apple. Why would Nuvia agree to this? Possibly because they had no other choice. If ARM won't give you an architecture license without this, you have to agree to it. Or maybe it was a way of getting a lot of cost savings. Or maybe ARM would give you the kind of support and service that would cut years off the development of your custom cores because ARM felt safe knowing that you couldn't just sell that on to Qualcomm or MediaTek. Ultimately, this doesn't impact Apple because Apple isn't buying Nuvia. ARM says, "The licenses safeguarded Arm's rights and expectations by prohibiting assignment without Arm's consent, regardless of whether a contemplated assignee had its own Arm licenses." For ARM, the potential issue here is that Qualcomm (one of their largest licensees) stops buying ARM-designed cores because they have their own designs. That is fair insofar as Qualcomm has an architecture license. However, it isn't fair if they do that by buying a company that explicitly agreed that their tech wouldn't be transferred without ARM's consent. Let's say that ARM licensed Nuvia and the restriction was explicit: you can never sell your company to Qualcomm. Then they sell the company to Qualcomm. Not allowed, right? In this case, Qualcomm is arguing that Qualcomm has its own architecture license so it should be allowed to use its architecture license with Nuvia's designs. ARM's complaint: https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/08/31/pacer_arm_qualcomm.pdf https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/08/31/pacer_arm_qualcomm.pdf Now, I don't have access to the Nuvia/ARM contract so I can't really say if ARM's complaint is valid. Did Nuvia's license require the destruction of any technology created under such license when the license terminates as ARM alleges? Qualcomm says that the requirement to destroy information only applies to ARM-provided information and not anything developed under the license. https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/11/01/pacer_qualcomm_arm_filing.pdf https://regmedia.co.uk/2022/11/01/pacer_qualcomm_arm_filing.... It's really hard to tell without actually having access to the license agreements who is right. Qualcomm's filing seems to fall back on the idea that it would be ridiculous to give ARM this kind of power over what Nuvia had created. However, companies seem to make these types of agreements all the time. ARM wanted to give Nuvia an opportunity to succeed, but also wanted to prevent Nuvia from just selling itself to Qualcomm, MediaTek, etc. So it inserted a clause to prevent that without ARM's agreement. Nuvia could be an independent company and sell all its chips and become the next big chip designer. If they wanted to be bought by Qualcomm or someone, they could negotiate with ARM for ARM's consent. To me, this op-ed reads like Qualcomm propaganda. To me, it sounds like ARM has Qualcomm dead-to-rights and Qualcomm is trying to allege something unrelated to the case: that ARM wants to cease its architecture licenses because it sees that companies will be able to stop paying them for ARM-designed cores. That would certainly be problematic, but many ARM licensees have perpetual architecture licenses (like Apple and presumably Qualcomm as well) so it wouldn't actually impact them if ARM pivoted their business model in this way. It's also just speculation on ARM's future business model. I definitely understand the position of those who would hate ARM in this case. ARM isn't an open-source company. They're open...to companies paying them royalties. ARM wants to protect their current revenue while also being open enough that they can enter new markets - like the datacenter. That's a hard line to balance, but it sounds like they tried to do that with Nuvia: giving them a license on good terms in exchange for a guarantee that they weren't just a trojan horse to undercut revenue from Qualcomm, MediaTek, or others. I'm not trying to argue that's good for consumers or the market in general. As a consumer, if we eliminated all existing patents while pinky-swearing "we won't do that again" it would mean we'd continue to get all the future benefits of patents (since inventors would feel safe that their future inventions would get paid back) while not suffering the monopoly of current patents (since once the invention has been made, we no longer need to incentivize that invention). Likewise, if we just eliminated ARM's IP, it would be great - as long as we didn't make other companies worry that we'd be eliminating their IP as well. While we're eliminating IP, eliminating Qualcomm's patents might have some of the biggest impact - Qualcomm literally wants more royalties from a device if it includes a better screen or camera despite using the same LTE/5G. I'd love to actually see the architecture license with Nuvia, but instead I guess I'll just read the sniping that Qualcomm and ARM make in their filings.
- bombcar 4y agoWhere does a 2.2 trillion dollar company sit? Anywhere it wants to. Apple could buy Arm easily if needed, hell they could buy SoftBank.
- kevin_b_er 4y agoApple has likely signed a massive licensing deal with ARM at the 'architectural license' level or an even more specialized deal because Apple is Apple. I'd think that Apple's signed a nice long contract because when Apple bought PA Semi and had goals to design their own chip which takes quite a long time. Also note that you can't just buy M1 chips off digikey. Apple only makes these chips for Apple's products, and their agreement may have included that Apple wouldn't become a chip vendor.
- metaphor 4y agoMaybe it's just me, but I rather disliked the pubescent, sensationalized tone of this opinion piece. Previous discussion[1][2] of Dylan Patel's coverage a while back. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33419138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33419138 (6 days ago, 179 comments) [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33371725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33371725 (10 days ago, 10 comments)
- rkangel 4y agoI quite like this sort of style, just as a change of pace from the normally pretty dry style that we're used to on these topics. Sometimes it helps strip away the layers of complexity and point out the fundamental oddities in play. The master of this style as far as I'm concerned is Matt Levine and his "Money Stuff" column for Bloomberg. He goes back to first principles on complex matters in the finance sector, and explains it all humorously.
- justin66 4y agoThere might be some stylistic similarities but Matt Levine is actually good.
- smeagull 4y agoYou can use all the fancy words you like, but if you're just going to call the writer a dick, then just call them a dick. Don't bring pubes into it.
- mikro2nd 4y agoI think that "pubescent" does not mean what you appear to think it means.
- gjvc 4y agoMaybe it's just me, but I rather disliked the pubescent, sensationalized tone of this opinion piece. That's the house style of "The Register" to a "T".
- causi 4y agoI'm going to be so very angry if this kills Adreno. Making every device use a Mali GPU would set mobile game emulation back half a decade in performance.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoWorth remembering for those wondering, could this effect Apple? Most likely, no. Apple has every license ARM offers… and Apple actually cofounded ARM with Acorn and VLSI and had an Apple VP as its first president, and so likely gets special unlicensed privileges. As for VLSI, it was sold to Phillips and is now owned by NXP. A company Qualcomm also tried to buy, which sells a metric ton of ARM chips themselves. Ironic that a company Apple cofounded now is now the CPU designer for every Android phone, but so is the world. Edit: If I was a conspiracy theorist, I would almost say that Qualcomm trying to buy a cofounder (NXP), and NVIDIA trying to buy ARM directly, were both attempts at getting some of those privileges, but I have no evidence for that.