4 ms·
El Salvador’s $300M Bitcoin ‘Revolution’ Is Failing Miserably
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://archive.ph/kUgvo https://archive.ph/kUgvo
- ocbyc 4y agoHard to read. Wished for so much more from this experiment.
- onetokeoverthe 4y ago
- anecdotal1 4y agoWe won't know the results of this experiment for at least 10 years, though.
- MisterSandman 4y agoI would be surprised if El Salvador wouldn't have done a 180 with this Bitcoin thing. Especially since Bitcoin isn't even cool anymore, the really future of crypto is (apparently) in Ethereum.
- uni_rule 4y agoI thought that currency stopped being cool when it stopped being the most efficient medium to cash out on stealing electricity.
- nradov 4y agoWhy would you wish for more from idiots and criminals?
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- labrador 4y agoBitcoin has taught me that people have all sorts of irrational, fanciful and sometimes delusional feelings about money without really understanding what it is.
- extragood 4y agoIf you don't spend it, it's not a currency
- sjducb 4y agoI've never spent the Argentine Peso. Is the Argentine Peso a currency?
- birracerveza 4y agoYou didn't, others did though, therefore it's a currency. The same goes for Bitcoin, maybe op didn't use it and therefore doesn't consider it currency, but others did though, therefore it's currency. Even chickens can be currency, in a barter economy!
- kbrkbr 4y ago> If you don't spend it, it's not a currency > You didn't, others did though, therefore it's a currency From the first statement you can only conclude that if it’s a currency, then you spend it (by modus tollens). You can’t conclude that if you spend it, then it is a currency.
- birracerveza 4y ago>You can’t conclude that if you spend it, then it is a currency. Why not? It's an abstract concept. Consensus decides whether something fits the definition, or even change the definition so that it fits. And, IMO, if WoW gold is widely accepted to be a currency, then BTC is too. YMMV. My point refers to those who still bang on the fact that you can't pay BTC directly to buy bread, therefore it's not a currency. Just because it's not used in the economies YOU engage in, doesn't mean it's not a currency. You're just not involved with it.
- Laaas 4y agoI'm not sure whether the experiment is failing or not, but this is quite a biased article: They enlisted an entire country in a publicity stunt and cheered on Bukele even as he ordered mass arrests and packed the Supreme Court, which subsequently ruled he could run for reelection despite a constitutional ban. The mass arrests have nothing to do with the Bitcoin experiment? El Salvador notoriously has a big organised crime problem.
- zach_garwood 4y agoIsn't it telling that those organized crime interest pushed for the wide use of cryptocurrency?
- dustymcp 4y agoSort of like how porn started credit card payments?
- CaptainNemo17 4y agoDo you have any citations for this? As far as I'm aware porn companies don't accept credit cards. Pornhub is ach or some sort of crypto currency payments last time I checked. Porn and Weed companies struggle with banking because of the way the US System is set up. I have no idea what it's like outside the US
- nonameiguess 4y agoI've been buying studio-produced content with a Visa card for 20 years. The only porn companies having trouble with payment processors are the platforms that allow users to submit their own content, because of the difficulty in verifying age and consent of the performers. Any reputable production company has a notice up front in their films giving the contact info of a custodian of records that law enforcement can contact to get copies of government-issued ID and signed consent forms from all actors, for every scene. If you don't have that, then sure, you might have problems.
- imtringued 4y ago>The couple describe El Salvador’s problems as the fault of evil Western bankers who’ve conspired to exploit the country. That makes no sense. El Salvador has adopted the US dollar voluntarily and they can always introduce a demurrage currency. Alternatively they can double down on RAI which is a non pegged stablecoin that tries to minimize volatility. Yes it is approximately 10% down($3.14 to $2.85) vs the USD but that is still outperforming the euro and roughly comparable to Swiss francs which means it outperformed not only the vast majority of cryptocurrencies during the crash, it also outperforms most fiat currencies.
- twelve40 4y ago> El Salvador has adopted the US dollar voluntarily well, from political/populist standpoint he can always blame this decision on his (corrupt) predecessors, so that's pretty easy to explain in this discourse. Why is he so bent on Bitcoin, and the rest of it, i don't know.
- germandiago 4y agoThere is a big interest to relate bitcoin with failure and money washing or any negative thing or activity in general. Nothing new. Bitcoin is becoming money because it can be treasured without inflation. That is a terrifying idea for states. For sure Bitcoin has its risks also, so careful how much you put there. I plan to buy bitcoins before the digital currencies managed by central banks come and tell us what we can do or not and when depending on the mood and interests of the governor (hidden, of course) at that moment. Do not say I did not warn you :)
- yellowapple 4y agoIt's way too early to make any sort of determination of success or failure. Not that I expect Bloomberg, a mouthpiece of the very legacy financial system cryptocurrencies seek to replace, to be particularly impartial on the subject, but still.