4 ms·
ISP data caps are a complete scam. Xfinity offers gigabit connectivity with a 1TB data cap. Which means that if someone was actually using the network at those
by paxys 4y ago
ISP data caps are a complete scam.
Xfinity offers gigabit connectivity with a 1TB data cap. Which means that if someone was actually using the network at those speeds it would take them 2.2 hours to get through their allotted monthly usage.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoI reject 'complete scam', though that example is obviously egregious. My 50Mbps plan should be capped (1280GB in my case.) I don't know what the utilization factors are, but that would be a lot of traffic on what is not a high powered plan, and I appreciate the price I get. Even when I try to go for the cap, I've never even made it to 400GB (because I don't know how to use that much traffic, mostly.) As with almost all these broadband provider problems, it's the barriers to new entrants that prevent sensible equilibrium.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe scam part is where the limits are all disclosed in the small print while the large print on their advertising material says "unlimited"; it takes serious pilpul to redefine that word.
- selectodude 4y agoAFAIK there's nowhere on Comcast's site that says unlimited bandwidth. I just went to sign up and they were pretty clear about data caps.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoRight on "Xfinity"'s homepage I see them offering "Unlimited". Then in the fine print below it, in a much smaller font, it says they'll throttle your connection after only 20 GB. Serious pilpul to call that "Unlimited".
- 1123581321 4y agoIf you’re seeing references to throttling and 20GB, you’ve accidentally gone to Xfinity Mobile, their phone service.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhatever, it's advertised right on the front of Xfinity.com, and it's the same damn company. I have numerous emails from them telling me they'll me that I'm close to my monthly limit and they'll fine me if I go over. Comcast are snakes, just like the rest.
- 1123581321 4y agoThe practices of cable Internet and MVNOs have nothing to do with each other. They just share branding.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoSame company, same leadership, same scummy business practices. I don't know why you're trying to hold water for Comcast of all companies. I guess Elon Musk is just so awful that he makes you think Comcast is good? I don't particularly like the guy either, but get real. Comcast are scum.
- 1123581321 4y agoI don’t know what has given you this impression. Hopefully you’ll find it easier to navigate between their websites from now on.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoGiven me what impression? Should I not judge a company by the lies they put on their website?
- lostgame 4y ago>> I just went to sign up To Comcast? For the love of God, why?
- treesknees 4y agoIndeed, and it's happening while cable providers push more offerings to IP-based services. Xfinity will hand you a free Xfinity Flex streaming box to watch free shows and content that all count against your monthly data cap. My SO and I both work from home full time now, and we will easily hit 600-800GB/month. I can't imagine how homes with several kids streaming YouTube videos handles this without paying the extra monthly fee for the Xfinity modem just to remove their data cap.
- philjohn 4y agoSo glad this just isn't a thing in the UK. Yes, services are contended (1/32 on my FTTP), so if everyone goes full beans the whole time it would slow down, but I never have issues, even at busy times on my 900/100 plan. Turns out, most people's usage is bursty, and even every home streaming simultaneously at 4K is only using a fraction of the bandwidth available on the GPON circuit. I've used multiple TB a month (when working from home full time during the lockdown, with kids remote learning and spouse working remotely as well) and didn't get so much as a peep from my ISP. Unlimited really is unlimited.
- supertrope 4y agohttps://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/05/fios-customer-discovers-the-limits-of-unlimited-data-77-tb-in-month/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/05/fios-...
- bombcar 4y agoISPs are buying long and selling short or whatever it is called. They buy transit at some higher priced and fixed (10 Gb/s or whatever) and resell it to users at advertised speeds that are a major fraction of whatever the local uplink is. If you buy at 10 Gb/s and sell at 1 Gb/s you obviously can't sell to more than 10 users without somehow limiting something. So data caps are a way to isolate the harmful effects of those who use a lot of bandwidth from those who just use it rarely. It's standard market segmentation. You can pay more and get more, or get a business account.
- highwaylights 4y agoI mean, you could, but you very much thought you were buying that already because your provider put a lot of effort into leading you to believe that.
- Gigachad 4y agoI'd only call it a scam when they advertise unlimited and still have caps. Otherwise you are just getting what you agreed and paid for. If you want to pay for a dedicated gigabit line not shared with anyone else, you can, it costs a lot.
- bombcar 4y agoIt can actually be much cheaper than people might think, you just need to work it out with the business side (and they will correctly allocate for it). You're basically buying a loop to some exchange, and then transit at that exchange. The reality is nobody is ACTUALLY pushing 1 Gb/s continuous so the expense ain't worth it (the people who are already have it setup).
- paxys 4y agoData caps existing to prevent network congestion is a myth. Otherwise Xfinity would go down on the 1st of every month when all their users had fresh data allotments and were using the service without any restrictions. This model is simply an additional revenue stream for ISPs.
- Havoc 4y agoHardly makes it a "scam". Annoying and restricting perhaps. It also isn't nearly as tight as your 2.2 hours suggests in practice. Gigabit is fast enough that most downloads take seconds so the chances of someone spending hours at full speed is pretty low. Unlimited is definitely nicer
- marcrosoft 4y agoIt is a scam when xfinity advertises unlimited when it is intact not.
- Havoc 4y agoI mean I could also roll up at a coffee shop with a tanker truck and demand they fill it up based on my $5 bottomless coffee purchase. But nobody sensible reads bottomless that way. Also I don't think your reading of their offerings is right. 1.2TB allowance on the basic package and those that want more can purchase an unlimited package: https://www.xfinity.com/support/articles/exp-unlimited-data https://www.xfinity.com/support/articles/exp-unlimited-data
- Dylan16807 4y agoYour analogy is too far off in scale to work. Constant coffee refills would take days to fill up a tanker truck. If a tanker truck is 1.2TB, then getting a coffee refill every few seconds isn't the equivalent of full speed downloading, it's the equivalent of streaming high quality video. So the analogy you proposed would say that streaming video is abuse. The analogy is wrong. Also, when talking about how "most downloads take seconds", video game (re)installs can be over 100GB. You could have two people each install two games and blow out half your data cap in an hour without doing anything remotely unreasonable.