4 ms·
Moreover, if this case wins, it threatens to disrupt one of the biggest technological progressions of all time. AI/ML will change every field just as the Inter
by echelon 4y ago
Moreover, if this case wins, it threatens to disrupt one of the biggest technological progressions of all time.
AI/ML will change every field just as the Internet and smartphones did. It doesn't show any indication of peaking, either.
If the US chooses the wrong path here, we'll only tie our hands behind our backs. Other countries won't be so foolish.
We should be able to train on any media a child could see, hear, or read.
- still_grokking 4y agoEspecially the copyright / IP obsessed USA won't go this path. Otherwise they would create the ultimate "copyright laundry machine".[1] I'm very sure at least Hollywood and the big music labels would not like that… ;-) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33459967 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33459967
- ranguna 4y ago> it threatens to disrupt one of the biggest technological progressions of all time. Chill dude, all they have to do is include the licenses on their generated code. If anything, this is going to generate even more progress. The copilot team would have to create some kind of feature that would connect the generated output the the relevant training data. That'd be pretty incredible to see in the field of AI/ML in general.
- WithinReason 4y agoThey already have that feature and you can turn it on
- ranguna 4y agoAh great, then it should be on and with no way to disable it. Of course, end user could just strip the license/attribution off their generated output, but that's a different story.
- bobbruno 4y agoIf they can actually link output to specific input, the lawsuit has merit and more, GPT-3 is a lie. A neural network is supposed to learn how things work, not memorize a large number of examples and spit them out verbatim - or keep connections to specific inputs. Copilot losing the lawsuit is evidence it’s a case of overfitting, not true ML.
- ranguna 4y agoMind you, not all outputs are the result of over fitting.
- visarga 4y agoNot just AI is threatened, but also the use of sites like StackOverflow because some of those snippets might infringe a license. So we have to write everything from our heads, de novo. No more googling for solutions. I think we should just relax copyright, it's dying anyway. Language models allow people to borrow skills learned from other people, and solve tasks. That's huge. Like Matrix, loading up a new skill at the press of a button. Can we give up such a huge advantage in order to protect copyright? I think the notion of copyright has been under attack already for 2 decades by the internet, search engine and social networks. They all work against it, and AI does it even more. It just encapsulates the whole culture in a box, mixing everything up, all copyrights melting away, everything one prompt away. This could be a new medium of propagation for ideas. No longer limited to human brains and books, they can now propagate through language models more efficiently.