9 ms·
The New York Times made a weird editorial decision with its tech coverage
- _zgx0 4y ago>Instead of covering the [tech] industry with a business press lens or a consumer lens they started covering it with a very tough investigative lens — highly oppositional at all times and occasionally unfair. ... >Tech executives and investors mostly did not like this change, for understandable reasons. And I mostly agree with them on the merits. The author agrees - that the tech industry should not be subject to investigative coverage? That's nonsense. Tech now is the most wealthy and powerful industry in the US. Large tech companies have huge impacts on politics and news. Suggesting that tech should not be subject to investigative coverage is hard to understand. It seems like one of the most important subjects of that coverage today. You can suggest that coverage is inaccurate or unfair, but suggesting that tech should not be covered with an investigative lens is hard to argue.
- torstenvl 4y agoAs noted in the quotes you yourself pulled, what OP "agree[s] with" "[t]ech executives and investors" about is tech coverage that is "highly oppositional at all times and occasionally unfair." Nobody is "suggesting that tech should not be covered with an investigative lens."
- WillPostForFood 4y agoYou said that the tech industry should not be subject to investigative coverage?! Yglesias actually said: And the press should try to normalize coverage of the tech industry as just another business sector. Which would include investigative coverage when appropriate.
- smeagull 4y agoFawning is typical of media coverage of most business sectors.
- astrange 4y agoDon't think mining and oil and gas really get fawning reviews, or the local pizza place. Or the most expensive restaurant in NYC: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/13/dining/pete-wells-per-se-review.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/13/dining/pete-wells-per-se-...
- couchand 4y agoDude's been going on a downward spiral for years. Nothing he says these days follows any kind of coherent framework, it's just something thrown on the wall to see what sticks. He's really honestly describing himself with this take.
- astrange 4y agoMattY is extremely consistent, but also can't help himself and constantly tweets in a layer of irony or two. This causes some people to get extraordinarily mad at him in the replies, at which point I like to play a game of figuring out how they misread the tweet, which they always seem to have done. His actual articles are perfectly straightforward, sincere, and usually on some topic like "Boston subway stations should cost less to build".
- couchand 4y agoHe certainly USED to write articles like that!
- ForrestN 4y agoHe's not saying that they shouldn't be subject to coverage "with an investigative lens." He's talking about the adversarial, negative tone of the coverage, relating to the tech industry primarily as full of bad actors rather than a power center worthy of investigation that also does some good things, say. I don't think Yglesias would say we shouldn't investigate these companies, but rather that we should paint a more wholistic picture about both the good and bad contributions of these companies that better matches reality.
- _zgx0 4y agoHe correctly identifies a fundamental difference between business/consumer reporting, which is often fawning regurgitations of PR materials made with limited due diligence and investigative reporting. I stand by my comment, it seems to me that he is saying the change from business/consumer to investigative was unwelcome and he agrees with that reaction. I think investigative journalism should be fair, but I don't think someone investigating Alphabet has to present the good that the company does - that's the job of Alphabet's PR department. Fair journalism does not leave out relevant context but doesn't speak to unrelated "good" contributions. Should an investigation into political corruption talk about what good that politician did? Maybe if its directly related to the corruption, but otherwise no.
- JamesianP 4y agoPersonally when I look at the tech section I want to hear what's new in technology (I guess you'd call this marketing), not politics and gossip about what some rich meathead said. Put politics in the politics section, and the gossip in the tabloids.
- pixl97 4y agoThat boat sailed a long time ago. And while yes, there is a lot of interesting tech news out there, we've had tech companies become the largest corporations on the planet gobbling up every bit of information on every person, well it gets political really quick.
- AlexandrB 4y agoThe tech industry needs more investigative coverage, not less. The reason disasters like Theranos or Nikola were able to waste as much time and money as they did is because most of the tech press is focused on regurgitating press releases and hyping up the next big thing.
- Aerroon 4y agoI don't see how investigative journalism would fix the situation though. Theranos scammed wealthy investors. Wealthy investors should be able to do at least a little bit of due diligence. If they had done that then they would've known their idea was not feasible. It's the investors themselves that added to the hype regardless of the press releases.
- paulgb 4y agoTheranos scammed wealthy investors but also hurt a lot of other people in the process, namely patients who received bad tests and employees who have a black mark on their resume. In an ideal world maybe investors would have done more DD, but there is a lot of money out there. Many investors likely did turn them down, since their funders didn’t include many traditional SV VCs, despite being next door to Sand Hill Road. It was ultimately the WSJ that broke the story. Even if investors find something during DD, they have strong incentives (libel law) not to share it.
- astrange 4y agoRemember Theranos wasn't even big tech, and only had one major Silicon Valley investor in it; they were a fake big tech company attracting people who wanted to be SV but weren't. The usual VCs didn't even trust them!
- pencilguin 4y agoAdd NRGV ("Energy Vault", once well over $2B, now $0.4B and still badly overvalued) to the Theranos pile. And all but one of the fusion startups. (Maybe them too.) Kyoto Fusioneering has realized that there is lots of money to be made selling parts for phony demos to fusion startups. BTW there will not be any Mars colony in this century. Or Tesla office-robot.
- Overtonwindow 4y agoA major problem with the technology media is that they don’t investigate the companies, because they have to stay on their good side in order to be invited to the events, and to get the information. When they criticize the company the company freezes them out; i.e. Apple.
- klooney 4y agoYglesias doesn't think that no investigation should be done or that tech is all good- he has a riff that "Facebook is bad, Facebook employees should feel bad about working there, and they should feel shame admitting where they work" that he goes on occasionally.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KKKKkkkk1 4y ago> You can suggest that coverage is inaccurate or unfair, but suggesting that tech should not be covered with an investigative lens is hard to argue. That's because he's being very charitable to what is happening. In fact, under the guise of aggressively investigative coverage, the media is constantly propagating false memes about the industry. Biggest example is the idea that it's dominated by a culture of white tech bros, when in fact it's dominated by highly educated and hard-working Indian and Chinese immigrants.
- throwaway1777 4y agoToo on the nose. When I worked at faang almost my entire org was Indians.
- PradeetPatel 4y agoThe generalisation of "Indians" in the tech sector is doing a lot more harm than one may think. India is a massive country, with some of the most diverse range of cultures and people. The fact that most FAANG CEOs are Indians should speak volumes. Negative stereotyping hurts everyone, only by acceptance and embrace our differences can we move forward.
- bagels 4y agoDo you consider "Indians" to be pejorative?
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoHe probably considers being lumped in with certain other Indians pejorative. It's funny, on producing that interpretation my first thought was 'He must be high caste'. Now that's a negative stereotype!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xwolfi 4y ago
- DeathArrow 4y ago>Tech now is the most wealthy and powerful industry in the US. I thought weapon and pharmaceutical industries beat the tech.
- tsimionescu 4y agoOn power, probably (at least lobbying power - direct influence on us is the opposite); but on wealth, Apple + Microsoft is enough to make the tech sector the wealthiest.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoTech now is the most wealthy and powerful industry in the US. Nowhere near as powerful as media. Wealthy sure.
- froh 4y agomedia == tech these days. twitter, Instagram, TikTok, FB, they are media, YouTube is media.
- LAC-Tech 4y agoWhen it comes to the business of telling you what the nature of the world is and how to think, it's really impossible for me to conjure up something more authoritative than the New York times. Sure there's people on social media saying things, but the stuff that's an echo of the NYT sounds right and true, the stuff that's against it sounds low-brow and coarse.
- mindslight 4y agoThe New York Times (et al) set the official narratives. Faceboot and its ilk shape the many counter reactions to it. Despite being comprised of multiple journalists, everyone basically thinks of NYT as a singular entity with its own reputation. On Faceboot, memes carry the social proof of your own personal relationships. And the most worrisome is that people know NYT's narratives are not their own thoughts, whereas people think the narratives they got from Faceboot are.
- anticrisis 4y agoThat is your educated perspective. A larger share of Americans place greater trust in what they hear about public issues on social media from interesting personalities than in the NYT, sadly.
- froh 4y agothe NYTimes at this time has 4.sth Mio subscribers and 10k videos, indeed: https://youtube.com/c/nytimes https://youtube.com/c/nytimes
- rrwo 4y agoI was going to post the same thing.
- BurningFrog 4y ago> The author agrees - that the tech industry should not be subject to investigative coverage? That this very basic failure of reading comprehension has been voted to the top is both sad and surprising.
- scrozier 4y agoThat this very basic lack of clarity in writing was misunderstood is unsurprising.
- majjgepolja 4y agoNot so sure about that, with a certain clickbait coverage of solarwinds story creating bad PR for Jetbrains, (perhaps among the least controversial tech companies). That's what happens when liberal arts people think they're too delicate to understand anything more nuanced than US political thing of the day.
- colinmhayes 4y ago>> highly oppositional at all times > tech industry should not be subject to investigative coverage? I don't see how you can read his quote and come up with yours. Absolute strawman
- mensetmanusman 4y ago“Tech now is the most wealthy and powerful industry in the US.” Industries more powerful: -Finance -Banking -Defense -Oil&Gas
- fullshark 4y ago> As a longtime working journalist, longtime check-haver, and someone who knows lots and lots and lots and lots and lots of media professionals I can promise you that working journalists derive zero value, social status, or self-esteem from this. Blatantly false, as the childish histrionics over the new verification system from many journalists this past week have shown. A lot of journalists' entire self worth seems wrapped up in their twitter audience frankly.
- mikkergp 4y agoMost of the journalists I've seen have expressed just the oppossite, an ease with leaving twitter if these get enacted, what makes you say that " A lot of journalists' entire self worth seems wrapped up in their twitter audience frankly."
- fullshark 4y agoEhh this is all so vague, both Yglesias's original thread and my disagreement with it, and I"m not sure it's benefited from getting specific. Who cares if I find some random tweets supporting my point, I'm sure you can find counter tweets. This ironically is the problem with a lot of modern journalism in a nutshell, tweet hunting to support narratives. In any case my opinion is that a lot of journalists (at least the active ones, not the ones with auto-tweets of their stories) really enjoy twitter and really enjoy being "a blue checkmark" and are annoyed that their club is no longer exclusive. This annoyance has been verbalized in a myriad of criticisms of musk, the new system, etc. Edit: because I can’t completely punt I did remember seeing this tweet which amazingly has 85k likes https://twitter.com/AshaRangappa_/status/1587508595553353729 https://twitter.com/AshaRangappa_/status/1587508595553353729 Which blew my mind, oh course not completely representative of all journalists
- mcphage 4y agoSo you read that tweet, but you think it is support of blue checks? Like, you think that tweet indicates the author thinks blue tweets are important and valuable?
- tinalumfoil 4y agoTo save you a click, > What's happened is that they have mistaken their own resentment at journalists' unearned checkmark privilege for something that journalists themselves care deeply about and are either willing to pay for or are mad that other people will be able to buy. Basically he's arguing Musk's $8-check decision comes from a misunderstanding of the journalism industry. His point is only marginally related to NYT's coverage of tech.
- watwut 4y agoBy this interpretation, it is attack on free speech. He wants to prevent criticism of Tesla. Yglesias said not me.
- Hamuko 4y agoThis seems like wild conjecture. As far as I can tell, the only part where Musk ties into the story is the fact that he's monetising the checkmark. At no point is there actually any discussion on how Musk feels about journalists and their cbeckmarks. I find the notion of "Musk overpaid for Twitter and is now desperately trying to figure out what people would pay for" as convincing if not more convincing, and to be backed up by as much evidence.
- _fs 4y ago
- asdajksah2123 4y agoTech has received almost universally fawning coverage for the at least 2 decades that I've been following it. The only tiny hints of holding it to account came from the RMS Free Software folks. The idea that the press should be focusing on fawning coverage instead of highly investigative reporting when there's a whole ecosystem of tech news, Youtube videos, and conferences and WWDCs and Google IOs to do that seems completely nonsensical. The correct criticism of the NYTimes here should be why their investigative coverage does not extent to other areas where it might be missing.
- m0meni 4y agoI feel like people are forgetting the real value of verification. If you aren't verified, someone will pretend to be you on Twitter. Prominent people aren't paying $8 to get a check, they're paying $8 to make sure they can't be easily impersonated, which I think is really worth it.
- webmobdev 4y agoIdentity theft is a crime. If a platform facilitates this, it should be liable.
- lokar 4y agoIdentity theft is a crime when used to commit fraud. Just claiming to be someone but not otherwise defrauding anyone is fine.
- bigfudge 4y agoBut if a conventional media source published a quote from someone impersonating a public figure, and discovered this, they would publish a correction. Big tech companies wash their hands if this kind of responsibility. That degrades the value of our public spaces.
- testHNac 4y agoNote - I am not an American. From what I have read in American News Media I see so many things that have been blatant lies published by respected News Media like NYT and WaPo. But I don't think I have come across corrections regarding such national and international stories. Regarding your statement - " ... degrades the value of our public spaces." I believe even your mainstream news media is guilty of the same.
- bigfudge 4y agoI don’t disagree with this, but it is a form of whataboutism so it doesn’t really undermine the original point that some MSM are also terrible actors. Press in the UK is bad, but I don’t yet see it as this bad.
- matthewdgreen 4y ago"[The NYT] decided tech was a major power center that needed scrutiny and needed to be taken down a peg, and this style of coverage became very widespread and prominent in the industry ... the press should try to normalize coverage of the tech industry as just another business sector." The irony here is that a prominent member of the 'tech industry' (with enthusiastic support from other prominent tech industry luminaries) just bought one of the most important social media networks with the specific intention of making substantial changes to the way information is disseminated in the United States. That may turn out for the best, or it may not -- it doesn't matter. What does matter: the NYT's decision to focus skeptical reporting on tech as an "important power center" sure seems to have been vindicated.
- dralley 4y agoMeanwhile Bezos owns the Washington Post, and while he doesn't seem to have messed with it too much, Amazon has absolutely been messing with the neutrality of IMDB where it comes into conflict with Amazon's media IPs.
- doomlaser 4y agohttps://letterboxd.com https://letterboxd.com is the best source for scoping out a movie now. The ratings histogram for each film is incredibly informative about quality. It also happens to be my favorite social network right now since it's so focused.
- ecshafer 4y agoI like letterboxd a lot as well. Its a bit like patreon for me where you can follow some person that you really like and read their stuff and its cool. You get a lot of nice in depth reviews from people, and varied tastes, and unlike other movie sites it doesn't feel like big blockbusters with big budgets float to the top. I also like hackernews. I think the magic is in very focused social media.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoMusk's acquisition of twitter was, among many other things, an attempt to use his wealth to steer the marketplace of ideas. The man lives in a world where he can freely attempt to destroy anyone who tells him "no" without consequence. The New York Times, then, would seem to have been fully warranted in their apprehension regarding social giants like twitter.
- bad_username 4y agoTwitter is hardly a marketplace of ideas. It is a marketplace of hot takes. Twitter format is the enemy of depth and nuance. More importantly, Twitter has been steering this marketplace in a very specific direction, promoting certain viewpoints and suppressing the opposing ones. I am not convinced Musk is going to handle the issue in any good way, but Twitter has not been a neutral "public square" for a good number of years already.
- watwut 4y agoIt was the place where you could read what actual biologists think, actual layers think etc, without having it filtered through third party. As duch, you really could use it as marketplace of ideas.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> The man lives in a world where he can freely attempt to destroy anyone who tells him "no" without consequence. That's Tuesday for the NYT -- they live in a world where they can freely attempt to incite wars and overthrow governments.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> What's happened is that they have mistaken their own resentment at journalists' unearned checkmark privilege for something that journalists themselves care deeply about and are either willing to pay for or are mad that other people will be able to buy. This is telepsychology.
- fmajid 4y agoWas it really a top-down decision by the NYT publisher, or a visceral reaction by the journalism profession to the destruction of its career prospects by the Internet?
- mesozoic 4y agoI thought it was $8/month and thought that was way too low.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoIn other words: jaded, snarky, city hipster. Not about fairness or journalistic integrity like Walter Cronkite, but with a particular agenda. That's not investigative journalism but merely lazy, superficial gossip with a patina of formality and credibility-washed with their brand. So much for "the paper of record".
- socialismisok 4y agoNew York Times is a rag, imo. Maybe it's just because I'm a leftist and NYT absolutely loathes the idea of leftists even having the ability to discuss non "radical centrist" ideals, but I've never found much worth reading there. Some anemic both sides opinion pieces, some inflammatory diversity pieces, etc. (And I'm an extremely pro b diversity, equity, inclusion person). It's just not a great paper unless you are a boomer looking to tell yourself, "no it is the children who are wrong."
- concinds 4y agoI agree. Other commenters seem to think the NYT actually does proper tech investigative journalism, which is completely untrue beyond sensationalistic coverage, surface-level coverage of antitrust critiques, an obsession with social media misinformation, and whining about techbros. Their acquisition of Wirecutter has made their coverage even worse, filling it with "tech advice" blogspam. The idea that the NYT holds the powerful to account is risible.
- kristianp 4y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1588190763413868553.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1588190763413868553.html
- d--b 4y ago> I can promise you that working journalists derive zero value, social status, or self-esteem from [being verified] That’s totally missing the point. Journalists want to be read. If Twitter decides to have verified accounts show up earlier in the search results, or in some aggregated feeds, journalists will pay the 8 bucks. Twitter in that regard is the opposite of Youtube. Youtube’s bread and butter is make litlle known content creators famous because they’re good (and sell ads on top of it). Nobody gives a shit about content on Twitter - Twitter is ALL ads. So journalists will pay to have their voices heard cause Twitter is in essence an ad network for personal brands.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoWhat a joke, standing anywhere else other than the spot where this guy has found to lodge his head it's been clear that the people most enamored with pontificating on Twitter and checkmarks are journalists. The only reason Twitter has been so overrun and to some extent captured by journos is that before they were aware of its existence people had started to rely on it for news and reporting over the existing media outlets. As soon as they got wind of that they flooded in to mine it for red meat stories or easy topics they could latch onto. Now it's practically the de facto source for most reporting. This guy is trying to spin it as the very bad, no good tech bros are really jealous because journos get free checkmarks with their laptops when they get hired? That tech execs are angry at the media for doing so much hard hitting, in depth Journalism about the tech sector? Does this guy think we were all born in 2017 and don't remember the Obama Twitter years when the media and tech were side by side in the big 'ol government circle jerk? I guess the media have found their new Trump, his name is Elon and he's elected himself president of their little clubhouse so they've gotta try real hard to make it seem like they're the resistance fighting against the evil dark lord, cause everyone loves Star Wars. That's what the kids are into these days, right? ----- I apologize for the snark but goddamn it's just revolting how fucking whiny they are right now. Twitter isn't real life ffs just do your job and write about real things that people care about, not shitty internet drama.
- dan-robertson 4y agoRelated: https://twitter.com/i/status/1588231892792328192 https://twitter.com/i/status/1588231892792328192 And the first tweet here: https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1588240007000911873 https://twitter.com/balajis/status/1588240007000911873 (I think it’s generally right even though I don’t really like the author) I think the general thrust seems pretty reasonable: saying ‘we should cover all tech with an investigative lens’ isn’t actually a neutral policy because if you’re a newspaper then you already want to find good investigative stories anyway. Instead it’s saying that the only stories that go through must be critical or uncovering various hidden harms or issues. It doesn’t seem like a good way to learn what is true. (Nitter links) https://nitter.fly.dev/i/status/1588231892792328192 https://nitter.fly.dev/i/status/1588231892792328192 https://nitter.fly.dev/balajis/status/1588240007000911873 https://nitter.fly.dev/balajis/status/1588240007000911873
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it’s saying that the only stories that go through must be critical or uncovering various hidden harms or issues Speaking outside my circle of competence. But I don't think it's that direct. When a topic is put under an investigative lens, it's assigned investigative journalists. These aren't folks who write fluff. They don't resonate with baseless optimism. They're men and women of hard facts. So they sniff, sniff, sniff until they find something juicy. Then they write about it. Everything they're writing is true. (It may also flatter. Underdog stories, for example.) But when the beer fridge was swapped with a gin cabinet, the journalism got noticeably darker. No conscious filtering needed. Now that I think about it, this may also be happening in political journalism. Positive stories are dismissed as shilling. Writers write to be read. So they stop writing those, and instead write darkly.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI think we have different views about what ‘investigative journalism’ is and different expectations for the competencies of journalists. I also assign a lot of importance to editorial decisions: they are a lot of the selection that leads to selection bias in everyone else. Perhaps you assign less importance to those decisions. An example totally unrelated to tech is that if some politician spaffs tens of millions of dollars up the wall or tens of billions of dollars, the stories can look roughly the same to readers despite 1000x the money being spaffed in one than they other. I think it leads to people assigning badly wrong importances to the different spaffings.
- aaron695 4y agoA good example that people with Blue Checks are idiots? When Blue checks mention each other they get notifications. This is valuable to journalist who want to interact with other people of note. Ever wonder why Blue Checks seem to interact more than the unwashed masses. It's more than respect or following, it's also the Blue Check technology pushing them together. Will allowing anyone with a Blue Check give Stephen King a notification, meaning it'll all get blocked and make the whole thing pointless and not worth $8. Probably, but something new will emerge with destroying the old money that goes with Twitter journalism, and that at least is interesting.
- seydor 4y ago> I can promise you that working journalists derive zero value, social status, or self-esteem from this. indeed it is the other way around, Twitter derived a lot of prestige by essentially pursuing "endorsements" by having their checkmarks accepted by prominent journalists with big audience. Twitter does not control the narrative, except from very fringe issues in which they go with the flow of journalists to keep them on their side. The MSM still controls the narrative and of course they dont depend on checkmarks
- m0d0nne11 4y agoWhy the content-free click-bait headline? Why not honor us all by providing enough info so we can make an informed choice about whether we're likely to be interested?
- musicale 4y agoThe weird NYT editorial decision that tech companies HATE!
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoThat's because they directly compete with big tech for ad revenue.