10 ms·
I always wonder how people say Musk is a failure with a straight face. If that's failure, I wonder what would be a success! I wish my businesses "failed" like
by WalterBright 4y ago
I always wonder how people say Musk is a failure with a straight face. If that's failure, I wonder what would be a success!
I wish my businesses "failed" like Tesla and SpaceX!
- slaw 4y agoSpaceX succeeds despite any Musk's involvement.
- terafo 4y agoSpaceX is something that Musk created and controlled fully for the entirety the full period of existence of SpaceX. I think it is delusional to think it is successful despite Musk, especially with how many better funded space players such as ULA, Blue Origin and various government initiatives are falling behind.
- slaw 4y agoI would like to read opinion from someone working at SpaceX. I don't trust what Elon Musk brags at all.
- panick21_ 4y agoSure I have, you disagree with pretty much all of the leader of SpaceX who have said the opposite. Have you not bothered to look? You disagree with the journalist who has spent most time investigating space. You disagree with most experts who have studied the topic.
- dotnet00 4y agoFortunately there are entire books written on SpaceX's founding years from interviewing employees which support the point that Musk played a pretty big role in SpaceX getting to where it is now.
- damagednoob 4y agoAt the very least you have to say he has a knack for hiring the right people.
- joshxyz 4y agothis. guy got flaws for sure but he's good at finding and funding talent.
- chasd00 4y ago> has a knack for hiring the right people buildings teams is part of my day job, Musk's ability to get the right people in the right spot at the right time and motivated is his biggest gift IMO. If you're good at that then there's really nothing you can't actually do.
- badwolf 4y agoI'd say a big part of SpaceX successes can be attributed to Gwynn Shotwell
- bpodgursky 4y agoShe's definitely critical for the the commercial success, and probably federal contracts. Elon contributed the "what if we landed the rocket?" moonshot ambition. Definitely need both.
- WalterBright 4y agoElon contributed the company and contributed getting the talent hired and pointed in the right direction.
- LargeWu 4y agoAmbition, backed by a lot of money. He's certainly not the first person to say "What if we could reuse the rocket?". Musk's contributions can pretty much be summed up by "already had a lot of money" and "hired smart people". Contrast w/ the founding of Microsoft or Apple, in which the founders were the actual people creating their first products from scratch. Musk is certainly a big-idea person, but I think he is a prime example of somebody who was in the right place to get lucky at the top of the dotcom boom, which in turn rested on him being from an already wealthy family. His foray into Twitter, "how to solve the Ukraine-Russia war", and the Thai cave rescue suggest he's not quite the genius his fans make him out to be.
- dhedberg 4y ago> Musk's contributions can pretty much be summed up by "already had a lot of money" and "hired smart people". He almost went bankrupt getting their first small rocket to space. He wasn't exactly poor at the time thanks to paypal, but he didn't have anything close to unlimited funds. He is a billionaire now because he succeeded, not the other way around. > [..] which the founders were the actual people creating their first products from scratch. If your claim is that Elon was not involved in creating the products, this is misinformed. https://old.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/k1e0ta/evidence_that_musk_is_the_chief_engineer_of_spacex/ https://old.reddit.com/r/SpaceXLounge/comments/k1e0ta/eviden... is the link I have handy. > which in turn rested on him being from an already wealthy family. https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1005593651219582977 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1005593651219582977, "I arrived in North America at 17 w $2000, a backpack & a suitcase full of books. Paid my own way thru college. Dropped out of Stanford Eng/Phys grad school w $110k in college debt." > Thai cave rescue The "pedo"-thing was stupid and deserve criticism, but he was actually asked to continue working on the submarine: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1016684366083190785 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1016684366083190785
- Symmetry 4y agoHere's Tom Mueller, the main rocket expert at early SpaceX, describing his experience working with Elon: >And, uh, I’ve seen that hurt us before, I’ve seen that fail, but I’ve also seen— where nobody thought it would work— it was the right decision. It was the harder way to do it, but in the end, it was the right thing. One of the things that we did with the Merlin 1D was; he kept complaining— I talked earlier about how expensive the engine was. [inaudible] [I said,] “[the] only way is to get rid of all these valves. Because that’s what’s really driving the complexity and cost.” And how can you do that? And I said, “Well, on smaller engines, we’d go face-shutoff, but nobody’s done it on a really large engine. It’ll be really difficult.” And he said, “We need to do face-shutoff. Explain how that works?” So I drew it up, did some, you know, sketches, and said “here’s what we’d do,” and he said “That’s what we need to do.” And I advised him against it; I said it’s going to be too hard to do, and it’s not going to save that much. But he made the decision that we were going to do face-shutoff. >So we went and developed that engine; and it was hard. We blew up a lot of hardware. And we tried probably tried a hundred different combinations to make it work; but we made it work. I still have the original sketch I did; I think it was— what was it, Christmas 2011, when I did that sketch? And it’s changed quite a bit from that original sketch, but it was pretty scary for me, knowing how that hardware worked, but by going face-shutoff, we got rid of the main valves, we got rid of the sequencing computer; basically, you spin the pumps and pressure comes up, the pressure opens the main injector, lets the oxygen go first, and then the fuel comes in. So all you gotta time is the ignitor fluid. So if you have the ignitor fluid going, it’ll light, and it’s not going to hard start. That got rid of the problem we had where you have two valves; the oxygen valve and the fuel valve. The oxygen valve is very cold and very stiff; it doesn’t want to move. And it’s the one you want open first. If you relieve the fuel, it’s what’s called a hard start. In fact, we have an old saying that says, “[inaudible][When you start a rocket engine, a thousand things could happen, and only one of those is good]“, and by having sequencing correctly, you can get rid of about 900 of those bad things, we made these engine very reliable, got rid of a lot of mass, and got rid of a lot of costs. And it was the right thing to do. >And now we have the lowest-cost, most reliable engines in the world. And it was basically because of that decision, to go to do that. So that’s one of the examples of Elon just really pushing— he always says we need to push to the limits of physics. Like, an example I’ll give is, on the car factory; you know, a car moves through a typical factory, like a Toyota or a Chevy factory; a car is moving at you know, inches per second. It’s like, much less than walking speed. And his thoughts are that the machinery, the robots that are building the car should move as fast as they can. They should be moving so fast you can’t see them. That’s why you can’t have people in there, because they’d get crushed; people move too slow. That’s the way he thinks. “So, what are the physical limits of how fast you can make a car?” He looks at videos of like, coke cans being made, and things like that, where you can’t even see them; it’s just a blur. And, you know, the puck of aluminum, cut it up, deep-draw, fill it with coke, you put the lid on, you put the lid on it; it’s just like going down the assembly line so fast you can’t even see it. And Elon wants to do that with cars. People often claim SpaceX was just Musk's show rather than a team effort where Mueller and Shotwell at least were just as important and probably more people besides. And he's had his share of bad ideas. But at the same time the sort of restless perfectionism he tries to get people to have in their engineering is a net force for good, similar to what Steve Jobs did with design at Apple.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoYou can be a failure while being successful in business.
- hinkley 4y agoIn the eyes of your children for sure. Among your peers that’s a harder sell.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoIn the eyes of everyone that knows you. Your peers don’t know you, they are just business relationships and cast a blind eye to who you are as a person. I’ve worked with many extraordinarily successful people and it’s hard to point to more than a few that are successful people outside their work.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI do believe he positively influenced these companies. I also believe he seems to be an insufferable megalomaniac; perhaps less malicious than others but still not healthy. I don't think his goals at twitter are long term profitability or a healthier American society/democracy, so I am very skeptical of his character.
- WalterBright 4y agoMerely "positively influenced"? Come on, without Musk those companies would not exist. > insufferable megalomaniac Nah. He's arrogant, to be sure, but nobody would attempt SpaceX or Tesla without being arrogant. It's a feature, not a bug. > I don't think his goals at twitter are long term profitability or a healthier American society/democracy Do you really think he spent $44B on Twitter to lose money on purpose?
- unethical_ban 4y agoThe top line is debatable, it gets into the great man theory. And FWIW Tesla literally did exist before he was involved. Credit to him entirely for SpaceX being founded, but IIRC Gwynne Shotwell runs it day to day. To the last point: Yes, I think he could. When you have $150,000,000,000, even losing $149,000,000,000 would leave you with $1,000,000,000, which is hundreds and hundreds of times the lifetime net worth of most Americans. Meaning yes, I can completely imagine someone with his money spending a lot of money to have major influence over how the world communicates. Bloomberg spent a billion dollars of his own money trying to be president and he's still quite rich.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Bloomberg spent a billion dollars of his own money trying to be president The Clintons made around $100 million for being President. The Clinton Foundation is worth $300m, and is largely used to fund the Clintons. Obama is worth $70 million. Trump initially viewed his run for office as publicity stunt for his businesses. He was obviously surprised that he won. Being President is very, very lucrative. > FWIW Tesla literally did exist before he was involved I know. And without Musk nobody would have ever heard of it.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y ago> I always wonder how people say Musk is a failure with a straight face. If that's failure, I wonder what would be a success! Business is about improving the quality of life of the consumer. Musk never went directly at that, he always involved himself in industries whose main customer is Government, or that would not exist without Government. Apple, Microsoft, Google, Walmart, JPM...those are real businesses, which would thrive even if Govt. expense were to plummet at 5% of GDP (actually they'd do much better). If Govt. expense were to plummet at 5% of GDP all the functional companies which Musk has would go belly up, not to mention the scam ones such as the NeuraLink and Boring.
- bumby 4y agoIt's also worth mentioning that this effectively outsources much of the risk to the taxpayer. Because the govt is self-insured, there is no insurance needed to limit losses. This is particularly important in risky business ventures, like aerospace. I'm not saying that's a bad thing. The hybrid contractor/govt model has many upsides. SpaceX deserves a lot of credit for what they've done, but that context is important when gushing about when big gambles pay off. Those risks may never occur in a different paradigm.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoSpace is a big waste of money. At best it's a zero sum game playing field between countries. Regular people will never benefit from space. Commentators and pundits were fooled by GPS , Sat-TV and Internet and are extrapolating loads of quality of life which would come from space if only could be cheaper to send stuff up there. The world is increasingly urbanised. Fiber and 5G for telecomms will always be cheaper in an urban setting compared with sat-internet.
- avmich 4y agoAre you saying people won't want to travel and won't need internet outside of cities? Space is already paying for itself.
- 4y ago
- itsoktocry 4y ago>I always wonder how people say Musk is a failure with a straight face. Show me somewhere, anywhere, where someone of any relevance says Musk is a "failure". What people actually say is that he's not the uber-genius, gods-gift-to-humanity that he and his super supporters extoll.
- WalterBright 4y agoI've seen it frequently on HN, that he's a fraud and failure. Here's one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33390278 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33390278 As for gods-gift-to-humanity, there are very, very, very few people who have contributed to humanity like he has.
- vkou 4y agoThat poster is correct, SolarCity was an utter disaster, with a generous helping of self-dealing. People aren't pissing on him when he's right, they are pissing on him when he's wildly, wildly wrong, because he can't stay in his lane. Pedo guy submarine cave rescue is a great example of that. Covid will go away by April 2020 was another. Full Self-driving Tesla robotaxi that makes you money while you sleep in 201? is a third...
- Retric 4y agoIt’s absolutely true he had used more companies to support others, most recently using Tesla workers to look at Twitter. However that argument alone doesn’t support the posts conclusion: “he's simply a highly privileged technocrat who has quite successfully failed upwards his entire career”
- marcusverus 4y agoI find it odd that Elon’s imperfections are a cause of such strong feelings. Imagine how suffocating life would be for him if he endeavored to live up to the expectations of his detractors. He would never start a company without being certain of success. He’d be super nice to the diver (who told Elon to stick a submarine up his ass). He’d never speculate about anything or discuss his vision for the future, because imperfect foresight makes people mad! …and the haters would still hate. Happily for Elon, he seems content to be himself and deal with the silly complaints.
- memish 4y agoProjection and Tall Poppy Syndrome. Also there's extra incentive to tear down anyone with multiple successes, as they're a constant reminder that success isn't all due to luck.
- Jerrrry 4y ago>constant reminder that success isn't all due to luck. this is the crux of it. If he isn't just lucky, than that pushes one's own perils from misfortune to the realm of a lack of self-actualization and agency. Hard work makes you much more lucky, and that oxymoron is a hard pill for the "unfortunate" masses to swallow. No one wants to admit to not working hard; they want to push the responsibility to (mis)fortune.
- WalterBright 4y agoHard work is necessary, but not sufficient. One also needs the audacity to do things everyone else says are impossible - like making a new car company from scratch, or reusable rockets - something NASA has failed at for 60 years. (The space shuttle had to be essentially rebuilt after every mission, the boosters were thrown away, the concept was a dead-end from the start.)
- bumby 4y agoThis misunderstands the differences in how NASA is managed and constrained. It has inefficiency built in as a feature, not a bug. E.g., NASA cannot build a major program with an assembly line mentality. The need to spread their work out across multiple constituencies to ensure continued support. Ever wonder why major NASA centers are in key political states like Florida, California, Texas, and Ohio?
- WalterBright 4y agoNo argument there. Socialism doesn't work very well.
- bigmattystyles 4y agoIt's not that people (including myself) say he's a failure, for me, it's a massive amount of skepticism with admittedly a fair amount of snark. To me, he seems to want to take all the credit - I've rarely seen media reports of him saying the efforts of someone else were paramount (edit: other than a team at one of his companies) - It could be the media I'm consuming, but even on his Twitter feed, I've not seen him mention Shotwell for instance. One man, I don't care how smart, cannot be this involved in so many projects and succeed so wildly without being incredibly demanding, maybe too demanding of those who work for him. Let's give credit to those there day to day, like Shotwell, who realistically is a lot more involved and hands-on than he is. Or you know - maybe he is that amazing, I doubt it, but Trump did invent the MRNA vaccines all by himself as well, so...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dhedberg 4y agoI really do think it's the media you're consuming. Here he thanks Tom Mueller: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1333544636137283586 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1333544636137283586 Here he thanks some Tesla club members: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1211836235762880512 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1211836235762880512 Here he thanks NASA for all the support over the years, "without which this would not have happened": https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1219127317957615617 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1219127317957615617 Here he says that "Gwynne is the best": https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1538400836669296640 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1538400836669296640 That's just a random collection I found with a couple of quick google searches. If you have actually watched for example the starbase tours with Elon, it's difficult to claim that he isn't "involved": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t705r8ICkRw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t705r8ICkRw
- bigmattystyles 4y agoI didn't mean to say he wasn't involved at all, just that imho (which doesn't matter) most of these companies would be fine without him. He is a savvy business player, knows how to grab available resources as well as the spotlight. I don't see anyone heralding Bezos or a few other CEOs I could name to this level and he's quite a bit more successful. Sidenote, all but a few of his twitter mentions of Shotwell are responses to mentions of her and it seems like he's injecting himself into the discussion.
- varjag 4y agoYes there's definitely a yearning for a person with crap politics to be also a fraud and under-performer. The most famous auto maker of the last century was a Nazi sympathizer and the previous space program darling an SS officer, you'd think people figure it out by now.
- api 4y agoHow many musicians do you like who are complete lunatics or toxic narcissists in real life? There just doesn't seem to be a correlation between success in some narrow domain like engineering, business, art, or music and being a good human being in general. I also wonder if there's a causative factor. When someone becomes super successful they tend to get surrounded by people telling them what a genius they are. That can definitely distort someone's self image. Could you stay balanced if millions of people compared you to a comic book superhero for years and loads of people did whatever you said because you had tons of money? Now throw in tons of stress and quite possibly a good helping of loneliness due to the difficulty all this creates with forming real deep relationships with others.
- WalterBright 4y ago> There just doesn't seem to be a correlation between success in some narrow domain like engineering, business, art, or music and being a good human being in general. I don't see any particular correlation with being a bad human, either. Look hard enough at anyone and you'll find feet of clay. Success in their domains greatly outshine the clay.
- justinator 4y agoRemindMe! 1 Month "What's happening with Musk in re: Twitter"
- rootusrootus 4y agoIt's possible to be successful in business and still be an insufferable douche. Elon regularly punches down, not up. It's hard to really respect a man like that. And Tesla is a famously consumer-hostile company. We don't need more success like that. SpaceX is a much better example, and a lot of that can be attributed to how well he delegated leadership to someone competent. Now he's waded into one of the most difficult lines of business and we'll find out in the next couple of years whether he's just been lucky and well-funded, or if he really is a business genius.
- bombcar 4y agoWho can he punch up to? Overthrow governments? Bezos?
- avmich 4y agoFor example, Musk gives AI predictions, and there are some quite knowledgeable ML scientists. E.g. Andrej Karpathy?
- dotancohen 4y ago> Tesla is a famously consumer-hostile company. I own a Tesla, and I was a technician at a Ford dealership decades ago. Despite what you read on the internet, Tesla had better service and comparable quality to almost any vehicle on the road today. It's not Lexus, but Tesla's quality easily surpasses and other American brand. There are tons of issues, sure, but that is no different than any other car company. You just don't hear about the others. It seems to me that being a technology company in addition to being a car company, Tesla's buyers are more likely than other brands' buyers to complain on the internet. And every supposed journalist knows that a Tesla hit piece will garner clicks.
- bumby 4y ago>Tesla had better service and comparable quality to almost any vehicle on the road today. Initially, Consumer Reports seemed to really like Tesla. But much more recently, they have not generally rated Tesla comparable to other cars. They only have one model (the Model 3) that even scored average. One of their issues is that they like to move fast in their designs. Changing sensors, suppliers, components etc. means it's really hard to nail reliability and quality. As the saying goes...move fast and, well...break things. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/17/cars/tesla-consumer-reports-drop/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/02/17/cars/tesla-consumer-reports-d...
- sixothree 4y agoWho is saying he is a failure? Cite you darn sources.
- WalterBright 4y agoI provided a link.
- mathverse 4y agoI prefer to think Musk is Andrew Tate's version of the tech world.
- WalterBright 4y agoOne reason Musk is so successful: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587894226695884800 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1587894226695884800 It's darned good marketing. Simple and effective.
- grecy 4y agoYour comment makes no sense. SpaceX build one engine per day while the competition is building one every 91 days. They're landing and re-using rockets every single week. They're taking humans into space. Tesla build cars that have won basically every award there is. They're are basically the safest cars on the road. They outsell other EVs enormously. There is no marketing it any of that, it's simply all facts.
- ninefathom 4y agoSuccess and failure are, of course, highly subjective terms. Success, according to what definition? What flavor of failure? I'd almost be inclined to suspect that Musk says (privately, to his closest confidants) that he's had very few successes and a great many failures. Now, on the other hand, if one wanted to say that his public persona is often that of a pompous windbag, I'd be hard-pressed to disagree, though I'd hasten to add that (unfortunate as it might be) one almost has to be a pompous windbag in public to get far in business in contemporary culture. We live in the Era of Outrage, after all; "number of people pissed off" might as well be currency.
- nrb 4y agoI haven’t really seen him called a failure unless it’s in the context of habitual over-promising and failing to meet frequently and very publicly stated goals. But, the stuff his companies are doing is hard so it is what it is. Couldn’t hurt to be more realistic from time to time though.
- kamaal 4y agoPeople do this all the time. Remember the times when people used to go around hating Steve Jobs(He didn't build the entire iPhone or iPod by himself etc etc, "so why does he get the credit" sort of reasons). I was there when Bill Gates would attract similar hate. Jeff Bezos is only lucky that there isn't much of public facing information on Bezos, like Bezos speeches or Bezos is not known to routinely give out success advice on commonly accessible media. Elon Musk is a highly successful immigrant entrepreneur, built several companies, some of them happen to be some of the hardest businesses ever to win in. Has a very powerful social media presence, he announces his intentions often, which many feel are impossible, but he wins nevertheless. He also is also very good in social culture scene too, which many people find cool. He is what most people want to be, but can't for various (at times valid)reasons. Being a counter thesis to your (at times valid)excuses is bound to attract some resentment and hate.