8 ms·
One in eight U.S. adult deaths aged 20 to 64 involved too much alcohol
- barbazoo 4y agoI would suspect alcohol consumption to be a symptom of some underlying issue but still, it's shocking. And even more shocking that we've known for decades how destructive alcohol consumption is yet society and policymakers do very little about it depending on where you are.
- mehphp 4y agoI'm genuinely curious what can/should be done. If we ban it, people will still make it illegally, there will be violence, and we are in the same place that cannabis is now.
- jeffbee 4y agoYou could erase one of the mechanisms by making America a place where you can walk to a party or a bar, instead of driving there and then killing yourself with your car afterwards. Also possible benefits from making America be a place where fewer want to commit suicides.
- barbazoo 4y agoI think many countries were successful in reducing the popularity of smoking cigarettes and if I'm not mistaken a big part of that was to ban advertising. As with cigarettes, we do know that alcohol is addictive and destructive. An advertising ban might be a good first step.
- AlgorithmicTime 4y ago
- sparrish 4y agoThis isn't the responsibility of policy makers. It's fathers and mothers who should be teaching their children about the dangers of alcohol and living an example worth following.
- lostapathy 4y agoA moral high horse is great, but if you're stuck in the cycle where you learn destructive habits from your parents that are hard to overcome in adulthood, how do you break that cycle with out a nudge from society and policy makers?
- retrac 4y ago> policymakers do very little They're constrained. There aren't terribly many policy levers to pull! At the extreme, we outright tried banning it in North America once; that didn't work very well. Taxes and minimum pricing do work to reduce consumption, but they're quite unpopular with the public. A political party in my part of the world recently won an election by promising to expand retail availability of alcohol and to lower the price. I'd note that the majority of the cost of alcohol is already taxes. The untaxed cost of alcohol is kind of frightening and is enough to make me reconsider my more libertarian inclinations with drugs. Pure grain alcohol of the kind used to make cheap spirits or for industrial purposes is literally around $1 a litre to make. Sells for $30 a litre here -- swill vodka has a 3000% markup imposed due to tax policies designed to curb consumption. Cranking it up higher has negative consequences too. I know that with tobacco, among the most dedicated cigarette smokers, increases in prices have little impact on consumption; the addicts we'd want to incentivize the most to quit with price signalling are the most resistant to price signalling due to their addiction -- they just get poorer. It becomes a dichotomy/trade-off. How how hard do we kick the homeless alcoholic when he's down vs. how much we stop college kids from taking up binge-drinking? Booze is also pretty easy to make at home so there's the consideration of prices being high enough to push people to the grey/black market, too. I would like to see our governments go after alcohol advertising; it's basically a free-for-all in many jurisdictions. It's interesting to compare the new regulations in Canada on cannabis advertising (essentially banned in all forms) vs. the regulations on alcohol advertising (what regulations?) Yet which is the more addictive and compulsive drug?
- kennend3 4y ago> It's interesting to compare the new regulations in Canada on cannabis advertising (essentially banned in all forms) vs. the regulations on alcohol advertising (what regulations?) Yet which is the more addictive and compulsive drug? I'm Canadian as well. You know why cannabis was deregulated? Tax revenue and to kill off the illegal sales. They knew there was a demand for the product and finally caved in and opened up legal sales so they could get in on that action. As you rightly point out, it is already taxed to death and yet the demand continues? Outright prohibition wont work.. what are the options available? We saw what happens with Cigarettes and taxes, black market. Canada did a study and counted butts outside a courthouse - a very high percentage were contraband.
- kennend3 4y ago> yet society and policymakers do very little about it depending on where you are. I think your focus is misplaced. It is not policy issue, it is the general public itself that is the problem. Policymakers tried, via prohibition, would you mark this as a success? I dont drink, and never have so i am on the outside looking in. It is astonishing how "alcohol" is front and center in many things. Hard day at work and you want to go out with coworkers.. Where do you almost always end up? Want to celebrate something? Head over to the bar? The root issues with alcohol are the same with other drugs, smoking, etc. Peer pressure, societal norms, etc. Policymakers hands are basically tied. On one hand they LOVE the revenue. Here (Canada) we have "sin taxes" and alcohol is heavily taxed. No government will want to forfeit this revenue. Manufacturing alcohol provides jobs, inspecting it provides jobs... If it is not legal, bootlegging will return. I would also like to see a decline in Alcohol consumption, much as we saw with smoking.. but you need to take the successful aspects of the "quit smoking" program and apply them to alcohol.
- barbazoo 4y ago> Policymakers hands are basically tied. > I would also like to see a decline in Alcohol consumption, much as we saw with smoking.. Exactly and one way to do that is to ban advertising. And that's totally in the power of policy makers I'd say.
- t-3 4y agoI wouldn't be so sure. There seems with most substances to be a cultural hedonism-puritanism cycle. Alcohol and tobacco have both been through many of these.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> It is astonishing how "alcohol" is front and center in many things. Alcoholics love to normalize their behavior and there are a lot of them in the media making subtle decisions that promote their lifestyle.
- kennend3 4y ago
- tester756 4y agoLet's start with smoking Unlike alcohol it have no positive value
- barbazoo 4y agoI think we were pretty successful with smoking at least where I live(d). I don't know anybody who smokes cigarettes.
- tester756 4y agoI'm envy as hell 90% of my friends smoke 30% of them smokes a lot I wish this shit got banned worldwide and tobacco's industry C levels were gunned down
- kennend3 4y agoSmoking where i am from has fallen drastically. Both my parents smoked a lot (my dad smoked two packs a day). I dont know anyone who smokes. "In 2017, the overall prevalence of smoking in Canada was 15.1%, equivalent to approximately 4.6 million Canadians. This represents a significant increase from the 2015 estimate of 13.0%." here's a nice chart showing the gradual decline before a spike in usage?? https://uwaterloo.ca/tobacco-use-canada/adult-tobacco-use/smoking-canada/current-smoking-prevalence https://uwaterloo.ca/tobacco-use-canada/adult-tobacco-use/sm... The government has been VERY aggressive at curbing it. https://www.tobaccocontrollaws.org/legislation/country/canada/summary#:~:text=Most%20forms%20of%20tobacco%20advertising,border%20advertising%20is%20not%20restricted https://www.tobaccocontrollaws.org/legislation/country/canad.... I noticed it is still a "cultural" issue? My ex is Chinese and when i went to China it seems everyone smokes there? If the government is willing to accept the loss of revenue from taxes.. They can hammer away at something and make changes.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWeight loss via appetite suppression and (speculating) giving you something else to do with your mouth. Admittedly that doesn't balance out the downsides, but there is that. Non-smoker, for the record.
- mdaEyebot 4y agoPolicymakers tried to do something about it in the United States - alcohol was made illegal by a constitutional amendment (the 18th), which means that 2/3 of the legislative body had to vote for it. Predictably, people continued to consume alcohol in less safe ways, illegal "speakeasy" bars flourished, and moonshining became a very popular occupation. NASCAR was born when bootleggers started racing the cars that they had modified to outrun the police. Eventually, the 21st amendment was passed to repeal the 18th.
- barbazoo 4y agoThat was 100 years ago. Since then many countries have successfully reduced the usage of other harmful substances, for instance tobacco which was done by prohibiting advertising. It doesn't need a ban to change the public's behavior.
- aeternum 4y agoYes, an all out ban is foolish, there are smarter ways to deal with it. Why not slap a significant tax on alcohol advertising just as we do with alcohol sales?
- mlinksva 4y agoIndeed why not. Yet another possibility: remove copyright restrictions on any work featuring alcohol or an alcohol brand.
- mdaEyebot 4y agoThe taxes on alcohol are already quite high; vice taxes are good politics. I am all for a complete ban on alcohol ads, even if it seems about as likely to happen as a ban on car ads.
- croes 4y agoBut marijuana is the dangerous drug
- glonq 4y agoIt's 1/8 for ages 20-64 For 20 to 34 it's 1/4 For 35 to 49 it's 1/6 Those numbers are [literally?] quite sobering.
- metacritic12 4y agoIt's also a statistical trick because so few people die before 64 (even more so for e.g. 49). This table [1] shows that someone who makes it to 20 only has a 2% chance of dying before 64. This means eliminating that 1/8 of deaths due to alcohol probably only results in something like 0.1 QALY. The alcohol result is a corollary of the fact that people who die between ages 20-50 usually die in graphic accidents versus "natural causes" like heart attack, stroke, that are actually the unconditional largest causes of death. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/241572/death-rate-by-age-and-sex-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241572/death-rate-by-age...
- xapata 4y agoThe magnitude is interesting as well, tis true. However, I wouldn't say it's a statistical "trick" because that implies the ratio is not useful information.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoStill a useful trick where the goal is to understand unnecessary death.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoYeah but how does it compare to countries that have public transport?
- quantified 4y agoNothing in there on what the involvement was, so not at all useful. Drunk driver killed self or othere? Drunk domestic partner did the killing? Drunk and killed by police for acting out? Health problems? Died because caregiver was drunk? Simply had alcohol in the system at the time of death (but also perhaps meat, sugar, nicotine, etc.)? I don't dispute that alcohol causes acute and chronic problems. But "involved" is just too vague.
- BeefWellington 4y agoIf a drunk driver kills sober people, I'd argue it's correct to consider alcohol "involved" in the deaths.
- soco 4y agoSame if a sober driver kills drunk people, alcohol is involved - maybe even causally (they fall over the road)...
- notch656a 4y ago"Involved" is a nice weasel word that was invented to imply 'caused' without having to prove it.
- happytoexplain 4y agoThe first line of the article is "One out of every eight deaths in Americans ages 20 to 64 resulted from drinking too much alcohol, according to a U.S. population-based study." (emphasis mine) They certainly still have the burden of demonstrating that somehow, but exclusively focusing on the particular near-synonym they used in the title seems uncharitable if you have read the first line of the article.
- bdcravens 4y agoThat feels like a "guns don't kill people" take.
- 4y ago
- fdgsdfogijq 4y ago
- tristor 4y agoI find this hard to believe, unless we are stretching the bounds of "involved" to mean that /any/ participant in /any/ event where-in they had /any/ alcohol detectable in their bloodstream is "alcohol involved". I don't see how alcohol could be the causative factor in this significant a number of fatalities, as someone who regularly consumes alcohol in safe ways. Maybe I'm simply not as reckless as most other people (other parts of my life would seem to indicate this may be true), but this is a huge statement that seems to be largely unsubstantiated in the article.
- 1123581321 4y agoIt’s because total deaths are rare in the age range (20-64.)
- ananiochita 4y agoThere are no safe ways to consume alcohol. The only completely safe amount is zero. https://thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0140-6736%2818%2931310-2 https://thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0140-6736%2818%293...
- s1artibartfast 4y agoSpeaking in absolutes is rarely helpful or informative. There is no safe way to leave your house. The only completely safe option is to stay in a bunker.
- ananiochita 4y ago> Speaking in absolutes is rarely helpful or informative. The study I link and from which I quote is rather informative.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI agree it is quite interesting. If you look to figure 5 you will see that moderate drinking has very low impact on relative risk, and figure 4 shows some moderate benefit with respect to ischemic heart disease and diabetes. IF you buy into this kind of high level analysis, drinking 1-3 drinks a day may lower your risk for these diseases ~10-20%. At the end of the day, the conclusions are much the same as people would intuit. moderate drinking has little impact, may help some conidiations and exacerbate others and will depend on the individual. for the average person, the effect will be slightly negative. What I find most shocking is that you have to get to 5-6 drinks before relative risk hits 1.5X. 30-40 drinks/week is a lot for non-alcoholics.
- notch656a 4y agoPeople are quick to point out vehicle crashes where evidence of alcohol is found in the body of the driver, but are there any studies that show how much driving time is avoided due to alcohol consumption? I know drinking and driving is bad (and so do many others), so for many of us I would wager it keeps us away from driving and many other dangerous activities. Sober me with too much free times starts thinking "lets go walking into back alleys in Mexico or riding motorcycles through the twisties." That's not to say one is healthier that way, though.
- scrumbledober 4y agoIt may keep you away from driving but does it keep you away from travelling by car? Riding in an uber because you drank is just as dangerous as driving yourself sober.
- mindslight 4y agoIt's actually riding in a car time as opposed to driving time, so not as much as you're thinking. Taking it as given that you're going to a bar for the social venue, abstaining and then driving yourself home would have a similar risk profile to taking a cab or carpooling with a designated driver. To have the effect you're pondering, the actual transportation mode needs to change. Like being in a city and perhaps driving to meet up would be the most convenient, but you take public transportation (even though it takes twice as long) so that you can drink.
- bdcravens 4y agoThe article isn't limited to drinking and driving. Only 12-24% of the deaths (depending on the age group) are due to vehicle crashes.
- fullshark 4y agoRecommend adding "ages 20 to 64" to the headline, pretty misleading otherwise
- happytoexplain 4y agoIn my opinion, I wouldn't go so far as to call using the word "adult" as a stand-in for "20 to 64" misleading.
- yunwal 4y agoWould you not consider someone who is 70 an adult?
- kwhitefoot 4y agoSecond childhood? :-)
- glonq 4y agoYup, it's all diapers, naps, and mushy food again.,
- fuckstick 4y agoIf you are being above board you can split the “adult” population into elderly or senior, but without that stated up front I would expect adult to mean everyone 18+. And especially since most people under 64 don’t just up and die, it’s misleading to state that ratio without that qualification.
- rsynnott 4y agoWait, what do you consider a 65 year old, if not an adult?
- kulahan 4y agoUsually they're considered sorta "past" the adult stage since they're eligible to retire. Most studies are interested in people living their prime years - aka their working years. That's not to say "adult" doesn't ALSO encompass what a senior citizen is, it's just not the common usage.
- LatteLazy 4y agoCan we ban Association Studies like these please? It's just clickbait...
- endisneigh 4y agoAdvertising of alcohol needs to be banned in all channels including but not limited to internet, billboards, radio and tv. Banning consumption of alcohol in general or banning scenes involving alcohol in The media are futile but advertising needs to be done imo.
- bdcravens 4y agoThe same argument could be made of guns, and like with guns, I think it would have little to no effect.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWithin the gun community, popular media is often credited with teaching gun enthusiasm to younger generations. Particularly video games and internet videos. But these aren't traditional advertising, gun manufacturers (mostly, not always) don't pay for these things, and a law banning people from producing such media with their own funds would surely be unconstitutional. Also I don't think the public is up for another round of geriatric politicians trying to ban violent video games.
- jgtrosh 4y agoFrance did this successfully with the loi Evin in 1991. Since then, consumption has gone down, but it's not clear how much the law helped. Overall, most people would agree it's a good thing.
- jpmattia 4y agoThe JAMA article is open and has more precise info: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2798004 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle...
- bdcravens 4y agoI see a lot of defensiveness in the comments here. Speaking for myself, and myself only, I'm a four years sober alcoholic, and knowing my behavior at the height of my addiction, I could have easily harmed myself or someone else while intoxicated.
- jahsome 4y agoDon't mistake needless pedantism (a hn sport) for defensiveness.
- karaterobot 4y agoWithout drawing any conclusions, I cannot help but notice a deeper than usual skepticism in HN threads about articles that report on the negative effects of alcohol.
- rtev 4y agoPeople get defensive when they feel like they’re being attacked. Many people really enjoy alcohol and don’t like to think about it as a dangerous drug (which, of course, it is).
- taeric 4y agoI think the skepticism is on any article that has a single answer to health related problems. For me, I find that a lot of people blame alcohol for other negative behavior in ways that doesn't make sense. It is fair to say alcohol gets too free of a pass, at large, while also thinking it is too quickly blamed for things, too.
- glonq 4y agoPretty much the same skepticism you'll see outside of HN too. It's a difficult subject to touch without one side soundy too preachy/judgy and the other side getting defensive and irrational. The way I see it is this -- our brave new world is tough, and many people need their happy juice to cope with the burden of it. Maybe better work/life balance and better mental/emotional health resources would improve this, but unfortunately both those things get in the way of the rich becoming richer so don't expect much.
- t-3 4y agoDrinking is incredibly common, so everyone has some experience with it, and very few experience loss due to it. Same reason the flu vaccine has perpetually low uptake. Prohibition is also taught in American schools as THE failure of government policy. The barest suggestion that alcohol regulation might be necessary to prevent some problem is going to be immediately viewed through that lens.
- taylodl 4y agoSometimes the effects of a lifetime of alcohol consumption, even moderate consumption, don't catch up with you until you're much older. Ask me how I know...
- rsynnott 4y agoHeadline: > One in Eight U.S. Adult Deaths Involved Too Much Alcohol First line: > One out of every eight deaths in Americans ages 20 to 64 resulted from drinking too much alcohol, according to a U.S. population-based study This is _disgracefully_ misleading headlining; not sure I've ever seen one this bad. People aged 20-64 don't die all that much, and generally die of different things than the population at large, who on average do their dying later, so, this is perhaps true, but not at all what the headline claims.
- ketanmaheshwari 4y agoI personally didn't find it _that_ misleading.
- croes 4y agoIt depends on the actual numbers. The death rate above 64 is much higher. https://www.statista.com/statistics/241572/death-rate-by-age-and-sex-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/241572/death-rate-by-age... So one in eight could be massive exaggeration.
- deeblering4 4y agoWhat age range would you classify as "adult"?
- bombcar 4y agoI would first think "18+" and I certainly wouldn't have a cutoff at retirement age unless it was "working-age adults".
- croes 4y agoI think it's more about the point, that most people who die are older than 64. So it's less than one in eight that die with alcohol involved
- Rebelgecko 4y ago18 to infinite. For the topic I suppose 21+ would also be reasonable. But excluding a 65 yo seems weird.
- juancn 4y agoSo 87.5% of US adult deaths did not involve too much alcohol. News at 9.
- puchatek 4y agoMaybe to you this is all plain as day but it wasn't so long ago that people thought one glass of wine per day was good for the heart. Now we know that alcohol is always toxic with no safe minimum. I bet that hearing just how many preventable deaths are linked to this one thing is a big surprise to many.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoAnd one glass of wine per day is still quite safe, despite not being perfectly safe. Almost nothing is perfectly safe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]