13 ms·
U.S. pushes Japan and other allies to join China chip curbs
- elzbardico 4y agoUSA, this brave champion of Free Markets!
- qwezxcrty 4y agoI feel like they are creating a new version of The Plaza Accord.
- hello_friendos 4y agoI'd rather my country not follow the US off yet another cliff. We still remember the US lying about weapons of mass destruction to justify yet another unnecessary war (only necessary to feed the American war machine)
- cenal 4y agoYes, because China is a bastion of good information...
- unity1001 4y agoCompared to the US, yes, everyone is.
- HyperSane 4y agoSeriously?
- unity1001 4y agoSeriously. Many countries' establishments have a fear of lying, due to the repercussions of what happens if they were caught. That is the very reason why Soviet establishment chose not to lie, as we see from the period's records. Which made their propaganda much less effective compared to the emotional manipulation - especially atrocity propaganda - that Angloamerica uses. Lying is an establishment practice in Angloamerica only because Angloamerican public uses ignoring their own lot's offenses and directing their ire at external enemies as a way to create and protect group cohesion. They are not dumb. They believe the lies that they are told willingly for that purpose and ignore the offenses of those who perpetuate them for the above reason. That's why the entire administrations who lied about things like Iraqi WMDs, Vietnam etc and murdered tens of millions of people over 30-40 years are still on top of the establishment instead of getting persecuted. The history of the atrocity propaganda as a policy tool in Angloamerica goes back to Elizabethan England, which used a lot of smears against its Spanish enemies and it worked. In the following centuries, we see the English establishment using lies about external enemies and atrocity propaganda as a means to scare the English to support the aristocratic regime and justify wars. From the war of Jenkins' Ear to whatever example one may pick. "Evildoers are about to beat our fleet and invade our islands" is the constant propaganda in between 1560-1760. In World War I, atrocity propaganda was institutionalized - there was no other way to justify a millions of commoners dying for aristocratic monarchies whose monarchs were cousins among themselves. So was invented the "Germans murdered and raped babies in Belgium" lie, which STILL goes on today with many people believing that Germans actuall did that. It worked very well for Britain in Ww I. From that point on, Britain never let go of atrocity propaganda and lies, and the US copied a lot of their practices. Iraqi WMD case is just a trifle compared to the constant lying, smearing and 'wag the dog' cases over ~100 years of recent history.
- HyperSane 4y ago" That is the very reason why Soviet establishment chose not to lie" I love the things insane tankies say.
- unity1001 4y agoI have no problem with being labeled a tankie. So save that for the American discourse. It has absolutely no effect in my country. ... Its only insane because you have no knowledge of actual history, less, the actual declassified documents of the USSR and instead 'know' things based on the cold war propaganda that you sucked up over the years. Like how 'propaganda' was something that only 'others' did, and there was 'free press' in 'the West.
- _kbh_ 4y ago> Its only insane because you have no knowledge of actual history You realise that Russia and the USSR lied nearly constantly right? And you can hear about it from like hundreds of millions of post soviet citizens?. I mean it’s gotta be beyond clear to anyone that Russia lies to its own citizens there soldiers dug defences in one of the most radioactive parts of the world.
- unity1001 4y ago> You realise that Russia and the USSR lied nearly constantly right? No. We dont. That's what the American propaganda tells us. Not the circumstances and actual declassified documents. Character assassination, nothing else. > hundreds of millions of post soviet citizens?. Hundreds of millions of post soviet citizens do not say anything like that. https://www.thetrumpet.com/18312-poll-two-thirds-of-russians-miss-the-soviet-union https://www.thetrumpet.com/18312-poll-two-thirds-of-russians... > I mean it’s gotta be beyond clear to anyone that Russia lies That's a religious statement. Nothing else. The US lied about nonexistent WMDs for EIGHT years. And yet, its propaganda is the one that's being trusted to determine the trustworthiness of others. That's just crazy.
- pessimizer 4y agoEven when we lie, it's somehow China's fault.
- HyperSane 4y agoAnd China is just so trustworthy /s
- hunglee2 4y agoUS must coerce allies into accepting anti-China strategy - sieges do not work unless it is complete. Depriving China of the ability to advance technologically, economically and militarily will ensure supremacy and the maintenance of the rule based order
- peppertree 4y agoIt would have worked if China didn't have deep pool of engineers and fundings to backup multi decade R&D projects. We are going to look back at this and realize it's a strategic mistake.
- oa335 4y agoWhose rules?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hunglee2 4y agothe international community's
- PKop 4y agoIs that what blowing up Nord Stream 2 was for, the benefit of "the community"? Sounds like a load of crap. Doesn't sound very rules based or orderly.
- plushpuffin 4y agoRussia did that. They've damaged/destroyed their own pipelines before in order to avoid penalty clauses in contracts or to get out of a bad deal after the price changed out of their favor, and that's why they did it this time, too. https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2022/09/29/russian-sabotage-of-the-nord-stream-pipeline-mark-a-point-of-no-return/?sh=3200d4005dba https://www.forbes.com/sites/arielcohen/2022/09/29/russian-s... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-russia-turkmenistan-gas-sb/turkmen-may-sue-russia-for-vacuum-bomb-pipe-blast-idUSTRE54S4TG20090529 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-russia-turkmenistan-gas-s...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dirtyid 4y agoVoluntary CHIPS4 a bust so down to unilateral "pushing". Weaken Yen = more demand from PRC and incentive to de-americanize supply chains while increasingly expensive for JP to procure US defense. US can coerce with big sticks but at some point the logic/draw of carrots may be overwhelming.
- unity1001 4y agoRant about "Free market" until you lose the competition. Then its all out, hypocritical, double-standard protectionism, even economic warfare.
- remarkEon 4y agoThe "free market" is just a tool, nothing more. The second it starts to interfere with the livelihood or your country or the health and welbeing of its citizens, governments are well within their bounds to step in and interrupt this "free market". The wisdom and second order effects of those policies is a secondary discussion.
- wnevets 4y agoThis is implying that China is providing a "Free Market". For example it is impossible for American companies to even open a chip plant in China without first going through a Chinese company.
- metacritic12 4y agoThe original international theory of the free market is that they don't need to be recursive for it to work. It's OK if country X decides to subsidize sector A or B -- it's just free money for the world. The logic of this is the same as within countries. It's OK if Google uses search to subsidize it's smart phone operations. On the highest layer, it's still capitalism and should still work. We don't kick Google out of US markets just because it's internal departments don't use free markets to allocate goods. The international free market is still supposed to work even if a country doesn't have internal free markets. That the US is going back on the first shows that in the end, it was always about geopolitics. When free markets aligned with US geopolitics, it was nice to be able to say "oh we're being principled".
- wnevets 4y ago> It's OK if country X decides to subsidize sector A or B -- it's just free money for the world. Tell that to the American steel industry.
- yrgulation 4y agoOh dont worry germany wants access to china’s car market and so it will push for china friendly policies in the eu. Germany is heading towards stagnation and thats likely the only market that can drive growth. Same reason they dont mind uighur slave labour, much like they ignored russias human rights abuses - yet quickly sanctioning allies for even the slightest disagreement. I hope the us manages to push this through so more high tech manufacturing returns to the us and free europe.
- lizardactivist 4y agoThe US realized it can't win in a globalized world, so now they work to partition the world and call themselves "the good guys" and hope other countries will join and remain dependent and obedient.
- president 4y agoI think you're partially correct but the framing is a bit off. A country's interests and security comes first. We have seen China's values and goals obviously clash with western values so why would the west let them have their way?
- HyperSane 4y agoOnly a fool trusts China.
- ShivShankaran 4y agoand the poor trusts US. We will find out in 5 years how poor the EU will be. Like Macron said: the good times are over. Lie down with dogs, get up with fleas.
- HyperSane 4y agoWhat are you even talking about?
- lizardactivist 4y agoCan you elaborate on that, and as a relevant point maybe show that trusting the US has always turned out well.
- HyperSane 4y agoIt turned out pretty well for Western Europe and Japan after WWII.
- neonsunset 4y agoIt is beyond me why would people try to even consider an idea of defending China or arguing from devil's advocate PoV. It is in the best interest of literally everyone in the civilized world to curb the current regime in China with Xi continued power centralization and breakneck pace at catching up with North Korea in terms of how the country is ruled.
- d0mine 4y ago
- neonsunset 4y agoSince you're willing to engage in such an argument, you should count by the number of civilian casualties and violations of human rights instead, in which China and Russia would be holding the top spots by a wide margin.
- zmaurelius 4y agoCan you show some data to back that up? Post 9/11 US wars have displaced more than 38 million people and directly caused more than 900,000 deaths. China and Russia both have terrible records when it comes to human rights, but where are you getting the numbers that they have caused more deaths?
- TinkersW 4y agoGreat Leap Forward, Korean War(NK had support from China to kick it off), Chinese civil war. I see no reason to limit to post 9/11, but if you wish, then Covid is completely China's fault for lax preventative measures and killed more than 900,000.
- zmaurelius 4y agoBy your logic, Congo should be topping that list for introducing HIV to the world and causing more than 40 million deaths. That sounds ridiculous to me, but hey whatever floats your boat.
- ram4jesus 4y agoAs an American this constant China fear-mongering feels so out of place; it's like trying to plug the Titanic with your fingers. Historically China has been one of the most important financial centers in the world; this is just a regression to the mean. Why are we trying to stop it when the Chinese clearly want to collaborate with us. The train's leaving the station without us. There's a political, multipolar, realignment between the Global South, i.e. the non 'golden billion', and Eurasia - and we're not playing a leading role when we should be. Unipolarity is a unique abnormality throughout history; why do we think the current status quo of the U.S. hegemon is the default for the future?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIt is important to understand that "the western world is conspiring against us" is a major tenet of state propaganda in Russia, China, Iranian and other totalitarian countries. Moves like this only serve to confirm it.
- kelnos 4y agoWhere is the evidence that China wants to collaborate with "us"? It seems like their standard playbook is to entice or force others to open their markets to them, but then refuse to reciprocate. They are an isolationist authoritarian nation, with already-large and still-growing influence over world politics and economic matters. Perhaps what the West is doing right now to attempt to curb this is the wrong move, but I don't think the "fear-mongering" is unwarranted at all.
- amaccuish 4y ago> They are an isolationist authoritarian nation, with already-large and still-growing influence Your first part doesn't really go with the second. I agree, China is very isolationist. But that's precisely why I'm not concerned about this "influence". They're absolutely not interested in converting other countries to their system, they will work with anyone who they can do business with.
- iconhacker 4y agoWhat about Saudi? Is it an authoritarian but still US ally? Double standards?
- HyperSane 4y agoShame that people's irrational hatred of the US has prevented reasonable debate on this topic.
- boc 4y agoThe internet in general is incapable of admitting that the US does some things right. I'm thankful every day that I live in the world the US created and shaped, and not the world that was created and shaped by China (or the Soviet Union, or the British Empire)
- rntn 4y agohttps://archive.ph/x2AKP https://archive.ph/x2AKP
- MichaelZuo 4y agoSeems like it would be difficult to accept for Japanese companies, after all most of their equipment isn't nearly as difficult to copy as ASML. Also, Tokyo will likely push for concessions in exchange from Washington regarding military basing and other hot button issues.
- xadhominemx 4y agoLeading edge equipment from Tokyo Electron is still very hard to copy, and the Japanese are years ahead of Chinese counterparts.
- cute_boi 4y ago"Japanese are years ahead of Chinese counterparts." This is simply not true, at least to me. Chinese tools used to be cheap and bad. But, these days I find them cheap and better than Japanese expensive tools.
- f1refly 4y agoNot according to my experiences. Most of my tooling is high end and the company I work for lets us order from brands of our choice, which lead to a fairly broad range of competing products across the workbenches here. I have never seen even once a case where a chinese high end product surpasses or even comes close to its japanese counterpart.
- fomine3 4y agoAnyway affordable home tools quality is irreverent to "Leading edge equipment from Tokyo Electron"
- xadhominemx 4y agoWe’re not talking about hand tools here.
- SkyMarshal 4y agoI doubt Tokyo will be asking for removal or drawdown of US military bases given the current situation in the South China Sea.
- TazeTSchnitzel 4y agoThis such a short-sighted move. It might curb China today, but tomorrow they will have developed their own domestic technology and the US will no longer have anything to sanction. It also stops Western companies' ability to grow.
- melling 4y agoYes, but this will accelerate total R&D. Consumers will benefit because more competition means better products at lower prices. The same will happen for AI (machine learning). The United States wouldn’t have gone to the moon in the 1960’s if it weren’t for The Soviet Union.
- mantas 4y agoMindless consumers? Yes. Citizens? Not so much. There’s so much more to life than better product at lower price.
- godelski 4y agoIP theft doesn't really promote competition that way because the one that steals the technology gains all the advantage. They don't have to recoup their costs and by default have lower margins. That's impossible for the original creator to compete against. IP protectionism on the other hand does promote competition[0]. If an inventor is able to create and market a successful product than competition has to invent their own versions. Not through theft, but through innovation. This will mean they do things differently. It also means they will NEED to gain some edge (either reduced cost or higher utility or different niche). While there was a lot of theft in the space program, it wasn't the same as it is today with the current situation. The supply chain issues mean that innovation still had to occur. The current situation is more like you subcontract a company to manufacture parts for you and then that company says "thanks for the instructions, we'll now just sell our own." There's no innovation pressure in this framework. [0] Too much protectionism also does hurt. If intellectual rights are provided for too long than a technology that has failed to properly be marketed by the creators is lost to society. Similarly, too broad of protection can also hinder competition. But there is a sweet spot which gives inventors the first rights and isn't too broad. This promotes competition.