10 ms·
Yes, the embedded space pays terrible, and the employers don't seem great on the whole. When I was at Google I got to work on embedded stuff and really liked it
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
Yes, the embedded space pays terrible, and the employers don't seem great on the whole. When I was at Google I got to work on embedded stuff and really liked it; but I was getting a Google salary. When I left Google I pursued IoT and embedded jobs a bit and while I was not expecting Google level compensation at all, I was astounded at what was going on there, pay wise. General software eng back end jobs pay better.
The problem is I really like writing C++ (and Rust, etc.)! So I'm cultivating other "systems programming" type career paths; DB internals, have always fascinated me, so I'm trying that direction. Working fulltime in Rust now, but it's hard to find work there that isn't crypto-tainted.
Other people have pointed out that lower pay in embedded has to do with the influence of EE salaries. Which are sadly lower than they rightfully should be.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoMy local bus/transit agency was hiring an embedded programmer a couple of years ago and while I thought it would be fun to do embedded stuff and get to work on busses/trains (!) the pay was like half my web dev salary. (Granted there is a pension but it's not that good)
- danuker 4y ago> crypto-tainted If the government did its job and we had sound money, and taxation were explicit instead of this wacky adjustable-and-unpredictable-devaluation that is inflation, there would be no need for cryptocurrency.
- three_seagrass 4y agoI don't know why you say that, because even in lieu of high inflation, USD has been less volatility than the majority of cryptocurrencies.
- jmnicolas 4y agoWith fiat you KNOW you're getting poorer by the minute, but with crypto you have the hope you will earn more. Fwiw I have a grand total of 300€ "invested" (or "lost" if you're a pessimist) in crypto, so I'm not exactly a crypto fanatic.
- astrange 4y agoThe point of money is to be spent, not to hold it. You can't have an asset that's both good to hold over the short and long term. (I forget where this is stated.) That's because the point of an economic system is to trick other people into making food for you, and holding money instead of trading it obviously isn't going to lead to that.
- three_seagrass 4y agoYep. A good currency is meant to have low volatility and an expected value in the future. Confusing or conflating good currencies with investment assets is a common crypto evangelist move.
- danuker 4y ago> The point of money is to be spent, not to hold it. Why? Why prioritize spending now rather than later? If I can't defer consumption, I will always need to work, and I can't retire. That would be financial oppression. > You can't have an asset that's both good to hold over the short and long term. I am abnormally curious why this is the case. > That's because the point of an economic system is to trick other people into making food for you I'd rather they make food for me when I'm old, instead of when I'm young and I can make it for myself. How is this an argument against saving? > holding money instead of trading it obviously isn't going to lead to that. While it's true that if everyone saved in the short term, we'd see persistent recessions, it's bound to end, as people start to want to spend their earned money. In "Die with Zero", an argument is made to allocate and spend everything you've made, because this life is all you've got to do so. I agree with this book. Even in extreme deflation, people buy things they need. For example, technology prices have been in exponential free fall for decades, yet today the world's largest companies have a lot to do with selling computers, phones, and/or software. The only reason for government currency inflation is balancing the (wasteful) budget, after the government spends beyond its means. This allows soft-defaults (government paying bond coupons in a diminishing currency) instead of hard-defaults (government failing to pay bond coupons). But both kinds of defaults should be seen as bad, by investors. To get an idea of the scale of the misallocation, compare the tax revenue to GDP with government spending to GDP. The US government pays for 44% of the yearly domestic product, while only taxing 9.9%. This amounts to a LARGE benefit to those printing money and spending it before price inflation hits. - https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GC.TAX.TOTL.GD.ZS https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/GC.TAX.TOTL.GD.ZS - https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/government-spending-to-gdp https://tradingeconomics.com/country-list/government-spendin...
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago>EE salaries are sadly lower than they rightfully should be. Profit margins of an EE will almost always be lower than profit margins of a software engineer. A team of software engineers can quickly scale to selling to millions of users (and collect nearly 100% of the resulting revenue as pure profit), whereas a team of EE's cannot a) scale their customer base as quickly, since scaling up manufacturing takes time and b) realize a profit anywhere close to 100% of revenue, since much of their revenue goes towards manufacturing and distribution costs. In other words, the marginal cost of selling one unit of a physical product is always nonzero, whereas the marginal cost of selling one unit of software is often (very close to) zero. That differential goes towards higher salaries for the software engineer.
- sentinalien 4y agoI understand this but I think the biggest driver for software salaries is the sheer number of companies that are interested in hiring software engineers. Plenty of hardware companies are very profitable but do not raise their salaries because there is no market pressure to do so as the more limited job market means EEs/embedded engineers do not switch companies nearly as frequently and switching companies is generally the best way to get a substantial salary increase.
- adrianN 4y agoWhich hardware companies have SaaS margins? I think 10% margin is very good for a hardware company. A software company would aim for multiple times that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- KptMarchewa 4y agoYeah. For giant majority of applications and compankes the hardware exists already. Servers, phones and personal computers.
- VLM 4y ago
- wutbrodo 4y agoI feel almost exactly the same way as you. I've flitted around the research/applied research boundary for ML for the last decade+, so I write plenty of Python. I enjoy the way Python gets out of my way so I can focus on interesting research problems. But the actual act of writing code in C++ is so much more fun, once you get good enough at it that the footguns don't trip you up. The embedded AI space is a pretty good place to make money writing C++. I was in autonomous vehicles for a bit. It didn't really interrupt my post-Google compensation trajectory, and I got to write performance- and safety-critical C++
- lamontcg 4y ago> Working fulltime in Rust now, but it's hard to find work there that isn't crypto-tainted. There's a whole bunch of ex-C++ devs who have shifted to Rust in this thread. The existing C++ jobs probably need to shift to Rust.
- dataking 4y agoImmunant offers no-crypto remote Rust work. Send resume to team@immunant.com
- Stalecelin 4y agoAlso for EU people?
- antegamisou 4y agoYou may also look into Kernel Programming for a lucrative systems programming career. It is more C and low-level oriented though.
- anonymousDan 4y agoInteresting, what types of companies pay well for kernel programming?
- caskstrength 4y agoSignificant portion of kernel code is written by FAANG, for example. There are other companies that also pay reasonably well. You can check some statistics of contributions to Linux kernel here https://lwn.net/Articles/909625/ https://lwn.net/Articles/909625/
- synergy20 4y agonot many, I did it, jobs are scarce, most of the time you port a new version of CPU to the kernel, or add a few device drivers, the industry does not need a lot of those engineers, and per my experience, not compensated that well either. these days many kernel programmers work for big companies.
- antegamisou 4y agoI remember Apple having a lot of related listings so I'd assume companies that are somehow involved in OS development (Microsoft, Google, maybe RedHat/IBM and Intel).
- maldev 4y agoAlot of government and security researcher jobs pay google tier for kernel skills with strong knowledge of the OS.
- 0x0203 4y agoDefense industry has a few such jobs, working a lot with RTOS's, network devices, sometimes even embedded for signal processing/control systems, etc... The big defense contractors probably pay better than working directly for the govt depending on where you live.
- synergy20 4y agosystem programming is a tough and low reward path indeed, be it in c/c++ or whatever. embedded/EE is worse. unless you made into the big few(google,amazon,meta,apple,microsoft,...), salary will plummet by half in general, or even more.
- DeathArrow 4y agoWell, I am happy I transitioned from C/C++ to backend. And frankly, I do like backend more.
- zabzonk 4y agoc & c++ are backend languages, in my experience - what do you mean?
- DeathArrow 4y agoI mean web backend, web apps, services, microservices.
- pjmlp 4y agoI mostly do backend and devops at work, and C++ is quite present, not as main language, but writing libraries to be plugged into Java, .NET and node frameworks.
- ostenning 4y agoI have an EE background but worked in webdev for many years. I got pretty bored with webdev, and had the opportunity to get into embedded Rust development, so I did. Its been really awesome, learnt so much both in embedded but also hardware engineering. But now I think I'll head back to web development for my next job - I think web is better as an employee or as a contractor. It seems to me there is more freedom in webdev, often its possible to work from home or abroad... Embedded on the other hand is encumbered with equipment, oscilloscopes, devboards, protocol analyizers, you name it and often requires onsite hours. And then there is the pay and job availability... I recall interviewing for a role that involved designing a full-blown operating system for use in the auto-industry. The role was paying 40-50K euro a year in Germany, which is insanely low. React developers earn substantially more, but are required to know substantially less. The only reason why (I can imagine) someone would chose embedded is probably because its very rewarding and mentally stimulating. Its awesome creating physical devices. Its awesome interfacing with the real world. Its awesome deep diving into bootloaders, memory allocations and exercising a fundamental understanding of computing.
- Aromasin 4y agoI'm really hoping the salaries for EE type roles start to match software as the grey beards start to retire and talent becomes scarce. We've got a legion of grads going into CS, but EE classes are a fraction of that. Despite that, software roles are often more than double the salary. Any role I go into as an EE/Embedded Systems engineer, I'm more often than not the youngest by 20-30 years. I wonder how the industry in the West is going to survive it, beyond hiring contractors from India/South Asia.
- SteveMoody73 4y agoI design the majority of the electronics for my company and pretty much all the firmware as well. Wages are not bad for the area i'm in, which is fairly rural, but could be a lot better for the work involved. Move to a big city would probably help but I like the quieter lifestyle. I've not done any web development full time for close 20 years, first started writing JSP code. Dabbled with a few personal website designs since then. I'm sure if I went back to web development, it may pay more but I don't think it would have the same level of job satisfaction for me. I try to keep up to date on some of the technologies used but it seems overwhelming from the outside. Part is resistence to change, but I do find the work for the most part enjoyable so it's a risk to change jobs as well.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoThe industry will do just fine. In all my years assisting in the hiring process (I'm software, but due to my EE background I was often asked to help with interviewing EEs), I've never noticed a shortage of EE applicants. OTOH, we had a lot of trouble finding enough software people to hire. The reality is that EE jobs are a small fraction of the software ones and supply is keeping up with demand, so there's no upward salary pressure.
- georgeburdell 4y agoEE won’t go higher, SWE will go lower
- Retric 4y agoAlternatively, web is generally more valuable. You don’t buy a new washing machine because the current firmware sucks, but you will shop somewhere else if Newegg’s website is terrible. That relationship is generally true where people rarely test embedded software until after a purchase, but people tend to jump ship more frequently online. Net result a lot of critical infrastructure and devices suck as much as possible while still getting the job done.
- sqeaky 4y agoI did a few a few months of contracting at a major voting machine company. They make a significant portion of all US voting machines. They had 4 developer teams Firmware (C++ where I was), UI (web tech on a voting machine), poll book (java), and a web/support team. Before I was hired in a massive influx of contractors each team was something like 3~5 people, except UI which was a new team with the contractor hiring spree. After the work was done, they shed nearly all the contractors and about half of their previous full time employees. Just quadrupled their staff to make a voting machine then fired them all. They hired me as an "Embedded Software" on their Firmware team. It was a total shitshow we didn't have unit tests or CI. The new hires insisted on it and I spent a bunch of time maintaining a Jenkins setup for the team that really helped. The pay wasn't great, a little less than defense contracting, which was a little less than insurance companies and slow finance companies. If that is what most embedded development is like then I see why it is brings the average down.
- azinman2 4y agoSounds… problematic. What can you say about the state of security with it?
- sqeaky 4y agoThe code is quite secure, but the process and company are... typical processes and company people. Paper ballots and physical boxes are more secure if good practices are followed. At one point I was tasked with shuffling the data layout on disk in real time to mitigate de-anonymization attacks. Security was real concern. Crypto everywhere. The voted ballots were encrypted with keys generated and delivered immediately before the election. No networking by default. The end product had all the right things. That said, no one had clearances, third party auditors were morons, and pay wasn't great. So if I were an attacker I would just try to bribe people to make the changes I want. Can't bribe a ballot box company to election tamper, because they just make boxes. With all that effort they are still needless voting machines, they each count a few thousand votes and not all produce a physical paper trail. Because they have software and logic in them they need a constant chain of custody to make sure that the code we wrote is what is actually run. Just use a box and paper, it is safer all the ways digital things suck. A precinct counting votes only needs to tally a few thousand ballots so it might take a team of people a hour or two, less time than to fix a potential technical problem. And paper can more easily have bipartisan oversight and can have physical security measures that are impractical on a computer. All that said I have no reason to believe our elections have been tampered with on a national level or that anyone other than a local republican may have used our machines to steal elections, even then no firm or even circumstantial evidence, just baseless suspicions and conspiracy theory level anomalies.
- agumonkey 4y agoIsn't this a sign of a problem ? where important domains with hard problems pay few .. while some dubious applications are throwing money on css plumbers ?
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt's a sign that people inherently want to work on those hard problems.
- agumonkey 4y agoI interpreted it as 'the market only cares about frontend sexiness'
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, it's a sign that the people hiring developers and the developers want different things. That saying that the client is always right exists for a reason.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoNo, it's always been the case. Just because something is difficult, doesn't mean it pays well. Otherwise, teachers and mathematicians would all be millionaires.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThere's a strike happening here in Ontario schools by janitors and education assistants and early childhood educators, because they want more than a 2% raise on their $40-$50k year jobs ($30k USD, and look at inflation #s...). The government is going to use a special "shouldn't be used" clause in the Canadian charter or rights and freedoms to force a contract on them and ban a strike and forbid collective bargaining despite it being a charter right. These are people who clean poop, shape young minds, and keep critical systems running, and so on. All of this to say: difficulty and importance of a job seems to have almost nothing to do with either the pay one gets, or the respect one gets.
- npigrounet 4y ago
- jcelerier 4y ago> Yes, the embedded space pays terrible, and the employers don't seem great on the whole. in europe c++ pay is in general ridiculously bad, I got some job ads this morning. Senior job in real-time trading in C++ in Paris, multithreading and linux knowledge, english first: 55-75k. Embedded senior C++ FPGA engineer in paris: 45k-65k. No bonus in either position. thanks but no thanks
- DeathArrow 4y agoI make 54k net in Romania working as a backend developer. If I move to France and use C++ my living standard would take a hit. :D
- rprospero 4y agoThose job ads are both better than my current position. £40k for cross-platform C++ desktop app with both multi-core and distributed parallelism. PhD required. GPGPU experience preferred (notice that it's not CUDA experience because some users have AMD cards). Now, with two consecutive promotions, I could bump my salary up to £50k. Of course, to qualify for the second of those promotions, I need to receive personal commendations from three different professional organizations across at least two different countries.
- ttarr 4y agoI feel your pain, I've been there. My advice, get a job around (but not in) London area, if not, get a remote role with a company in south, that gave me a bump from 35k to 71k. Even better, leave perm and get a contract (outside IR35), you can easily get between 350 to 450 a day. ... and yes, that's doing C++, some Qt, some MFC, some Python, and no PhD/MSc nonsense.