10 ms·
Status vs. Wealth: Why the Rich Don't Act Rich
- madrox 4y agoThis was discovered and explored 25 years ago in The Millionaire Next Door: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Millionaire_Next_Door https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Millionaire_Next_Door
- pydry 4y agoThe rich generally do act rich. The existence of instagrammers who rent $5 million apartments for a half hour photoshoot hardly refutes this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoThis is literally indistinguishable from the opinion of a person who does not know any wealthy people personally, and bases their understanding of “the rich” on the behavior of social media influencers. I’m sorry to put it so bluntly, but the “understating wealth” pattern of behavior is quite real and common.
- sokoloff 4y agoThis might be my own bias here, but "the rich generally do act rich" seems tautologically true to me. IOW, however the rich act is definitionally how the rich act, which is what I think GP might have been getting at. Whether the way they act is congruent with the way the average person thinks they act is the question. From knowing a few "never going to have to worry about money in this or the next couple generations" families, they mostly fly private but go to great lengths to not post or boast about that.
- pydry 4y agoPretty much. I was referring to attempts to display status, whether covert or overt. I think he thought I was referring to ostentatious displays of status like top hats and monocles.
- bluGill 4y agoSome rich act rich. Trump is an obvious example of someone with a lot of money who acts it. Though I suspect he has enough that it is still living within his means. (I'm not sure if his bankruptcy was personal or just a business venture) Most rich though are not as obvious about it. Warren buffet isn't the only one living in a modest house, you just don't know the rest. Most rich are not at the level of the above either. Several million in various investment is enough for a comfortable modest life, but acting like money isn't a problem will soon spend it all.
- helf 4y agoTrump is a prime example of money brings money as he isn’t even /that/ rich but dipshits keep giving him money. It’s bizarre. Anyways, I have a family friend who is a doctor. He lives in a quiet neighborhood in a $400k house. It’s unassuming. He does drive a Panamera but he actually loves it and drives it because he loves it. If you saw them in public you’d think they were just a regular middle class couple. Last time I saw their /bank accounts/ (I do their IT work), not other assets like stocks or whatever, they had over $15million in cash. It’s pretty wild. They probably have more money than most of the assholes living in the Country Club in McMansions here. And no debt.
- thaumasiotes 4y agoBy definition, the rich can only act rich. Whatever they do, that's what acting rich looks like.
- dangle1 4y agoThe article focuses on the internal goods of 'stealth wealth', but I think it's also worth mentioning the external benefits of not appearing wealthy. Namely, good cover from the behaviors of those who do focus on status.
- readthenotes1 4y agoAnd don't forget: no fear of door dinks or car getting stolen. Of course, that goes back to Epictetus and his prized lantern...
- newbie2020 4y agoHow do you get wealth without money? You need to start by chasing money…
- johannes1234321 4y agoChasing for money rarely is successful, though. Inheriting a fortune is a way which worked for many of the rich, though. For some it was work on a good idea and producing a good product.
- bluGill 4y agoMost rich people in the US didn't inherit much money, they had to build it. A few prominent super wealthy did, but for the most part it is create it yourself.
- metadat 4y agoThis is false; people end up with tons of money all sorts of different ways, from inheritance, to luck, divorce, lawsuits, hard-work hustling and grinding, or even criminal activity like fraud or embezzlement. You generally can't know for certain, except in some cases such as a public figure. Lots of people expend vast amounts of energy projecting the image of wealth in a [pathetic] attempt to gain status, and they're faking it to the max. As the saying goes: "Mo' money, mo' problems."
- bluGill 4y agoAll kinds of ways, but most by their own efforts. https://www.economist.com/special-report/2011/01/22/more-millionaires-than-australians https://www.economist.com/special-report/2011/01/22/more-mil...
- kragen 4y agoMake something people want.
- deelowe 4y ago
- xiphias2 4y agoAs plane prices went down and most travel can be done with much less money than before, professional photos are easy to take, the hardest to fake part of social status remaining is looks. Naval won't have the status of Leonardo DiCaprio because he was never looking like him.
- biscottigelato 4y agoThe hardest part of social status is respect of others in high social standing. Looks gets you the opposite sex, and having access, perhaps even sharing that circle, gains you respect. Nothing else really matters in the status game except respect.
- readthenotes1 4y agoThere's that old essay that says *power" is the strongest, most unquenchable desire by those afflicted from it. (Shaw? Nobel prize speech iirc, Acquisition<rivalry<vanity<power)
- j_walter 4y agoThis is a lesson most people don't learn till they are older (if ever). It's hard to convince someone in their 20's that they shouldn't be spending money on status things in order to gain friends or a romantic partner. When you are older and settled down it's much easier to not care what other people think of you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anikan_vader 4y ago>> When you are older and settled down In general when you are settled down it is easier to care less about trying to gain additional romantic partners.
- biscottigelato 4y agoBut friends or romantic partner is actually what's important in life. Wealth is just a number on a ledger. We can debate whether friends gained through status or partners gained through status are ideal friends or ideal partners. But its undeniable that friends and romantic partner is much more important to life than wealth.
- j_walter 4y agoEventually you realize that if you need to prove status or wealth to gain friends or a romantic partner...then those aren't really the people you want to surround yourself with. Or maybe you don't realize this and will remain poor trying to always show how much money you have to people so that they will be impressed.
- helf 4y agoNo? It is not undeniable. Maybe for a huge chunk of people who require socialization or they eat themselves. But this bizarre idea that you HAVE to have friends and romance to be healthy is ridiculous.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoquick, someone go tell those in poverty that wealth is just a number on a ledger!
- yamtaddle 4y agoBetter covered by works like Fussell's Class. This just reads like low-content hustle porn.
- rwbt 4y agoGreat book although I don't really agree his concluding chapter of Category X. I don't think one can materially participate in society and also fully extricate themselves from the hierarchies.
- yamtaddle 4y agoYeah he let his optimism blind him on that part. There's always been a "Bohemian" set, his Class X was no revolution.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoYour Money or your Life is another classic.
- mmmpop 4y ago
- sharkbot 4y agoIn fairness, I would likely never been recommended that book unless this article had been published and remarked upon by you, so I think there was some value even if you consider it ancillary.
- bluemetal 4y agoFYI if anyone wants to pick up the kindle version of this book from Amazon, don't bother. It is an incredibly poor quality scan of a physical book, compiled horizontally and full of pencil markings. I can't for the life of me see a way to report the listing, and the comments about this issue are drowned out by comments about the book contents and being ignored
- pddpro 4y agoWhile I agree with most of what's written, I think that revenue from volatile stocks does come at others' expense and, thus, might not be an example the author should be including.
- biscottigelato 4y agoBuilding companies are not necessarily zero sum tho. You can win over your competition by delivering value. The value delivered to society generally more than cover of the loss your competition encounters. On net its a positive sum game that the more this is done, the more net positive society sees. Assuming fair competition based on innovation on efficiency of course. Corruption and coercion not apply
- melenaboija 4y ago> The Rich Don’t Act Rich Because They Buy Assets, Not More Stuff Not sure this makes much sense. Do rich live in a cave and literally sit on their money and wait until they die? I don’t think so, they buy flight tickets, a house in the beach, a bigger yard to do gardening, better health care to live longer, pay a baby sitter,… I feel money buys high quality time, not just time
- baremetal 4y agomoney buys the ability to build empire.
- thriftwy 4y agoPoint being, they will still have a look and feel of an upper middle class while being magnitudes more wealthy. That's a good tactics because middle class stuff has the best bang for the buck. Rich, status-displaying stuff delivers diminishing benefits for exponentially growing price.
- com2kid 4y agoI was just out in New England visiting some friends. In the area we were in[1], almost all the houses look the same, seriously unimposing, aggressively bland. They'd point over to a (admittedly large sqft) boring looking house and say "oh yeah, some super rich guy lives there, heir to some fortune or another." It was weird coming from the west coast where the front facade[2] of a house is itself a status symbol of sorts. [1] A generally well to do nice area with a bit of history to it. [2] And sometimes just the front, hah! Horrible vinyl siding everywhere else...
- tverbeure 4y agoA house on the beach and a plot of land with a bigger yard are assets?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- christophilus 4y agoI took a hotel shuttle from the airport recently. Got to chatting with the driver. He’s an immigrant who owns 6 industrial rental properties and a few single family rentals. You’d never know it, given his attire and evening job. But he is focused on keeping the cash flow growing. His net worth is probably in the millions but few know it unless they really get him to open up (something I tend to be naturally good at). I know a few folks like this. I call them the stealthy wealthy.
- tjs8rj 4y agoWhy is he driving a hotel shuttle? Unless he’s just retired and looking for something engaging to do, that’s a horrible waste of his clear talent for building wealth
- thenewwazoo 4y agoBecause extracting rent does not scale with effort (and, in fact, requires none of it). It's called "passive income" for a reason.
- tjs8rj 4y agoWhat does scale is his skills. If he’s able to pull off what he’s already done, get investors and do it on a larger scale.
- ianbutler 4y agoI used to know someone who’s family was worth at least 100million dollars. His family were shipping magnates out of Syria. Genuinely the nicest person. Other than dressing well and not obnoxiously so, you’d probably never know. It’s a shame that the city/our college gave him panic attacks, we lost touch when he moved to Germany and I wound up somewhat immaturely cutting the friendship short after initially keeping contact in my early 20s. Ironically he taught me the importance of relationships and people after otherwise being the type of techy that only values technical acumen. Legitimately changed my whole life direction. Shame I didn’t take to the lesson entirely before I cut things off. One of my few regrets.
- nicksrose7224 4y agoThis is a pretty lazy and non-value additive article honestly. All it does it just reference things Naval or Warren buffet has said and then “subscribe to my newsletter" at the bottom. I feel like you could easily write something like this by doing a scrape(Naval's twitter) + scrape(buffet's wiki page) -> GPT3_summarize(that content) and you'd get this article.
- nicksrose7224 4y agoWhile i'm on my soapbox, i dont understand this mentality that wealth creation is a positive-sum game. Me buying a property to turn it into an Airbnb that I lease out to generate money directly takes away supply from someone trying to buy a house or a similar asset. I would love to hear some examples of wealth generation that do not take away opportunity or money directly or indirectly from other people [edit] below commenters have some great points, i'm reconsidering my stance on this point
- biscottigelato 4y agoMe creating a self-driving car will take away revenue from drivers. However the rest of society will gain much more than the loss that the drivers suffers. On net humanity is better off. This is true when the computer replaced secretaries, when cars replaced the horse, when planes replaced the boats, internet replaced fax and phone calls, etc. Overall the quality of life of everyone improved even if a select few suffered each time progress was made, making even fewer rich, but everyone else better off. You create wealth by providing value to others, value that exceeds the competition you have displaced. That's why wealth creation is a positive sum game.
- kanyethegreat 4y agoI think it'd be more accurate to say "play the value creation game" then. The author specifically references wealth accumulation (ie. the accumulation of assets)
- andsoitis 4y ago
- bluGill 4y agoJust be careful, you can't take it's with you (this is a religious statement, most religions agree but if you believe an exception I guess this comment doesn't apply). As such there is no point in saving too much. Enjoy what you have, save money, but plan on spending that money before you die. (Since you don't know when you will die have some insurance for long life )
- abeppu 4y agoI think this is a bad, muddled version of these lessons. > Play wealth accumulation games, not status games. > Twitter is the ultimate battleground for status games. ... and then proceeds to quote his own tweets. He talks about the importance of living by an inner scorecard an then immediately transitions to claiming "the only game worth playing is the wealth accumulation game", which sounds a lot like an external scorecard.
- readthenotes1 4y ago"external scorecard" no: Wealth is/can be private knowledge. You assess your own score based on your own internal guidelines, not what other people think. The amount of wealth I feel I need to "pass" is unrelated to yours.
- michaelt 4y agoIs this really true, though? I mean, superyachts do exist. Mansions also visibly exist. Jeff Bezos does have not one but two private jets. Now, I know some of this stuff is illusionary - there are private jets that don't fly and just act as photo studios. Loads of people can qualify for a loan to get a fancy car, if they're willing to pay a lot in interest. I mean, I'd call someone with $10 million in the bank rich - but that's not enough money to own a superyacht. People who own superyachts aren't in my social circles, but they clearly exist.
- bluGill 4y agoDon't confuse rich with super rich. Some people have enough to afford that. The next step down can make the payments so long as things stay good, and look like they are just as rich. Where the line between rich and middle class is, isn't well defined, but most of us could cross that line, but only those who don't act like will. However the total number of people just over the line is vastly greater than those well over who can afford the expensive toys.
- timr 4y agoJeff Bezos' $500M yacht is like 0.4% of his net worth. I don't know how many properties he has, but I'd be shocked if it's more than a few percent. The man could buy Rolexes and Audemars Piguets on a whim, and it wouldn't even move the needle. Compare that yacht to the equivalent purchase of a well-off, working engineer (with, say, a $1M net worth): that's a $4000 purchase. It's a nice computer. Point being, some people are so wealthy that even relatively "conservative" expenditures look extravagant.
- thefaux 4y ago> Wealth creation is a positive-sum game. Is it though? Even if it were true in aggregate, which I'm not ready to grant, there are clearly individual losers in the the "wealth creation" game.
- bluGill 4y agoNot really, this is about creation. When you turn a tree into a house you create value. The losers in this game either fall to vandals, or create something that isn't valuable. When you gamble money there are winners and losers. When you create something that creates wealth.
- throwamon 4y ago> When you turn a tree into a house you create value. Of course, because the tree has no value, right? As long as you call things you don't care about "externalities" you can trivially prove anything is a positive-sum game.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agoWhat's even worse is the poster didn't realize this obvious rebuttal existed. And I'm with you, I actually dislike the word "externalities", it smacks of calling employees "resources".
- bluGill 4y agoWhat is pathetic is you think that rebuts anything.
- bluGill 4y agoIt has more value as a house than as a tree. You could grow the tree from a seed and create value.
- throwamon 4y ago
- petra 4y agoI'm sure Naval gets a lot of high-status from his job and general interactions with people. So it's easy for him to "ignore" the need/drive for status.
- jetrink 4y agoI wonder if most people who appear to be concerned with status are actually worried about belonging. They seem to be playing a zero-sum game with their peers, but they really just want to be secure within that group and not at the margins or in the out-group. I've certainly known people who want to be recognized for their expensive car or clothes, but I think most people just want to fit in and they've been convinced that what they wear or drive is an important part of that.
- biscottigelato 4y agoExactly. Viewing status acquisition as worthless assumes that people do not want social attachment and that social standing within groups or society doesn't matter. I'd argue they matter more, and wealth is actually just the mean to this end.
- every 4y agoA different metric: If you lack for nothing you are wealthy. If you yearn for more you are poor...
- Barrin92 4y agothe genuine reason why certain rich people don't act rich has nothing to do with status gains or zero sum games. There's plenty of rich people who do indeed act rich. Pick your favorite sports superstar. The real difference is between new and old money. The nouveau riche like to show off because they're fixated with the idea that they've earned it themselves, very much on display among super rich techies. It's precisely the "non zero-sum" people who love to signal their wealth openly because they take it for granted that their wealth is based on merit. It's your old money folks who have some sense of noblesse oblige who understand that wealth most of the time is indeed pretty zero sum and who think of flaunting wealth one as distasteful and secondly as potentially stupid if it attracts attention, which new money craves and old money does not.
- andsoitis 4y ago“They were new money, without a doubt: so new it shrieked. Their clothes looked as it they'd covered themselves in glue, then rolled around in hundred-dollar bills.” ― Margaret Atwood, The Blind Assassin
- riskneutral 4y agoAll of them play the status game, old money is just more subtle and hidden about it but they are even more viscous with their status games. It depends a lot on the person, but there is no getting away from it. To a certain extent, every person must play the status game in order get what they want from the world in their business and personal lives. There is no need for black and white, all or nothing thinking, everything in moderation is okay.
- kanyethegreat 4y agoisn't wealth accumulation inherently zero-sum? like, there's a fixed amount of capital and resources in the system. accumulating it for yourself means someone else won't have it, right?
- readthenotes1 4y agoClearly not, or the wealth of the world would be constant through history. I could argue that most wealth comes from optimizing the efforts to extract and transport resources, plus all the other optimizations on the paper shuffling we do after (e. g., Communication, entertainment, etc.).
- alphabettsy 4y agoFew people seek Love? Hmm.
- nunez 4y agohonestly, after you buy all of the expensive toys, then what? i suppose some people seek more exclusive and expensive things to get that high from buying stuff or chasing clout, but others just get tired of it and find stasis in their life.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoThere is a more serious and thorough treatment in this area in the many books by the late wealth researcher Thomas J. Stanley. Common points he would repeat: - There is no magic formula to find rich people or to become one - They don't live above their means - Beside poor impulse control, a habit of lottery ticket purchasing is the strongest signal negatively correlated with long-term wealth - Rich people often married but rarely divorce because it's a more efficient lifestyle and financial suicide to split - Rich people tend to meet their spouses in college where there's a better cohort to meet "Stop Acting Rich" was a title of one of his books. Not sure if it's an accident or the remote possibility of a ripoff. It's an obvious title. One interesting positive correlation with single-family, suburban, non-forest-interface home property values is the number of trees. It's not a perfect rule, but single-family home areas without trees tend to appear unappealing and are statistically less affluent (i.e., fake grass, plastic flamingos, wrought iron fencing, and bars on the windows). The exception to the rule is San Jose, California which is a horrible mix of unmaintained houses with overgrown weeds beside nice homes. If property owners there had leadership sense and wanted to maintain their property values, they would influence code enforcement to cite unkempt properties.