10 ms·
That's the core problem with this approach. Elon and others have the idea in their head that Twitter is a social graph where people come to interact with each o
by paxys 4y ago
That's the core problem with this approach. Elon and others have the idea in their head that Twitter is a social graph where people come to interact with each other, and everyone is relatively equal. So every user paying $X/mo to solidify their place in the graph makes some conceptual sense.
In reality Twitter is more akin to YouTube than Facebook. A tiny percentage of users are creators while the vast majority are consumers. If you go by the rough count of their currently verified accounts, only ~0.16% of monthly active users are producing content of any real value.
An average user (part of the 99.9%) isn't going to care about any status or badges – they are only there to look at memes.
Creators and influencers on the other hand are going to care, but (1) there are too few of them for their $8/mo to make a substantial difference to the company's bottom line, and (2) the platform needs them as much as they need platform.
So you really want to instead do the exact opposite – ask the consumers to pay and fund your creators with that money.
- charlie0 4y agoBut if you are a frequent creator, you're also planning on making the content a viable financial venture. At the very least, Twitter is used as a marketing platform. Which means paying $8 a month for what is essentially free hosting for your marketing, is a no brainer. I'm not sure why asking consumers to pay would be a good idea because we already have Patreon. Only a fraction of consumers would actually pay for content, so doing this would probably cause a lot of consumers to leave. Whereas the price for a content creator is very low, even at $20/month. In other words, if you want the blue checkmark, you're definitely interested in the marketing yourself. So, why not pay for that privilege?
- xtracto 4y agoI always felt Twitter as "old man yells at cloud" kind of communication. I've never seen proper "content" created (like pinterest, tik tok, etc). Most of the "content" I see are the asinine multi-post threads and text-pictures notices from angry people/companies.
- felinix 4y agoWell, the funny thing is that Twitter itself is THE content It kind serves as a continuation of bashorg for millenials and zoomers
- resoluteteeth 4y agoThe "content" here is just tweets. It may not be "content" in the way you are imagining, but it's still true that almost all twitter users are using the site to view tweets from a small number of people (call them content creators or influencers if you like) with large numbers of followers.
- koonsolo 4y agoSure, but that small number of people are already famous outside of twitter. YouTube and TikTok creates new celebrities, twitter doesn't.
- ABeeSea 4y agoI’d argue this isn’t true in sports journalism. A news tweet from Woj, Schefter, Rappoport, or Shams has far more reach than the same content in a random ESPN article or sportscenter segment. Without twitter, a whole world of addicted sports fans would have no idea who those guys are.
- CydeWeys 4y agoYou haven't been paying attention closely enough. Plenty of people get big on Twitter, and then parlay that into success in other spheres too.
- kritiko 4y agoRed Scare and Chapo Trap House are niche media brands, but their hosts are new celebrities who got famous primarily through Twitter.
- koonsolo 4y agoAre you sure the popularity on twitter was the driving factor and not a lagging indicator of their podcast success?
- s_ting765 4y ago> So you want to instead do the exact opposite – ask the consumers to pay and fund your creators with that money. I think it's only Onlyfans that can get away with such a business model.
- meheleventyone 4y agoTwitch, Patreon etc. etc. Arguably also Netflix, Roblox and free-to-play mobile games run on this sort of scheme as well.
- NationOfJoe 4y agoalso i guess YouTube is that as well, Consumers pay with attention to ad's, YouTube red, Channel members, super chat.
- paxys 4y agoOnlyfans may be an extreme example of it, but all such successful platforms – YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, Twitch and the rest – are paying their popular users a lot of money to stay there.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> > So you want to instead do the exact opposite – ask the consumers to pay and fund your creators with that money. > I think it’s only Onlyfans that can get away with such a business model. OnlyFans is not (by far) the only site that has a business model of “consumers purchase from producers and the site rakes in a share from that”, nor even the only one (again, by far) with that model where what is purchased is digital content.
- s_ting765 4y agoHow many people are willing to directly pay for content on those other platforms vs those who are not? Contrast that to Onlyfans' monetization success rate.
- warkdarrior 4y ago
- koonsolo 4y ago> In reality Twitter is more akin to YouTube than Facebook. There is a very big difference between Twitter and YouTube, and it's obvious once you know it. Look at the most popular people on twitter: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-followed_Twitter_accounts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-followed_Twitte... All celebrities outside of twitter. Then look at YouTube: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-subscribed_YouTube_channels https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most-subscribed_YouT... Almost all made famous by YouTube. Twitter has no real "content creators", YouTube does.
- causality0 4y agoYeah, if you got famous exclusively on Twitter it's because you're a demagogue, not a content creator.
- koonsolo 4y agoCan you name the MrBeast or PewDiePie of twitter?
- smcl 4y agoYes his name is @dril and he is more powerful than 100 of your Misters Beast or Pewdies Pie
- koonsolo 4y ago@dril seems to come close (I didn't know him, probably because he only has 1.7M followers). On twitter he's only at place 5,391 (https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/dril https://socialblade.com/twitter/user/dril). MrBeast and PewDiePie are both millionaires ($40M-$100M) thanks to YouTube, and each have 111M followers, that's around 65x @dril. Can you state exactly what you mean with @dril == 100 * Mister Beast?
- saagarjha 4y agoyour problem is, that youre perfect, and everyone is jealous of your good posts, and that makes you rightfully upset.
- jonas21 4y agoIt may be true that only a very small percentage of Twitter users are actually creators and influencers. But a far larger number of people think they are or aspire to be influencers, and they're going to want the badge too.
- arkades 4y agoStephen King’s tweet on that topic, to summarize: “ $20 a month to keep my blue check? Fuck that, they should pay me. If that gets instituted, I’m gone like Enron.” https://twitter.com/stephenking/status/1587042605627490304?s=46&t=G0n-uTzWc5CCKs89mzeNkg https://twitter.com/stephenking/status/1587042605627490304?s...
- bufferoverflow 4y agoHe is bluffing.
- bandyaboot 4y agoAre you saying he won’t leave or that he will accept paying money to Elon Musk for his checkmark?
- bufferoverflow 4y agoHe won't leave. Not sure if he cares about the blue checkmark enough to pay, but he is rich enough not to care. His net worth is half a billion.
- blaser-waffle 4y agoHis publicist will care, and they probably charge him way, way more per month than $20. SK will hem and haw but 6 months from now his team will quietly reinstate the account.
- mateuszf 4y agoI don't think anybody believes he cares about the money. Seems like it's a matter of principles for him.
- slimebot80 4y agoTotally right. And Musk's answer was to offer $8/m King wasn't talking about paying anything
- sangnoir 4y ago> Creators and influencers on the other hand are going to care, but (1) there are too few of them for their $8/mo to make a substantial difference to the company's bottom line As Stephen King rightly pointed out: Twitter should be paying him - not the other way around (IHO). Anyway, this is going to be interesting.
- IncRnd 4y ago> That's the core problem with this approach. Elon and others have the idea in their head that Twitter is a social graph where people come to interact with each other, and everyone is relatively equal. I doubt you know what thoughts Elon has in his head. He likely has ideas for changes, similar to the linked page. After all, he purchased the company in order to make changes.
- bandyaboot 4y agoHe purchased the company because his lawyers finally convinced him he was going to be forced to and that it was a poor choice to continue damaging the asset he was going to be owning.
- IncRnd 4y agoThat's your belief. It is quite likely that the court actions were mean to pressure twitter. That isn't an uncommon tactic. The two facts we know are that Musk stated he would purchase twitter to make changes, and he has started to make changes after the purchase.
- bandyaboot 4y agoHe was trying everything he could to get out of a horrendous deal. If you can’t see that, I don’t know what to tell you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simonpure 4y agoThe 1% rule seems to hold up pretty well across any online community [0] [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule > In Internet culture, the 1% rule is a general rule of thumb pertaining to participation in an internet community, stating that only 1% of the users of a website add content, while the other 99% of the participants only lurk.
- hsn915 4y agoCreating YouTube content takes considerable effort besides just having interesting things to say. Twitter on the other hand is just text. Anyone can write tweets. Not anyone can post YouTube videos.
- hnaccy 4y ago>f you go by the rough count of their currently verified accounts, only ~0.16% of monthly active users are producing content of any real value. Maybe I'm an outlier but of my hundreds of follows ~1% have checkmark. The bulk of my followers are artists, photographers, niche bloggers, subculture news aggregators which are all creating content. The verified checkmark is basically a non-entity to my time on twitter, maybe it's different if you mainly follow more mainstream western pop culture and political/news media.
- assttoasstmgr 4y agoGonna disagree with you here. Musk is only doing with Twitter what Fark.com did over 20 years ago with TotalFark - you pay a small monthly fee for admission, and you get a shiny badge next to your username, along with a few perks. Just like Something Awful forums did before that - paid admission - it's an excellent tool to weed out the obvious bots and low effort trolls. Twitter has no "creators" - it's just a fancy message board. Everything old is new again. The Gen-Z kids on Twitter and TikTok were still pooping in diapers when these sites ruled the Internet, and now have sadly been relegated to a dusty corner thereof.
- abenga 4y agoBad actors who are trying to push some agenda to make money for example, are more likely to pay than ordinary lurkers who click the "retweet" button once in a while. Twitter is not that important, if it becomes pay-to-play, I'm out, sorry.
- smcl 4y agoIt'll just become the new version of Twitter's "super follow" - a thing that makes you stand out as a bit of a mark, and a target for ridicule.
- underwater 4y agoAnd Fark and Something Awful are both dead.
- FooBarWidget 4y ago> So you really want to instead do the exact opposite – ask the consumers to pay and fund your creators with that money This sounds like "pay to follow" (or at least "please donate X monthly to your favorite creators" ala Patreon). I think to most Twitter users, content has a value of €0. If you ask users to pay then they'd rather switch to another free creator, or not use Twitter at all. If users see any value in creators at all, that'll be having interacted with creators for a long time and having developed a deep connection. Or if creators started publishing "premium content" that's obviously worth in.
- sooyoo 4y agoBut who wouldn't pay $8/mo to reduce the number of ads they see to only half!!1 /s
- gorgoiler 4y agoI assumed the verification fee serves a different purpose to gathering revenue: the cost to buy influence could go up by an order of magnitude. Economics will neuter the bots. Everyone working at the IRA.ru troll farm now needs to be issued with (even more) stolen payment credentials and monthly costs go up by $8 per troll account. Even worse, recruiting useful idiots — unwitting members of the public who are aligned with the troll message and who voluntarily amplify misinformation — is going to get much harder. Now you don’t just need Average Joe to retweet your carefully worded calls-to-action about missing emails or stolen elections. You need him to pay $8 a month too.