13 ms·
US Supreme Court to weigh end to race-based college admissions
- eli 4y ago
- timmg 4y agoDo you think it is? As-in, is it the right (legal) decision in your view?
- kennend3 4y agoFrom the article: ""Americans have come to view diversity as integral to learning and to trust that the path to leadership is open to all," lawyers representing Harvard University wrote in a court filing." Do you see the "open to all" statement? Is this true? What about the Asians who were denied entry based on their race? Is this "open to all"?
- eli 4y agoHarvard obviously can't literally be open to all. They only have so many spots and many applicants. If admissions were based entirely on GPA, is that a more fair system?
- adastra22 4y agoYes.
- kennend3 4y agoIs it legal to discriminate on race where you life? Let's say i own a company and refuse to hire [ethnic minority]. Is this legal? Isn't that what is taking place here? Asians are being denied entry simply because they are Asian.
- eli 4y agoGPA isn't an objective measure and is not free of the influence of race
- hindsightbias 4y agoAsians are over-represented by population at Harvard. Whatever magic equation replaces AA, you can rest assured that there will be more whites and less Asians. And SCOTUS will be perfectly fine with that.
- eli 4y agoNo. If I were on SCOTUS I would probably vote to uphold the existing precedent.
- timmg 4y agoHow do you feel about the fact that it effectively discriminates against Asians? (And do you think it is relevant to mention the previous discrimination against Jews, decades ago?)
- pueblito 4y agoWhich precedent? The one where the 14th Amendment forbids racial discrimination, or the narrow carve out 20 years ago that has allowed it to continue in higher education?
- eli 4y agoI don't think they are incompatible and I don't think the people who voted for the 14th Amendment would think so either.
- nkingsy 4y agoWasn't familiar with the term outcomes-driven: It is when "a court decides what the outcome of the case should be and then works backward to determine the reasoning that will reach the desired conclusion"
- thomastjeffery 4y agoOtherwise known as Circular Reasoning: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_reasoning https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circular_reasoning
- 1980phipsi 4y agoIf you think conservatives have a monopoly on this, then take a look at some of the most important Supreme Court cases from FDR through the 1970s or so.
- BobbyJo 4y agoWhat make you think they view conservatives as having monopoly on misusing the supreme court?
- eli 4y agoThe Supreme Court is a political organization that likes to pretend it's something else. I think that's always been the case and I agree it isn't inherently one party or the other. That said, with the notable exception of the Warren court, SCOTUS has been conservative for its whole history.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y ago>That said, with the notable exception of the Warren court, SCOTUS has been conservative for its whole history. I think that depends a lot on one's perspective. If you're very far-left and support all the equity you can dream up, then yes I see how one might think that. I disagree, but still... If that were objectively true, I don't think it's the damning claim you may have meant it to be if you consider the overall history of the USA and contributions to the world.
- kube-system 4y agoThere are plenty of liberal reasons to dislike race-based admission processes as well. I agree with the spirit of what these programs are trying to accomplish, but punishing Asian applicants for their race is a perfect example of what is wrong with this solution from a fundamental level.
- robertlagrant 4y agoThis is the distinction between old-school liberal (judge by content of character not colour of skin; what you do behind closed doors is your business as much as possible; free speech) and more recent liberal, which seems far more likely to keep the middle of those three, but jettison the others. Bill Maher's journey over the last 2 years has been interesting to watch as he tries to berate the modern left into returning to liberal roots.
- eli 4y agoAre you conflating liberal and libertarian? MLK, of course, coined the phrase "content of character not color of skin" and he was very much in favor of affirmative action.
- weberer 4y agoNope. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Are you conflating liberal and libertarian? I don't think so. Old school liberal and modern libertarian are fairly closely related. The term libertarian has appeared I think due to the changing of the word liberal. > MLK, of course, coined the phrase "content of character not color of skin" and he was very much in favor of affirmative action. Sure, at least sort of. But this conflates a principle (the thing I quoted) with one man's politics.
- hedora 4y agoI don't think that's the point. This court has been shredding the rule of law in this country for the last year, and is systematically replacing our democracy with fascism. Their ruling is definitely going to be more damaging to minorities than anything I can come up with. Hell, they banned abortion by eliminating the right to privacy in the US. They were even complete assholes about it. Despite being minority (and arguably illegally, in some cases) appointed, they blame the (underage) women their rulings victimize for not voting enough. The text of the ruling explicitly states that no ruling the court makes could be sexist or victimize women, since women are allowed to vote. I fully expect this ruling to use similar logic to blow an equally large hole in our constitutional rights.
- tekla 4y agoGood, it took a while, but "lets not discriminate based on race" seems to be a fairly easily defensible position.
- eddof13 4y agohopefully
- petilon 4y agoWhat do you think is the conservative outcome? It is not so obvious. The allegation is that Harvard is discriminating against Asians (and thus favoring Whites). California colleges are not allowed to consider race. Check Asian vs. White student percentages at UCSD. Is that the outcome conservatives want?
- hedora 4y ago> Conservatism: an in-group who are protected but not bound by the law; and an out-group who are bound, but not protected, by the law.
- eli 4y agoRepublicans have been generally against affirmative action since its inception. Trump was explicitly against it. The particulars of this case and this argument don't really matter.
- legitster 4y ago> This is a conservative, outcomes-driven court. I find this view to be pretty naive. The vast majority of judges in the US legal system are naturally going to be conservative in that the job is to follow the letter of the law. To the extent that progressive justices move up through the legal system is only through political appointments. It seems easier to me to say the vast majority of progressive opinions from the Supreme court have been outcomes driven and the current court is reverting to process-driven (you have to actually pass legislation for legislative changes).
- HWR_14 4y ago> To the extent that progressive justices move up through the legal system is only through political appointments. All federal and most state justices only move up through political appointments. The rest of state justices are directly elected, which is even more political.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> All federal and most state justices only move up through political appointments. Federal justices have either 0 or 1 steps they can move up, and of the ones that can move up, there is only 1 position for them to move into, that of Chief Justice. Judges, OTOH...
- eli 4y ago> The vast majority of judges in the US legal system are naturally going to be conservative in that the job is to follow the letter of the law. C'mon, who's being naive now? The law was already settled on this issue. This case is being heard with the goal of overturning precedent. It's not because we learned new things about the Constitution in the last 20 years.
- marcusverus 4y agoNobody--yourself included--wants us to honor every bad precedent. Should we be stuck with Citizens United for all of eternity? Of course not--everybody wants that sumbitch overturned!. Pretending that you believe precedent to be sacred is both silly and transparently self-serving. > The law was already settled on this issue. The idea of "settled law" is a rhetorical device and nothing more. SCOTUS has been overturning precedent on an almost annual basis for centuries[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_overruled_United_States_Supreme_Court_decisions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_overruled_United_State...
- kennend3 4y agoI so hope this is struck down. ""Americans have come to view diversity as integral to learning and to trust that the path to leadership is open to all," lawyers representing Harvard University wrote in a court filing." This is not true, and the Asians who were denied entry based on their race would agree. What ever happened to access based on merit?
- epgui 4y agoWhat happened to it refers to a concept called the meritocracy trap.
- kennend3 4y agoLet's say you need open heart surgery. Doctor one has a 3.9 GPA from Harvard medical. Doctor two barely passed your state's medical school Which do you want doing your operation? The "meritocracy trap" often caves into "wealth and privilege" and this is not meritocracy.
- whimsicalism 4y agoThose signals are not as important to being a successful surgeon as you think.
- VLM 4y agoThe problem with redefining, such as redefining success, is it eliminates any possibility of a conversation.
- whimsicalism 4y agoYour comment is opaque. As far as I know, a successful surgical operation is generally pretty cut and dry. No redefining here.
- VLM 4y ago
- dongobongo 4y agoI have a feeling that in hindsight, 30-40 years from now, this will seem like no brainer and that the period prior was heavily anti-meritocratic and counterproductive.
- DeathArrow 4y agoMore likely in 10 to 20 years.
- syrrim 4y agoThis sort of thing is endemic to most parts of the world, and I doubt the rest of the world will come around in that period. The political forces that drive this will likely be as strong in fifty years, just as they were as strong fifty years ago.
- jmull 4y ago> anti-meritocratic How do you measure merit, though? People just leave this critical detail to our intuitions for some reason. I think we want something good and fair... What's the measure of "merit" that's good and fair? People who are good at the SATs usually want SAT scores to matter. People who get good grades in high-school want high-school grades to matter. Not unreasonable... but that's still just people defining "merit" in a self-serving way. I think we want to focus on outcomes... Let's suppose the college experience and fact of an elite university degree confers significant advantages of reach and power to those who get it... and that there are 10x more people able to take advantage of those advantages than there are spots available. I think the question is: of those 10x people, who are the 10% we want to give a spot to? I think we want to give them to the people who are most likely to benefit all the rest of us (completely fine by me if they benefit themselves as well -- In fact, I think it will work best that way, by a large degree.) So that's the "merit" I'm looking for. (I think when left to intuition, people tend to image "merit" as something that would favor people like themselves and their families... usually, in effect, something quite narrow with a heavy self-serving bias.)
- cuteboy19 4y agoBut we can for sure say what is not merit. Choosing or discriminating against a person for their race is not merit
- throwaway2203 4y agoIs the decision coming today or are they just hearing arguments today?
- tannhauser23 4y agoOral arguments are today. The justices vote afterwards but we won't know the result until the opinions are issued, which will be several months from now.
- vnchr 4y agoUnless it’s useful to leak before the midterm elections
- lm28469 4y ago> American schools: we're not racist Also American schools: https://i.redd.it/1gt966pyolw91.png https://i.redd.it/1gt966pyolw91.png https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/yfq52x/annual_update_form_for_my_childrens_school/ https://www.reddit.com/r/funny/comments/yfq52x/annual_update...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- twic 4y agoIf they're ending race-based admissions, does that mean they're also ending athletics scholarships for runners? Sorry.
- ck2 4y ago> Nine US states - including California, Florida, Georgia and Michigan - currently prohibit the use of race as a factor in admissions for public universities Sounds like instead of doing polls on opinions and "gut think" that there are already large real-world examples that can be examined precisely to see what that policy does or doesn't accomplish.
- adastra22 4y agoAt least in California, I don’t think there has been enough time to really know. It was a recent change iirc.
- hot_gril 4y agoIt was 1996, pretty long ago. Looking at a UC vs a private uni, the most obvious difference is how UCs tend to have majority Asian students. UC Berkeley chancellor publicly denounced the ban when it was upheld a couple of years ago. Then Cal removed SAT/ACT as an admission requirement. Next admission cycle, she sent out an email to all students and alumni (me) cheering that the school is now more diverse. The percentages of White, Black, Hispanic, etc students in the incoming class all increased. Percentage of Asian students sharply decreased. If you ranked the deltas, it was similar to the ranks of average SAT scores for each group (Asian students have the highest SAT scores, etc). I guess the most diverse class would be achieved using a pure lottery system.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoAbout time. The whole idea behind it is stupid and racist... "if you're a certain skin color, you're too stupid, to compete on merit"... then when people complain, they add the "socioeconomic" factors: "if you're a certain color, you're too poor to compete on merit, but instead of looking at your family income, we'll look at your skin color". I have no idea how something like this gets support in developed western countries.
- tyho 4y agoThat is because the gaps persist when controlling for income. The gaps actually increase the higher up the income scale you go! This happens in a democracy because whilst a tiny minority of people care about principles, most people care about power. AA empowered the right people so happened. It's a mistake to try to understand its justification from a first principles approach.
- snovv_crash 4y agoOn average, yes. But many things are multimodal and the average doesn't actually represent very many real people.
- petilon 4y ago> "if you're a certain skin color, you're too stupid, to compete on merit" Hold on. You realize Harvard's policies have historically been designed to favor Whites, right? The whole "holistic review" process was invented to favor Whites. See https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2019/03/history-privilege-elite-college-admissions/585088/ https://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2019/03/histor...
- hot_gril 4y agoSounds like they've been excluding Asian students for a long time then.
- cuteboy19 4y agoSpecifically, it was invented because Jewish people performed too well on objective metrics and of course we cannot have too many Jews. So they did away with those pesky objective metrics and came up with an opaque system that no one could easily audit but at the same time they could easily apply their racial biases On a completely separate and unrelated note Harvard is also getting rid of objective metrics now.
- nradov 4y agoWe should stop differentiating people by race, but whichever side loses this particular case can take solace in the fact that it won't make a huge difference either way. Studies have shown very little difference in average long-term career outcomes between highly selective and less selective colleges, after controlling for SAT scores and high school class ranking. Let's stop fetishizing schools like Harvard.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoThat's what always gets my goat. People seem to be less concerned with actual equality and improving things and more interested in claiming symbolic prizes. Why bother trying to make to her schools and opportunities better when what we really want is just to cash in a piece of the pie for ourselves. Another example is the push to STEM for women and minorities, it's not about actually learning the skill or contributing it's that being a coder is seem as an easy path to the good life and so we want to get in on that. If it were really about equality or income there would be more people pushing for representation in being an oil worker as those guys make great money too, but it just isn't seen as high status.
- Game_Ender 4y agoThe average person is not someone who moves the needle in society and it's not what you would target if you were a parent pushing to give you child the best achieving something remarkable. You want to give your child an outsized chance to end up the very top top of the band: successful founder a large business, national level politician, C-level executive, high successful doctor, well compensated finance professional, managing partner at a law firm. Or more crucially to be know those people and get opportunities the average person does not through their network. If both places produce the same average outcome, then you would be crazy to not pick the place that is several times more likely to have an amazing outcome.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- balozi 4y agoThe oral arguments are an excellent listen: -https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/live.aspx https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/live.aspx (live) -https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_audio/2022 https://www.supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_audio/2... (recorded)
- BryanBeshore 4y agoFantastic links. Looking forward to listening while having lunch today.
- colpabar 4y agoThank you for this. Are news outlets not allowed to include links to actual source material or something? Why is it that I almost always find these links in HN comments rather than the article itself? It's really annoying and I genuinely don't understand why this is so common, just like not linking to the actual studies for "science" news. To me it just seems sneaky, like if the article is correct, why not link the source so I can verify that myself? I know most people won't do that, but it feels like including the source when once exists and is already publicly available should be a hard requirement for any piece of journalism.
- D13Fd 4y agoI agree, and it irks me. When there is clear online source material, like in an article about a court case or viral video, the newspaper should link that material. I think many of these outlets must have a no-external-linking policy. But it really hurts their credibility and even their readability IMO.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoCheck out timestamp 1:01:08 in the Harvard case. CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Okay. So we're talking about race as a determining factor in admission to Harvard. MR. WAXMAN [representing Harvard]: Race in some -- for some highly qualified applicants can be the determinative factor...
- legitster 4y ago> Institutions like Harvard say they consider an applicant's race as one of several factors - including economic status and religious belief - in order to build classes that accurately represent the racial and ethnic diversity of the country. I mean, this is all kind of window dressing for elite institutions to be elite, right? There are millions of people qualified to attend these university, Harvard gets to hand select from all of them who gets to join their walled garden based on whatever Harvard Admissions is into right now. Notice that they don't care about diversity of viewpoints or politics. If these universities actually cared about minority enrollment, they could always expand the size of their enrollment. But none of them want to admit that the only real cache of their education is the exclusivity.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> they could always expand the size of their enrollment There are reasons beyond manufactured exclusivity for why this doesn’t work. College education isn’t just about students soaking up material. We need more online vocational schools where that’s the sole purpose. But let’s not throw out the baby with the bath water.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoCompare say, Berkeley to Stanford, and you'll see why this could work.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Compare say, Berkeley to Stanford Berkeley is highly exclusive [1], albeit 3x less so than Stanford [2]. The class-size difference, about 12,000, is noise against the millions of degrees conferred to Americans every year. Meanwhile, Stanford produces different graduate as a result of its process. Forcing homogenisation to one model for ideological purity is misled. [1] https://admission.universityofcalifornia.edu/campuses-majors/berkeley/freshman-admit-data.html https://admission.universityofcalifornia.edu/campuses-majors... [2] https://stanforddaily.com/2021/10/14/stanford-admit-rate-drops-to-record-low-3-95-for-the-class-of-2025/ https://stanforddaily.com/2021/10/14/stanford-admit-rate-dro...
- pcurve 4y agoHow well you do academically is influenced predominantly by genetics. It’s unfair to idolize these institution as something to aspire to and worship. Doing so is a gross misallocation of precious resources as a society. Instead they should be viewed as trade school for academically gifted. We should find different ways to harness the remaining 95 percentile. Striking it down would be the step in the right direction
- colinmhayes 4y agoHow well you do academically is influenced primarily by parental involvement.
- spoonjim 4y agoI’m of two minds here. Obviously race based admissions is unfair. But Harvard isn’t trying to admit the next generation of scholars, it’s trying to admit the next generation of power. Will that generation be 75% Asian, the way a class would be if formed with standardized testing? Doesn’t seem likely.
- petilon 4y ago[flagged]
- ALittleLight 4y agoYeah, but the Supreme Court isn't trying to help Harvard accomplish its goals. It's trying to determine the legal principles to resolve an issue. Whether that helps or hurts Harvard shouldn't be a concern.
- room505 4y agoHere's a great response to how colleges can ensure diversity since this will likely get struck down. https://www.bostonglobe.com/2022/10/20/opinion/affirmative-action-college-admissions-is-risk/ https://www.bostonglobe.com/2022/10/20/opinion/affirmative-a... Edit: TLTR: Dump standardized college admission tests as an admissions requirement, end legacy admissions and tap corporate activism.
- puffoflogic 4y ago> The fact that we get any Black students in under-resourced neighborhoods testing within 100 points of White students, who have been prepping for the test since the eighth grade, that is a miracle of over-performance That is disgustingly, outrageously racist.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoCould you elaborate?
- Ntrails 4y agoNot the poster, but the implication is that all white students are highly privileged in well resourced school districts. It's not technically what was said, but I agree the implication is pretty strong and unreasonable. You can have other readings ofc. Honestly the boundary between race/money/class/privilege is a pretty rough space to hang around.
- trention 4y ago"Ensuring diversity" is not a worthwhile goal for any institution.
- hot_gril 4y agoStandardized tests are an opportunity for students to distinguish themselves no matter what school they're stuck in. Yes the wealthier students on average study more for the SAT, but anyone can study for it with widely available materials. UC Berkeley got rid of the SAT/ACT requirement and is making their own test instead; if other schools did this, having so many different tests would ironically favor those with the most resources. And what's the alternative? There's not a lot else to go off of since GPAs are whatever.
- velavar 4y agoI'm curious as to why affirmative action in the US has always been race-based and not economic-status or household income based? Asking as someone with no skin in the game; I'm merely curious if anyone has any constructive opinions on why they think economic status based affirmative action may/may not work?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> why affirmative action in the US has always been race-based and not economic-status or household income based? We have both. We reserve the term “affirmative action” for race-based tilting. But means-based aid is also significant.
- function_seven 4y ago> But means-based aid is also significant. Does this refer to scholarships and other forms of tuition assistance, or does it also include admissions criteria as well?
- kennend3 4y agoSocioeconomic status is a much better goal if you want to "even the playing field" but it has serious flaws. The most obvious is it is incredibly easy to game: https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/incomeless-students-spent-57-million-on-vancouver-homes-in-past-two-years/article31892652/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/income... Any ideas on how students with no income managed to own $57 million in houses? Would these people qualify for a socio-economic advantage when applying for school?
- AnonCoward42 4y agoThe term "socioeconomic" is really malleable, when in actuality you probably meant "low income" or "poor". This might be a better measure, but can be gamed also as you point out. This however doesn't necessarily mean the measure is bad.
- 4y ago
- tlogan 4y agoThe problem is there but the current AA is not helping. Here is what might work: - Harvard is required to do only merit base admission - Harvard is required to increase diversity. They will be required to achieve that by investing in high schools in poor areas. Basically university will recruit poor students by helping them during middle and high schools. Something like opening Harvard middle or high school. (This is one of things what communists did right after WW2)
- anonAndOn 4y agoIf race is barred then the next method could be increased emphasis on perfect price discrimination to distinguish applicants socioeconomically. Outrageous tuition prices coupled with generous "scholarships" can also create a diverse student body.
- LatteLazy 4y agoPresumably if you cannot use race to decide who gets a place, you cannot use race to decide who get's a scholarship. At least as Harvard University, different rules might apply for the NAACP etc.
- anonAndOn 4y agoWho said anything about race? If you can afford Choate, you can afford $250k/year at Harvard. But the kid from Biloxi, MS gets a "scholarship" so she only pays $25k/yr.
- LatteLazy 4y agoOf course, for 250k*4y I could probably just buy a house in Biloxi... And many of the people the current system removes from the pool come from areas that would be just as economically under-performing as other groups. Sorry if I have missed your point?
- anonAndOn 4y agoWealth is a proxy for race.[0] Good luck to any court striking down wealth based admissions. Also, Biloxi is very affordable![1] [0]https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/wealth-inequality-and-the-racial-wealth-gap-20211022.html https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/notes/feds-notes/weal... [1]https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/bilxi-ms_rb/ https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/bilxi-ms_rb/
- josh_fyi 4y agoUS private colleges cost about $250 to $330k for am entire BA.
- BaculumMeumEst 4y agoMy child has the misfortune of being born Asian, so I'm looking forward to the outcome.
- tonystubblebine 4y agoI look at this through the lens of the San Francisco public schools. When I went to the magnet high school there, Lowell, they had explicit race based standards. We all got scores out of 70 based on our standardized tests and middle school grades. The differences were pretty stark. Chinese kids needed a 68, which could mean they got just one B. White kids needed a 62, black and latino even lower. So I totally get why Chinese families were screaming. The standards for them were way higher than for other races. But also just as jarring, the middle schools that fed this system were incredibly biased. My middle school, Hoover, had a segregation system that split the school in half. The honors half had at most one black kid per grade. We even had a different lunch period. The honors half was being groomed for schools like Lowell or at least to look at High School as an on ramp to college. It's not like we didn't have a lot of black students. We actually bussed in two, maybe four busloads of black kids from another neighborhood. But only one of those was ever admitted to honors. I just can't believe that there were no kids on those busses that were smart. I knew a lot of them through sports and they were plenty smart, together, hard working. If this level of segregation can happen in San Francisco, I can't imagine how bad it is in the rest of the country. It's complicated, and you can have your own takeaway, but mine is that merit often defined wrong. I'm on the lookout for people who did more with less, or even did equal or near to it with less. To me, that is more a measure of merit than top line measures like test scores.
- hot_gril 4y ago> It's complicated, and you can have your own takeaway, but mine is that merit often defined wrong. I'm on the lookout for people who did more with less, or even did equal or near to it with less. To me, that is more a measure of merit than top line measures like test scores. I agree with this, and the problem is how many schools look directly at race for that. This reminds me of predictive policing ML models that take race as a factor. Yes it gets more accurate results than if it didn't use that information, but that doesn't make it fair.
- cool_dude85 4y agoSo giving Black students a slightly higher chance to get into Harvard, all other things being equal, reminds you of sending the cops to overpolice neighborhoods Black people live in? I guess they're the same in a way. Doing bad things reminds me of doing good things because things are being done in either case.
- throwaway-9000 4y agoEven if SCOTUS does end affirmative action with this case, how are we going to undo the decades of damage that this policy has caused?
- lukas099 4y agoThis sounds suspiciously close to one of the main arguments for affirmative action: that it is meant to compensate for past discriminatory policies.
- hot_gril 4y agoIs this relevant on HN? > Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. [...] If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
- abeppu 4y agoI think this is being framed poorly. The "-based" in "race-based" suggests that race is a dominant factor. But it sounds like the real question is, can admission decisions consult race even as a minor consideration. > The court is hearing challenges to their admissions policies, which consider race among many factors when evaluating applications. > Institutions like Harvard say they consider an applicant's race as one of several factors - including economic status and religious belief - in order to build classes that accurately represent the racial and ethnic diversity of the country. In which case -- sure, perhaps this is a valuable conversation to have. But if one considers the efficient frontier of tradeoffs between the goals of having the most "meritocratic" class of students with the best grades and test scores or most AP credits etc, or having a "representative" class which reflects the diversity of the nation, I'm guessing there are bigger opportunities for improvement. Legacies and athletic recruitment, perhaps? If the explicit consideration of race is removed from admissions, are there not plenty of ways for admissions offices to try to consider similar factors other than personal academic performance, which would leave the plaintiffs still unsatisfied? Non-race factors for which admissions offices could try reflect national statistics in incoming classes: - percent public school vs private school - percent households which rent vs own their primary residence - distribution over home values in admits' zipcodes of residence - share of admits who had a parent incarcerated for some portion of their childhood - personality big 5 scores We get indignant in public about different treatment on the grounds of race. But I think students and families get frustrated because of the (inevitable) feeling of a loss of control when being judged based on criteria out of their control. If instead of race, one had the sneaking suspicion that one was not admitted because there were too many other private school, owned-home, 800k - 1.2M home, non-incarcerated-parent, high-conscientiousness applicants ... would you feel better?
- legitster 4y agoMy favorite part of the article: > A 2021 Gallup poll found that 62% of Americans were in favour of affirmative action programmes. A separate poll released by the Pew Research Center earlier this year, however, found that 74% of Americans - including a majority of black or Latino respondents - believed that race should not be factored into college admissions processes. I think my takeaway is that even if you give a horrendously unpopular program a catchy enough name, people will think they like it.
- dragonwriter 4y agoAffirmative action isn’t just for college admissions, and outside of college admissions, affirmative action programs generally do not involve decision preferences, but are limited largely to training programs, outreach efforts, and other funnel-shaping efforts. So, the poll results are perfectly consistent with people understanding the question and either supporting AAP in general but not in college admissioms, or supporting it in general but not when it goes beyond funnel-shaping to include decision preferences. They are also consistent with them supporting it in college, and involving decision preferences, but only on ethnicity, gender, and other non-race factors, though that seems less likely.
- legitster 4y agoI think that's a fair point. Then it's worth noting the Supreme court is not considering ending affirmative action at all, just the race-based selection.
- throwaway-9000 4y ago> Students for Fair Admissions, accuse Harvard of discriminating against Asian American applicants in order to boost representation from other groups. Why does this argument need to be framed entirely as discrimination against Asian Americans? Affirmative action clearly harms White people too. Are White people so incapable of advocating for themselves that they can only point out a policy is bad when it harms another minority group?
- colpabar 4y agoWell when the narrative is that all white people are at least slightly racist and that only white people can be racist to begin with, white people aren't really allowed to advocate for themselves, and any instance of it would immediately be designated as a hate group. I'm waiting for the day that "caring about discrimination against asian americans" is listed by the ADL as a dog whistle for white supremacy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]