6 ms·
I dont understand what makes Stock not liquid? Unless you want to sell it all, you can borrow against your stock for cash. If you want "Cash" only. I believe t
by ksec 4y ago
I dont understand what makes Stock not liquid? Unless you want to sell it all, you can borrow against your stock for cash.
If you want "Cash" only. I believe that point of owning cash is privacy and not having to disclose them.
- popol12 4y agoThat's very limited If you're Jeff Bezos there's no bank that is going to lend you 100B$ against your stock, because: 1. they don't have this money available themselves 2. there's less than 100B$ liquidity to dump these stocks on the market if they go down in value and Jeff's assets have to be liquidated, so the bank will limit the amount of money it will lend
- eastern 4y agoThe liquidity of anyone's stock holding depends entirely on how much one holds compared to how much is routinely traded on the markets. If I own 0.01 percent of any heavily-traded stock, it's 100% liquid. I can sell it whenever I want at a moment's notice. In any such accounting it will be added to my liquid wealth. But if I own 25% of the same stock, it's illiquid. If I also run the company, then it's worse because any attempt to sell a large part of my holding will itself trigger a crash in the price.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoPoor Bezos, one of the richest man in the world, yet has no cash at hand. I've heard stories of him having to ask money to the passerby to afford lunch. So sad to be the richest man but to actually own nothing. Hey poors, take example from Jeff! He's not liquid at all, like all of you, but he's always so happy!
- GaylordTuring 4y agoWho said anything about that you should feel sorry for Jeff Bezos? The parent commentator simply described the circumstances regarding what Jeff Bezos can get. Who are you arguing against?
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoMostly against the trite argument that net worth != liquidity, it's just reiterated everywhere here so I figured I could comment on any thread. Everyone is just skimping on the fact net worth still grants billionaires more power than entire countries have. That is what people are angry for.
- popol12 4y agoThe sole existence of billionaires bothers me a lot, yet I don’t see the issue in rectifying the truth about their fortune being 1 or 2 orders of magnitude smaller than what people believe. But don’t get me wrong, I think they are still way too rich even after accounting for this discount.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoI agree but I feel this has been rectified over and over, as I'm hearing the argument for years both online and on conventional media. By now it only feels to me as a cheap way to hijack the discussion and derail it further from the fact that we have to debate why billionaires exist and not how liquid they are. In the end the anti-billionaire/anti-system sentiment exists for valid reasons and it doesn't need to be educated to show us that there is an ever growing discontent with the way things work.
- imtringued 4y agoCan you buy groceries with your stocks? Liquidity implies that you can buy anything with stocks. People sell stocks for money because money can buy more things than just money.
- marcinzm 4y agoNo, liquidity means you can quickly convert something into cash and not that it has to be cash. To quote Cornell (https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/liquid_asset https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/liquid_asset): >Liquid assets refer to cash on hand, cash on bank deposit, and assets that can be quickly and easily converted to cash. The common liquid assets are stock, bonds, certificates of deposit, or shares. >Liquid assets are different from non-liquid assets, such as property, vehicles, or jewelry, which can take longer to sell and may lose value in the sale. Liquid assets are perceived as being the most basic type of asset available.
- synu 4y agoLiquid definitely doesn’t mean legal tender, just that you can quickly sell (like stocks on the market.) In contrast with property, collectibles, etc.
- Eisenstein 4y agoNo, but you can buy groceries with your no-limit American Express Black card and pay it off with stocks you sell.
- georgeplusplus 4y agoSelling billions of dollars worth of stock is very different than logging on robinhood and trading hundreds of shares. Making a list of richest people based on stocks is disingenuous because they will never be able to get that valuation if they sold it on the market due to the selling pressure such an event would exhibit from selling that much stock. Also gains in stocks are called unrealized wealth. It's not considered wealth until you decide to sell. Recently Elon sold stock to shore up funds to buy Twitter. Doing so he tanked the price of TSLA.
- synu 4y agoIf this is true, how would a founder or large shareholder ever retire (or even unexpectedly die and have their estate liquidated) without immediately killing the company they are a majority shareholder in? It seems like this must have happened at some point.
- zokier 4y agoIf your net worth is in the billions then extracting few millions for retirement is not a problem.
- synu 4y agoThat makes sense. But even if you’re one of the world’s richest people and decide for some reason to retire just on the savings of a FAANG engineer, you still eventually die and your assets must be sold or passed on to others. Someone is going to cash out. I just don’t understand how once you reach a certain level of wealth you are functionally locked out of ever accessing it except on paper. Someone must have kept their wealth or cashed out (one way or the other) at some point. It feels like, if true, no business would ever exist more than 30 years but clearly there are many businesses that have.
- kasey_junk 4y agoThe shares get dispersed to the broader family, children, grandchildren etc. Typically at those levels of wealth there is a “family office” which is just a word for “hedge fund” that’s only clients are the family. Like any hedge fund they can use those shares as parts of lots deals to diversify, manage risk and pull out cash. Sometimes it’s even simpler, dividends can provide a significant cash flow for large shareholders. In any case, it would be extremely strange for someone to get very wealthy and then hold most of their portfolio in cash.