10 ms·
You'd arguably have a case that Musk is not acting in the interest of Tesla and is using his Tesla position to enrich himself rather than the Tesla company. Exa
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
You'd arguably have a case that Musk is not acting in the interest of Tesla and is using his Tesla position to enrich himself rather than the Tesla company. Exactly what the "CEO is supposed to serve shareholders" is all about.
- ajross 4y agoThe counter argument is that Tesla has created more shareholder value over the past few years than any other single company, and in fact more than a ton of whole market segments. I mean, investors know he's sort of a loon, this is hardly the weirdest thing he done[1], and they're still on board. And FWIW: if you really want to structure this in a shareholder-friendly way, Twitter can just pay Tesla a consulting fee. Given that they're a private company now, that's almost literally as simple as just writing a check. [1] I mean, seriously, if "I'll buy TWTR for $40B!" didn't spook the market, you think they're really going to freak out about a few hundred hours of engineering time?
- bitexploder 4y agoMaking a bunch of money does not give you ethical credits you can spend later. He can probably get away with it though.
- geerlingguy 4y agoMany shareholders would offer their firstborn if Elon asked. He's a strange and unique character among the billionaires.
- kaesar14 4y agoProven track record gives you a really, really long leash. Only Steve Jobs has attained the rarefied air of being able to do whatever the fuck you want that Musk has.
- dmitriid 4y ago
- notjoemama 4y agoI recall Steve Jobs was known to blow up at his staff, sometimes seemingly randomly. He arguably created a hostile work environment. He also denied and estranged his own daughter. Let's not put CEOs on a scale. @kcplate Site isn't allowing me to reply, but I guess I can edit here? What I meant by scale was weighing CEOs or their behavior against each other. It sounded to me, and maybe I read it wrong, from the comment I replied to that Musk's issues were being levied against Musk with the implication (Their first sentence) Jobs didn't have issues like that. A better example of Jobs tanking Apple stock price was the partnership with Microsoft. At the time that was seen as Apple marrying the evil Jobs regularly criticized. So much for thinking different. But my point was the other things carried some form of risk and certainly didn't paint Jobs as not having character flaws. So I'm in agreement with you, he's human, Musk is human, mistakes are allowed to be made without, I don't know, "cancelling" someone I guess. Maybe it's just fashionable to pick on Musk right now? I don't know some people are so judgmental. I mean honestly, what does the average HackerNews user know about the nature of the Tesla engineers reviewing Twitter code? While it could be a problem, it could also be legal and considered above board. No one here seems to know the contractual agreements and why would they? Companies don't publish every thing that runs across executives desks.
- kcplate 4y agoExactly what is the point here? I’ve seen fast food shift supervisors blow up at their staff and know at least one person who is estranged from a child. Are CEOs (including famous ones) not allowed to be human. I have never met a human that wasn’t to some degree or another a shithead at various points of time.
- Klinky 4y agoI think their point is exactly that, they're human. The whole Twitter acquisition seems impulsive, petty, and obviously was poorly thought out.
- lolbert2 4y ago
- lolbert3 4y ago
- burnte 4y agoYeah, it does.
- tedunangst 4y agoMartin Shkreli returned a profit for his investors, and yet...
- mikeyouse 4y agoWinning at the casino with money you stole from the gas station doesn’t make the original theft okay, even if you return more than you stole.
- deaddodo 4y agoExactly the point being made. Musk stealing Tesla's resources to buy an asset for himself is not ok, even if it later helps Tesla.
- notjoemama 4y agoIsn't it the case people on news.ycombinator.com aren't familiar with the nature of the arrangement? Is there maybe a source that substantiates a perspective of "theft"? Or am I just missing that a rhetorical discussion is being had here?
- tedunangst 4y agoGiven the timeframe, I think people are skeptical that 1. Elon arranged for twitter to contract with Tesla for code review and 2. Recused himself from the negotiations regarding scope of work and rate charged.
- ericd 4y agoWho cares? The companies in his orbit benefit substantially from the cross pollination between them, and the PR opportunities that generates - much more than any arms-length negotiated rate would. Avoiding the type of fake work that you describe is very helpful for achieving the high iteration speeds his companies have.
- ilyt 4y agoYeah, investors don't care about ethics
- threatofrain 4y ago> Making a bunch of money does not give you ethical credits you can spend later. If this wasn't in the realm of how moral calculations work in society, then you wouldn't need to make this argument. People do accept funny moral trades and it's not clear how the calculus works. Tesla shareholders accept the fact that the guy in charge sometimes plays games like "FUNDING SECURED $420", so the fact that some Tesla engineers were borrowed/contracted/whatever is just a tiny detail in the big picture.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoIsn't the counter argument to this that he's also the guy who has lost the stock 43% of its value over the last year?
- kjksf 4y ago
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoAh, so the good is Elon, the bad is Jerome Powell? Also, the whole stock market isn't down 43% - the S&P is only down 13%.
- wfme 4y agoTSLA has underperformed the S&P 500 over the last year, but vastly outperformed it if you expand your time frame to 5 years - ~1,000% vs 50%. Perhaps comparing the 43% drop over the last year to other comparable companies would provide a better picture. 1 Year TSLA: -43.28% GM: -29.99% FORD: -26.13% STLA: -33.09% 5 Years TSLA: 1,019% GM: -8.24% FORD: 9.24% STLA: -25.23%
- Klinky 4y agoObviously Musk should go on Twitter and lie that he's taking Tesla private again to juice the stock. Maybe he'll get two slaps on the wrist this time.
- spookie 4y agoYou can't compare such a recent company, to others that were well established for decades. It means nothing. I believe the criticism comes from the volatility of the company.
- cercatrova 4y agoWho says Jerome Powell is bad? Fighting inflation due to, well, inflated asset values is a good thing, not bad. Just because it makes numbers go down doesn't mean it should be considered a bad thing.
- bagacrap 4y agothat announcement most certainly did spook the market and news about the Twitter acquisition has been a drag on TSLA all year. You may have noticed the stock trading for slightly more than half of its peak value.
- ratsmack 4y ago> sort of a loon I prefer eccentric, which may be an advantage for him.
- wwweston 4y ago> Tesla has created more shareholder value over the past few years Given the PE, seems to me the shareholders have created the shareholder value.
- conductr 4y agoShareholders already know he’s part time and has multiple jobs. As for leveraging talent, I doubt it’s effecting their productivity in a significant way or deadlines are slipping due to this.
- ramraj07 4y agoYour doubts will not stand up in court, even if they are grounded in reality, which *I* doubt. These engineers took time off work during work hours to go somewhere and do things that are not in service of the publicly traded company they’re employed at. That’s not something you can just hand wave away.
- jaxn 4y agoUnless Tesla is interested in adding social networking / messaging features to the car interface. It’s not hard to envision a potential business case
- acdha 4y agoThat’s not “unless” - it’s a translate post hoc rationalization. It’s a stretch that they’d be working on that feature - considering the distracted driving problem it’s something of a liability - but even if they were, that might mean that you send a couple of people from that specific team to talk APIs or something. Pulling random engineers over to review things outside of their specialty doesn’t make any sense.
- eclipxe 4y agoNot to be used while driving. Tesla has a bunch of built in apps not to be used while driving. Ex: TikTok and Netflix.
- acdha 4y agoYes, and people use them while driving because the vehicle doesn’t prevent it. You can get away with that kind of legal attempt to dodge responsibility but at some point public awareness catches up with you, similar to how telling people to drive safely wasn’t enough to avoid generations of safety technology becoming legally required.
- ratsmack 4y agoDo you believe that Musk is not going to push his cars on Twitter? Seems to me that you have access to a fairly large audience on there.
- rtkwe 4y agoJust being tangentially related to the company isn't enough to justify it imo. You could also buy a lot of twitter ads for the cost of having devs come over.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI guess that’s the concept of a CEO, to decide if it is justified. He will answer to the board and shareholders.
- rvba 4y agoDoesn't USA have the tax concept of "transfer pricing"? Musk (who is definitely the beneficial owner of Twitter and probably of Tesla too) is providing "free" consulting service of Tesla employees for Twitter -> without an invoice and without tax. (or maybe there will be an invoice?) In EU that should be taxed (and also invoiced) - with similar prices as a consulting provided by a consulting company that does code reviews. The tax office is interested most in the missing tax of course.
- powerapple 4y agoIs it confirmed that it is "free" consulting service? The article didn't mention anything about it.
- nerdawson 4y ago> Later, people inside the company reported that Tesla engineers were in fact reviewing the code. There’s very little here to make any kind of judgement from. Perhaps they were being paid for some private work outside of their employment. Maybe there’s some kind of arrangement in place to cover the costs of their time. From the outside we simply don’t know.
- zackees 4y agoThere’s the presumption here that Tesla is footing the bill. For all you know Tesla hired out of these workers on contract and the Twitter is footing the bill.
- weinzierl 4y agoEither Twitter footing the bill or maybe he pays Tesla for the project out of his own pockets.
- ed_elliott_asc 4y agoBut surely at the very least there is an opportunity cost of the Tesla engineers not working. What is the point of them if they don’t work?
- morelisp 4y agoIf Twitter is paying under fair market rate, that's collusion to benefit Twitter at the expense of Tesla. If Twitter is paying above fair market rate, that's collusion to benefit Tesla at the expense of Twitter. If Twitter is paying exactly fair market rate, why does it need to be Tesla employees? That starts to look like self-dealing to make Musk's live easier. You can't really win in this situation, which is why any sane executive avoids such a conflict of interest in the first place. (I'm not claiming there will be any repercussions mind you - if Musk got away with SolarCity he'll surely get away with this.)
- dr_dshiv 4y agoCollusion? No.
- ratorx 4y agoDoes Case 2 matter if the company is privately owned?
- morelisp 4y agoYes, because it's not really public vs. private that matters, in both cases it's whether the shareholders care. (If it's public they complain to the SEC, if it's private they complain to their contract lawyers who hopefully included some accountability in the contracts.) This is also why Musk can get away with it - he's got fanboys, albeit of slightly different types, dominating the shareholders in both cases. (In the case of Twitter he may even be personally the majority shareholder with no obligations beyond cash now, but who knows...)
- dumpsterdiver 4y agoCurious, why would you think that a person who has trouble finding a group of banks (what is a group of banks called, a flight?) to produce the cash that he owns on paper, is solely interested in chasing more cash? Is it not more believable that he has a social agenda? At this very moment, I find it believable that Musk is drawing a line in the sand to be seen by folks who would have others irreparably silenced if their views aren't fashionable.
- Jotra7 4y ago
- fallingknife 4y agoYou probably wouldn't since those engineers probably signed consulting agreements with Twitter, and are being paid by Twitter, not Tesla for this work.
- marvin 4y agoHe’s doing the reverse with SpaceX employees, so it’s a net win.
- chris_wot 4y agoA truly confidence-inspiring move, to have Twitter developers work on mission-critical SpaceX systems. Bravo!
- dhruval 4y agoSpace X engineers are working on Tesla
- broknbottle 4y agoReal life Rocket League?
- chris_wot 4y agoA truly confidence-inspiring move, to have Twitter developers work on safety-critical Tesla subsystems. Bravo!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]