8 ms·
Freetone – Pantone-ish colour palette for Adobe products
- philips 4y agoThe about page provides some context https://www.culturehustleusa.com/pages/about-us https://www.culturehustleusa.com/pages/about-us
- aliqot 4y agoI have not a single clue what's going on here, because I'm not a designer.. but I like it.
- jkingsman 4y agoAdobe and Pantone, a major color designer, have struck a deal where you need to pay additional licensing fees to access a portion of Pantone's color palette in Adobe products[0]. This has made a lot of people, very understandably, quite frustrated, as Adobe products will now replace those Pantone colors with black when you open a project that uses them. [0]: https://boingboing.net/2022/10/28/adobe-replacing-old-pantone-spot-colors-with-black-when-you-load-files-using-them.html https://boingboing.net/2022/10/28/adobe-replacing-old-panton...
- xcdzvyn 4y agoNowhere does that citation imply Adobe worked with Pantone to achieve this, but that it was solely Pantone's decision.
- josephcsible 4y agoThe Pantone colors used to be included with Photoshop. Now you need to pay for an extra subscription to use them, and it's retroactive: if you open any of your old .psd files without the subscription, all of those colors get replaced with black. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33369951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33369951 has a big discussion about this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ilyt 4y agoThe perils of service model, normally you'd just be able to use it with older version of their product just fine and only have that feature taken away when you upgrade
- jw1224 4y agoGood to see something new from Stuart Semple — the guy who made the “blackest black” (Black 2.0), which everyone except Anish Kapoor can purchase… https://www.thecollector.com/vantablack-anish-kapoor-stuart-semple-controversy/ https://www.thecollector.com/vantablack-anish-kapoor-stuart-...
- zimpenfish 4y ago> Good to see something new from Stuart Semple ... Black 2.0 I mean, he's released Black 3.0 and about 20 other things since then. The man is a non-stop craft supplies firehose.
- undoware 4y agoHadn't noticed that Freetone was Semple's brainchild. It checks out and I love him for it. I dabble a bit, and Black 2.0 (havent' tried 3.0) is like magic. I also heartily recommend Semple's glow-in-the-dark pigment, but be sure to mix well, it's a non-soluble powder and can yield unintended 3D effects if the mix is off (or you did not mortar/pestle)
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThat is absolutely hilarious. I wonder how much Anish Kapoor paid for those exclusive rights.
- fimdomeio 4y agoThe story in podcast format: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/their-dark-materials/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/their-dark-materials/
- ibbtown 4y agoAdobe or Pantone seems to canceled some kind of contract about the use of panotme color library. As Adobe creative cloud is a monthly paid service and not a bought software, all illustrator and other Adobe product software can not use the Pantone colour libraries anymore, which are really important as a professional. You have to buy a additional add-on from Pantone. The important part ist that pantome as a IP company only sells a library with name and color codes. This freezone palette seems to be a free copy of color values with different names.
- shrx 4y agoSo how do you actually use this? As far as I know there's no option in photoshop to convert an image from RGB to Pantone/Freetone.
- CharlesW 4y agoPantone/PMS colors are used for spot color¹. If you're not designing for spot color print reproduction, you wouldn't need this. If you want to translate a specific RGB color to a Pantone color, there are sites like https://www.ginifab.com/feeds/pms/ https://www.ginifab.com/feeds/pms/ which can make suggestions. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spot_color https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spot_color
- shrx 4y agoThanks, so this is an extension/generalization of the CMYK colorspace?
- samwillis 4y agoProfessional/industrial printers can have up to 10/12 inks and pigments, plus metallics, and varnishes. you also then have different optical characteristics depending on substrate. It’s so far removed from the cmyk colour space.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Thanks, so this is an extension/generalization of the CMYK colorspace? As a spot color standard focused on the printed (or otherwise reproduced) result, I think it's most useful to think of PMS as its own thing. CMYK is the standard 4-color "process" model, in which those four colors are combined to create all colors possible by mixing them. In contrast, Pantone/PMS colors are solid colors and reproduced as such (rather than as combinations of CMYK), and include colors that fall both inside and outside what's possible with CMYK process printing. For example, Target red is "PANTONE PMS 2035 C" when printing to coated¹ paper. For printed pieces, designers at Target can specify that as a spot color and know that the reproduced result will match this. This same red can be approximated as a halftone of all 4 CMYK colors, but the result won't look as sharp or vibrant. ¹ https://www.paperpapers.com/news/coated-vs-uncoated-paper/ https://www.paperpapers.com/news/coated-vs-uncoated-paper/
- frob 4y agoThe inclusions of "Blackest Black 3.0" is just beautiful. I hope the Hex is `-1-1-1`. Or maybe it sucks brightness from the pixels around it.
- ATsch 4y agoI'm not sure how helpful this is? The service Pantone provides is not really a list of colors. It's the calibration of almost every printer and item that can create color, in every medium and on every surface, against their color library. Not just printable colors either, also things that can't be printed like metal and florescent colors. It means you can get a book cover and a business card printed, some plastic injection molded, have your car painted and be assured they are all going to be exactly the same color when they arrive. It's the mapping between pantone names and the real world that's valuable, and this doesn't seem to help with that.
- Gare 4y agoBut if there is a 1:1 mapping from Freetone to Pantone, shouldn't this still work? Crappy thing is that Pantone wants designers to pay for the ability to associate some area with a specific Pantone hue.
- samwillis 4y agoPaying Pantone for the work they put into developing a calibrated colour system across printers, inks and sub-straits isn’t “crappy”. Adobe pulling a product feature from paid customers existing install/subscription because they failed to licence the feature properly from the supplier is crappy. Pantone is, in my option, being somewhat unduly attacked for this change. This is 100% on Adobes head. Pantone have been a popular punching bag for the design industry for 30 years. And it may be true they over charge for what they offer. But this is Adobes f*up. Frankly, a 1:1 mapping of Pantone to Freetone sounds like copyright infringement. What I would love to see is a new “free”/libra/open colour system, superseding what Pantone offer. Let’s not just copy people because we feel slighted.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThey can and do charge for products related to actually making the colors. That doesn't mean they should get paid for which RGB code looks close. And the idea of copyrighting colors is ridiculous.
- raphlinus 4y agoI was quite impressed with the FreieFarbe[1] presentation at Libre Graphics Meetup 2019. It is an open source service that actually does attempt to provide similar value as Pantone, not just the naming of sRGB colors. In particular, they've put nontrivial work into calibrating it to physical colorants. [1]: https://www.freiefarbe.de/en/ https://www.freiefarbe.de/en/
- app4soft 4y agoRelated post in their blog:[2] [2] https://www.freiefarbe.de/en/adobe-produkte-demnaechst-ohne-pantone-farben/ https://www.freiefarbe.de/en/adobe-produkte-demnaechst-ohne-...
- Kye 4y agoThis video was very informative on the value Pantone provides: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JF8UziDHqZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JF8UziDHqZo
- Sporktacular 4y agoHard to tell if making everyone go through a shopping cart to download it is a joke. Am I missing something?
- djmips 4y agoIf this particular person already sells things then to them, adding a zero dollar product was probably the path of least resistance. It's only a minor inconvenience for someone who wants this plugin.
- cthalupa 4y agoAs someone that works a lot with both Pantone and RAL, I've never understood the value proposition of the these digital color palettes - the fact of the matter is, they're just not good matches to the physical colors to begin with. Obviously, a physical product is reflected light, a monitor is emissive light, etc. This means they're never going to be exact no matter how much work you put into it, but... I have a calibrated monitor with measured coverage of over 99% sRGB, a delta E max below 1, a delta E average of .4, calibrated to D65, with a 98 CRI D65 color matching light, and... the colors are way off. At best the hex values they give are decent starting points, but if you are attempting to provide an accurate representation in digital form of what the color is, these were never good enough to begin with. You need the physical samples (books, plastic chips, whatever), a calibrated monitor, and a good color matching light to really dial the colors in to be close. These libraries were never worth it to begin with. When you go to get something printed/resins and inks mixed for plastic/whatever, they're not matching to these digital values - they match to physical samples. My printer won't produce the same physical product using the same CMYK values as your printer, etc. They get out their pantone book and compare the printed color to what is in the book, and then adjust from there. For anything requiring high color accuracy, anyway.
- WhiskeyChicken 4y agoThat's what I always thought, too, that the point of referencing Pantone colors is simply that I know what I'll get from the print shop will match the physical swatch I looked at.
- kelsolaar 4y agoHave you considered Observer Metamerism, your display might have very narrowband primaries for example. Your vision could also be an outlier of the CIE Standard Observers, thus any calibration attempt will not be super effective.
- cthalupa 4y ago>your display might have very narrowband primaries for example I am using a professional display that is intended for color-accurate work, and similarly have other very accurate, calibrated, monitors that show the same results. > Your vision could also be an outlier of the CIE Standard Observers, thus any calibration attempt will not be super effective. I've scored near perfectly to perfectly on a variety of Farnsworth Munsell 100 Hue (and inspired) tests using the same displays, and I speak frequently with others who also have to do color accurate work while dealing the Pantone and RAL colors. They universally report the same thing. Fundamentally if these digital values were good enough, we wouldn't need the physical samples to begin with.
- robenkleene 4y agoWhy didn't the dupe detector catch this? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33381528 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33381528
- detaro 4y agobecause it is a different url, and even if it weren't something with no comments or votes isn't really a dupe.
- robenkleene 4y agoAh, the submitted URL is different. I missed that because they both redirect to the URL I submitted (for me at least). > something with no comments or votes isn't really a dupe. I thought the dupe detector was designed to catch this exact situation? I get redirected to existing submissions all the time with no upvotes or comments when I submit dupe URLs myself?
- oktwtf 4y agoAll this accomplishes is allowing a designer so choose from a palette list of comparable colours. You could always make your own named spot swatches and let your printer sort it out. (This is basically what is happening) Often if they are named, like Pantone, they are looked up on the digital press/printer's controller/rasterizer based on the stock selection, available toner/inks, etc. Then there is often a loop for calibration and adjustment for humidity, temp, and the lot. Some pre-press worker is going to have to manually swap Freetone picks for the actual Pantone names so the rasterization process spits out a reproducible and accurate set of separations for process. I wouldn't hold your breath for a Freeflow/Firey upgrade to automate Freetone anytime soon...
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: This file has Pantone colors that have been removed and replaced with black - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33369951 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33369951 - Oct 2022 (224 comments)
- jeegsy 4y agoMy general point in these sorts of stories is that while you can name a bunch of advantages of subscription only software, its the disadvantages that really get ya!
- superpanic 4y agoI almost never use Pantone libs anyway. I usually just use Cyan or Magenta as Pantone plates and tell the printer what Pantone color the C or M plate should be printed in.