14 ms·
Texas solar and wind resources saved consumers nearly $28B over 12 years
- AHappyCamper 4y agoYes, but how much did it cost them?
- kyrra 4y agoAnd what was the financial impact of the blackouts that happened in the last few years? During that event the solar was effectively zero, and wind was close to that. Plus too many gas plants were in maintenance or froze/broke, which caused outages. If Texas would have still been fully on gas/coal/nuclear, would there have been a blackout? If they would have invested more in nuclear, what would be the financial impact? Would it have operated better in the freeze? There are trade off with every decision made. I'm trying to sus out of the state would be better off spending money in a different way.
- black_13 4y agoTexas energy problems are not from technology but from poor governance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andsoitis 4y agoLike the sibling said, poor governance. Wikipedia on the 2021 Text Blackout (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Texas_power_crisis): State officials including Republican governor Greg Abbott[13] initially blamed[14] the outages on frozen wind turbines and solar panels. However, data showed that failure to winterize power sources, like wind turbines and natural gas infrastructure, had caused the grid failure.[15][16] Texas's power grid has long been separate from the two major national grids to avoid federal oversight, though it is still connected to the other national grids and Mexico's;[17] the limited number of ties made it difficult for the state to import electricity from other states during the crisis.[18] Deregulation of its electricity market beginning in the 1990s resulted in competition in wholesale electricity prices, but also cost cutting for contingency preparation.
- roenxi 4y agoThe Wikipedia article mentions "The winter storm caused a record low temperature at Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport of −2 °F (−19 °C) on February 16, the coldest in North Texas in 72 years.". A bad outage in a 1:70 year event may be reasonable governance. If you demand people gold-plate the grid to prepare for a few bad days every 70 years, it'll really hurt all the other 69 years and however many days because a lot of money gets spent for a contingency that happens rarely. It might make more sense to just have warm shelters ready, rather than try and make the grid robust. Give the market a chance. Plus, practically, a 1:70 tail event is usually outside a regulator's tolerance for preparation too. COVID springs to mind as something on a similar timeframe.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoIt was a total fluke and hit at least 2/3 of the state, most cold blasts don't do that. I was lucky and near a hospital, so my power only went out a couple of hours and I had 2 families (friends) come and live with me for 3 days or so. They cleaned out my larder, but honestly I enjoyed my time with them immensely. However, climatologists predict it will happen more often as the jet stream that usually keeps most of the arctic air out of the state is getting weaker of the years.
- katbyte 4y agoIt also happened in 2011, and nearly again in 2014: https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/22/texas-power-grid-extreme-weather/ https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/22/texas-power-grid-ext... The market has abjectly failed customers in texes - but the utilities made off like bandits charging outrageous amounts each time. The texes power grid is broken and the market won’t fix it. There is a reason the regulations they don’t want to implement exist.
- roenxi 4y ago> It also happened in 2011, and nearly again in 2014 Texas has cheap power though. If I were moving to the US for some reason, I'd consider Texas for it's cheap power then try to mitigate the risks myself. Just because something isn't perfect doesn't mean that changing it makes it better. You're assuming that 100% reliability is the only acceptable outcome. It is possible 99% reliability and alternate mitigation is the best outcome. If people prepare for the power grid going down from time to time that will also prepare for other events and build up resiliency. People freezing is really bad. Relying on a large and complex system working in extreme events is also bad, however. This is one for Texans to resolve for themselves, but there is a story here where the problem is actually the resiliency to the grid failing rather than the failures themselves. Cheap power + good emergency procedures is probably going to be a really cheap path, plus hit a whole heap of alternative disaster planning scenarios.
- csours 4y agoA nuclear power plant went down when it's lake froze. Coal power plants did the same. Natural gas fared better when the supply wasn't frozen, because natural gas turbines don't require intensive cooling that steam generation does. And yes, it's really ironic that steam generation had to stop due to lack of cooling on the coldest day of the year. Wind Turbine gearboxes froze up (oil congealed, not froze) because they were too cold and also not winterized. They could have been but they weren't. Solar could have powered some people's homes, but most home solar turns off when the grid turns off.
- sidewndr46 4y agoWhen it is overcast in Texas residential solar doesn't really generate an appreciable amounts of power. It is grid tie so despite what many people think they don't have any power in the case of the grid going out. I know of a few folks on co-op power that are allowed to have Tesla powerwall (or similar). But in that case they can't sell power back into the grid economically. The reason why the 2021 freeze was so intense is that during the day we didn't get sun, we had cloud cover 24 hours a day. It's entirely normal to get freezing nights in most of Texas. But by 10 AM stuff is back up to a temperature that it's 40 F or so because of the sun. When we get days upon days or freezing nights followed by even just overcast weather, that is when it becomes an issue.
- abathur 4y agoNot sure I'd blame the cloud cover over the polar airmass wrt intensity. I think we had at least a couple sunny days in Houston (I remember opening blinds to get as much free heat as possible) and still didn't get out of the low 20s iirc.
- noneeeed 4y agoTwice as much capacity was taken offline from gas, coal and nuclear generators than from wind or solar. https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/16/natural-gas-power-storm/ https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/16/natural-gas-power-st... In all cases it was because the infrastructure wasn’t hardened for the weather. This is something that they have now been doing I believe, although how ready they are will only be found out at the next big freeze. Wind works fine in cold weather if you build it with the weather in mind. Cold states like Michigan have wind turbines and do just fine https://empoweringmichigan.com/how-do-wind-turbines-work-in-cold-weather/ https://empoweringmichigan.com/how-do-wind-turbines-work-in-...
- ed25519FUUU 4y agoA more accurate thing to say is that turbines need to be heated in cold weather, which has an effect on their cost and operation efficiency. In places where a deep freeze is unlikely it’s usually better just to shut them down in extremely cold weather.
- noneeeed 4y agoAs do natural gas and other energy systems, as demonstrated in my point that twice as much gas/coal/nuclear generation was turned off during the Texas feeeze. All generation systems need to be adapted to the weather, Texas energy producers of all kinds decided not to, the blackouts were the result.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jackmott42 4y agoSolar worked fine during the winter storm.
- ed25519FUUU 4y agoOnly if the house was equipped with a battery, which is not common. There’s a NEC requirement that solar power stops when the grid goes down to prevent power islands. The only way around this is a battery. Also lithium batteries can’t charge in sub-freezing temperatures without permanent damage.
- pengaru 4y agoSolar isn't limited to homes, does Texas not have any solar farms on the grid? TFA doesn't clarify this.
- vel0city 4y agoThere are solar farms in Texas, a bit over 8GW installed so far with several large projects planned to come online soon. I've driven past some pretty large solar fields out in far west Texas. It's an interesting scene seeing extremely flat lands all the way to the horizon filled with some randomly placed rusty old pump jacks, massive arrays of solar panels, and massive wind turbines in the distance.
- shagie 4y agoThere's an NPR podcast series about that - The Disconnect: Power, Politics and the Texas Blackout https://www.npr.org/podcasts/1004840920/the-disconnect-power-politics-and-the-texas-blackout https://www.npr.org/podcasts/1004840920/the-disconnect-power... The issue is how they set up the grid and avoided any federal regulation. Additionally, the market structure that it uses is designed to be running as close to being a blackout as possible without actually blacking out in the name of "an efficient market".
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoIf someone in Texass experiences a blackout, they can just go to https://comparepower.com/ https://comparepower.com/ and select a different provider, right?
- _JamesA_ 4y agoThe correct site is https://powertochoose.org https://powertochoose.org but your observation of having a pseudo-choice of energy providers still stands.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoWhat are you even talking about? We had that awful blackout, and it sure as heck wasn't renewables, it was the fossil fuel power plants and gas plants that provided for them. I hate to see it but you really should go look up the real causes of the blackout. It was winterization at fossil fuel plants (gas and electric) if you want the short version. It's not like we have constant blackouts. could we improve the grid? Of course and by a lot. Are we experiencing 3rd world power grid conditions? Not even close.
- jeffbee 4y agoTexas is likely to pass California in total renewable energy resources soon, which kind of annoys me. I would like California to step up its construction game, and not just rest on our head start.
- nappy-doo 4y agoHave you met PG&E?
- jeffbee 4y agoI have but for the audience who might not know much about California: PG&E are not players in the renewable energy construction game. Other entities build and operate the plants, and the utilities buy the energy. My impression is the main hurdle for us is CEQA, which gives every homeowner, misguided Sierra Club member, and union goon a way to stop or delay the projects.
- mistrial9 4y agothere is a quiet non-profit based around Palo Alto that builds long-term residential solar installations, directly under the wing of PG&E. The tradeoff is that they put three "phone home" operators in your solar controller, and reserve the right to shutoff power back into the grid for their own reasons; high-quality installs though.
- shagie 4y ago> The tradeoff is that they put three "phone home" operators in your solar controller, and reserve the right to shutoff power back into the grid for their own reasons. The ability to push any substantial power back into the grid always comes with that. Consider Hawaii's solar options: https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/products-and-services/customer-renewable-programs/rooftop-solar https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/products-and-services/custo... > Customer Grid-Supply Plus (CGS Plus) systems must include grid support technology to manage grid reliability and allow the utility to remotely monitor system performance, technical compliance and, if necessary, control for grid stability. > Smart Export customers with a renewable system and battery energy storage system have the option to export energy to the grid from 4 p.m. – 9 a.m. Systems must include grid support technology to manage grid reliability and system performance. > Customer Self-Supply (CSS) is intended only for private rooftop solar installations that are designed to not export any electricity to the grid. Customers are not compensated for any export of energy. --- Having too much power on the grid can be as damaging as not enough. There are systems that take longer to power up and down and corresponding issues with environmental regulations. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonbruner/2011/10/20/the-high-stakes-math-behind-the-wests-greatest-river/?sh=455c0a5b222b https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonbruner/2011/10/20/the-high-s... > But as large as the dams are, their margins are minuscule and operating them takes unerring foresight and subtle management: let too much water fill reservoirs and a rainstorm might flood Portland; keep the reservoirs too empty and you’ll parch farmers. Send too much water over a dam’s spillway and you’ll suffocate fish with dissolved gases; send too much through its turbines and you’ll overload the electrical grid. > ... > It’s also brought about tension when the BPA hasn’t been able to change its output. Both wind and hydro generation are subject to nature at the extremes. In May 2011, with near-record snowmelt swelling the Columbia River and spillways at their limits under environmental regulations, the BPA had to keep the Columbia’s hydro turbines spinning. It told regional wind power producers to curtail their output by 6%. The producers howled, and in June the BPA ended up the subject of a complaint before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. At issue is what happens when too much electricity is on offer. The enormous supply of hydroelectricity during spring runoff can push electricity prices to zero—the BPA gives away electricity to local utilities for free when it’s forced to produce more than it wants to. Since wind producers enjoy production subsidies, they can push rates below zero, effectively paying other utilities to switch off their generators. Last winter, the BPA told wind producers under its balancing authority that it wouldn’t pay negative rates to them during high-water events. Making sure that the water doesn't go over the spillways in a hydro plant during a spring peak to avoid killing fish means turning off power from other sources. In that example, it was primarily wind
- VoxPelli 4y agoSoon someone will enter here and tell why nuclear anyhow is the answer to all problems and worries. Great to see this in Texas! Didn’t know they were big in this
- melling 4y agoTexas grid still isn’t reliable. https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/fed-report-says-texas-grid-still-not-reliable-experts-discuss-current-proposals-ercot-winter-storm-uri https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/fed-report-says-texas-grid-... Remember when they had the power outage and people died? Wind turbines in Texas aren’t winterized so usage drops to around 10% in the winter. The natural gas also stopped working because it wasn’t winterized either. Remember when the governor of Texas blamed frozen wind turbines for the disaster? https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/02/17/texas-abbott-wind-turbines-outages/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/02/17/texas-abbot... Remember 45 years ago we were warned not to burn all that coal or we would cause climate change? We’re still at 40% coal for electricity globally and it’s now too late to prevent a significant amount of warming. But hey, the batteries are almost ready? We can’t be more than 10-20 years from widespread adoption?
- hsnewman 4y agoI agree, the savings from not maintaining the system could also add up to real $.
- PM_me_your_math 4y ago
- melling 4y agoYes, I’ve heard the Obama ocean front mansion story a thousands times. How high above sea level has been debated. Could be totally under water by 2100? https://wattsupwiththat.com/2019/08/28/sea-level-rise-dooms-obamas-new-martha-vineyard-mansion/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2019/08/28/sea-level-rise-dooms-... I’d say maybe he was assuming we’d address climate change or he’d simply move by 2061 when he turns 100. Miami is only 6 feet above sea level so it will be gone before his house. Once Miami floods climate change deniers will have a more difficult time convincing people they are right. But I’m betting the limits of denial are boundless. In the meantime, sounds like a great house.
- roenxi 4y agoI'm a long way from Texas. Should I note this as a win for the free market or is there something going on here?
- jeffbee 4y agoOnly if you’re a blind ideologue. The wind boom in Texas is the result of raising their renewable energy portfolio laws to require a certain amount of it, and by establishing renewable energy zones which give power plant builders expansive powers to condemn and take private property. You see it’s quite the opposite of free market forces.
- phrz 4y agoThat begs the question: if oil and gas is steeply subsidized, does government support for renewables simply create a level playing field?
- anecdotal1 4y agoYou're not supposed to mention that there is no free market / price discovery with fossil fuels :)
- kodah 4y agoAt least on the ground, that's what I saw. Turbines work a lot like someone asking to use other types of rights on your property. Unfortunately, iirc most of the windfarms are owned by a few people, but people are getting paid for wind instead of fracking. I don't think wind and oil are at competition in Texas though. Most oil drilled in Texas isn't destined for Texas, or the US really.
- patrick451 4y agoMost of what passes for a "subsidy" in this conversation is writing off normal business expenses, the same way ever business in the country does. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2013/01/02/oil-gas-tax-provisions-are-not-subsidies-for-big-oil/?sh=1299b3b852e8 https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2013/01/02/oil-ga...
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI’m sure all of that extra capacity has been wasted by now on Bitcoin mining. Edit: Let me do some math instead of guessing. > The Texas grid operator expects crypto miners to increase electricity demand by up to 6 gigawatts by mid-2023 > Texas leads the U.S. in wind installations, with 30.46 GW, and it’s second in solar energy, with 8.6 GW as of August. Still. Not great. Almost every solar panel in Texas going to mine something with seven transactions per second. There is no excuse for this amount of power wasted since Ethereum moved to proof of stake. https://ultrasound.money/ https://ultrasound.money/.
- replygirl 4y agomining is less than 1.5 gw of texas demand. still bad, but not that bad
- api 4y agoEthereum is a technology. Bitcoin is a religion.
- irusensei 4y agoCool slogan but how does that contribute to the discussion?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- irusensei 4y ago> There is no excuse for this amount of power wasted since Ethereum moved to proof of stake. https://ultrasound.money/ https://ultrasound.money/ There is. After the PoS merge more than 50% blocks on the ethereum chain are OFAC compliant raising censorship concerns. https://cointelegraph.com/news/51-of-ethereum-blocks-are-now-compliant-with-ofac-standards-raising-censorship-concerns https://cointelegraph.com/news/51-of-ethereum-blocks-are-now...
- JohnJamesRambo 4y ago
- jiggyjace 4y agoThat's $37 per month less per customer. Now factor in inflation and rising energy costs and what's the total calculus?
- graton 4y agoBased on your $37/month. So over a year that would be $444 and over 12 years it would be $5,328.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- mpweiher 4y agoDoes inflation only affect renewables?
- byyll 4y agoHow did you get to that high number? 29,000,000,000 / 29,145,505 (population) = ~$995 savings per person over 12 years $995 / 12 years = ~$83 per year $83 / 12 months = less than $7 per month per person. Am I missing something?
- drdec 4y agoThe parent post calculation was per customer, i.e. household not per person.
- byyll 4y agoAh, that's what I missed. Thanks!
- lemondrink 4y agoUsing the population is not correct. Most people live with another and surely children do.
- didgetmaster 4y agoWhy does renewable energy sources have to be so political? Personally, I like the idea of better and more wind and solar generated power, but not because I 'hate fossil fuels'. If solar panels keep getting cheaper and more efficient, I will eventually get a rooftop solar system. If I can buy a good electric car without breaking the bank then I will. Renewables seem like a great way to meet the growing demands of an energy hungry society but if they are really good then we shouldn't have to try to scare people away from competing energy sources.
- namuol 4y agoAs usual, follow the money: I suspect this is a wedge issue because it has been manufactured/amplified as one with the encouragement of the fossil fuel lobby.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoI agree. More renewables = more natural gas consumed. Case and point: Germany. The proponents of renewables on large scale are usually fossil fuel companies or groups funded by fossil fuel companies [0]. [0] https://www.ft.com/content/3ffe84d3-6b56-4781-a218-a598d43e8ac5 https://www.ft.com/content/3ffe84d3-6b56-4781-a218-a598d43e8...
- danhor 4y agoThe only issue with that point is that the share of natural gas in the electricity mix hasn't meaningfully increased in germany over the last decades.
- namuol 4y agoSurely it’s not that simple. In Germany, wasn’t it the abandonment of nuclear that ultimately led to the heavy reliance on fossil fuels? I would think that plays a deeper role.
- danhor 4y agoGermany never went all-in on electricity like e.g. France did, even while building NPPs. What is now an issue for germany is the move away from domestic or easily replaceable fossil fuels like coal or oil in favour of gas.
- propogandist 4y agoThis headline is derived from a report published by for-profit Energy consulting company (IdeaSmiths) that specializes in writing reports to justify big CapEx investments. From their site- > Our analytical and due diligence capabilities can provide significant value to early-stage inventors and professional investors and legal firms. The “article” (and Study) also features BS projections like this: > The drop in emissions has saved Texans between $10.2 billion and $76.4 billion in healthcare and other environmentally related costs, the report states. These sorts of reports and headlines are aimed at people that want 3rd party validation rather than objective, unbiased analysis. It’s even noted on IdeaSmiths LLC’s website as a speciality: > Technical due diligence for investors vetting new ventures and inventors looking for 3rd party validation https://www.ideasmiths.net/services-provide/ https://www.ideasmiths.net/services-provide/
- ghufran_syed 4y agoPart of the problem of these kind of studies is that the allocation of costs between solar+wind vs fossil is difficult when fossil fuels alone can provide all the energy, but solar+wind are intermittent and have to be backstopped by fossil fuel plants. So if you have to use short-term and therefore expensive fossil fuel plants when solar+wind can't supply enough energy, the additional cost over long-term fossile fuel use should be allocated to the renewable side IMO. If you don't do that, you make renewables look cheaper than their real economic cost. Another way to think about it is if renewables were saving us a lot of money over fossil fuels, shouldn't our fuel billsbe going down? Most utilities are regulated so they are not allowed to keep excess profits. But even before the spike in oil prices related to Ukraine, the places with a higher proportion of renewables have higher energy costs than those without. So where are these so-called savings? You could make the alternative argument that we need to use renewables despite their greater cost to help the environment, and in the hope that greater use leads us down the learning curve to lower costs in future, but that's clearly not the argument being made by the posted article
- insane_dreamer 4y ago> shouldn't our fuel bills be going down? I believe the point is that the cost/kW to consumers has remained steady despite the large increase in the price of fossil fuels. See https://www.texaselectricityratings.com/resources/historical-rates https://www.texaselectricityratings.com/resources/historical... (there has been a sharp increase this year, which counters the argument made, but otherwise steady since 2016).
- bee_rider 4y agoBacking intermittent sources with dispatchable generation is a solution, but not the only solution (energy storage and deferring loads are some alternatives for example). The cost of the fuel also doesn't account for costs they can externalize (ecosystem, healthcare) and the political issues it causes (Saudi Arabia gets by with more shit than they would otherwise, Russia is a big problem).
- epistasis 4y ago
- TheDesolate0 4y ago